Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Continued Petitions

A77 Upgrade (PE1657)

Thursday 23 November 2017 Public Petitions Committee About 09:45–10:45 Petitions 88 contributions · 7 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

88 contributions
Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Agenda item 3 is further consideration of continued petitions PE1610, by Matt Halliday, on upgrading the A75, and PE1657, by Donald McHarrie, on upgrading the A77.

At our meeting on 21 September, we agreed to write to the Scottish Government to ask two specific questions regarding PE1657, including what the timetable was for the Maybole bypass and the action that is being taken by the Scottish Government to address the traffic lights at Marchburn. A response has been received and is included in our meeting papers. We also agreed to join together PE1610 and PE1657 for future consideration and to take evidence from the Scottish Government on the significant concerns that are raised in both petitions in relation to the economy and the road infrastructure.

I welcome, from the Scottish Government, Humza Yousaf, the Minister for Transport and the Islands; Alison Irvine, head of strategic transport planning; and Paul Junik, head of transport forecasts and infrastructure planning.

The minister will make a brief opening statement of up to five minutes, after which we will move to questions from committee members.

Humza Yousaf SNP The Minister for Transport and the Islands · Glasgow Pollok
link

Thank you for inviting me to appear before the committee this morning, convener. I understand that the committee has been considering two separate petitions on dualling the A75 and A77. I will be happy to respond to your queries.

Before I do that, it may be helpful if I set out the Scottish Government’s position. The Government understands the important strategic role that both the A75 and the A77 play in connecting the communities in Dumfries and Galloway and South Ayrshire with the central belt and the north of England. In particular, both routes provide the necessary strategic connectivity to Prestwick airport and to the ports at Cairnryan. Both roads carry a mixture of commuter, tourist and, importantly, freight traffic along their length.

The Government’s on-going commitment is demonstrated by the investment in maintenance since 2007 of £66 million approximately for the A75 and £48 million for the A77. On capital investment, approximately £50 million has been invested since 2007 in six new schemes along the length of the A75 to improve overtaking and to remove known pinchpoints. Approximately £35 million has been invested in four schemes on the A77 and the planned investment on the Maybole bypass.

10:00

Regarding my interest in the south-west of Scotland, I chaired the Dumfries and Galloway transport summit in August 2016, which was an excellent opportunity to hear from key stakeholders about their views on the transport network. The most discussed topics were the A75 and the A77. The final report from the summit contained 14 action points, and an updated document reflecting the current position on those action points was published earlier this month. In the margins of the summit, I had a productive meeting with dual the A75 campaigners who put their case to me. More recently, I met South Ayrshire councillors regarding their concerns about the A77, while only last week I met representatives of the A77 action group to hear their concerns. They were also accompanied by two committee members.

The 2017-18 programme for government reaffirmed our commitment to commence work early on the review of strategic transport projects in the Dumfries and Galloway area. In line with that commitment, we are progressing a study that will consider the rationale for improvements to road, rail, public transport and active travel on key strategic corridors, including the A77 and the A75. The study will have a focus on access to the ports at Cairnryan. Over the coming weeks, Transport Scotland will commission consultants to progress the study. In advance of the study, we have completed a programme of data collection on roads in Dumfries and Galloway and South Ayrshire to understand trip-making patterns on major routes across the south-west of Scotland.

In addition, Transport Scotland has just completed a two-day-long survey of departing passengers from the Stena Line and P&O ports at Cairnryan. As the Scottish transport appraisal guidance pre-appraisal study moves forward, a key aspect will be engagement with stakeholders, and there will be opportunities to engage with the study before the initial report in autumn 2018. The outcomes of that study will feed into the second strategic transport projects review. STPR2 will report later in this parliamentary session, as it must take cognisance of the strategic outcomes and priorities of the new national transport strategy review. I reassure the committee that the Scottish Government recognises the importance of the A75 and the A77 to the strategic transport network and the economy of south-west Scotland and, indeed, to the country as a whole. I am more than happy to take questions.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

The committee has heard evidence that the south-west is the “forgotten corner” of Scotland and that investment in road infrastructure in the area has been limited in favour of other roads in the country, such as the A8 and A9. Will the minister respond to these concerns?

Humza Yousaf SNP Glasgow Pollok
link

My meetings over the past few weeks have largely focused on the A77, but there has also been a focus on the A75. A number of members have made a similar suggestion. As I travel through communities everywhere in Scotland, I understand that they would like more investment in trunk roads. Clearly, we face pressures on our budget, but I reject the premise that the south-west is the “forgotten corner”. We made a £50 million capital investment in the A75 for schemes that were not small—for example, the Dunragit bypass on the A75 is a £17 million scheme. In addition, £35 million is being spent on the A77. I could list the schemes but, for the sake of brevity, I will not. We also have planned investment of £30 million in the Maybole bypass. That campaign has been going on for years, but when I spoke to the campaigners, they told me that it had been going on for decades. We are delivering on that.

