Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 17 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Continued Petitions

Adult Cerebral Palsy Services (PE1577)

Thursday 16 March 2017 Public Petitions Committee About 09:15–10:00 Petitions 67 contributions · 9 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

67 contributions
Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

I welcome to the meeting Murdo Fraser, who is here for the next agenda item, which is PE1577, by Rachael Wallace, on adult cerebral palsy services. We are also joined by the Minister for Public Health and Sport, and her officials: Dr Gregor Smith, who is deputy chief medical officer, and Elizabeth Porterfield, who is head of strategic planning and clinical priorities. I welcome you to the meeting.

We have a bit of time, so if you would like to make an opening statement we would be happy to hear it.

Aileen Campbell SNP The Minister for Public Health and Sport · Clydesdale
link

I understood that the committee wanted to go straight into questions.

Thank you for the opportunity to respond to Rachael Wallace’s petition. I had the privilege of meeting Rachael with her member of the Scottish Parliament, Murdo Fraser, last week, when I had the chance to explore some of the issues about which she has concerns. It is a tribute to her that she has articulated those concerns to try to make a difference and make improvements for others across the country who suffer from cerebral palsy.

We undertook to explore further some of the issues that Rachael raised around physiotherapy access, and the main point that she had been trying to articulate, which is about a national clinical pathway. I think that the committee will want to probe us with questions on those things and on our work with Bobath Scotland and the local pilot in West Dunbartonshire, which we hope will go a long way towards reassuring Rachael about the action that we are taking to address the concerns that she has raised.

We have undertaken to work with Rachael on a range of activities to provide her with a bit more reassurance and comfort that the action that we are taking addresses her concerns. In addition, I will instruct my officials to explore a bit more fully with national health service boards across the country their provision and how they are helping people who have cerebral palsy to cope with their transitions. A lot of people who have disabilities and conditions face a tough transition from children’s services into adult services. We should explore that issue not just in terms of NHS Tayside, in whose area Rachael lives, but across the country.

That work will complement the work that Capability Scotland is undertaking in its mapping exercise and the work that Bobath Scotland is undertaking on the pilot. Together we will get evidence and information that will allow us to take forward a framework that provides reassurance to Rachael and the committee. We will keep the committee updated with our progress on making the difference across the country that Rachael wants us to make.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

You will be aware that the petition has been carried over from session 4. As you said, you are funding a pilot project that is being led by Bobath Scotland in conjunction with the West Dunbartonshire health and social care partnership. The Scottish Government has described the pilot project as an

“alternative supported pathway for adults with cerebral palsy”.

The suggestion appears to be that the Scottish Government will not consider the need for a national clinical pathway until the pilot programme is completed. For the record, will you explain the scope of the pilot and why it is described as an

“alternative supported pathway for adults with cerebral palsy”

in circumstances in which there does not appear to be an established clinical pathway?

Aileen Campbell SNP Clydesdale
link

For your benefit, I might ask Gregor Smith to explain more fully the processes for establishing a national clinical pathway.

In a broad sense, national pathways are delivered for more specialist conditions that require fewer interventions from clinicians and fewer providers. Because of the range of ways in which cerebral palsy can manifest itself and because its management relies very much on a variety of providers across health and social care, there is much more merit in having a more local and bespoke way of ensuring that people get the care that they need. That is why we are keen to learn from the Bobath Scotland pilot in West Dunbartonshire, understand the information that has been amassed during its 18 months and work alongside Capability Scotland and its mapping exercise. From that, we will be able to develop a framework that will allow us to have national principles that will enable a bit more consistency across the country.

We will not proceed with a national clinical pathway because the way in which cerebral palsy manifests itself does not allow its management to be easily translated into that course of action. We want to ensure that local activity is as good, strong and robust as it can be. We are proceeding with the pilot to amass evidence, so that we can ensure, with an evidence backing, that local services are delivered appropriately and in a timely way.

Dr Gregor Smith Scottish Government
link

We have a couple of decades of experience in developing pathways at local and national level, and a better understanding of the conditions required for the development of pathways in either of those manners.

The petition refers to an “alternative pathway”, but it would be better described as an alternative approach. Traditionally, when we developed a clinical pathway—this goes back to the first pathway that I was involved in, in the early 2000s—a group of clinicians and experts would get together in a room and examine the evidence for a particular approach to care, look at the contributions from each of the professionals and develop a pathway with supporting data to assess the quality of care along it. That approach is used less now, and we have a very different approach with much more co-creation of pathways with patients and the public.

