Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Continued Petitions

Children (Scotland) Act 1995 (Section 11) (PE1635)

Thursday 23 November 2017 Public Petitions Committee About 09:00–09:45 Petitions 90 contributions · 8 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

90 contributions
Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Agenda item 2 is the taking of evidence on a continued petition, PE1635, by Emma McDonald, which calls for a review of section 11 of the Children (Scotland) Act 1995. I welcome Neil Findlay.

Recent correspondence from the Scottish Government and the petitioner has been circulated with our meeting papers, along with a range of documents and papers that are referred to in the submissions.

Our previous consideration of the petition was in May, when we took evidence in a round-table format from Relationships Scotland, Families Need Fathers Scotland, the Children and Young People’s Commissioner Scotland, Scottish Women’s Aid and the ASSIST project. That session was very useful in informing our thinking on the petition, and it drew out a number of issues that the committee agreed to explore with the Scottish Government.

I welcome Annabelle Ewing, the Minister for Community Safety and Legal Affairs, and Simon Stockwell, head of family and property law at the Scottish Government. Thank you for attending, minister. You have up to five minutes to make some opening remarks, after which we will move to questions.

Annabelle Ewing SNP The Minister for Community Safety and Legal Affairs · Cowdenbeath
link

Good morning. Thank you for the opportunity to make a short opening statement. Before I do so, I draw members’ attention to my entry in the register of members’ interests, which notes that I am a member of the Law Society of Scotland, as I hold a current practising certificate—albeit that I do not currently practise.

The Scottish Government recognises the concerns that are raised by the petition. The petitioner is not alone in having those concerns, as a good proportion of my ministerial correspondence is about contact and residence cases. Having recognised that there were concerns, we made a commitment to consult next year on potential changes to primary legislation in that area, and we are committed to making changes to improve the system, where we can, in advance of primary legislation. For example, we have chaired a working group on child welfare reporters, who provide reports to the sheriff in such cases. That working group led to greater clarity in court rules on the remit of reporters, and it produced a guide for parties and guidance for reporters. We are currently preparing a guide for children on the work of reporters.

In another area, we recommended to the family law committee of the Scottish Civil Justice Council, which works on court rules, that the court form that is used to obtain the voice of the child in such cases should be improved. That work has been taken forward, and rules to put in place a new, more child-friendly form will be considered at the next meeting of the family law committee of the Scottish Civil Justice Council on 5 February 2018.

We also recommended to the family law committee that changes should be made to the case management of family actions. A sub-committee has reported on suggested improvements in that area, and the Scottish Civil Justice Council has just agreed that there will be an open consultation on the proposals. We await the exact timings of that consultation.

I recognise the particular concerns that have been raised by the petition on child contact centres. Next year’s Scottish Government consultation will discuss the role and remit of those centres. It will also seek views on regulating them. In the meantime, the Scottish Government is making it clear to Relationships Scotland and the four independent child contact centres that we expect those centres to offer safe, secure and welcoming environments.

Next year’s Scottish Government consultation will be wide ranging. Its timing is no accident. As the committee will be well aware, the Domestic Abuse (Scotland) Bill is currently being considered by the Justice Committee. The bill is about the criminal justice response to domestic abuse, but points are being raised during its passage about the civil justice response to domestic abuse in areas such as contact. We will cover those issues in next year’s consultation.

To recap, among other issues, next year’s consultation will include consideration of the regulation of child welfare reporters, including issues to do with training; the regulation of child contact centres; the protection of domestic abuse victims when contact cases are being heard and the need to consider further how contact cases are dealt with when domestic abuse has been alleged; and further steps to ensure that the voice of the child is heard in contact cases.

In conclusion, the Government recognises that action is needed in the areas that the petition identifies. I look forward to answering the committee’s questions.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Thank you. The petitioner’s most recent submission sets out some concerns about the consultation that is to be undertaken by the Government and details a number of questions that she would like to be asked. How would you respond to the concern about the consultation and the business and regulatory impact assessment being a means of

“pushing the issue further into the future and putting off taking any action”?