I can understand the frustration of campaigners who want more investment. Cairnryan port is strategically important and campaigners there strongly argue that further investment is needed. That is why we are proceeding with the study that I mentioned. When the maintenance budget is added to the figures I have quoted, hundreds of millions of pounds are being spent on those strategic roads.

Angus MacDonald SNP Falkirk East
link

The minister said that he met the petitioners last week to discuss their concerns and that the Scottish Government will conduct a study. How much will be invested in the study and will it include a specific assessment of the remedies that are called for in the petition? How will the study fit into the overall strategic approach to transport planning in Scotland?

Humza Yousaf SNP Glasgow Pollok
link

The study will help to add weight to the argument of those who are calling for additional investment in the A75 and the A77. Everyone around the table will understand that everything we do has to be evidence based and that the investment of every pound of Scottish taxpayers’ money has to be evidence based, so a power of work is being done.

Angus MacDonald asked about the cost of the study. My officials will keep me right if I am wildly off, but we expect it to be in the order of £200,000. On top of that we are doing some data collection, which will incur its own costs as well. That is a significant investment, and the study will take a broad overview of the issues—it is not just about roads, although roads will be an important part of it. As I mentioned, the study will also look at rail, public transport options and active travel, but it will focus on the ports at Cairnryan. When I met P&O and Stena, which have been part of the conversations that I have had on this topic in the last few weeks, they made a very strong case for the investment that is needed on the A77 and the A75.

The study will help to feed into the STPR2, and I expect it to come with a long list of options, which we will then have to look at narrowing down. We will have to look at the budgetary resource implications of each option and make a decision on the type of investment that we want to see in the future. However, I would say to those who support the A75 and the A77 campaigns that they are in a strong place in terms of consideration for future investment.

Michelle Ballantyne Con South Scotland
link

Thank you and welcome, minister. When we visited Dumfries and Galloway in September, one of the frustrations that came through very strongly was the sense that promises had been made by successive Governments and had not been followed through on.

I listened carefully to what you have said this morning about investments that have already been made. I would say that maintenance is a core part of normal revenue spending, but you have wrapped that up and said that that is how much you spent on it. However, we are discussing not maintenance investment but capital investment to improve and upgrade the road.

Given the economic value, and the commentary that has been made time and again to people in the area, how do you respond to concerns that any improvements to date of the A75 and the A77 have been piecemeal in nature and have failed to deliver a long-term solution to the area? How would you reassure people that your undertaking another review will not just result in more promises that do not actually deliver a solution?

When we were in the area, we heard that the extension of the ports and the work that has been done for the shipping lines was to some degree in response to Government promises that there would be investment in the roads.

Humza Yousaf SNP Glasgow Pollok
link

That is a really good question. During my discussions with campaigners, I felt that sense of frustration also. Interestingly, there was even some scepticism about projects that we have absolutely committed to.

The Maybole bypass is an example where people said that they will believe it once they see it built. From my point of view, we are absolutely committed. We have committed the funding to it and there will be a Maybole bypass. It is important and imperative that the Government demonstrates along every part of the process for the bypass that we are engaging with communities and giving them the reassurance that they need.

I would not say that that is restricted to the south-west corner. When I talk to colleagues in the north-east about the Laurencekirk junction, they say that people say they will believe it when they see it and that they have been told for years and years that there will be a new junction. It is coming. The proof is in the eating of the pudding, but I am committed to the schemes that I have mentioned.

I take slight issue with what the member said about maintenance. You only have to talk to those chief operating officers of transport at local government level to hear that even if funds should be spent on a road for maintenance, they often do not get there. The fact that we have continued to invest tens of millions of pounds—or, if we take the two roads together, almost hundreds of millions of pounds—on maintenance is important. However, I accept your point. That is why I made the points about the capital spend that we have made on both road schemes, which is not insubstantial.

We have tried to remove some of the pinchpoints and traffic hotspots, but there is clearly a desire in the communities along the length of both the A77 and the A75 for really significant investment. That will, they tell me, be a game changer for them.

The campaigners have made a strong case that we should consider the ports of Cairnryan to be strategically important not just to the south-west, but to the entire country and to connections beyond these islands. The promises that I can make are that we will absolutely deliver the schemes that we said we would deliver, such as the Maybole bypass.

We would not spend the money that we are spending on the study not to have tangible outcomes at the end of the process. Therefore, the expectation on the Government to deliver meaningful investment after the study is absolutely merited. As I say, stakeholders will have a chance to engage in the study.

I must be absolutely frank about two points. First, we can sit around a committee table discussing matters and there can be petitions, but everybody will understand that a solution will not necessarily come overnight. Secondly, there must also be an understanding that there are pressures on our budget, but that is a matter of prioritisation.

As I said, the campaigners on the A77 and the A75 and the ports of Cairnryan are putting together a very strong case for looking at future investment.