The alternative approach that Bobath has suggested is to develop a pathway from the service user up, working closely with people who have experience of cerebral palsy to see what their needs are and to develop a pathway using evidence of those needs. That is why the phrase “alternative pathway” has been used.

As the minister has explained, for a condition such as cerebral palsy, there are a number of influencing factors when the approach to developing a pathway is considered. One is the kind of evidence base that exists for that pathway, whether there is consensus around that evidence base and whether the data exist to support the development of that pathway. Is a high-volume specialty or a particularly specialist type of service needed? There can then be consideration of whether the pathway is necessary on a national basis or at a local level. I am convinced by the argument that, in the case of cerebral palsy, we require a stronger evidence base that is developed from the ground up and that informs the national framework for services, so that local pathways can be developed and people can receive care on a local basis.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

To me, it feels illogical to say that, because cerebral palsy is a complex condition, it cannot have a national pathway and the process has to start at a very local level. I do not understand that from the petitioner’s point of view. She describes having had a series of people around her when she was a youngster but, as an adult, she had to go and find all the support for herself. It feels as if it should be pretty basic to have a system whereby she would have someone to go where those services would be identified. The idea of a condition being too complex to have a national pathway does not make sense to me. Even if that were the case, I do not get the logic of saying that a pilot in one particular area is going to tell us everything about the condition right across the country.

Dr Smith
link

I am sorry If I have suggested that it is the complexity of—

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

I think that it was the minister who said that it is too complex.

Aileen Campbell SNP Clydesdale
link

I think I said that there needs to be cognisance of the fact that the condition manifests itself in a number of different ways. If, as Gregor Smith says, we have local pathways, that will give us a much more holistic picture of the individual patient and their individual needs so that we can ensure that the appropriate transitions are in place and that local services are delivered around the patient in a way that allows them to move seamlessly from children’s to adult services, as in Rachael Wallace’s case.

That is why I said that, at this point in time, there are no plans to develop a national clinical pathway. Nevertheless, the Bobath work is important. It is not just a local pilot; it will develop and enhance our understanding of the condition and the way in which services are delivered. We can then upscale that model and ensure that the principles are understood across the country, so that people do not have the feeling, which Rachael Wallace has described, of falling through the cracks at transition.

That is why we will engage with every NHS board in the country to make sure that appropriate provision is in place so that people do not fall through the cracks, because none of us wish that to happen. There should already be ways in place to help people move seamlessly from children’s services to adult services. If we have much more rigour and a much better and clearer understanding of how services are delivered—which is what the Bobath pilot will offer us—that will move us towards a situation in which the transition is seamless and people feel supported, which I think and hope is what Rachael Wallace wants.

09:45

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

I am still not clear on that. You said that it has to be done locally because it is complex, and that we cannot just have a national provision or pathway. However, we are not developing local services or pathways—we have a pilot.

Aileen Campbell SNP Clydesdale
link

It is a pilot to help us understand what we need to do to enhance local provision around the country, but with the national principles that we all understand will be useful and critical to ensure that the transition is seamless.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Is there a possibility that the pilot will lead to a national pathway? Are you excluding that as a possibility?

Dr Smith
link

From a clinical perspective, one of the characteristics of national pathways tends to be a really narrow range of providers that can give care to patients, so if one or two providers can deliver that care at a national level, that would be a tangible approach for a national pathway.

In the case of the cerebral palsy pilot, there is a requirement in the planning phase to develop robust evidence that suggests the services and approach that are necessary at a local level by multiple providers so that patients receive the best care possible. That is the best way that I can describe it.

National pathways tend to be for a very narrow provider range—for the one or two providers throughout Scotland who are capable of providing care. However, the Bobath pilot will provide the evidence for a framework that underpins local pathway development, allowing for care according to the needs of the local population. I hope that that makes sense.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

In your meeting with the petitioner, there was a suggestion that it might take 10 years to develop a clinical pathway and framework for adults with cerebral palsy. Do you agree that that is far too long? Will you set a timetable for developing that work?

Aileen Campbell SNP Clydesdale
link

At the time of our discussion with Rachael Wallace, there was a misunderstanding about the 10-year timeframe and we tried to give reassurance that it will not take 10 years to develop improvements for cerebral palsy.

The Bobath pilot is 18 months long. It will be pulled together with work that is happening on other neurological conditions—for instance, Huntington’s disease—to help us to develop a framework to make the changes that Rachael has said that she would like to see. That will not take 10 years.

