Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Continued Petitions

Air Traffic Management Strategy Project (PE1804)

Wednesday 2 February 2022 Citizen Participation and Public Petitions Committee About 10:15 Petitions 16 contributions · 6 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

16 contributions
Jackson Carlaw Con The Convener · Eastwood
link

We move on to consideration of continued petitions. The update that I have to give on one or two of the petitions is quite lengthy, so I apologise in advance for giving uninterrupted speeches—I do not often make those in the chamber.

Our first continued petition is PE1804, which was lodged by Alasdair MacEachen, John Doig and Peter Henderson on behalf of Benbecula Community Council. The petition calls on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to halt Highlands and Islands Airports Ltd’s air traffic management strategy project and to conduct an independent assessment of the decisions and decision-making process of the project.

I am delighted to welcome Liam McArthur, who joins us online this morning, and Rhoda Grant, who is back with us in the committee room. Both are with us to speak to the petition. Before I come to them, I will offer a little more background.

The Scottish Government’s latest submission provides an update following the assurance of action plan that was conducted in the week commencing 25 October. The plan was set in the context of HIAL’s announcement that a framework for discussion had been agreed with Prospect, the trade union, to establish a new way forward for the implementation of the ATMS programme. It noted that programme delivery activities were largely paused to enable further delivery options to be appraised.

The submission confirms that the digital assurance office, the portfolio, programme and project assurance team and HIAL would continue to liaise to ensure that appropriate assurance arrangements are planned in as decisions are taken on the programme’s direction.

In its most recent submission, HIAL explains that, as a result of those developments, all industrial action was suspended while talks continued. In addition, new ATMS working groups were established with 27 air traffic colleagues from across several airports to help detail the benefits and risks of a potential way forward. The first of those groups met on 6 December.

At the end of January, HIAL announced that the HIAL board had agreed

“the future strategic direction for the ATMS programme. This will comprise a centralised surveillance operation for Sumburgh, Kirkwall, Stornoway, Inverness and Dundee airports, based at HIAL’s existing approach radar facility on the Inverness Airport Site. Air traffic tower services will continue to be provided locally at each of these airports.”

A late submission from one of the petitioners, commenting on the detail of that announcement, has been circulated to members. In summary, the petitioner raises concerns about the timescales for the new developments; the £9 million that has been spent so far; the implementation of surveillance radar; the timeline for Inverness to be granted controlled airspace; whether HIAL intends to introduce controlled airspace at Dundee, Stornoway, Kirkwall and Wick and, if so, when; and moving Benbecula and Wick from air traffic control to aerodrome flight information service. He is also concerned about what will happen to New Century house, the building that was bought to house the combined surveillance centre and remote tower centre.

The petitioner asks the committee to correspond directly with the Civil Aviation Authority regarding the issues raised and would welcome the opportunity to discuss his concerns with the committee in person. I understand that we heard from the petitioner two years ago.

Like others, I got quite excited when I saw “Reporting Scotland” feature announcements in relation to the petition and thought that maybe we were seeing progress of some kind. However, the petitioners are underwhelmed, to say the least.

Before the committee considers the petition, ask Liam McArthur and Rhoda Grant whether there is anything that they would like to update us on, although we do not want to hear the original submissions all over again. Mr McArthur, I will come to you first. Is there anything that you would like to update us on?

Liam McArthur LD Orkney Islands
link

I will try to be as brief as possible, convener.

The petitioner has set out very well some of the remaining issues. For example, it is not at all clear where the idea of radar surveillance has come from. It certainly begs some questions about the £3.5 million that was spent on New Century house, which now seems to be a rather expensive white elephant in relation to ATMS. That speaks to the concerns that both Rhoda Grant and I, and, more importantly, the petitioners raised about the incremental costs that have been incurred through the process on an objective that was seen as the only show in town but which has miraculously now been temporarily dumped. There is an on-going concern that HIAL may simply dust down the remote tower proposals four or five years down the line and seek to reintroduce them.