Michelle Ballantyne Con South Scotland
link

I do not think that it is a case of expecting a return overnight, but the petitioners have been campaigning on the issue for years and successive promises have been made on and off the record. Now that you are doing the study, I suppose what they are looking for is that, if the study tells us what we think we already know, you will step up and, this time, keep the promise that you make.

Humza Yousaf SNP Glasgow Pollok
link

It was more of a statement than a question. As I said, we have kept the promises that we have made on investment. However, I absolutely understand the campaigners’ frustration because they want to have more. In some respects, I also understand the scepticism. The member is absolutely right, in that it is our job to deliver on the promises that we have made, so I agree.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

The petitioners’ frustration with the Maybole decision is not just about whether the work will happen—they are also frustrated that the decision is not the right one. The petitioners’ submission says that not recommending a dual carriageway

“is a missed opportunity by the Transport Minister.”

At this point, I welcome Finlay Carson MSP, who also has an interest in the issues.

Humza Yousaf SNP Glasgow Pollok
link

I met the Maybole bypass committee. Some of its members have been campaigning not for years, but for decades. On the Maybole bypass decision, yes, some were still saying that they would wait until the spades were in the ground before they would accept that it was happening, but the response was overwhelmingly positive.

The dual carriageway option for the Maybole bypass was explored. I will provide some context, but if you want more detail, we can, of course, provide it. Our in-depth study showed that the proposed single-carriageway dual bypass scheme will deliver 85 per cent of the journey time improvement that a dual carriageway would deliver at 60 per cent of the capital cost.

You said that not recommending the dual carriageway is a missed opportunity. I say that 85 per cent of the benefits for 60 per cent of the cost is great value for the Scottish taxpayer.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

It was not me who said that, obviously.

Humza Yousaf SNP Glasgow Pollok
link

No. I was just making the point for the record.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

The petitioners said that it is a missed opportunity. Furthermore, 85 per cent is maybe not 100 per cent.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

Surely, to take a long-term view, that decision is short-sighted, because all you are doing is moving the pinchpoints further up the road to Minishant. I think that the scheme covers 5.4 miles. You are not affording traffic the opportunity to overtake the 44 tonne lorries that are coming up the road.

Humza Yousaf SNP Glasgow Pollok
link

The decision is not short-sighted. You have not taken cognisance of the statistic that I have just used: the scheme will get 85 per cent of the journey time improvement that we would have got had we chosen to dual the carriageway

The convener is absolutely correct in her assessment—85 per cent is not 100 per cent. Could we have gone further? Yes, but that would have added 40 per cent on to the capital cost. That is not good value for taxpayers’ money. I respect the fact that you and other campaigners say that you would have wanted 100 per cent of the journey time improvement and 100 per cent of the benefits that we would have had with the dual carriageway, but I think that, when I have competing pressures across the country, 85 per cent of the improvement for 60 per cent of the cost is not a missed opportunity.

I return to what I have said. When I met the Maybole bypass committee, the members were overwhelmingly positive that the scheme will be delivered.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

It is a case of not “Could you have done that?” but “Should you have done that?” It is not good value for money if you will have to upgrade the road yet again in the future.

10:15

Humza Yousaf SNP Glasgow Pollok
link

I do not envisage having to go back to the Maybole bypass and extend it from a single to a double carriageway. When we deliver that percentage of benefit for the cost, it is about not “Could you?” or “Should you?” but the resources that are available for the various priorities. When I spoke to the Maybole bypass group, which has been campaigning for decades on the issue, they were overwhelmingly positive.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

The Maybole bypass is about not just the community near the bypass but the transport link from Cairnryan to the central belt. If you are taking cognisance only of the community’s requirements, you are taking cognisance simply of the people who want to take the traffic away from Maybole. What about the traffic that uses that route? Have you taken cognisance of the views that the drivers are expressing?

Humza Yousaf SNP Glasgow Pollok
link

When we carry out any infrastructure project, including the Maybole bypass, we take account of not just the relatively small community in the particular area but the wider picture, too. The pre-appraisal study that I have committed to producing, and for which we are on the verge of appointing consultants, will also look at the wider picture, including investments that are planned and that we have already made. The design of the Maybole bypass does not just look at what the effect will be then and there, as it is built; it forecasts traffic volumes for 15 years ahead. Therefore, to say that it is shortsighted is an incorrect and unfair assessment.

I am not saying that I cannot understand the frustrations of those who want a dual carriageway bypass. I completely understand the desire for one and, in every community that I travel to, many people desire dual rather than single carriageways on the trunk road network. However, in terms of value for the taxpayer, with pressures on our budget, I am confident that the current design for the Maybole bypass will deliver great benefit not just for the local community but for wider communities. It is not shortsighted—I point the member to the fact that we look at 15-year traffic forecasts.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

There is concern about making false economies, which is why we were keen to put the matter in context. Your responsibility is for transport projects, but a different test might be applied if the project was being looked at strategically from a broader economic perspective. Obviously, it is not for you but for the cabinet secretary to make that decision.