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

We know that there are national clinical pathways in Scotland for other conditions, such as motor neurone disease. Roughly, what would it cost to set up a national pathway? Does that have any bearing on what you are planning to do for cerebral palsy?

Elizabeth Porterfield Scottish Government
link

I honestly do not know how much it would cost, but I know that it would—as Gregor Smith described—have several layers and areas of work that would need to be progressed with the involvement of people with cerebral palsy, as well as specialists, non-specialists and all the managers. It is possible to do that, and the Bobath pilot has been looking at how that is done locally with all the providers.

Although there may be, and I use the phrase in quotation marks, “specialist needs” within a general service—physiotherapists are all trained to provide physiotherapy for a range of conditions—what someone with cerebral palsy needs must be defined by looking at the individual.

Yes, we can set up a pathway, but the time costs of the people who would need to get together in order to do that would vary. No specific cost has been attached to this work and cost has not entered into any thinking around it. We agreed that we needed to do the work, so we funded the pilot to see how it could be done in the partnership context, because of health and social care integration. Meeting the needs is not all about healthcare services; there are also issues in the join up with social care. IJBs are responsible for commissioning services, which is why the work must be done locally.

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

Will you remind us how much the pilot costs?

Elizabeth Porterfield Scottish Government
link

It is £73,000, so far.

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

Dr Smith, do you want to comment?

Dr Smith
link

I do not recognise cost as a consideration when thinking about what qualifies for a national pathway and what needs work to develop local pathways. That is not one of the considerations that people factor in.

Aileen Campbell SNP Clydesdale
link

In the discussion that I had with Rachael Wallace, she described a situation that is often the case in many areas of social policy and health policy, which is that, had issues been identified earlier and the transition been smoother, perhaps she would not have needed costlier services, because some of the issues that she is encountering now would have been prevented.

That is a lesson about the importance of getting services delivered holistically around the person, so that they are empowered to be in control of what services are delivered to them, that they are able to articulate clearly and that they feel that they are being responded to by local services. In that way, the costlier consequences for people’s health and the public purse of not identifying and dealing with something can be avoided.

The whole reason for developing the alternative pathway is to embed the approach of early intervention and prevention. That is the right thing to do for the person; it is also the right thing to do for how we marshal public funds.

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

Thank you; that is helpful.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

The point is that there is no transition. That was the petitioner’s experience—not that it was not terribly well organised.

Aileen Campbell SNP Clydesdale
link

The pilot is in place to try to identify how transition can be dealt with adequately. We want to make sure that we have a better understanding of what other NHS boards are doing, whether the situation that arose is particular to Rachael Wallace, and whether it is a matter that we need to address much more quickly. The evidence from and the research into the pilot will allow us to speed up some of that across the country.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Is the work to identify what the health boards are doing across the country taking place in parallel with the Bobath pilot?

Aileen Campbell SNP Clydesdale
link

Yes, it will do. Although I have not been involved in the work, I understand that Capability Scotland is doing a mapping exercise through which it will identify areas that need to be addressed, which will complement the learning not only from the Bobath pilot but from other work on neurological conditions such as Huntington’s disease. The Scottish Huntington’s Association is also developing a framework to help people cope with the condition. I understand that those involved in other neurological conditions welcome that work and want to build on and develop it further, so that it caters not just for Huntington’s disease, but a suite of other conditions.

At this time, we are gathering the evidence and the research in order that we can proceed in a much stronger way and give the reassurance that Rachael Wallace needs.

Dr Smith
link

To expand on that response, it is utterly critical from a clinical perspective that work on transitions is led at a local level. The experience of people with childhood illnesses who transition into adult care—whether that be in chronic diseases such as asthma, epilepsy or whatever else—is about how local services configure themselves, develop the relationships between clinicians and their patients—

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Surely transitions must be shaped by the national understanding of issues relating to a particular condition. You are not suggesting to everyone in a geographical area who has asthma that their asthma is specific to their local conditions. There must be a national perspective on how you would manage any condition, which would then inform the local issues.

Dr Smith
link

But that is different from a national pathway, where you might get national guidance or a national framework to help support that local work. A national pathway would take us into a whole different spectrum of approach with regard to how we manage that condition.

