Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Continued Petitions

Healthcare Services (Skye, Lochalsh and South-west Ross) (PE1591)

Thursday 23 November 2017 Public Petitions Committee About 09:00 Petitions 21 contributions · 8 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

21 contributions
Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

I welcome everyone to the 21st meeting in 2017 of the Public Petitions Committee. I remind members and others in the room to switch phones and other devices to silent.

The first item on our agenda is consideration of a continued petition, PE1591, which is on the major redesign of healthcare services in Skye, Lochalsh, and south-west Ross. I welcome to the meeting Kate Forbes MSP, Rhoda Grant MSP and Edward Mountain MSP. The petition was scheduled for consideration at our previous meeting on 9 November, but because of time constraints the committee agreed to defer the agenda item until today to ensure that we had sufficient time to consider the issues.

In May, when we previously considered the petition, we agreed to write to the Cabinet Secretary for Health and Sport to ask her to address the petitioner’s on-going concerns about the service redesign. The cabinet secretary’s response is included with our meeting papers, along with submissions from NHS Highland and the petitioner. In her response, the cabinet secretary sets out the assurances that she has received from NHS Highland with regard to concerns about the further development of services for local people, including palliative care, community care, respite care and care at home. She notes that the board’s integrated community team is taking forward development work in that area. In addition, she refers to the assurances that she has received from NHS Highland in relation to concerns about access to primary and emergency care, and on the board’s efforts to engage with local communities to

“build greater confidence in the process”.

It is the cabinet secretary’s understanding that the board’s offer to meet local councillors was turned down, and she reiterates her encouragement to all local stakeholders

“to work with the Board to take this important work forward”.

The submissions from the cabinet secretary and NHS Highland address the concerns about transport and access to Broadford hospital. NHS Highland acknowledges the concerns, but it considers that the issues are long standing and span a wider area than health services alone. The board has commissioned a team from the University of Aberdeen to assess any specific implications of the changes to transport and access to Broadford and to look at how those might be addressed.

The petitioner expresses in her submission the view that the community’s concerns are being ignored and that the service redesign is

“being used as a cover for cuts to essential health and social care services”.

Do members have any comments or suggestions for further action? It might be helpful if colleagues who represent the area speak first, so I will bring in Kate Forbes.

Kate Forbes SNP Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch
link

I am happy to kick off. I will touch on two issues, which have been mentioned previously at the committee and which are totally interlinked: the redesign and the current management of services. The petition ultimately calls for an independent scrutiny panel, and if the committee were to go down that route, I would support it. The petitioner highlights two main issues that relate to transport and to population growth at the north end of the island.

I turn to my concerns. The greatest flaw that I can see in the redesign is that it is full of nice ideas that are not matched by the reality on the ground. One issue is the number of beds. If we had a thriving care-in-the-community system that was working exceptionally well, I could see a reason to cut bed numbers, but there are problems with care in the community. A second issue concerns residential care beds. Again, the redesign is based on the premise that there will be a certain number of residential care beds, but numbers have been cut by private operators in the past few years. The third issue, which is of concern to most people, is out-of-hours care. When I asked the First Minister about that issue a few weeks ago, she said that there would be “no changes to out of hours”. However, when I speak to people on Skye, they feel that there have already been changes to out-of-hours services. Those three issues are to do with the redesign, which is an issue in and of itself that the committee is considering today.

I move on to the current management of services, which the committee has discussed at large. There has been a continual apparent downgrading since the summer. First, Portree hospital was closed to admissions due to staffing, then out-of-hours services were temporarily suspended. This week, not in Portree but at Broadford, maternity services have been temporarily suspended for a month as a result of staff absences. That is currently a critical concern for my constituents.

Over the past month, the cabinet secretary has recognised those issues and has asked NHS Highland to consider undertaking an external review of out-of-hours and emergency services in Portree. The review was announced at the end of October, but I believe that the terms of reference for an independent external reviewer are still being agreed. There are concerns that the review’s remit does not go far enough, but I certainly welcome it as a first step. The cabinet secretary also asked NHS Highland to establish a steering group in which community representatives from the north end of Skye could participate. Again, though, everything has been happening so slowly. The establishment of a steering group has been discussed since the middle of summer, but it has still not happened. I would like to have seen more progress on the external review in the past month than has been the case. The petition offers an opportunity to highlight those issues again, and to flag up the frustrations that people in the north end of the island continue to experience.

