We have a couple of decades of experience in developing pathways at local and national level, and a better understanding of the conditions required for the development of pathways in either of those manners.
The petition refers to an “alternative pathway”, but it would be better described as an alternative approach. Traditionally, when we developed a clinical pathway—this goes back to the first pathway that I was involved in, in the early 2000s—a group of clinicians and experts would get together in a room and examine the evidence for a particular approach to care, look at the contributions from each of the professionals and develop a pathway with supporting data to assess the quality of care along it. That approach is used less now, and we have a very different approach with much more co-creation of pathways with patients and the public.
The alternative approach that Bobath has suggested is to develop a pathway from the service user up, working closely with people who have experience of cerebral palsy to see what their needs are and to develop a pathway using evidence of those needs. That is why the phrase “alternative pathway” has been used.
As the minister has explained, for a condition such as cerebral palsy, there are a number of influencing factors when the approach to developing a pathway is considered. One is the kind of evidence base that exists for that pathway, whether there is consensus around that evidence base and whether the data exist to support the development of that pathway. Is a high-volume specialty or a particularly specialist type of service needed? There can then be consideration of whether the pathway is necessary on a national basis or at a local level. I am convinced by the argument that, in the case of cerebral palsy, we require a stronger evidence base that is developed from the ground up and that informs the national framework for services, so that local pathways can be developed and people can receive care on a local basis.