Aileen Campbell SNP Clydesdale
link

There are key principles for transition with regard to any issue or condition, and they are about having those relationships and ensuring that services are delivered timeously to an individual and that they feel empowered. Unfortunately, that does not seem to have happened in Rachael Wallace’s case, and she has explained that to us.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

With respect, I think that she would suggest that this is an issue not just for herself but for other people with her condition. Anyway, let us make progress.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

Ms Wallace is calling on the Scottish Government to consult stakeholders on the development of a clinical pathway, and she is particularly keen for national health service professionals who support and deliver services for adults with cerebral palsy to be involved in that. Are you prepared to do that?

Aileen Campbell SNP Clydesdale
link

Absolutely. I am always keen to engage with people with real-life experience of such issues. Again, we have offered to work—and to continue to work—with Rachael Wallace herself to ensure that she has the confidence that our actions are addressing the concerns that she has raised in the petition. Moreover, Bobath Scotland’s work in West Dunbartonshire features very deep engagement with people with the condition, clinicians and the whole range of service providers in that area. We are always absolutely keen to engage with people who have lived experience, because that is how we enhance services.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

The petitioner notes in her written submission that she has experienced difficulty in using self-directed support to pay for specialist physiotherapy. It is one example that she uses to highlight why, in her view, a national clinical pathway for cerebral palsy is merited. Are you familiar with that problem and why there might be confusion about which types of services self-directed support can be used for?

Aileen Campbell SNP Clydesdale
link

The guidance that accompanies the self-directed support legislation states that direct payments can be spent in this way, provided that approved outcomes are met, and that such support should be empowering for people with particular conditions. In our discussion with Rachael Wallace, we undertook to carry out further work in case that was not understood in a national sense, and we have also worked with COSLA on developing much more consistency in the more general application of self-directed support across the country. After all, the desire behind and the aim of self-directed support is to ensure that people feel empowered and in control of their condition and the way in which they get help.

Murdo Fraser Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

First, I want to put on record my thanks to the minister and her officials for the opportunity to meet her and the petitioner a couple of weeks ago and her officials prior to that. The meetings were very helpful.

Reflecting on some of the exchanges that we have just heard, I think from my experience of talking to Rachael Wallace her biggest issue was the inability to find anyone in the NHS with the correct knowledge and expertise to address her issues. It was different when she was a child, but when she made the transition to adulthood there seemed to be nothing available and no one to even point her in the right direction. That is really what led to the petition being taken forward, because she was left having to source specialists in physiotherapy herself and, in some cases, to travel quite large distances to get the specialist treatment that she needed.

I am quite keen to focus on two issues that have come up, the first of which is the local pathway that has been mentioned. The petitioner has made it very clear that there is a need for a national clinical pathway. My concern about going down a local route is: if you leave it to health boards to develop this pathway themselves, what confidence is there that they will do so? I am sure that Rachael Wallace’s experience so far in Tayside is not atypical of what is happening elsewhere in the country, and the whole point of having a petition calling for the establishment of a national clinical pathway was to ensure some uniformity of care and support for CP sufferers right across the country.

The second issue, which the convener has already touched on, is about timing. We want to know that there will be some urgency in dealing with this matter. I am encouraged by what the minister has said about the work that is going on, but we do not want to come back here in five years’ time and find that very little has happened.

10:00

Aileen Campbell SNP Clydesdale
link

Absolutely. People will be going through transitions now, and we do not want to hear more stories like Rachael Wallace’s. I agree that pace needs to be injected.

We are coming to the end of the pilot. After it, we will be able to move forward on ensuring that there is a better national understanding and that there are ways in which we can build a framework that has national prominence for local NHS boards or local providers to understand.

I go back to the points that Gregor Smith made about the local clinical pathway needing to be based on cognisance of the individual’s condition and the local support that can be brought around them. Murdo Fraser is also right, however, that we need to drive this nationally, too. That is partly about ensuring that people have a better understanding of the condition and that there is much more general awareness of it, so that Rachael does not feel that she has to go over what her condition means for her or explain it to people whom she believes should already have knowledge of what she might be going through. One of the points that Rachael made was that she was not able to speak to anyone who could tell her what related conditions she should anticipate as part of her cerebral palsy. We will certainly undertake to ensure that there is greater awareness raising.

I think that there will be the ability to develop a framework that is based on the Bobath Scotland pilot. Bobath Scotland has just launched a new website and, although it is for children, we want to explore ways in which we can develop it to be applicable to everybody, including adults with cerebral palsy. We will continue to work with Rachael on all those things to give her the confidence that pace has been injected into the work so that she does not find herself having to resubmit her petition in five years’ time.