Annabelle Ewing SNP Cowdenbeath
link

I noted the petitioner’s submission in that regard. The business and regulatory impact assessment, or BRIA, is a normal part of the process of proceeding with legislation and having consultation—that is absolutely standard. We have gone out to talk to stakeholders about it.

The consultation will be publicised on the Scottish Government website in the normal way, and I imagine that it will be picked up by the media, because the subject is sensitive and people will have differing views on the way forward on family law issues.

The petitioner wondered how her views could be factored into the consultation. It will be an open consultation. In correspondence that I have received as minister that has raised cases in this area, we have flagged up next year’s consultation and have asked whether the correspondent would wish to be added to the list of people with whom we will make direct contact. If the petitioner would wish to be in that position, we would be happy to facilitate that.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

The business and regulatory impact assessment seems to have a higher profile than in other consultations that I have seen. Are you saying that, when you do a consultation, that bit of the process is always the same?

Annabelle Ewing SNP Cowdenbeath
link

We have to have a BRIA to proceed with legislation. We felt it prudent to start to engage with stakeholders now, which is part of the standard process.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

I suppose that I was trying to get at whether the BRIA would normally be as highlighted as it has been in this consultation. I have not noticed it before, but that might be because, on this occasion, it has been drawn to my attention. It seems more evident than it has been in the past.

Annabelle Ewing SNP Cowdenbeath
link

As far as I am concerned, it is fairly standard. I will ask Simon Stockwell to comment.

Simon Stockwell Scottish Government
link

With this BRIA, we took the approach of asking a wider range of questions than would perhaps be normal when preparing a BRIA. As the minister said, we prepare a BRIA for major consultations. When we looked at this consultation, we thought that it was an opportunity to seek information not just about costs and savings, but about the wider policy questions that stakeholders have raised and that people have mentioned in correspondence to the minister.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

You said that the consultation will be next year—in fact, I think that you said that it will be early in 2018, which is not very long now. Can you provide more specific dates? How long will it run for?

Annabelle Ewing SNP Cowdenbeath
link

We hope to have the consultation out in spring 2018; the consultation period is 12 weeks.

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

Good morning. You have acknowledged that Relationships Scotland has said that it would support external regulation of child contact centres. There was a consensus on that at our round-table session in June.

Serious concerns have arisen about the physical accommodation of contact centres and the potential impacts on child safety—you alluded to that in your opening statement. I am concerned about whether the timeframe for the consultation will enable the Government to take the necessary steps to ensure the safety of the physical environment at the earliest opportunity. The fact that there is to be a 12-week consultation next year means that children will continue to attend those centres for quite a while when they will not be entirely safe. There is still quite a wee way to go.

Annabelle Ewing SNP Cowdenbeath
link

I do not know whether I would accept that the children are not entirely safe. Relationships Scotland, which has 45 or 46 of the contact centres in Scotland, has a quality assurance framework whereby it has various policies and standards in place. It has staff training, as it has mentioned in its submission to the committee. Although the bricks and mortar varies from place to place, I recently visited the Avenue service in Aberdeen and the Family Mediation Central Scotland office in Stirling—it also has offices in Alloa and Falkirk—and I left without any qualms. The issues are dealt with with the utmost seriousness. The respective heads of the Avenue and the centre in Stirling have been working in the field for many years and, for them, the safety of the child in the contact centre is absolutely paramount.

09:15

I take the wider point about how we will progress the matter and the need to proceed with the consultation. That will not to lead to primary legislation overnight. We would be happy to continue our dialogue with Relationships Scotland and, indeed, with the four independent contact centres with which we have been in touch, to ensure that all relevant safety and other standards are being adhered to.

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

If I understand you correctly, you are saying that you will be making extra checks on the centres. When we took evidence, we heard about some incidents. Those might have been specific to one centre, but they were alarming—there were child safety issues, with children being left unaccompanied with boiling water and allowed to run out into the street. Will you commit to saying that, until the consultation is completed, the existing centres will be checked and staff refreshed on the safety aspects of their duties?

Annabelle Ewing SNP Cowdenbeath
link

If there are issues to do with physical safety, a number of rules come into play, particularly those on health and safety. It would be really helpful for the Government to know if health and safety issues have been raised in relation to specific contact centres, because we would not hesitate to pursue those issues via the relevant channels to ensure that safety standards are being adhered to.