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

Good morning, minister. The committee understands that the Loch Ryan ports are facing increasing competition from Holyhead, in Wales, and Heysham, in Lancashire, where the roads infrastructure has been significantly improved over recent years, the economic benefits of which appear very positive. For example, we understand that an assessment was made that every £1 that was invested in the new Heysham link road will earn £4.40 for the local economy. What is the Scottish Government doing to secure the long-term future of the Cairnryan ports? Will the study be enough at this point? What assessment has the Scottish Government made of the socioeconomic impact of the contributions that the ferry services make to Dumfries and Galloway and to Scotland and of the possible impact should the ferry services withdraw from Loch Ryan?

Humza Yousaf SNP Glasgow Pollok
link

We fully understand the strategic importance of the ports at Cairnryan not just to the local economy in the south-west but to Scotland. The point that the convener made before Rona Mackay’s question is important. The ports at Cairnryan give us an economic focus. Almost every trunk road that I travel on in Scotland has economic significance for the local community because of connectivity, but I agree with the assessment that there is an added focus for the ports at Cairnryan.

We understand the value of the ports and, in recent meetings, Stena Line and P&O have made a strong case that, if investment in Cairnryan is not forthcoming but investment continues to be made in Heysham or Holyhead, the Cairnryan ports risk losing business and their competitive edge.

That is why we are looking at the holistic picture in our study. We are looking at rail, road, public transport and active travel, although the study will focus on the ports at Cairnryan because of their strategic importance. For example, the Government has provided other assistance, with a grant of £1.3 million through Scottish Enterprise. We understand the importance of both ports.

For the study, consultants will be commissioned to analyse road-based freight on the A75 and the A77 and to estimate the value of goods going into the ports, which will aid analysis of the economic value of the ports. The economic significance of the ports to the area and to the country more widely will, therefore, be a key part of the study. Stena Line and P&O have both made a strong case to me in that regard.

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

You acknowledge the investment that Stena Line and P&O have made in the ports infrastructure, but the committee has heard that that investment has not reached its full potential due to a lack of investment in road improvements. One written submission goes so far as to say that the current infrastructure on the A77 “strangles economic activity”. What is your response to that?

Humza Yousaf SNP Glasgow Pollok
link

I have probably touched on this in previous answers. We have invested in the A75 and the A77 but we are getting clear, consistent messages from campaigners and members representing all the different political parties that, because of the strategic importance of the Cairnryan ports, we need to invest to unleash further economic potential. That is why we are undertaking a study that will look at that in a holistic manner. We will examine not only the transport infrastructure, as we have plans for a south of Scotland enterprise agency, but we will have to introduce legislation to get the ball rolling on that. That fits in with the work that I am doing and that the cabinet secretary, Keith Brown, is doing to consider the wider economic picture.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

We want to understand the economic profile of Dumfries and Galloway and how it compares to the wider profile of the Scottish economy. I have in mind, for example, business start-up rates, business survival rates, employment rates and migration patterns into and out of the area. Could you supply us with information of that type?

Humza Yousaf SNP Glasgow Pollok
link

I do not have that information to hand, but perhaps I can go through the convener, as is usually appropriate, to get you some detail on migration patterns in and out of south-west Scotland. We are committed to establishing a new enterprise agency in the south of Scotland that will drive inclusive growth, but we are also committed to working with local authorities to shape the borderlands inclusive growth initiative, which was mentioned in the UK Government’s budget speech yesterday. We will work with partners and will have detailed discussions with the Dumfries and Galloway and Scottish Borders councils to explore a deal that supports their aspirations. I will write to the convener with the detailed information on business start-ups and migration patterns, and she will, no doubt, share that information with the other committee members.

Angus MacDonald SNP Falkirk East
link

Let us turn to the Cairnryan landslip and other landslips along the A77. We are encouraged that work to repair the Cairnyan landslip is due be completed early next year. However, the petitioners are seeking action on a number of other landslip sites along the route. Why has there been such a delay in resolving the Cairnryan landslip, particularly when similar situations appear to be resolved more quickly? What plans does the Scottish Government have to repair the other landslips along the A77?

Humza Yousaf SNP Glasgow Pollok
link

When I met the A77 action group recently, I could sense their frustration. There were a number of councillors present at the meeting, and I know that one councillor, in particular, is very keen to see a resolution to the A77 landslip. I am well aware of, and completely share, the frustrations of the community in regard to landslip issues.

As you will know, the A77 landslip at Cairnryan is on its way to being resolved. These things are not simple and can take a long time to resolve however it might look to an outside eye. Complex engineering solutions are needed, particularly considering the gradient of the slope, and ground investigations have to take place. In this case, specialist geotechnical engineering input was needed. I share the frustrations of Angus MacDonald and the action group that the process took so long, but I give the petitioner a degree of reassurance, I hope, by saying that the improvement works commenced on 30 October. Depending on the weather, they are due to be completed by the end of February 2018.