Murdo Fraser Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

So that I am clear about the local pathways that you have talked about, what is the role of the Scottish Government and the national NHS in ensuring that such pathways are delivered by local health boards?

Dr Smith
link

Local ownership is really important in pathway development, because local clinicians and local co-ordinators are relied on to champion that. One of the best ways of trying to resolve some of the problems that Ms Wallace has experienced in co-ordination at a local level—the signposting, the availability of services and the visibility of those services to local clinicians—is by local ownership and development. That can be influenced in a variety of ways through the national medical directors and the national nurse directors group, who can be examined on where they are with that development and how they assure themselves of the service through their local clinical governance structures. There is also a really strong role for groups such as Capability Scotland to hold to account the local boards, alongside the Scottish Government, for the services that their members and the people whom they represent experience.

Aileen Campbell SNP Clydesdale
link

We also have the national advisory committee for neurological conditions. There might be a role for it to ensure that there is national oversight of the way in which local provision is delivered. A workforce planning sub-group is part of that. That gives us another opportunity to have a national understanding of local delivery.

Dr Smith
link

Ultimately, our aim is to improve the service that people with cerebral palsy experience. There is a variety of ways to do that. I will use the example of another area of clinical practice: respiratory medicine. The pathway work with respiratory medicine started between 2006 and 2008. Across the country, we gradually saw huge improvements in the way in which patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, in particular, experienced care. The formation of the national airways group, which represented all those pathway groups coming together, sharing good practice and learning from one another, has meant that they are able to take things on further. There was never a national pathway for respiratory medicine. Those pathways developed cognisant of local needs and local services, they were owned by local services and respiratory care has been taken forward.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

I think that it is remarkable to suggest that it is the job of the charity Capability Scotland to hold an NHS board to account, given that I would imagine that the board often commissions work from an individual charity. That would seem to me to be a very uneven battle. However, are lessons emerging from Bobath Scotland’s work at a local level about what local services care would encompass, including health and social care, beyond physiotherapy? Are there early lessons emerging just now that might be worth sharing with those who are concerned about this question?

Aileen Campbell SNP Clydesdale
link

I think that what Dr Smith said earlier was about the number of ways in which boards can be held to account and I mentioned in response to Murdo Fraser the national advisory committee for neurological conditions. I think that it is a bit disingenuous to suggest that we are only and solely looking for Capability Scotland to be holding boards to account.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

I did not say that. I said that it would be remarkable if a charity was able to hold a board to account. It would be a first, as most—

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

I think that there is an issue about anyone holding a board to account, so there would be an interesting lesson to learn from that.

Aileen Campbell SNP Clydesdale
link

Perhaps. There are early lessons from the Bobath Scotland pilot, which has been on-going for around 18 months. The organisation has been concentrating on working with the workforce and ensuring that they have a better understanding of the condition and where the gaps in provision exist. The organisation has been working to ensure understanding of the transitions for people with cerebral palsy. Phase 2 of the pilot has been looking at practical improvements that can be made and what interventions need to be undertaken to ensure that the transition is smooth and outcomes are improved. We will shortly get the final lessons of the pilot and we can share that full learning with the committee, if that would be of interest to it.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Okay. Are there any further questions from members?

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

I know that the convener has gone over this issue previously, but I still have a problem with it. I understand the necessity for the local delivery of services, but I am struggling to connect the dots between having a pilot for one local pathway and developing different local pathways across Scotland. How can each local authority have its own pathway to follow if there is not at least at least a framework for a national pathway?

Aileen Campbell SNP Clydesdale
link

It is not unusual to develop policy and practice by having a pilot to test what works and what is possible, to understand what barriers there are, to see what more needs to be done and to see what unintended consequences might crop up through the process, then to distil that learning and share it and those key principles nationally. That is why there has been a pilot and why there has been the engagement with Bobath Scotland. Given its expertise on cerebral palsy, it was commissioned to provide us in the Government, before we undertake national policy decisions, with research evidence and understanding about what needs to happen with the condition and what needs to be improved, which we can then share with boards so that they can apply the key principles to their local clinical pathways to ensure that provision is improved across the country for people with cerebral palsy.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

To me, you have just described a national pathway.

Dr Smith
link

As is often the case in these circumstances, Mr Whittle, it is really easy for the terminology to get mistaken. You referred to a national framework, which is important. The evidence from a variety of sources, including current practice across the boards, will provide us with a sense of a national framework that can inform best practice in pathway development, rather than provide us with a national pathway, which is a completely separate thing. A national pathway would be a way of delivering care to patients from only one or two providers on a national basis.