The other point that I stress is about the extent to which HIAL is relying on co-operative surveillance. There have been some suggestions from HIAL that that was up and ready to go, but that has been refuted by the CAA. It would be interesting to hear HIAL’s response to that challenge, because, fundamentally, if the CAA is not convinced, it will not get off the ground.

There are many questions that remain to be answered. The immediate risk to jobs on the islands and at the other airports is to be lifted, but there is some deep anxiety about the medium to longer term. There is also anxiety about HIAL’s handling of a project that seems to have been calamitous and which looks set to rack up more and more costs at the public’s expense.

If the committee were minded to hear directly from the petitioners and had time available in which to do so, that would be very valuable, in that more detail could be laid out on some of the issues that the committee could usefully continue to keep under review.

Jackson Carlaw Con The Convener · Eastwood
link

Thank you very much, Mr McArthur.

Has the immediate lifting of threats to jobs maybe underpinned Prospect’s welcome? Have you had any contact with Prospect?

Liam McArthur LD Orkney Islands
link

I think that that must be the motivation. We are at an impasse where, in a sense, HIAL was suggesting that installing remote towers was the only way of achieving the modernisation that everybody accepts is necessary for future air traffic services in the region. Having reached an agreement that lifts that immediate threat to jobs, perhaps Prospect feels that things have been moved on. However, there is certainly an anxiety among staff at the local level that HIAL is buying the time that it was always going to need to achieve the remote towers.

I would be interested to know whether Prospect believes that that remains the case, but a number of its members, including staff in Orkney and, I understand, at other airports, remain anxious about the longer-term intentions of HIAL management.

Rhoda Grant Lab Highlands and Islands
link

I agree with everything that Liam McArthur has said. The news that there has been a pause is welcome, because that is what Prospect was asking for and, indeed, what the staff and communities were asking for—they want time to look at the alternative solutions.

Nobody is arguing that we do not need to improve safety; the argument was that HIAL’s proposals did not provide additional safety but were about centralisation. They would cause huge economic damage without providing the safety that people want.

I would be grateful if the committee would look at a number of things. The proposed discussions about Benbecula and Wick were overlooked because of the enormity of the proposals, which impacted all the airports. There is concern that the downgrading of Benbecula and Wick will go ahead. Those airports need safe surveillance and locally based air traffic control. Both Benbecula and Wick are looking at becoming satellite launch sites, so they need safe airspace.

Benbecula is also host to QinetiQ’s Hebrides range, which means that there is often a huge amount of air activity when tests are taking place. The Hebrides range also provides a potential solution, in that it has radar. HIAL could work with the range to provide that in Benbecula. That would be a very affordable course of action that would not cause huge disruption.

One of the issues in all of this was the recruitment of air traffic control staff. The air traffic control staff in Benbecula tend to be young, so that airport has staff into the future. They are local people—they are not going to move anywhere. They will be lost to HIAL if it ends air traffic control at Benbecula.

There is also talk of a new island’s impact assessment. Therefore, any downgrading of Benbecula should surely wait until that impact assessment has been done. That would be within the spirit of the law.

With regard to Wick, people will be aware of the closing of Dounreay and the need for an economic focus on the area. A lot of work is going on with renewables and with the maintenance of devices, but the area needs good air traffic links to other parts of the United Kingdom to be able to attract jobs. It is very important that it has a safe airspace. Indeed, we are trying to encourage more traffic there.

I will not repeat what the convener said about the CAA’s comments, but it would be well worth the committee speaking to the CAA to find out what is happening, including about Wick perhaps being managed from Orkney. There was some discussion about that, and the CAA was not keen.

HIAL used to be very good at staff recruitment. It used to recruit from local communities. It would train people up and those people stayed. HIAL had its biggest recruitment issue in Inverness, where people tended to be more mobile. The committee should make HIAL look at that again and ensure that it starts recruiting again, because that is one of its reasons for stepping back—it says that if it cannot recruit, it will continue with the position as it was.

I know that the petitioners were keen to see Digital Scotland’s second report published. HIAL has it so it would be useful if the committee would ask it to publish that report.

