The final petition this morning is PE1591, by Catriona MacDonald, on behalf of SOS-NHS, on the major redesign of healthcare services in Skye, Lochalsh and south-west Ross. I welcome Kate Forbes and Rhoda Grant to the meeting for this item. Members have received a note by the clerk and submissions from the Cabinet Secretary for Health and Sport and the petitioners.
Members will recall that when we previously considered the petition in December, we agreed to write to the cabinet secretary, inviting her to respond to the points raised in the critique provided by the petitioners and to address concerns on patient transport provision. In the context of the decision-making process, the cabinet secretary is quite clear in her view that she cannot reasonably add anything to what she has already communicated in previous submissions to the committee. She notes that, with regard to patient transport provision, the Scottish Ambulance Service has confirmed that the region is covered by two service vehicles, both of which have stretcher capabilities and are covered by three full-time posts. She indicates her understanding that the service will
“work with NHS Highland and other partners to deliver services which support the public and local communities”.
11:00
The petitioners consider that the cabinet secretary has failed to answer specific key questions and has ignored the “fundamental issues” that were set out in the critique that was submitted on 8 December last year. They identify five areas that they feel have not been sufficiently addressed, which are a response to the critique, the mandatory guidance in the Scottish capital investment manual and the Treasury green book, a failure to include evaluation of the relative costs and risks of the possible locations for the new hospital, the role of the Scottish health council, and concerns that were highlighted by elected representatives.
Do members have any views on what action we might take on the petition?