Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Work Programme

Tuesday 27 September 2005 European and External Relations Committee Procedure 103 contributions · 10 speakers

Speakers

Showing Irene Oldfather only · show everyone

Irene Oldfather’s contributions

18 contributions
Irene Oldfather Lab Cunninghame South
link

I am happy to comment first, although, because of personal and unexpected circumstances, I could not attend the committee away day. On reading the paper and reflecting on the inquiries that the committee has undertaken, several points occurred to me. We did quite a bit of work on the G8, the fresh talent initiative and other matters that relate to our external relations remit, and I am keen to move to a subject with a European dimension.That said, I recognise, as Mr Gallie says in his letter—

Irene Oldfather Lab Cunninghame South
link

I have had a wee look at the letter, although it is not in front of me. I recall some of Mr Gallie's points, such as the one that structural funds are more or less a moving target, with which I agree. He mentioned one or two other matters that we have considered, such as the constitution, which is another moving target. We should have a watching brief on some of the obvious issues that the committee might want to examine.I would like a practical European subject to be chosen and I am attracted to one or two issues. I am interested in giving a little more thought to Mr Wallace's suggestion about better regulation. That could be a practical exercise from which we could learn. I am also interested in throwing into the pot for discussion tripartite contracts, the youth initiative and the communications strategy. Perhaps we could consider Scotland's role in those initiatives.I note from the paper that the Commission will go into further detail on the annual work programme in November, and I wonder whether the committee would be interested in inviting a member of the Commission to come along and speak to us about that in November. The October break is coming up, so there is not an awful lot of time between now and then. We still have our fresh talent inquiry report to agree and I doubt that that will be done and dusted in one meeting. I wonder whether there is scope for our not taking a definitive view today but inviting the Commission to discuss the communications strategy, the tripartite contracts and the youth initiative, and to give us a practical analysis of the better regulation initiative.

Irene Oldfather Lab Cunninghame South
link

I had assumed that the recommendations were just a loose grouping.

Irene Oldfather Lab Cunninghame South
link

To be honest, I would want to reject some of them.

Irene Oldfather Lab Cunninghame South
link

I think that Mr Gallie proposed in his letter that we do not hold that inquiry at this point. I find myself in the unusual position of agreeing with Mr Gallie twice in one meeting. We are in the hands of others in relation to structural funds. From what we heard from Douglas Alexander, the Minister of State for Europe, we are waiting to see what will happen over the next few months. The committee should certainly keep a watching brief, but I am not convinced that we want to undertake a reporter-led inquiry. I am interested in what other colleagues think. We have produced about four reports into structural funds; it is not that long since we concluded our most recent one and I do not know that the picture has changed very much since then.

Irene Oldfather Lab Cunninghame South
link

We have always said that we would keep a watching brief on the issue. I am happy with Jim Wallace's suggestion. Obviously, the time towards the end of the year is also the time towards the end of the presidency. We would want to review progress, see exactly where we are at and what the cascade might be further down the line.

Irene Oldfather Lab Cunninghame South
link

If the proposal is to invite the minister back at the end of the year, I am supportive of that. That is a little bit different to entering into another full inquiry at this point, which I am not particularly keen to do.

Irene Oldfather Lab Cunninghame South
link

I agree with what John Home Robertson and Jim Wallace said. Further to that, after the European Commission has produced its policy strategy in November, perhaps a Commission representative could attend a committee meeting and we could consider the strategy. The Lisbon strategy is big, but the Commission tends to look at different aspects of it at different times, especially where growth is lagging or where it wants to take particular initiatives—for example, on the employability of people over 55. There are also continuing initiatives on improving competitiveness in different member states.As part of refining the scope of our inquiry and discussing it with the Enterprise and Culture Committee, we could consider what the Commission is focusing on in its November policy strategy document. Given that the Lisbon strategy covers a big area, we could refine the scope of our inquiry over a few committee meetings and decide what we want to focus on.

Irene Oldfather Lab Cunninghame South
link

I agree. An issue that was discussed early on in relation to the directive was where services of general interest, with particular application to public services, would come in and whether they would, indeed, be excluded from the directive. I have lost track of the current situation because of the continuing amendments.The services directive is a political issue and different political groups and member states are taking different perspectives and viewpoints on it. I would be keen to know how we are progressing, especially on issues around services of general interest, and I would be interested to know whether any agreement has been reached. I see that John Edward is in the public gallery, so perhaps I could have a word with him afterwards—he probably knows something about the situation. I lost track of the discussion a few months ago.In the Committee of the Regions, we were pushing our position very hard. We included calls in a number of resolutions to ensure that services of general interest with respect to the public sector were protected to some extent in the directive. I do not know what stage the discussions have reached. It would be helpful to have a briefing paper with an update on the situation.

