I was pleased that Irene Oldfather thought there was something worth while in what I said about better regulation. I am intrigued by the fact that that did not seem to find its way from paragraph 26 to the recommendations.
Official Report · Committee
Work Programme
Speakers
Showing Jim Wallace only · show everyone- Linda Fabiani SNP 41
- Irene Oldfather Lab 18
- Margaret Ewing SNP 12
- Jim Wallace LD 10
- John Home Robertson Lab 7
- Dennis Canavan Ind 4
- Derek Brownlee Con 4
- Karen Gillon Lab 4
- Alasdair Rankin Clerk 1
- Gordon Jackson Lab 1
Jim Wallace’s contributions
10 contributionsI share Irene Oldfather's view that the committee has dealt with structural funds a number of times. Indeed, I remember giving evidence to the committee on the issue and the recommendations that flowed from that. However, it is important that we keep track of the issue. The situation is the opposite of fluid; it seems to have got stuck and stagnated.As we saw under the previous agenda item, the issue is due to be discussed at the general affairs and external relations council next week—on 3 October, I think. In the light of any progress that is made there—or lack of it—and without doing a full report, perhaps it would be worth while for us to ask the minister to give us a progress report towards the end of the year. We could ask him to speak to the work that the committee has done previously.
As John Home Robertson said, the Lisbon strategy is an important subject. However, I would be wary of duplicating the work of the Enterprise and Culture Committee, which is considering business growth and research and development. The Lisbon agenda is wide and there may be aspects of it that the Enterprise and Culture Committee is not dealing with. It would not be a good use of our resources and time to replicate what another committee is doing. Perhaps the convener could discuss the matter with Alex Neil, the convener of the Enterprise and Culture Committee.
That would be helpful.
Phil Gallie will be able to read that in the Official Report.
Many positive suggestions have been made. However, it strikes me that we are proposing a unilateral inquiry into bilateral co-operation. I wonder whether we could think outside the box. Does anyone know whether the inquiry could be conducted bilaterally? Is there an equivalent committee in the Dáil?
Yes. As we are all aware from our constituency postbags, some small and medium-sized enterprises believe that there is always gold plating of European regulations. At our away day, I suggested that it might be worth while to use our collective experience to identify two or three regulations and to carry out an in-depth study of their implementation to ascertain whether we have gone beyond what was necessary and whether there has indeed been gold plating. We could select two or three other member states and examine the way in which the regulations were implemented there. In the case of regulations over which there is devolved responsibility, we could examine how they have been implemented in England, for example. That might—even just in those individual cases—allow the Executive to consider whether it has embellished the regulations. That might not be the case; we might well find that Scotland is a model of good regulation. However, if we can identify one or two cases in which the implementation of regulations has gone too far, that would put the people who draft them on alert and it would indicate that we should not unnecessarily disadvantage our businesses by overegging the pudding. I managed to get about five metaphors into that.
As long as I get to suggest which other member states we consider.
The point is to get beyond the anecdotes to the specifics. I am currently dealing with the Scottish Executive Environment and Rural Affairs Department on one example, on waste incineration—I cannot remember the precise name of the directive. I have received representations that in Scotland we have implemented the directive in a way that is far more restrictive and demanding than is the case south of the border.
The circumstances are such that waste oil from cars and farm machinery will have to be put to landfill because the company concerned cannot get a licence to treat it. The directive has an environmental objective but it has a counter-environmental effect. I have been told that the authorities south of the border have not implemented it in such a restrictive way. That is one example, but I am sure that we all have others, even from recent experience.
In this meeting
Everything on 27 Sep 2005 →- Scottish Parliament European and External Relations Committee Tuesday 27 September 2005 Committee business · 1
- Interests Procedure · 6
- Convener Procedure · 7
- Items in Private Procedure · 16
- Pre and Post-council Scrutiny Committee business · 13
- Sift Committee business · 2
- Convener's Report Procedure · 20
- Work Programme Procedure · 103
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.