Thank you, convener. My report summarises the circumstances surrounding the delay to the opening of the Royal hospital for children and young people, the department of clinical neurosciences and the child and adolescent mental health service in NHS Lothian. The report is not an investigation into the causes of the delay, but it aims to clarify the facts as we currently know them.
The Scottish Government announced a non-profit distributing funding route for the project in 2010. In 2014, NHS Lothian appointed Integrated Health Services Lothian to design, build, finance and maintain the project. Total costs were estimated at £230 million, which was made up of construction costs of £150 million plus enabling and equipment works of £80 million that were outwith the agreement with IHSL.
The hospital was originally due to open in July 2017, but it has been delayed by a series of technical and contractual disputes. In February 2019, with Scottish Government approval, NHS Lothian signed a settlement agreement with IHSL, and an £11.6 million payment was agreed. In February 2019, the independent tester—Arcadis NV—issued a certificate of practical completion and the hospital was handed over to NHS Lothian. However, in June, final compliance checks revealed that the ventilation system in the critical care department did not comply with current guidance, leading to the decision not to open the hospital on 9 July as planned.
Since then, two reviews that were commissioned by the Cabinet Secretary for Health and Sport have been published. The first report, which was produced by KPMG, focused on governance arrangements. It set out a picture of confusion and human error in relation to the interpretation of the relevant specifications and guidance, together with missed opportunities to spot and rectify that error. NHS National Services Scotland, which produced the second review, carried out a series of checks to ensure that the relevant technical specifications and guidance had been followed. It identified a range of issues to be addressed.
It is estimated that the additional work that is required to ensure that the new hospital complies with the relevant specifications and guidance, as well as the work to keep the current site open while that happens, will cost an additional £16 million. A public inquiry will be held to examine those issues and those at the Queen Elizabeth university hospital in Glasgow. My report aims not to pre-empt that inquiry but to set out a factual account of what I currently understand about the situation, based on the reviews that were carried out by KPMG and NHS National Services Scotland, and on NHS Lothian’s annual audit report, which was produced by Chris Brown of Scott-Moncrieff.
My report is not the result of a full investigation into the project; instead, it identifies a number of issues for consideration to ensure that lessons are learned for future projects of such nature. Those include the clarity and application of the relevant guidelines and how they were managed, the contractual implications, the roles and accountability of all the parties involved and the effectiveness of oversight and scrutiny.
As usual, my colleagues and I will do our best to answer the committee’s questions.