Irene Oldfather Lab Cunninghame South
link

Members will not be surprised to learn that I would not be in favour of undertaking such an inquiry. I note what Margaret Ewing said. I read in the newspapers today that Mr Barroso is absolutely committed to reducing regulation for business, and I await developments there with interest. There seems to be a firm commitment on the part of the Commission to do something about the matter. I also noted in the newspapers something about European schools and who should pay for them. We could end up getting into a minefield. It is more about conditions of employment, benefits, and so on.On Mr Gallie's suggestion of investigating "wider fraud issues", I point out that committees of inquiry are dealing with that in Europe and they have been coming up with results that Mr Gallie would probably be surprised by. I would not be in favour of entering into such an investigation at this point.

Irene Oldfather Lab Cunninghame South
link

I know that Dennis Canavan produced a very good report for the committee in the past, so I would be happy to endorse his appointment as rapporteur. Anything that we can do to maximise funding and funding opportunities for Scotland is to be greatly welcomed. At the moment Scotland is participating in a strand of Interreg—Strathclyde European Partnership is doing something. I know that Sachsen-Anhalt, one of the regions that were involved in the network of regional parliamentary European committees, is very active in Interreg, so there may be opportunities for us to explore that connection. Sachsen-Anhalt was instrumental in developing the way in which the criteria for the new tranche of moneys, post 2007, are proposed, to ensure that there are opportunities for regions that do not have an immediate border with one another to work together. It was keen to develop transnational links. It might be helpful in the first instance if a paper could be produced to enable us to consider some of the issues. Something is being done in Scotland in this area.

Irene Oldfather Lab Cunninghame South
link

Possibly not. However, I am sure that Strathclyde European Partnership would be able to give us further information. I am happy to endorse Dennis Canavan as a rapporteur, if he is interested in the issue and is willing to explore further any opportunities that exist.

Irene Oldfather Lab Cunninghame South
link

There is a structure involving the Welsh Assembly, the Northern Ireland Assembly, the House of Lords and the Scottish Parliament. There are regular meetings two or three times a year, at which we share good practice.

Irene Oldfather Lab Cunninghame South
link

Although the Dáil is not represented in the structure to which I refer, because Ireland is a separate member state, there are regular meetings between the House of Commons European Scrutiny Committee and the House of Lords European Union Committee and representatives of the Dáil, and between representatives of the Northern Ireland Assembly and the Dáil. There are good links, so it may be possible for us to produce a paper. I am not sure whether it is our turn to host the meeting between the different committees. The previous meeting that I attended was held at Stormont. I know that the committees have met at the House of Lords and the House of Commons. There was also a meeting in Aberdeen, when Richard Lochhead was convener.

Irene Oldfather Lab Cunninghame South
link

As I said in my initial comments, I am interested in tripartite contracts, which the committee examined briefly some time ago, and in the new communications strategy. I guess that both matters could be covered when the European Commission representative comes to speak to the committee. Tripartite contracts are a practical example of how the European Commission can enter into agreements with individual regions or authorities to advance environmental, education and other action programmes, and there could be merit in undertaking something practical. I am willing to have further discussions on that in November when the Commission's representative comes; I simply wanted to ensure that the matter is noted.

Irene Oldfather Lab Cunninghame South
link

I am entirely happy to have the clerks produce a written briefing, but I feel that we touched on those things in our promoting Scotland worldwide inquiry. We took evidence in New York and Boston, and we asked people from the various organisations to come to the committee. I do not think that it is a priority for the committee, although that is a personal view.

Irene Oldfather Lab Cunninghame South
link

The issue was raised at the away day before last. Professor Drew Scott spoke to the committee in private and raised some of the issues. Probably 95 per cent of committee members, with the exception of John Swinney, thought that the issue was for a very much later stage. That is certainly my view.

Irene Oldfather Lab Cunninghame South
link

We also agreed that we should take into account the Commission's work programme.

  1. Scottish Parliament European and External Relations Committee Tuesday 27 September 2005 Committee business · 1
  2. Interests Procedure · 6
  3. Convener Procedure · 7
  4. Items in Private Procedure · 16
  5. Pre and Post-council Scrutiny Committee business · 13
  6. Sift Committee business · 2
  7. Convener's Report Procedure · 20
  8. Work Programme Procedure · 103

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.