Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Continued Petitions

Healthcare Services (Skye, Lochalsh and South-west Ross) (PE1591)

Thursday 25 May 2017 Public Petitions Committee About 10:30–10:45 Petitions 15 contributions · 7 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

15 contributions
Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

The next petition is PE1591, by Catriona MacDonald on behalf of SOS-NHS, on the major redesign of healthcare services in Skye, Lochalsh and south-west Ross. I welcome Kate Forbes MSP and Rhoda Grant MSP, who are present for the petition. Members have a note by the clerk, along with the most recent submissions from the cabinet secretary and the petitioner.

The cabinet secretary’s submission appears to indicate that she is confident that appropriate consideration has been given to any unintended consequences of the redesign and that she is content that due process has been followed. She also makes clear her expectations of the work that is required by NHS Highland to ensure full engagement with local stakeholders. However, the petitioners appear to still have concerns that they are not being listened to or fully engaged with. That is perhaps a matter for the board to consider.

Before I ask members for their comments or suggestions, I ask Rhoda Grant and Kate Forbes whether they have a view on the progress that has been made or on the response from the cabinet secretary.

Kate Forbes SNP Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch
link

The most important thing that you just mentioned, convener, was Shona Robison’s letters about the expectations on NHS Highland. The issue concerns matching up what has been promised and expected and what people feel is really happening on the ground. There is also an issue around the engagement with the community. Most people in the north end of Skye, in particular, still have concerns, and they must have confidence in the redesign and what it will mean for them. We have raised concerns in the past, but the particular issues of concern at the moment are around care beds in the north end of Skye. The last time that I was here, I mentioned the closure of another care home, and there is growing pressure in the area on care beds for elderly people, palliative care and emergency care. That remains a concern. In addition, Ronald MacDonald has previously submitted evidence about the mandatory national guidelines and the need to take account of the density of the population in the north end of Skye.

My role this morning is to represent the views of those who have continued to write to me with their concerns about the current provision of beds and emergency services and about the need for the redesign process to take into account the population density.

10:45

I should add that other parts of Skye, such as the south end, which is where the redesign at the moment suggests that the new hospital should be, are content, although they have also made it clear that they would like to see more services being committed to in the north end of Skye. The question for the committee is whether it is worth asking for more evidence or asking the petitioners to come back and make their views known—as a final point—about whether what has been expected and promised marries with what people sense on the ground.

Rhoda Grant Lab Highlands and Islands
link

I do not disagree with anything that Kate Forbes has said. I would, however, add that there are concerns about the ambulance service—both patient transport and emergency ambulances—and the fact that people have to go to Broadford. There is an ageing population and public transport is not what it would be in a city—it is pretty sparse. If people are unable to drive, their ability to access health services and, indeed, visit people becomes a big issue. There are promises of better care in the community and the like, but nobody has seen the shape of that, and press reports say that NHS Highland is looking to make more major savings from its budgets. If I was sitting there, I would be wondering how it was going to deliver all those services with a budget that is contracting substantially.

I have tried to think what the committee can do to help, and I throw this out as a suggestion. Would it be possible for the committee to hold a round-table meeting with the health board and the petitioners, to see whether some of the issues that are concerning them could be answered in that way? I feel that the committee is just being passed backwards and forwards, and we do not appear to have resolved very much for the petitioners. I do not know whether that is a way forward that the committee could examine, or, indeed, whether the petitioners and the health board would be willing to participate in such a meeting.

I may be at odds with the petitioner, but I have said all along that we need to get on and have a new hospital in Skye, because neither hospital is fit for purpose any more. Any delay is going to mean that people are going to have to travel not to Broadford, which is bad enough, but to Inverness, which will be even worse. We need the new hospital, but we need to ensure that the whole community is content with the services that they are receiving and know that they will be able to access healthcare without barriers in their way.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

I am interested in the committee’s views on what we should do. The Scottish Government has said that it is content that due process has been followed, but the local people clearly do not agree with that, and I am not sure whether a round-table discussion would resolve that issue, although it might highlight the individual anxieties. I would not want to misrepresent the role of the committee—it is not a scrutiny committee in the sense that it could establish X, Y and Z and come to a judgment on what has been done. We do not have that role. We do not want to continue the petition unnecessarily in the expectation that there will be a resolution that we cannot achieve for the petitioners. We have to be honest about what we can and cannot do.

I am interested in members’ views on the issue. There is a balance for us. Should we close the petition on the basis that the issue is not going to be resolved through the petitions process, or is there something useful that we can do that would illuminate some of the challenges and bring the community together by providing the services that they are looking for and want to have confidence in?