On other landslips, Angus MacDonald will know that our operating company delivered the improvements to the A77 at Kennedy’s Pass on 10 September this year. On the wider issue, Transport Scotland issued a south west unit landslide action plan, which includes Cairnryan, on 27 October. We have budgeted for resolving some of the landslip issues, but the community is absolutely right to be frustrated by the amount of time that it has taken. We will work hard to resolve the issues sooner rather than later.

Humza Yousaf SNP Glasgow Pollok
link

As I mentioned, the plan is to resolve the landslip at Cairnryan by February next year, although I always add the caveat that that is weather dependent. Just this week, we have seen landslips across the country, further north, close to Dingwall. The safety of workers and engineers while they repair landslips is important, but the programme is to have the repairs done by February 2018.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

There were temporary traffic lights sitting on the A77 at one of the landslips for four years. You may recognise where the frustration comes from. You discussed the complexities of some of the issues, but the Government managed to build a bridge over the Forth for £1.7 billion in six years. That leads some people to reflect that the area around the A77 is the forgotten part of Scotland. Four years is too long to have temporary traffic lights.

Humza Yousaf SNP Glasgow Pollok
link

I agree with the first part of your question on having temporary traffic lights for that length of time. You will have an issue with temporary traffic lights for a number of years at Enterkinfoot on the A76. It is frustrating, but the reason that the landslip was not resolved was not budgetary; it was largely due to engineering complexities and the nature of the A77, which we have spoken about extensively. The diversion of routes can cause long tailbacks, which is why looking at further investment and the holistic picture of the A77 and the A75 is so important. I understand the frustration, which is why we published the action plan in October. I hope that it will give some reassurance to those on the A77.

Michelle Ballantyne Con South Scotland
link

I have a couple of final questions for you. One is supplementary to the question that my colleague Brian Whittle asked about a wider profile for the Dumfries and Galloway review. When you conduct the review of the roads, will you include the wider economic profile of the region? Some of the evidence that we took mentioned that, when there is an accident on the road, it puts people off living there, makes people rethink their businesses and, in effect, causes businesses to fail because it has an impact. Will you consider that wider aspect?

10:30

Michelle Ballantyne Con South Scotland
link

I recognise that we do not get a resolution of such matters overnight. Stena Line has suggested that you could get a quick win by implementing a 50mph limit on the A77. I assume that that is to do with preventing accidents. What is your view of that suggestion? Could any other quick wins be implemented in the interim while you work towards a bigger solution?

Humza Yousaf SNP Glasgow Pollok
link

I am not convinced that raising the speed limit is necessarily a quick win.

Humza Yousaf SNP Glasgow Pollok
link

I thought that you were talking about increasing it from 40mph to 50mph for heavy goods vehicles. Is that not what you were saying?

Michelle Ballantyne Con South Scotland
link

Stena Line did not specifically say that; it just asked for a 50mph limit.

Humza Yousaf SNP Glasgow Pollok
link

Aye, which would be an increase in the speed limit, because it is currently 40mph for HGVs. That is not necessarily a quick win, because we all know that every study under the sun has shown that increasing speed limits for any type of vehicle has road safety implications.

That said, we are trialling an increase in the speed limit for HGVs to 50mph on the A9. That is being done on that road because we have average speed cameras on it. We are trialling that over three years to find out the effects on road safety. I will double-check when that pilot is due to finish. If the evidence from it shows that there is a quick win, as you characterise it, from increasing speed limits, we will consider that.

It is difficult to identify other quick wins. If we want to make a significant intervention in transport, it has to go through the statutory process. Even investments such as those in the Dunragit bypass, in which we invested about £17.5 million, or the Maybole bypass, which we are currently planning, have to go through the statutory process and that can take time, especially if there are objections to them, because there then has to be a public local inquiry.

There is space to consider what might be, in transport terms, relatively short to medium-term interventions versus long-term ambitions and interventions. I would be cautious about raising the speed limit for HGVs to 50mph, though. There is a pilot going on, so let us see what the results of that are. Road safety must never be compromised.

Michelle Ballantyne Con South Scotland
link

I suppose that I was having a dumb moment there. That proposal is about reducing the potential for overtaking or people getting frustrated behind vehicles and forcing themselves into the overtaking position, which is often the cause of accidents. On a road such as the A77, the aim is to keep the traffic moving without detrimental impacts.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Given the fact that it has been suggested that that might help and that it is exactly the same measure as the pilot that is taking place on the A9, could you not trial it in both places at the same time?

Humza Yousaf SNP Glasgow Pollok
link

We are piloting a scheme at the moment, and I would need to look at the exact profile. There are average speed cameras on the A77, but it would depend on which parts of the route we were talking about. We can give the matter some consideration.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

You said that it would be a bad idea because, if we increase speed, that can cause problems. I presume that there is evidence to back that up. Nevertheless, if you have a pilot that is doing exactly what has been suggested for the A77, you should do that in both places.