We will do what we can, but the issue that we need to address—and which we will address through the consultation process—is that there is no regulatory base on which to act. However, as I say, we are in dialogue with Relationships Scotland and the other four contact centres, and we have made it clear that we expect them to be safe, secure and welcoming. We will ensure that we continue to monitor the situation.

Angus MacDonald SNP Falkirk East
link

Good morning, minister. Good morning, Mr Stockwell. I will stick to the child-centred approach and ensuring that a child’s voice is heard. The petitioner has offered her observations on the working group on child welfare reporters. She considers that that seems to

“merely represent what has been the status quo”

as per the Government’s “Guide to the Child Welfare Report”.

The petitioner notes that the guide says that a child’s views could be included in a child welfare report, while it appears that the aim of the family justice modernisation strategy is to

“ensure the voice of the child is fully heard”.

What is your response to those concerns?

Annabelle Ewing SNP Cowdenbeath
link

I noted those comments. There might be a slight misunderstanding about the scope, because in circumstances in which there was a new-born baby, the part of the form that deals with that would not be relevant. There is no intention behind this other than simply to reflect that the child could be of any age.

On the child’s voice being heard, that key issue will very much be part of the consultation, because we recognise the very important work that is going on in that area. An example of that is the power up/power down project. There are many interesting strands to the work, and we are keen to ensure that that issue is fully debated in the consultation.

On the issue of the child welfare reporters, as I have mentioned, we have been carrying out a number of activities. One was to ensure that guidance was available for child welfare reporters and for the parties to the case, and we are working on guidance for children on child welfare reporters. There has also been a change in court rules in terms of remit to seek to make it possible for more specific instructions to be given to child welfare reporters in incident cases.

We have recommended that there be training. At the moment, the Lord President does not consider that that important issue can be proceeded with without a statutory basis, so that issue will be included in the consultation. However, we have written to the relevant bodies—the Law Society, the Faculty of Advocates, the Family Law Association Scotland and Social Work Scotland—to ask them to reflect on what training they can ensure that their members who are child welfare reporters have access to in the interim. It is not as if we are simply waiting for legislation. We are doing whatever we can that can be done outwith a legislative route, and we are happy to continue to engage in that way.

Michelle Ballantyne Con South Scotland
link

Funnily enough, I was going to ask about the qualifications of a child welfare reporter, but you have touched on that in the context of training. The petitioner has commented that, because solicitors are professional law practitioners, it should not be taken as read that they are the best option to fulfil the role of a child welfare reporter. She has compared it to the position of police officers, who have the same broad training, but some of whom receive specialist training if their role involves speaking to children. That is a good reflection on what needs to be done.

Minister, you mentioned the recommendations that have been made to you, but what are your thoughts on the need for anyone who carries out the role of child welfare reporter to have received specialist training? It is suggested that it might be beneficial to make more use of children’s rights officers or children’s advocacy workers to bridge the gap and allow a child to feel that their views are being heard and represented throughout the process. What is your view on that?

Annabelle Ewing SNP Cowdenbeath
link

On the first issue, we can all benefit from training in different walks of life. That is why we recommended that there be training, but we have hit this slight legal vacuum whereby we need to have primary legislation to do that, so we are taking the opportunity in the consultation to consult on that and on wider regulatory issues as well.

The issue of children’s rights officers involves local authorities and their resources, and how they interact with the civil legal system and, indeed, the criminal justice system in some cases. Therefore, the committee would need more information from the local authorities.

Michelle Ballantyne Con South Scotland
link

Dr Marsha Scott, who is very familiar with the role of children’s rights officers, particularly in West Lothian, commented that

“it is not rocket science”.—Official Report, Public Petitions Committee, 22 June 2017; c 10.

She said that it is important to have somebody who knows how to engage with children and win over their trust, and who understands the nature of domestic abuse. She pointed out that one officer has a case load of more than 200.

What is your view on managing workloads in whatever role is used to ensure that a child’s voice is heard? When someone is dealing with such a heavy case load, that definitely raises questions.

