We move on to PE1577, by Rachael Wallace, which is on adult cerebral palsy services. Members will recall that we took evidence from the Minister for Public Health and Sport when we last considered the petition. We have received a submission from the petitioner and members will see that the clerk’s note provides some additional background information from SPICe. I welcome Murdo Fraser MSP to the meeting—he is here for this petition.
Members may also recall that the minister and her officials considered that a national clinical pathway would not be appropriate for a condition such as cerebral palsy. They proposed that developing practice at the local level is the way forward for now. The Scottish Government has been working with Bobath Scotland on a pilot programme in that regard and will consider what learning from that work can be shared with health boards. We understand that Capability Scotland has conducted a national mapping exercise on therapy provision for cerebral palsy in Scotland. As that has only recently concluded, we are yet to have the Scottish Government’s view on what action it will take in response to the findings.
The petitioner takes the view that the Scottish Government should take the lead at a national level, in the form of either a national clinical pathway or another framework, to ensure that adults with cerebral palsy can access continuity in the specialist care and services that they require.
Do members have any comments or suggestions for action? It might be useful for Murdo Fraser to make some comments to help inform our views.
Thank you for letting me address the committee, convener. I had a discussion with the petitioner about the evidence session that was held with the minister a few weeks ago. Although some very helpful things were said during that session, I think that the petitioner’s biggest concern is that we lose sight of the ambition to have a national clinical pathway. The minister said that the Government was looking at developing local pathways, and the petitioner’s concern is that that might lead to a patchy picture across the country, with some health boards no doubt doing well and taking local pathways forward expeditiously, but other health boards doing less well. We know that many health boards are suffering with financial issues and staff shortages, so they might not see the development of local pathways as a priority.
The petitioner was very keen to reinforce the message that she wants to a national clinical pathway to be taken forward with national leadership from the Scottish Government, rather than that work just being left to the discretion of individual health boards. The on-going work with Bobath Scotland and Capability Scotland has been very helpful, and it will be interesting to see how it develops. It will also be helpful to get feedback from those exercises in due course. However, in terms of getting the impetus that the petitioner would like to see, we are keen that the issue of a national clinical pathway is not lost sight of.
I wonder whether you can help us with a point that the petitioner refers to in her response. Are there comparable conditions that have national clinical pathways? I think that that is the issue that we are wrestling with. I am not quite clear, even from the evidence, about why there would be resistance to having a national clinical pathway. Are there other conditions for which a national clinical pathway would be expected?
I do not have enough medical knowledge to say how cerebral palsy fits into the hierarchy of conditions. With motor neurone disease, for example, we saw a great deal of impetus over the past year when the Scottish Government provided a lead to make sure that local health boards provided additional support for those who suffer from that condition. That is a sort of parallel example: if the Government determines that something needs to be addressed, it can give a lead and make sure that health boards deliver at the local level and are not left to decide individually what actions to take.
That is absolutely the point. According to the petitioner, children’s services are quite robust; children with cerebral palsy are generally well cared for and get the attention that they require. The problem is with the transition to adulthood, where the support for too many people seems to fall off the edge of a cliff.
The baseline is that everybody is an individual with separate needs, but that does not prevent our having a national framework with a robust and consistent approach to establishing those individual needs. Members can correct me if I am wrong, but a framework that enables individual treatment protocols to be established seems realistic.
I was surprised by the petitioner’s evidence that she has to seek out her own physiotherapy and identify whether the therapists have the knowledge to deal with her condition, and that there was no national guidance on the issue.
My sense from the committee is that we want to pursue the matter a little further and ask the Scottish Government for the findings from the pilot programme and the mapping exercise and for a further assessment of the way forward that is informed by that work. That should include consideration of whether it will produce national guidance for health boards. I suspect that, for the petitioner and the committee, the technical nature of the language used—whether it a pathway or something else—is not as important as having a national view of what it is reasonable for an adult with cerebral palsy to expect and to access.
We will write to the Scottish Government in those terms and seek a timeframe for the pilot programme. It has just been confirmed that the pilot is finished, so we can get that information.
The committee has found the argument for national guidance convincing. There may be a compelling argument against it, but we have yet to hear it. We are keen for the Scottish Government to give us information on the pilot programme and the mapping exercise and to tell us whether it will produce national guidance for health boards, precisely to address the point made by Murdo Fraser: when people make budgeting decisions, the context of having national guidance becomes very important. Do members agree?
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.