Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Work Programme

Tuesday 27 September 2005 European and External Relations Committee Procedure 103 contributions · 10 speakers

Speakers

Showing Linda Fabiani only · show everyone

Linda Fabiani’s contributions

41 contributions
Linda Fabiani SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

Agenda item 7 is the committee's work programme for 2005-06 and possible subjects for future committee inquiries. I was not a member of the committee when the subjects were discussed and I did not attend the away day, so I found the paper useful. I invite comments from those who have been involved. I will pull together the discussion later and make decisions after that.

Linda Fabiani SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

I should have mentioned that Mr Gallie submitted a letter in the knowledge that he could not attend the meeting. Derek Brownlee will probably speak to the points that Mr Gallie has made. We have copies of the letter if members feel that it would be useful to them.

Linda Fabiani SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

Do members have comments before we consider the recommendations? I thought that Dennis Canavan was poised to make a wonderful contribution.

Linda Fabiani SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

In our defence, I should say that it was certainly there when we discussed the recommendations. I have it highlighted.

Linda Fabiani SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

That is why I want to have a general discussion before we consider them.

Linda Fabiani SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

I suggest that we consider each recommendation in turn. We will include Mr Wallace's suggestion about better regulation.

Linda Fabiani SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

Yes. It is included in the paper as one of the recommendations. We will go through all the recommendations to get an idea of how members feel about them. At the end of that, we will go back and decide what our priorities are.The first recommendation is that we have an inquiry into the way in which structural funds receipts will be distributed in Scotland between 2007 and 2013. The bit that interested me more was the consequence of no structural funds being available or of any delay in agreeing the programmes.

Linda Fabiani SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

Okay. Does any other member wish to comment?

Linda Fabiani SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

I agree that the committee has done inquiries into structural funds, but the issue remains of whether the funds will be distributed regionally or centrally. What do members feel about the suggestion of asking the minister to update us? He could address the mechanisms that are employed in the distribution of structural funds.

Linda Fabiani SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

Tom McCabe is the lead minister. I would expect him to be invited.

Linda Fabiani SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

That could leave us the option of looking at some form of further inquiry, depending on the outcome.

Linda Fabiani SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

Yes. Do you have anything to say on the matter, Derek?

Linda Fabiani SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

Okay. Are we agreed?Members indicated agreement.

Linda Fabiani SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

The next issue is the promotion of the Lisbon strategy. The committee has looked at that before, but we must now consider whether to undertake a major inquiry in 2006. As a newcomer to the committee's discussions, my first thoughts on discussing the subject with the clerks were that the issue is so big that the committee would need to focus on what it wanted to achieve from an inquiry.Looking at the various initiatives that have been going on, including what other commentators have said on the subject, I suggest that we focus on research and development—that is a big issue in Scotland and one in which we do well—innovation or employment. How do members feel about having an inquiry on the Lisbon strategy and how focused should it be?

Linda Fabiani SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

Oh yes, we are all one big happy family.It would help both committees if the work that we were to do complemented what the Enterprise and Culture Committee is doing, although there could be some crossover.

Linda Fabiani SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

We could come back to our next meeting with a firm recommendation.

Linda Fabiani SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

We will be considering the Commission's strategy for 2006, so that would be fine. Is everyone content with that part of our discussion?Members indicated agreement.

Linda Fabiani SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

The next recommendation, which must have come up at the away day, is that we undertake an inquiry into the effect of the services directive on public services, the business sector and the general public. There is a general awareness that the directive is at a late legislative stage; Phil Gallie referred to that in his letter. How useful can the committee be in this area? For example, our inquiry could examine the provisions of the finalised directive and investigate their likely effects.In discussion with the clerks, my first thought was that they could bring a briefing paper to a committee meeting to inform us of what stage the services directive is at and its likely effects. Are there any comments on that?

Linda Fabiani SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

I am unaware of that, but we can check.The next item for consideration is:"Mr Gallie's proposal that the Committee conduct an investigation into EU bureaucracy, terms of employment, benefits and wider fraud issues."That would be some inquiry, I must say. Would Mr Brownlee like to comment?

Linda Fabiani SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

Is that the general feeling of the committee?Members indicated agreement.

Linda Fabiani SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

The next recommendation is:"Mr Canavan's proposal that the Committee conduct an inquiry into the opportunities for bi-lateral co-operation projects between Scotland and the Republic of Ireland and Northern Ireland, using access to Interreg or Co-operation funding."

Linda Fabiani SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

Margaret Ewing is a member of the British-Irish Inter-Parliamentary Body and attends lots of its meetings.

Linda Fabiani SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

If we decide to proceed, we should do so by appointing a rapporteur.

Linda Fabiani SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

Irene Oldfather knows about that.

Linda Fabiani SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

We need to pull in the Dáil as well.

Linda Fabiani SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

I understand that it is Westminster's turn to host a meeting. We will produce a paper outlining the current situation, so that we can move forward with a view to appointing a rapporteur on the issue.