Annabelle Ewing SNP Cowdenbeath
link

When it comes to people who are employed by the local authorities, one would to need to discuss those matters with them, but the case-load issue has not been flagged up directly with me by the local authority concerned. If officials wish to write to me and meet me to have a discussion about that, I will be happy to do so, but that has not come up in correspondence with me.

On the wider issues that have been raised, the consultation will provide the opportunity to have a debate about the best model going forward. I accept that there will be many different views in that regard, and it may be that, for some people, the training of child welfare officers will be neither here nor there, because they would prefer to have something else in place. The consultation will provide the opportunity for a full discussion, and we will encourage as many people as possible to make submissions to it.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

Good morning. The annex to your submission provides the response from the Judicial Institute for Scotland with regard to the judicial training that has been available for the past year or so. I acknowledge that training is a matter for the Judicial Institute, but do you have any observations to make on the information that was provided?

Annabelle Ewing SNP Cowdenbeath
link

There has been some training. There was a suggestion in one of the submissions that I read that there was no training at all. The annex indicates the dates of the training, the topics covered and the total number of judges who attended, albeit that it was recognised that some judges might have been very diligent and attended several courses.

Brian Whittle is absolutely right to say that training is a matter for the Judicial Institute. It would not be appropriate for me, as the minister, given the independence of the courts, to dictate those matters to the Lord President, but we have raised the issue with the Lord President. We will continue to reflect back the comments that we receive on the subject matter but, at the end of the day, while we can work with the Lord President, ultimately it is up to the Judicial Institute to determine such matters.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

I will address training for contact centre staff and volunteers. When we took evidence from the petitioner, concern was expressed about how much time is spent on training staff. There was a sense that it varies according to resources, both in terms of personnel and funding. At a round-table meeting, we heard that there is a range of training to take account of two types of contact—supervised contact and supported contact. Much more in-depth training and knowledge are required to facilitate supervised contact which, we heard, accounts for approximately 10 per cent of all contact and requires two well-trained members of staff. What are your views on requirements for consistency in training, and what would you consider to be the minimum requirement?

Annabelle Ewing SNP Cowdenbeath
link

The submissions that we have received reflected—Relationships Scotland certainly made the point—that there is training, although they acknowledged that the number of available hours varies. I think that the training for supported contact is shorter than that for supervised contact, the training for which is more intensive in order to reflect the more complex scenarios that are presented in supervised contact.

We accept that there are concerns about consistency in the level of training. It is one of the issues that we will address next year in the consultation, which will include looking at regulation of contact centres.

Michelle Ballantyne Con South Scotland
link

That leads very nicely to the thorny question of funding arrangements for contact centres, in so far as they apply to centres that are operated by Relationships Scotland. The information that has been provided to us suggests that its network receives approximately £866,000 annually. The majority of that—£700,000—comes from the Big Lottery Fund and £166,000 comes from the Scottish Government. That funding covers 45 or 46 centres and somewhere in the region of 400 members of staff and volunteers, which is an average of about £18,000 per contact centre. Can you comment on the amount and sources of funding, given the role that contact centres are playing?

Annabelle Ewing SNP Cowdenbeath
link

I anticipated a question on funding. In 2016-17, £1.5 million was given to Relationships Scotland. The same amount was given again in 2017-18. In addition, the Scottish Government provided £370,000 to Relationships Scotland over the past three years to allow it to establish and develop its parenting apart service. Those resources come from the early years portfolio rather than the justice portfolio. It is important to flag that up so that if the committee has supplementary questions, you will know where to direct them in the first instance.

As far as the justice portfolio is concerned, it is important to bear it in mind that the Scottish legal aid fund also comes into play for supervised contact. In 2016-17, the amount that was sanctioned for supervised access was £481,973. It is important to give the committee that wider picture: the Scottish Government has not provided just £166,000, full stop.

Michelle Ballantyne Con South Scotland
link

That was a very fortuitous comment, because my supplementary question is about legal aid. You are quite right: according to figures that we have been given, a big chunk of the extra funding that is required by clients to access contact centres comes from legal aid.