There is also the centralisation of radar surveillance at Inverness. That does not make sense given that we are to have air traffic control at the airports, so how that decision was reached could be scrutinised. I know that there are concerns in Shetland about that, because the airport there has its own radar and there might be an impact if radar were centralised at Inverness.

I agree about the other issues that have been mentioned, such as the use of New Century house—I do not want to repeat everything.

Jackson Carlaw Con The Convener · Eastwood
link

There are several increasingly focused and quite serious issues.

Would anybody else like to come in?

David Torrance SNP Kirkcaldy
link

The petition has been on-going for quite a while—since last session—and we have not been updated by the petitioner for a long time. I am sure that, like me, committee members have a number of questions that they would like to ask the petitioner and HIAL management. I would like to bring in the petitioner and HIAL management to give evidence so that we can ask those questions.

Alexander Stewart Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

I very much concur with that. We have looked at the petition in depth, but from the information that we have received, it seems that there are more questions than answers.

It would be useful to get the petitioner in. There are also questions to be asked of the CAA about what it is doing with HIAL. It would be useful to have some correspondence with the CAA about the co-operative radar system that has been discussed in the papers. If we are to understand the situation, we require more information. Liam McArthur and Rhoda Grant have given us a lot of detail. That has been very useful, but there are still questions that we can ask of the petitioner and the CAA.

Jackson Carlaw Con The Convener · Eastwood
link

Mr McArthur would like to come back in.

Liam McArthur LD Orkney Islands
link

I will be extremely brief, convener. I very much welcome the comments from the deputy convener and Alexander Stewart.

As Rhoda Grant said, local recruitment is essential. HIAL almost made the process an exemplar when it last recruited locally. Since then, it has moved away from that model and sought to hire ready-made air traffic controllers. That was always a short-term fix, and it has left the company with some retention issues.

10:15

It would offer staff at various airports some reassurance if HIAL were to embark on a local recruitment drive. The approach has proven to be the best way of not just recruiting but retaining staff. If HIAL management gives evidence to the committee, that is a point that could be very usefully put to them.

Jackson Carlaw Con The Convener · Eastwood
link

In your role as Deputy Presiding Officer, you promoted Mr Stewart; my deputy convener is David Torrance.

Liam McArthur LD Orkney Islands
link

I was talking about the deputy convener and Alexander Stewart, rather than the deputy convener being Alexander Stewart.

Jackson Carlaw Con The Convener · Eastwood
link

Thank goodness for that.

David Torrance was on the previous Public Petitions Committee, which heard from the petitioner. Given the recent developments, I am minded to fall in with the suggestion that we bring in HIAL. I think that we should write to the CAA in the first instance to get its views on the petitioner’s latest concerns. I would quite like to get some information from Prospect about what underpins its welcome for the developments and where it now sits in the process. It may well be that that would lead us to invite Prospect to give evidence as well. Are there any other suggestions? Does what I have proposed seem reasonable?

Paul Sweeney Lab Glasgow
link

I would be interested to hear from airspace operators—the main scheduled carrier, which is Loganair, and others who use the airspace, such as the training school at Dundee airport—to understand what their concerns might be. I do not think that we have heard anything from them.

Jackson Carlaw Con The Convener · Eastwood
link

Thank you. I was going to ask the clerks whether that had been covered by any evidence. I ask the clerks to review that and see whether there is scope to follow up on Paul Sweeney’s suggestion, as I think that that is another facet of the approach that has to be understood.

I do not think that there is anything for us to write to the Minister for Transport about at this stage. Are members content to take evidence as proposed in the first instance?

Members indicated agreement.

Jackson Carlaw Con The Convener · Eastwood
link

Thank you. I hope that that will take us forward a little bit and that we can make our own contribution to this long-standing issue.

  1. 10:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. 10:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 16
  3. 10:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 15
  4. 10:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 3
  5. 10:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 8
  6. 10:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 6
  7. 10:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 10
  8. 11:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 9
  9. 11:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 7
  10. 11:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 5
  11. 11:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 4
  12. 11:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 4
  13. 11:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 3
  14. 11:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 4
  15. 11:15 New Petition Petitions · 6

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.