Humza Yousaf SNP Glasgow Pollok
link

We can give it some consideration, as I said. The reason for piloting the measure on the A9 is that we have controlled conditions because of the average speed cameras.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Did you not install the average speed cameras in order to deliver the pilot?

Humza Yousaf SNP Glasgow Pollok
link

The average speed cameras are there because the road is unsafe, as the fatal accident and casualty statistics show.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Forgive me; I am asking you because I do not know. Is it the case that the average speed cameras were already installed and, because they are there, you can facilitate the pilot? If so, does that not mean that you could do the same thing on the A77?

Humza Yousaf SNP Glasgow Pollok
link

You mean that we could install average speed cameras.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Yes. That would then allow you to conduct a pilot in parallel with the one on the A9.

Humza Yousaf SNP Glasgow Pollok
link

We can give that consideration, but it would obviously come at a cost. Others might say that, rather than spend that money on average speed cameras on that chunk of road, they would spend it on interventions on the road.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

The cost has been met in other parts of the country, which perhaps makes the case for people who feel that the same test is not being applied in all parts of the country. Also, the cost of the test would be met not from the transport budget but from the economic impact budget.

Humza Yousaf SNP Glasgow Pollok
link

I visit communities around the country, and a number of them want average speed cameras. Those come at a cost, but there may be specific accident hotspots. The A77 and A75 are not immune to hotspots, but the cameras were put on the A9 in the first place because of the high number of fatal accidents and casualties on that road. There are cameras on the A90 between Dundee and Stonehaven for that reason as well.

My officials might have a little more information on this, but I think that the pilot is at the halfway stage, so it has been going on for about a year and a half. Even if we got a new pilot up and running within six months, the other pilot would be two years in. I think that it will be better to see the results of the pilot—even interim results—and then, if it makes sense, to raise the HGV limit from 40mph to 50mph. Nevertheless, we will consider your suggestion.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

I urge you to look at the submissions on that issue. The initial reaction was that such a measure would not work because it is not a good idea. However, when it is established that the exact same measure has been taken elsewhere in the country, people will ask why, when evidence has come forward to do as Stena Line has suggested, you would not test the A77 in the same way. I take on board that you have said that you will look at the idea further.

It would be useful if you could get back to the committee on that and with the information that Brian Whittle asked for. It would be really helpful if we could get that in the next fortnight, as that would allow the petitioner to respond to your evidence before our next examination of the petition.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

I will take Michelle Ballantyne briefly, and I will then allow Finlay Carson in, since he has been very well behaved.

Michelle Ballantyne Con South Scotland
link

Minister, you said several times during your discussion with the convener that there is a cost for running a pilot. In the three months since I got involved with the petitions and heard the first evidence on PE1657, there have been, to my knowledge, three bad accidents on the A77. The road has been blocked, everything has been held up, and there has been significant input by services. That is a cost. Therefore, any measures that could prevent those things from happening will be offset anyway. It is not always about adding costs; sometimes it is about avoiding alternative costs.

Humza Yousaf SNP Glasgow Pollok
link

Sure. If we could reduce road accidents to zero, that is where we would want to be. All of us around this table share that ambition. One death on a road is one too many.

Humza Yousaf SNP Glasgow Pollok
link

There is, but we also have to look at the statistics. I will give Michelle Ballantyne some information. In 2015, there were 38 accidents in total from Whitletts roundabout to Stranraer on the A77. This year, up to 14 September, the number was down to 21. We have to wait until the end of the year to get the full statistics, and winter can be a particularly difficult time for accidents, but that demonstrates, cautiously, that there is a reduction in the number of accidents that are taking place.

Humza Yousaf SNP Glasgow Pollok
link

I accept that that is a significant cost. I am not arguing against that; my point is that the trajectory is going in the right direction. I am not dismissing the fact that there is a cost.

The reason why average speed cameras have just gone live on the A90 from Dundee to Stonehaven, for example, is that we have to look at priorities. If I could have average speed cameras along the entire length of our trunk road network from the Borders to Wick, I am sure that we would look to having them, but we have to prioritise areas where there are significant fatal accidents. That is not at all to dismiss the 21 accidents on the A77 to date this year. I am simply saying that the reality is that there are significant pressures on Government budgets. Where we can make our roads safer, let us make sure that we put in interventions to do that, but we face those pressures.