One concern is what happens when a client does not qualify for legal aid. Can you give us an example of what happens in that scenario?

Annabelle Ewing SNP Cowdenbeath
link

I will have to look into that, although I imagine that that is the exception rather than the rule.

Simon Stockwell Scottish Government
link

We can look into that. Some contact centres would probably charge, and the charge would vary from centre to centre. Many supervised contact cases are legally aided, but we probably do not have a precise split of how many are and how many are not. The expectation is that many such cases get legal aid.

Michelle Ballantyne Con South Scotland
link

That would be a good thing to look at, because there is a question about what happens in such situations.

Annabelle Ewing SNP Cowdenbeath
link

The answer will depend on how the information is broken down, but we will try to that find it out, if it is available.

09:30

Michelle Ballantyne Con South Scotland
link

It may be worth recognising where there is not a requirement but there is a fear, and therefore people are asking for that support through a contact centre. It would be good to know why they are being turned down, and the number of cases that are being turned down.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Rona Mackay wants to ask a supplementary question. Do you want to ask your main question at the same time?

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

Yes.

The Relationships Scotland submission says that it is developing a strategic post of head of professional practice for child contact centres, which would be a step in the right direction. However, that post will be funded only until March 2019, and the funding will come from its reserves. Could there be a problem with ongoing funding to retain that post?

Annabelle Ewing SNP Cowdenbeath
link

Regarding the contribution that the organisation gets from the Scottish Government, we are going into the draft budget period. Far be it from me to prejudge Mr Mackay’s processes—

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Surely you will make a presentation to the Cabinet Secretary for Finance and Sustainable Growth. It would be for you to judge that and to inform him that funds should be provided.

Annabelle Ewing SNP Cowdenbeath
link

The budget heading is in the early years portfolio, but I will pass that comment on to colleagues. Relationships Scotland has advised that it has managed to find money from its reserves, notwithstanding the fact that initially it did not think—

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Might it be the case that the organisation had to find the money from its reserves because nobody else was going to fund the post. I am interested in how that works. Relationships Scotland found the money because it recognised that there was a need, but because it found the money, it will not qualify for funding, which is a little perverse.

Annabelle Ewing SNP Cowdenbeath
link

The organisation found the money from its reserves and says that the money will be in place until March 2019. I will certainly pass on the convener’s comments to colleagues in the early years portfolio.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Is the funding that Relationships Scotland is being given for contact centres secure past March 2019?

Annabelle Ewing SNP Cowdenbeath
link

Its budgetary funding award is to March 2019. I am not in a position to say what its funding will be beyond then.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

So, Relationships Scotland cannot have any confidence to plan ahead.

Annabelle Ewing SNP Cowdenbeath
link

The budget has not been drafted or approved by Parliament. We are about to go through the budget process, so I cannot offer a guarantee or make a statement about that.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

If contact centres are fundamental to child protection and to supervision and are being directed by the courts to provide that service, should not they have secure funding?

Annabelle Ewing SNP Cowdenbeath
link

I do not know. You are arguing that bodies like Relationships Scotland should have secure funding, but for how many years? Should it be five, 10, 15 or 20 years? I do not know. That is another budget discussion to be had.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Something that may come out of our deliberations is why a voluntary body should provide a service that has been directed by the courts. That is part of the dilemma that we face.

Annabelle Ewing SNP Cowdenbeath
link

Although the organisation will be directed by the courts, most support will be paid for out of legal aid funds, as has been mentioned.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

We do not know whether that will be the case. Legal aid is certainly not paid for all cases.

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

What is the minister’s response to concerns about people’s confidence in the system? Serious concerns have been raised during evidence sessions. Will the consultation allay those fears?

Annabelle Ewing SNP Cowdenbeath
link

The consultation affords an opportunity to have a good discussion about where we will go from here. It is recognised in some submissions that how contact centres have developed has been driven by local community developments. They have evolved in an ad hoc fashion; therefore, it is time to have a look at them. The petition reminds us that consultation would be a useful process on which to embark. I was struck when I visited Family Mediation Central Scotland’s centre in Stirling a few weeks ago that 65 per cent of cases involve contact referral work. We should all bear that interesting statistic in mind as we look to the future.