I will leave it at that, as I recognise that my colleagues have more to say.

Rhoda Grant Lab Highlands and Islands
link

I will not repeat what Kate Forbes said; I will simply add a little to it. The review is welcome, but there are real concerns that it does not go far enough to address the issues that people have raised.

NHS Highland said, as the convener mentioned when she introduced the petition, that it is aware of a long-standing issue with transport. If the board is aware of such long-standing issues that are wider than the NHS, surely it should consider them in the redesign process, rather than just saying that there is an issue and that the redesign will take place in spite of it.

A group was set up to look at transport and was supposed to report in June and again in September, but it has still not reported. To an extent, all the work that is supposed to reassure the community and move it forward appears to be stagnating. There is a bit of a stand-off between the community and NHS Highland, which I think has arisen because of a lack of trust from the community.

In Portree hospital, which has been closed to new admissions, two in-patient beds are currently occupied by people who are waiting to go to care homes. The fact that they have been there for a considerable length of time shows us just how little people can rely on care in the community, especially in respect of step-up, step-down care and palliative care, which it is really important for people to access close to home. For the petitioner, there are still real outstanding issues.

Edward Mountain Con Highlands and Islands
link

The problem with speaking last in a group of three is that everyone has mentioned everything that I wanted to say. However, I will make two comments. The first concerns the lack of trust between the community and NHS Highland. The offer by NHS Highland to meet councillors is seen as divisive because the board is trying to pick off individual people rather than engaging with the community. Another concern, which is relevant not only to the situation in Skye but to all decisions by NHS Highland, is the board’s manipulation of statistics to achieve the end that it seeks. That might mean that it downgrades services slowly and therefore reduces the amount of people who are taken in, or that an ambulance moves from one hospital to another and bypasses the one in between.

Every day, I get letters to do with the situation in Skye or Caithness. An independent review, which has been called for by both my colleagues who represent the area, is critical, and it is important that we keep the petition open to ensure that that review happens. I thank you, convener, for allowing me to speak.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

That is no problem.

What do members think about the petition? We must be alive to the fact that some of the issues are simply operational—they are not simple for the people who are dealing with them, but they are operational matters and are therefore not for the Public Petitions Committee to consider. We have to look at the national issues. I know that the petitioner has expectations of the committee, and she has understandably expressed frustration about what is happening. Do members have any suggestions for how we might take the petition forward?

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

I have listened to discussions about the petition over a period of time, and it strikes me that more than half the population of Skye have signed it, so it is obviously of significant influence up there. I would like to hear from the population of Skye—from a representation of the people of Skye themselves.

The cabinet secretary has suggested that the Scottish Government is happy with what is being proposed, but I would be interested to see where the Public Petitions Committee could go with the petition. I am certainly not inclined to let it go. Too much of the population of the island have a vested interest and have taken the time to participate in the petition.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

I wonder whether the issue is as Kate Forbes has identified: that the forum and the independent review should be established, which could provide some sense of progress. Given the cabinet secretary’s commitment and the gap between what the First Minister has been advised and what has actually been happening, if we got reassurance from the cabinet secretary about a timetable for that, would that give people comfort? Would that be an option?

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

I think that that would be the road to go down at this stage. There is definitely a disconnect with information, and it would be good to get clarification on that from the cabinet secretary.

Michelle Ballantyne Con South Scotland
link

I am particularly concerned about the disconnect, in that the cabinet secretary is saying, “This is what is happening,” but there is other evidence from the petitioner, and now from our colleagues. I have taken part in health service changes reviews and transformations, and I am aware that there is a huge reliance on the data that proves that a service is not needed in one place or is needed in another place. If we downgrade and reduce access to a service, we can use such data to justify the changes.

The petition raises a number of questions about the process of the review, and the petitioner indicates that in some of the background information. She discusses how

“the design process and the public consultation that sought to justify its outcome are both deeply flawed.”