The convener suggested that we go back and look at the implications of a pilot to raise the HGV speed limit from 40mph to 50mph. We will consider doing that, but we have done that in a controlled pilot on the A9. Road safety will be paramount, of course, and if there are any indications that that will make accidents with HGVs any more likely, we will not push ahead with that course of action.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

On the test, you said that other areas were prioritised before the A77. Are priorities determined simply by numbers, or is the economic impact tested? As you have quite rightly said, no fatalities are acceptable and you want to have as high a level of road safety as possible but, if you were making strategic decisions about where you would go first, would you look at the impact in snarling up a whole area? That could be a huge impact. People might make economic decisions not to put freight through a particular road and to put it through another. Is that assessment made, or are priorities determined simply by numbers? I go back to my question on the extent to which transport decisions, which are entirely rational, might not necessarily be the same if you looked at the issue in the broader economic context for the whole of Scotland.

Humza Yousaf SNP Glasgow Pollok
link

First and foremost, speed cameras are deployed where they have the greatest potential to reduce injury collisions and there is evidence of both collisions and speeding. The vital factor is where the impact on reducing injury collisions will be greatest. That is not the only factor, as the convener has suggested, but it is the number 1 factor.

Finlay Carson Con Galloway and West Dumfries
link

I have very few questions left to ask and plenty of answers, so I commend committee members on how well they have covered the petitions. I thank them for that, because the petitions are of huge importance to people in south-west Scotland.

I want to raise a couple of points. It is of no comfort at all to anybody in the south-west when we hear figures quoted about how much investment has been made in maintenance on the road. Over the past few years, the biggest bulk of the money has been on the maintenance or rebuild of the Gatehouse of Fleet and Ringford bypass. If that money had not been spent, the road would have had to be closed, because it was breaking up. The holes got bigger with every lorry that went over them, and there was a road safety issue. We despair when we hear figures being bandied about on how much investment there has been in the road, because that goes only on keeping it open.

I would like more work to be done on the impact of closures of the A75 in particular and on the impact of road closures on the ferry traffic that travels up the A77. There are regularly long detours after accidents on the A75 and the A77, and we all know that accident investigations take considerably longer than they used to. The number of road closures makes companies think twice about siting depots in that area because of the effect on their ability to deliver goods on time. I have spoken to two companies in Stranraer whose decisions about expanding have been affected by closures of the A77 and the A75.

I want to put on the record something that was mentioned at our private meeting with the petitioners last week. When the port in Cairnryan was opened, the First Minister at the time gave a commitment to provide additional overtaking opportunities on the A75. Two have been delivered, but six were promised at the time. Those projects should have been scoped and shovels should have been in the ground. They should have been delivered by now; those are broken commitments and promises. This has been going on for a long time. I hope that, after your survey has been done and it comes back with recommendations, we will not be sitting here in 20 years’ time restating that commitments to road improvements have not been delivered.

The minister quoted the increased percentage of traffic flow around the Maybole bypass and the percentage of the total cost. Is that based on the Maybole section or on the whole length of the A77? How does that compare with the traffic flow and the percentage cost of the A9? When it comes to those figures, it is important that there is equity and equality for the south-west. I would not like to think that those statistics are taken in isolation. It would be useful to see the cost benefit analysis of dualling the A9 and not the Maybole bypass.

10:45

Humza Yousaf SNP Glasgow Pollok
link

I take issue with some of Finlay Carson’s statements. I do not know where the promise of six overtaking lanes came from. If he can furnish me with that information, it would be most helpful. I do not know whether he has it in front of him.

Humza Yousaf SNP Glasgow Pollok
link

It would be useful if you could forward that because, as you acknowledged, we have invested in overtaking lanes. The point that I made about maintenance before you came into the meeting was that maintenance is essential but, if you talked to local authority partners, you would know that money that should be spent on road maintenance is sometimes not spent on that. That was highlighted by the Public Audit and Post-legislative Scrutiny Committee. Such investment is important, but there has been significant additional investment in both the A75 and A77. I understand the desire of local communities for more. If you can furnish me with a copy of the promise for six overtaking lanes, I will consider it.

The Maybole bypass scheme will deliver 85 per cent of the benefit for 60 per cent of the cost. It is deeply unwise to pit one part of the country against another. There are a number of reasons for the dualling of the A9 and A96 and, if it is appropriate, I can forward you the information that you are seeking via the convener. The work is part of the city deals strategy connecting seven cities by dual carriageway, which is a laudable aim. Any country would want all of its cities to be connected in that way.

However, we should continue to invest, as we have promised, in other parts of the country. The dualling of the A9 and A96 clearly fits into the city strategy. You will make the argument, as you did fairly in our meeting last week, that the connections between the south-west and the central belt are of great strategic importance, not only to Scotland but to the rest of the UK and potentially to Europe because of the E18 route. I accept that view, which is why are conducting the study that will examine road, rail and public transport improvements with an economic focus particularly on the ports of Cairnryan.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

It would be useful if the minister shared a copy of the promise with the committee as well, as not all Government promises are written in stone.

The concern highlighted by Finlay Carson is that money that is described as investment in roads is used for maintenance of roads, which is a consequence of other work not happening. You said that local authorities get money to maintain roads but they do not spend it on maintenance. To what extent does that happen? Have you conducted an analysis of that? What will you do about that? It is unfortunate that local authorities are being given money to maintain roads but they are not doing that. I presume that there should be a reaction from the Government to try to understand why that is happening. What remedial measures will you take to prevent that from happening?