Neil Findlay Lab Lothian
link

We are dealing with the issue only because of the ambivalent attitude of the Scottish Government when I raised the matter a few years ago after the petitioner, who is a constituent of mine, came to speak to me. Had the issue been taken seriously at that point, we might never have reached this position, but we are where we are.

I always get worried when people say that things will happen in the spring, because in Parliament spring can run anywhere from January to December. A firm timeline on when we will see action would be helpful because the minister mentioned spring, but she also mentioned a 12-week consultation. What is the end point? When will the action point be? That is the most critical thing.

This is a very good example of how the rhetoric of wanting Scotland to be the best place for children to grow up in is not matched by the reality, so my first question is to ask whether the minister personally supports regulation of child contact centres.

Annabelle Ewing SNP Cowdenbeath
link

I do not want to pre-empt the consultation, but I can see that regulation is almost certainly the way forward. Relationships Scotland has acknowledged that and has no objection. When I spoke to the workers at the Avenue and the Family Mediation Central Scotland centres, they were quite happy with that, too.

I appreciate that Neil Findlay has represented his constituent well, and I do not want to take away from that, but it is not quite fair to say that the Scottish Government is ambivalent on the issue. We are very clear that a number of things need to be done. We need to have a proper consultation and a proper discussion, then to reflect on that and work out the best way to proceed, be that primary legislation for some matters, or other routes, such as court rules or whatever for other matters. We will work as quickly as we can, but we have to respect the processes that we as Government must go through.

Neil Findlay Lab Lothian
link

I was making the point that we are here only because of the petition. Previous efforts, including correspondence with and meeting civil servants, have not resulted in very much. That is why we are where we are.

Earlier, you mentioned the safety of children, which is always the paramount priority for us all. You expressed some confidence that the contact centres are providing that safety, but I have heard about a contact centre where a child was put in a room with an open window at ground level, where an electric bar heater was used to heat a room in which there was no closed-circuit television, and where the person who was staffing the centre had limited child protection experience and was trying to cajole and urge a child into contact with the parent when the child clearly did not want it. That does not sound like a satisfactory or safe situation.

Annabelle Ewing SNP Cowdenbeath
link

I understand your concern—I share it. I do not know in which submission that issue was raised, but I wonder whether the matter could be teased out such that we get information and hard facts about that contact centre. Is it a Relationships Scotland centre? Is it an independent centre? If we know that, the matter can be pursued, and it would be important to do so, given the incidents that Neil Findlay describes. If we do not know which centre it is, we cannot make progress such as we would like.

Any incident in which safety is compromised is worrying and must be dealt with, but I do not think that I have received any correspondence about an incident at any of the 45 or so Relationships Scotland contact centres and the four that are not Relationships Scotland centres. I am looking at my official as I say that—I can see that he is worried by my making such a statement. I just do not recall off the top of my head any such correspondence. I am happy to look into the matter, but such issues are not coming through my correspondence regularly.

Therefore, it is important to recognise that although we absolutely need to look to the next stage of how we operate contact centres, we should not lose sight of the fact that for many individuals who interact with contact centres every week such incidents are not their experience—they have a good experience. That is all credit to the workers in the contact centres, who do a fantastic job. We want information on any example in which that is not the case so that we can look into the matter.

Neil Findlay Lab Lothian
link

I have a small final point to make. You mentioned non-legal-aid cases. My understanding is that there is a charge of about £80 an hour for supported child contact service in those cases.

Finally, I return to my first point. You mentioned spring next year and a 12-week consultation. What is the timeline for the work?

Annabelle Ewing SNP Cowdenbeath
link

On the first point, Relationship Scotland’s submission said that

“Most of our child contact centres do not charge for supported child contact.”

You might want to factor that information from Relationship Scotland into the committee’s deliberations.