Linda Fabiani SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

Would Derek Brownlee like to comment? I know that Mr Gallie was not keen on the idea, but I am sure that he would have been swayed by the force of the argument today.

Linda Fabiani SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

At this point, I would like us to consider the better regulation case studies item that was omitted from the recommendations. Would Jim Wallace like to speak to that?

Linda Fabiani SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

Jim, do you have any ideas floating about in your head—Laughter. I will not stop the sentence there; I have another bit to say. Do you have any ideas about the issues—rather than the other member states—that you would like to examine?

Linda Fabiani SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

I suggest that the way forward is for Jim Wallace to have a chat with any members who are interested in particular issues. He can then have a discussion with the clerks with a view to bringing back a paper to try to focus the inquiry and move it forward. Is that agreed?Members indicated agreement.

Linda Fabiani SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

The final recommendation probably goes without saying. It is that we"Track the progress of the other issues covered in this paper as being potentially significant over the next 18 months, chiefly perhaps the Commission's Work Programme".As Irene Oldfather said, that is due out in November. We have already talked about inviting someone from the Commission to meet us to discuss its work programme.Before we move on to the external relations options, do members want to raise any other issues? For example, Phil Gallie states in his letter that he is keen on"Early considerations of the Green Paper on Future EU Maritime policy".

Linda Fabiani SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

It would make sense to speak to the Commission to take the matter forward. If there are no other comments, we will move on to paragraph 28 of the paper, under the heading "External Relations Options". I understand that, at its away day, the committee considered two options. The first was"an inquiry into global Scots and similar networks and how the Government and the Executive use the Scottish diaspora and its connections to identify and take advantage of economic, educational and cultural opportunities for Scotland."When I first spoke about that to Alasdair Rankin and David Simpson, I was aware that I was confused about where everything fitted in. I do not know how au fait the committee is with how all these things work and with what helps what. I asked for a briefing paper to be prepared, which I have found extremely useful. I wondered whether the committee would like at its next meeting to have a briefing on how all the various organisations work, what their remit is, and how they complement one another before we decide whether we should go any further.

Linda Fabiani SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

Should we have at our next meeting a short paper on the remit of the international development strategy and what has been happening with it? It could help us to decide what we should be investigating and whether the time is right for such an investigation. It might be too soon to consider the issue properly, but we should have that knowledge before we decide. Is that agreed?Members indicated agreement.

Linda Fabiani SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

The final option came, I presume, from the away day and from previous committee discussions. The suggestion is for "an inquiry into the operation of the concordats and the Joint Ministerial Committee (JMC) between Westminster and the devolved governments."The committee would consider the general principles. Does anyone want to speak to this? Whose suggestion was it?

Linda Fabiani SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

It must have been John Swinney's. It can be one of those things that we track.

Linda Fabiani SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

If members are all content, I will recap what I think the committee has agreed to in going through the recommendations.

Linda Fabiani SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

I ask members to jump in if they think that I have got something wrong.We decided that we would like Mr McCabe to speak to the committee on the distribution of structural funds. In tandem with that, towards the end of the year, we will ask for information from Westminster about where it is at on the matter. On the EU's promotion of the Lisbon strategy, we agreed that our approach should be more focused and that there would be joint discussions among myself, the clerks, Alex Neil as the convener of the Enterprise and Culture Committee and the clerks to that committee. I hope that we can come back to the next meeting with a more focused view of how we should proceed.

Linda Fabiani SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

Yes, of course. We recognise that the services directive is quite far down the line, so it would be ideal for a briefing paper to come to us.We reckon that we do not have the capacity to carry out an investigation into EU bureaucracy, terms of employment, benefits and wider fraud issues.On Mr Canavan's proposal on bilateral co-operation between Scotland and Ireland, we should be provided with a briefing paper that describes the current situation, with a view to appointing a rapporteur to take the matter forward.Mr Wallace will chat with anyone who wishes to have an input on better regulation case studies and will then meet the clerks to come up with examples of themes to consider and places with which to make comparisons.We will obviously track the progress of the other issues that are covered in the paper.On external relations, we will get a briefing paper on the different agencies that relate to Scotland's place in the world. We will also get a short paper on the international development strategy, with a view to examining relationships beyond Europe. That could perhaps also pull in concordats that relate directly to international development.Are members all content with the decisions that we have made?Members indicated agreement.

Linda Fabiani SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

I thank members of the public for attending the meeting. The committee's next meeting will be after the recess, on 25 October.

  1. Scottish Parliament European and External Relations Committee Tuesday 27 September 2005 Committee business · 1
  2. Interests Procedure · 6
  3. Convener Procedure · 7
  4. Items in Private Procedure · 16
  5. Pre and Post-council Scrutiny Committee business · 13
  6. Sift Committee business · 2
  7. Convener's Report Procedure · 20
  8. Work Programme Procedure · 103

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.