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

You have alluded to what I was going to say, convener. The cabinet secretary is content with the process but, at the same time, the concerns of the petitioners or the population in the area have not been allayed. It seems to me that there is a role for someone to play in somehow communicating between the two to try to find some middle ground. My question is whether that is the committee’s role. Is that what we do? At the end of the day, there are two opposing ideas based on the same evidence.

Angus MacDonald SNP Falkirk East
link

You make valid points, convener, as does Brian Whittle. Initially, I had a great deal of sympathy for the petition, and I have been keen for the committee to do all that it can within its powers to assist the petitioners, given the valid concerns that they have raised and that clearly continue among the population in Skye. Perhaps the concerns are not so much on the Lochalsh side, but they certainly continue in north Skye.

The cabinet secretary has confirmed that she is content that due process has been followed. As Kate Forbes mentioned, the south end of Skye is content and the north end is not so happy. Frankly, I do not see how that will change, no matter how long the committee deliberates on the issue. I think that the process has been exhausted. I do not see any benefit in having the petitioners back in to give further evidence, as Kate Forbes suggested, and I do not see the benefit of having a round-table session, because that would basically just prolong things and, clearly, the hospital has to be built as soon as possible. Given that we will not get the whole of the community to be content, I propose that the petition be closed, although I do so extremely reluctantly because I understand the concerns. As I said, we have exhausted the process, so I move that we close the petition.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

I am interested in other members’ comments on that. I have a question for Rhoda Grant and Kate Forbes. We have the analysis that was done by Ronald MacDonald, and there is a sense that the process was not done properly. I get the feeling that specific and definite points have not been responded to. Would people have more confidence in the process if we asked the cabinet secretary to directly address those points, or should we just discontinue the petition? I see the force of what Angus MacDonald has said, but perhaps we can do that one thing as a final shot. My sense is that the petitioners feel that those questions have just been ignored rather than addressed. We can ask the ministers to address them. Do you think that that would help?

Kate Forbes SNP Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch
link

Initially, the petition asked for a review. I have asked people whether their main concern is about the process, the outcome of the process—in other words, where the hospital is—or a general sense of downgrading of services. Repeatedly, people have told me that their main concern is about confidence in the process. If the committee asked the cabinet secretary to ensure in whatever way that everything has been followed correctly, that would be profitable.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

I will ask the devil’s advocate question. Do people complain about the process only when they do not like the outcome? Even if we were to establish that the process was right, will that change anything for someone in the north of Skye who is not happy? That is not to belittle or demean their concerns. Do we address concerns through looking at process or is there a next stage that allows the concerns to be addressed? It cannot just be about the location of the hospital; it is about all the things around that such as transport and ambulance services.

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

I broadly agree with Angus MacDonald, except that there seem to be unanswered questions. As Angus said, it is not worth while to have people back in to give evidence, but maybe we should send a letter to the cabinet secretary highlighting the specific concerns on access to primary and emergency care and asking for a response. That is the only reason to keep the petition open, and it would allow us to try to tie up the loose ends. I am not saying that it would give the petitioners the answer that they want, but at least we would ask those questions for them.

Maurice Corry Con West Scotland
link

I entirely agree with Rona Mackay. In my experience on Mull, where we had exactly the same situation, we resolved the issue by going in and talking about the reduction in access to primary and emergency care, which helped. I do not support closing the petition now, because I believe that we should send one more letter to the cabinet secretary. It is about confidence being felt by the people in the north end of the island. We had the same issue on the Ross of Mull. We got confidence back and we resolved the issue, and the cabinet secretary confirmed that.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

To respond to Kate Forbes’s point, we should ask the cabinet secretary and maybe also the health board about what measures they are putting in place to build confidence, because the process has stalled and nobody is benefiting from that.

Kate Forbes SNP Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch
link

I appreciate what the committee has done in going back and forth, and I know that the petitioners appreciate that, but at times it has felt as if the same answers have been coming back. It would be good if, in your letter, you could press the point about a tangible outcome that can instil confidence.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Okay. We have agreed to continue the petition.

As is happening across the country, the Parliament will reflect on the tragic events in Manchester with a minute’s silence at 11 o’clock. I want us to participate in that, so I suspend the meeting now.

10:56 Meeting suspended.

11:03 On resuming—

  1. 09:00 Continued Petition Petitions · 85
  2. 09:30 New Petitions Petitions · 108
  3. 10:00 New Petitions Petitions · 14
  4. 10:26 Continued Petitions Petitions · 7
  5. 10:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 12
  6. 10:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 8
  7. 10:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 15
  8. 10:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 17
  9. 10:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 11

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.