On timing, we will have the 12-week consultation in the spring. We hope thereafter to proceed as quickly as possible. The consultation will deal with many important issues of concern in family law including parental rights and responsibilities, child contact centres, how contact interfaces with issues of domestic abuse, the right of the child to have their voice heard, the position of grandparents and a number of other issues. It will look comprehensively at where we are with family law issues, given changes in society and related matters since the Children (Scotland) Act 1995 was introduced. We have no reason not to proceed as quickly as possible, but we accept that we have to go through the necessary processes.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Neil Findlay’s constituent has highlighted the specific concerns that prompted the petition, but we will be dealing with the broader issues. You could perhaps correspond directly with the committee on the specific concerns relating to those incidents.

Annabelle Ewing SNP Cowdenbeath
link

That would be really helpful, because we absolutely want to get to the bottom of the situation.

Michelle Ballantyne Con South Scotland
link

I am new to the process and may have missed this in the earlier discussions but are you working on the presumption that contact is good for the child? When you talk about the voice of the child in particular, is the starting presumption one of contact or one of not having contact unless the child wishes it?

Annabelle Ewing SNP Cowdenbeath
link

Under the current legislation—the 1995 act as amended by the Family Law (Scotland) Act 2006—that is the fundamental issue. The welfare of the child is the paramount consideration. That is the overriding benchmark by reference to which a decision has to be taken. You have to look at whether a decision on contact should be made—that is set forth in legislation. You have got to the heart of the matter because contact may not be in the best interests of the welfare of the child in all cases. The court already has that test before it.

There were wider issues on presumption against contact—for example, in domestic abuse cases—in some of the submissions. Some stakeholders put forward that view, at least as a matter for discussion. Other stakeholders took the view that if there is that presumption in those circumstances, that may cut across the voice of the child, and therefore the overarching test that the welfare of the child is the paramount consideration. Those issues are very weighty, difficult, complex and sensitive. A benefit of having the consultation is that those issues can be fleshed out and we can have the much-needed discussion that many stakeholders want.

Michelle Ballantyne Con South Scotland
link

It is extremely important because the context of presumption of contact or no contact affects the stress levels of young people—particularly those who are a bit older and recognise the stress of contact. A child will often not want to deny their parent contact even if they are stressed by a potential meeting. It is something that really needs to be looked at.

Annabelle Ewing SNP Cowdenbeath
link

You are right. For clarity, in legislation, there is not a presumption either of contact or no contact. You start with the welfare of the child.

Annabelle Ewing SNP Cowdenbeath
link

Many people have the perception that the presumption is one of contact. I understand that, and we must have that discussion.

Angus MacDonald SNP Falkirk East
link

Do any aspects of the Domestic Abuse (Scotland) Bill feed into the discussions on child contact centres and the child contact process?

09:45

Annabelle Ewing SNP Cowdenbeath
link

As I mentioned in my opening remarks, we were keen to proceed with the Domestic Abuse (Scotland) Bill to address how the criminal justice system handles domestic abuse while recognising that a number of issues would be thrown up as a result of those deliberations. Rona Mackay, as the deputy convener of the Justice Committee, is well versed in the deliberations on that bill. We recognised that a number of issues that would have an impact on our civil legal system would arise and the Cabinet Secretary for Justice has already indicated that we will consider the interconnection with the civil legal system in the context of the work on family law, our consultation and then the legislation to come.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Some of the people who have a view on the matter would not necessarily be reached by the consultation process or might feel uncomfortable about it. Do you have plans for reaching out to some of the people who are affected by the issues that have been highlighted but who might not be the normal stakeholders with easy access to the consultation?

Annabelle Ewing SNP Cowdenbeath
link

You make an excellent point, convener, and we will reflect carefully on that. Every consultation is slightly different. When Lord Bracadale was reflecting on how best to proceed with the consultation on the review of hate crime legislation, he had to bear in mind many issues about how to reach the people from whom he really wanted to hear in addition to the normal stakeholders.

Simon Stockwell Scottish Government
link

We might speak to some of the local women’s aid groups. In the past, I have spoken to women’s aid in Paisley to learn about their experience with child welfare reporters, for example. We are also mindful of the need to hear the voices of children. We might, for example, speak to the Scottish Youth Parliament or the Children’s Parliament. I think that the children and young people who worked with Scottish Women’s Aid on the power up/power down project are still available to speak to about their experiences of the system. There are a number of ways of getting out to people other than the usual suspects.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Another possibility would be to speak to or correspond with the petitioner about how you might get information from people who are using the service but are not necessarily involved in any particular groups.

