We move on to the penultimate petition on the agenda, which is PE1603, on ensuring greater scrutiny, guidance and consultation with regard to armed forces visits to schools in Scotland. I understand that Mairi Campbell-Jack, who is one of the petitioners, is in the public gallery. I welcome her to the meeting.
Members will recall that we took evidence from the Deputy First Minister when we previously considered the petition. Having had the chance to consider that evidence, the petitioners have made a further submission, which we have in our papers.
The petitioners’ submission covers a range of issues, including the content of careers advice information and data that they have compiled about armed forces visits to special schools in Scotland. The petitioners urge the committee to recommend that no such visits are made, that a child rights and wellbeing impact assessment is applied to armed forces visits and that good-quality data on armed forces visits to schools is requested.
Do members have any comments or suggestions on how we might take forward the petition?
We were offered a briefing. We would need to think about what form that information would come in, but it would be useful. We could usefully test with the armed forces questions that the petitioners raise, particularly on special schools, data about visits and a child rights and wellbeing impact assessment.
We had a really positive evidence session with the Deputy First Minister, but we could do things to follow that up, given some of the things that he committed to. I am concerned about the response to the freedom of information request that shows that the armed forces made 13 visits to special schools. We could certainly bring that up if we have another evidence session.
One of the commitments that the Deputy First Minister made was on the petitioners’ request for good-quality data on armed forces visits to schools. He asked the committee to specify what data would help. I am not sure whether we have provided that information so that he can carry out that commitment. We need to address that aspect, because he made an important commitment on it.
There should be information about numbers and areas—for example, on what schools have been visited in what postcode areas—so that we can see whether any pattern emerges.
The petitioners requested that a child rights and wellbeing impact assessment be applied to armed forces visits to schools. We could also press for that, but it might come after we have had a briefing from the armed forces. The data point could certainly be followed up now.
I wonder whether the purpose of the visits is also an issue. That came out of the Deputy First Minister’s evidence. To an extent, he addressed the question of careers visits, but one of the petitioners’ concerns is that softer visits by the armed forces are used for recruitment purposes. The other side of the argument might be that those visits are about facilities and about knowledge and information opportunities that the armed forces can bring into a school around health and fitness or whatever. I think that the issue that is at the heart of the petition is about pulling out whether the visits are used for recruitment purposes.
The Welsh Government has implemented some things around this issue. In my work as convener of the cross-party group in the Scottish Parliament on the armed forces and veterans community, I have found out useful information on that. I would like to see what the Welsh Government has come forward with, because that might help us.
I presume that there is a spectrum of views, from the view of people who think that the armed forces should not go into schools at all to that of those who think that, if there is a connection between a school and the armed forces, that should just go ahead. However, we want information and data to give us an idea of what the patterns are and where the balance is. To inform our views, perhaps it would be useful to know how the Welsh Government has responded to the question.
We can ask for the director of recruiting for Scotland for the three armed services to come to the briefing—there are appointed seniors in that regard—because we do not want just a generic report. That would give the briefing some substance.
That is helpful. Again, the committee is alive to the balance that we want to strike. We could have greater confidence in the process if we knew where the armed forces were going and why they were going there. For example, is there an issue about the work that is done with special schools? The purposes and cohorts of those schools vary, and there might be different work with different schools.
From the petitioners’ point of view, part of the problem has been that getting information about armed forces visits has been difficult. If we could make that information more open and transparent, that would be a first step in dealing with the petition.
We will defer further consideration until we have had the briefing on armed forces visits to schools by a representative of the armed forces. Maurice Corry’s point about who we hope will do that briefing is useful. In the meantime, we can forward to the Deputy First Minister our suggestions on data. Is that agreed?
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.