Humza Yousaf SNP Glasgow Pollok
link

I will forward the information that I have on the roads collaboration programme. We work closely with our partners in local government on the issue of roads maintenance. I have a particularly good relationship with the Society of Chief Officers of Transportation in Scotland. I understand the pressures on local government and I was not having a go at local authorities in this regard, but when there are pressures on their budgets, road maintenance is not the number 1 priority. The Audit Scotland report on this highlighted the difference between the condition of the trunk road network and that of the local road network. There was a substantial difference in maintenance. I have increased the maintenance budget but, where local authorities face budgetary pressures, we are trying to get them to collaborate with neighbouring local authorities. The Ayrshire Roads Alliance is an example of that. I will furnish you with details about what we are doing in relation to road maintenance with local authorities. Significant work is on-going in that respect and I can pass on information about that to the committee.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

That would be very helpful. I appreciate that the decisions about disproportionate cuts to local government budgets are not for you, but the difference in road maintenance is perhaps one of the impacts of that. I was concerned that you were suggesting that people at the local government level were making decisions that were having an impact more broadly, and I am comforted to know that you are having a conversation about that.

Michelle Ballantyne Con South Scotland
link

The roads that we are discussing are not local government-maintained roads.

Humza Yousaf SNP Glasgow Pollok
link

I do not think that I ever made that suggestion. I made the point that some people were somewhat dismissing our spend on maintenance and saying that we were doing that only because we had to. That is a political consideration that we make because we think that maintaining the roads is important.

Of course there is still work for the Government to do on maintaining roads, but I simply make the point that you will see from the Audit Scotland report that there is a stark difference between the spend on the trunk road network and the spend on local roads. As I say, I understand the pressures on local government, and we are working closely with it to try to face down some of the challenges on road maintenance.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

I will make sure that the committee is furnished with the Audit Scotland report.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

Do you envisage that the outcome of the study will be to give you a long-term strategic plan—an end goal, if you like—for the A75 and the A77? Without that, the measures that you are taking will simply be sticking plasters.

Humza Yousaf SNP Glasgow Pollok
link

That is a good question. The study will look at the next 20 years, so it will be a long-term forecast without a doubt. I agree with you that we should not be short-sighted.

It is an opportune moment to do the study, because it will feed into our national transport strategy review, which, again, is a 20-year vision for transport in the future. That will feed into the STPR, which is about the investment in our infrastructure that we will look to make over the coming period.

I get what you are insinuating, and you are right to suggest that no one wants a study for the sake of a study. We want to see concrete actions as a result. My caveat to that is that a process must be followed. Various organisations, groups and MSPs are engaging in that process. If I were using the A77 and the A75, I would be hopeful that there would be future strategic investment to those trunk road networks.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Finlay Carson said that he hoped that we would not be here in 20 years’ time. I would quite like to be around in 20 years’ time, but I am not planning to be convener of this committee then. Laughter.

On the subject of a 20-year stretch, the petition on the A77 was the second ever to be presented to the committee. Some of you were probably still at school back then—I am not bitter about that either.

It is very clear that the committee wants to look further at the petition. Are there any suggestions on how we might do that? We will be getting a number of bits of information, including public audit information and information from the minister.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

I think that the minister said in the meeting to which he referred that the study would be started in the next month or two. That was a week ago, and a month comprises four or five weeks. I want to know when the study will start and when it is likely to conclude.

The A77 is the only trunk road in Scotland with a 20mph and 30mph limit. From the Whitletts roundabout, you can get all the way to Inverness, across to Berwick and down to Barcelona without hitting another 30mph zone.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

We could ask the minister to provide information on that, too. Perhaps it would be useful to reflect on today’s evidence and to get a report from the clerks, which will then allow the petitioner to respond to what we have heard. A lot of interesting information has been provided.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

I thank the minister for how he has conducted himself. We have given him a bit of a hard time, but he has not hidden from our questions.

Humza Yousaf SNP Glasgow Pollok
link

Trust me, as transport minister, I know that it is not easy to hide, although I have tried my best at times.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

I very much appreciate the minister coming along today. I make the point that the committee considers that there is a broader economic context to this matter, but the Scottish Government made a decision that the transport minister, rather than the cabinet secretary, would attend. However, we are looking for assurances from the Scottish Government that it understands that we are talking not about individual transport projects but about the significant economic impact for business in that part of the country, which impacts on the rest of Scotland.

I thank the minister and his officials for their attendance. We will reflect on how we want to take forward the petition. I suspend the meeting briefly to allow the witnesses to leave.

10:55 Meeting suspended.

10:58 On resuming—

  1. 09:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 21
  2. 09:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 90
  3. 09:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 88
  4. 10:45 New Petitions Petitions · 40

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.