I am not entirely clear from the paperwork in front of me what those deep flaws are, or what the petitioner was referencing in the petition. I am assuming from the paperwork that I have that the action that the committee has taken so far is to write to the cabinet secretary.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

We questioned the matter, and we went back to the cabinet secretary at least twice on the question of confidence in the process. The cabinet secretary has said that she is confident in the process. I do not think that that will change.

In my experience, people tend to be confident in a process if it they get the outcome that they want. That is not to say that the process is not flawed. If people are unhappy with the way in which services are going to be configured, they will not be content with the process that got them to that point.

Michelle Ballantyne Con South Scotland
link

To be fair to the cabinet secretary, she is taking her information from NHS Highland’s management team, who are not going to say that their process was flawed. There is a slight disconnect there. I wonder whether we should have a conversation with the management team. We could ask them to come and give evidence on what they think about their process. We could also ask them some of the questions that the petitioner has raised in her last communication, and that Kate Forbes has raised this morning, on the downgrading of beds and the statements and operational activities that do not match up. Those are the key elements of what the islanders are experiencing.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

I would be concerned about creating an impression that we can somehow adjudicate on the matter and would be able to come to a view. Some of the issue is operational, and we are considering national issues. I do not think that we can insert ourselves into a process and create the impression that, having heard all the evidence, we can make a judgment on how services should be configured.

Michelle Ballantyne Con South Scotland
link

I do not think that we would be taking any view on how services should be configured or how they should look. The petition is calling for an independent review, and the petitioners want the matter to be looked at again. The committee has to come to a judgment on whether or not that is necessary, not a view on whether the decision is right or wrong. That would be for the review to decide.

09:00

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

The argument is how we get people to justify what they have done and to be open about the decisions that have been made. The independent scrutiny panel that Kate Forbes mentioned would do that job, but our concern is that that body has not been established.

Kate Forbes SNP Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch
link

Can I clarify that? There are two distinct issues. The petitioner wants an independent scrutiny panel to look at the entire consultation process, and a review of the redesign. A month ago the cabinet secretary announced an external review of services that are currently being provided at Portree hospital, because of the disconnect between the First Minister saying, “We will make sure they are good”, and the people on the ground saying that they are not good. The petitioner wants an external independent reviewer to go in now to establish whether the reality matches the assurances that there is reliable out-of-hours and emergency cover in the hospital.

There are two different issues. One of them relates to the redesign, and it is for the committee to decide what to do about that. On the other issue, the cabinet secretary announced an external review. I am frustrated that that is not being done faster, because the announcement was a month ago and the terms of reference are still to be agreed.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

We considered the scrutiny panel previously. Clearly, we do not want to let the petition go, because we recognise how important it is. We are also alive to the fact that decisions have to be made. Operational matters will be decided by NHS Highland and the cabinet secretary is content with the process. Will we seek movement on the independent review that Kate Forbes has talked about and the establishment of the forum?

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

We need to probe further into the progress on that. The response that we get to that will enable us to decide how we go forward with the petition.

Angus MacDonald SNP Falkirk East
link

Could we ask the cabinet secretary to extend the terms of reference of the proposed independent review of the out-of-hours cover in the hospital to include something more akin to what the petitioners are looking for? Given that we are still waiting for the review to kick off, there is an opportunity to extend its remit.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

I suggest that we contact the cabinet secretary with concerns about the mismatch between what she believes to be happening and what the petitioners say is happening on the ground. We welcome the establishment of the independent body and of a forum, but we want a strict timetable for them. We should ask her to give us a timetable and to look at the question of the terms of reference, which are in the process of being developed, recognising the concerns that have been highlighted to the committee. Is that agreed?

Michelle Ballantyne Con South Scotland
link

If we do that, can we also highlight the time critical nature of this? The papers indicate the progress that the national health service is making around the employment of architects and the site, et cetera. If we are taking the petition seriously, we need to ensure that the review moves faster, otherwise the redesign will become a fait accompli with no option to go back.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Your point about creating a self-fulfilling prophecy is well made: you run down a service and then prove to people that it is not being used. If that is justified, there will be changes.

There is a lot to be done. It is agreed that we will write to the cabinet secretary and await a response. I thank Kate Forbes, Rhoda Grant and Edward Mountain for their attendance.

  1. 09:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 21
  2. 09:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 90
  3. 09:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 88
  4. 10:45 New Petitions Petitions · 40

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.