Obviously, after the consultation, you have to analyse and report on the responses and then draft legislation. What is the timetable for that?

Annabelle Ewing SNP Cowdenbeath
link

We hope to proceed as quickly as possible but I cannot give an exact date because too many variables are involved. We recognise not only that it is a big piece of work but that it is very important and we want to proceed with it as expeditiously as possible. However, I cannot give you a specific date when a bill will be presented to the Presiding Officer for his reflections.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Could some things be processed more quickly? Contact is a massive area. However, confidence in the contact centres and their potential regulation is a small subset of that. If bits of the process look as though they can be fairly easily sorted, will you consider taking them separately? Just because you cannot do everything immediately does not mean that you cannot do some things right now.

I remind you that the petition came from a family’s direct experience of and concerns about a contact centre. Relationships Scotland has said that it would like regulation. Rona Mackay, who was involved in the hearings system before she came to the Parliament, was surprised—I am not putting words into her mouth—that what she thought the contact centres were offering was not people’s actual experience. Will you at least consider treating that issue as a discrete piece of work from the massive amount of work that you are doing on the broader legislation?

Annabelle Ewing SNP Cowdenbeath
link

As we proceed with the consultation, we will bear that point in mind. It would be premature to say one way or the other today because we often find that tasks that we thought were discrete and straightforward become less so because of interrelated and interconnected issues. It would not be helpful for me to prejudge the outcome of the consultation that is to be held next year. However, we will bear the point in mind.

We are anxious to make progress on all fronts as expeditiously as possible and, if there are ways to do that, we will certainly consider them. However, I cannot in all conscience prejudge the outcome of the consultation today because experience dictates that what we might think is a straightforward set of plans to do something frequently involves many other considerations and becomes a bigger task than we first thought. I certainly look forward to the committee’s report and we will carefully consider all the recommendations that it makes.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Thank you very much.

We have exhausted our questions. Do members have a view on how to take forward the petition?

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

We should ask the petitioner for her response to today’s evidence.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Okay. We can reflect on the evidence that we have heard and ask for a further response from the petitioner. That would be useful.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

I am concerned about the timescale. I would like to write to the Government and at least nudge it to give us some sort of indication of when the consultation might take place. Otherwise, if it is not working to a timetable, the matter could just slip and slip.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

I suppose, minister, that you could provide the committee with that information once you have a sense of the timetable.

Annabelle Ewing SNP Cowdenbeath
link

Once we have a clearer sense of the timetable, we will be happy to share it with the committee.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

I imagine that you must have in your head a timetable against which you are operating, which might slip because you discover that there is more to do. Perhaps you could give us that planned timetable.

Annabelle Ewing SNP Cowdenbeath
link

There might be an indicative timetable but, before we provide the committee with information, we want to be reasonably confident that we are providing it with the best, most accurate information, rather than red herrings that go nowhere.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

We could also write to the Judicial Institute for Scotland to ask it to provide information about the training courses that are available to judicial office holders. That information could include the duration of courses, how the content of the courses addresses issues in relation to contact centres, clarification of the overall number of the attendees at the training and the specific judicial office held by them. We got some information in our briefing and the courses certainly looked interesting but it would be useful to know their extent and how many people are involved.

Michelle Ballantyne Con South Scotland
link

I would like to see some reporting back on the concept of the right person being in the right job. It is about having someone with whom the child feels comfortable, whom they trust and who can really be their voice. To pick up on the conversation about the presumption of contact or no contact, it is important that the right person is involved.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

From our round-table session, we got a sense of the extent to which somebody who has a relationship with the child can be a more effective advocate for them or have an awareness of their anxieties.

There are a number of issues that we can take forward. I thank the minister and Mr Stockwell for attending. The session was very useful indeed.

09:52 Meeting suspended.

09:56 On resuming—

  1. 09:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 21
  2. 09:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 90
  3. 09:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 88
  4. 10:45 New Petitions Petitions · 40

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.