Maurice Corry Con West Scotland
link

Would it not be sensible, bearing in mind what Mr Whittle has just said, to run a parallel project in, say, Aberdeen or in another local authority area and perhaps have even a third one? Statistically, that would be more sensible than relying on just one, particularly one in West Dunbartonshire. That is in my local area and has a lot of rural parts, which means that we are not looking at the conurbations so much. I believe that there should be a balance in that regard in order to get the right result.

Aileen Campbell SNP Clydesdale
link

That might be one option, although I am also aware that the committee has asked me to inject pace into this work. As well as working with the clinicians, this is about working with individuals with cerebral palsy and the expertise and knowledge that Bobath Scotland has more generally, aside from the pilot. I think that, together, we will be able to get to a place where we can provide a national framework that understands the reality and complexity of Scotland’s geography, from the cities and urban areas to the islands. Understanding the condition as best we can will enable us to improve provision nationally. I do not think that the committee would want me to undertake more pilots at the risk of delaying improvements across the country.

Maurice Corry Con West Scotland
link

It is just a pity that you did not start off with pilots in, say, three different areas rather than just one. There are 31 other local authority areas.

Aileen Campbell SNP Clydesdale
link

I ask Elizabeth Porterfield to comment on the reasons why West Dunbartonshire was picked.

Elizabeth Porterfield Scottish Government
link

It was done entirely in working with Bobath. We wanted to look at the matter and that was Bobath’s suggestion, so that is how we agreed to go forward. There was no proposal to do pilots in two or three areas. We wanted to look at the possibilities, and the integration joint boards and the community health partnerships are now the commissioners of the services, so we have to look at it in that way.

I take your point, Mr Corry, that we might have looked at doing pilots elsewhere, but the partner in this case is Bobath, and West Dunbartonshire is where it proposed doing the pilot. It is as simple as that, I am afraid.

Aileen Campbell SNP Clydesdale
link

Bobath Scotland has an in-depth, national understanding of the condition, as it works with many people across the country. Along with the individual outcomes of the West Dunbartonshire pilot, Bobath’s national understanding and expertise will be used as we all work together towards ensuring that we get a framework that is deliverable throughout the country. The mapping exercise by Capability Scotland is looking to see where provision may need to be enhanced, and we have undertaken to further enhance that by working with NHS boards across the country. In addition, there is the work that the Scottish Huntington’s Association is doing on frameworks for that condition, which those who work on other neurological conditions have said they would like to use to enhance services for their particular conditions.

Piecing all that together will put us in a strong position to deliver a national framework that understands the geography of Scotland, understands the desire that we all share to improve services across the country for people who suffer from cerebral palsy and addresses the issues that Rachael Wallace raises in her petition such as transition, access to things such as physiotherapy and the sense of powerlessness that she felt as someone with the condition. I anticipate that that work will lead to improvements, and I hope that it gives her comfort. We will continue to work with her and test that against her expectations.

Maurice Corry Con West Scotland
link

I am just concerned about the situation. I would not say that you have been led by the nose by Bobath and I am not decrying the work that it does, but the approach takes away from the national picture. That is my concern. You might have gone out to a bigger area of Scotland.

Aileen Campbell SNP Clydesdale
link

As I highlighted, Bobath has a national presence and, probably, far more expertise in the condition than any of us round the committee table has. We have undertaken to test with all NHS boards what they are doing and whether it is appropriate, looking at their transition programmes and how they are helping people to overcome the barriers. We are also funding the Scottish Huntington’s Association to develop its framework, which people who work on other neurological conditions have said they are keen to use to enhance provision for their particular conditions.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

The only thing that I would add is that there is a bit of a chicken-and-egg situation here. I presume that you actively chose Bobath to do your pilot and had a conversation with it about defining the pilot. However, we will await its findings with interest.

We have come to the end of our consideration of the petition. I thank the minister and her officials for attending. We will want to reflect on the evidence that we have heard and to test it against the responses of the petitioner and others. We will decide what further action to take at a future meeting. We have been given plenty of food for thought.

Is there any suggested action that you would like to highlight, Mr Fraser?

Murdo Fraser Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

It has been a helpful session. Quite a lot of information has come out over the past half hour or so. It would be useful to take that away, digest it and get the petitioner’s view on where we should go from here.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

In that case, we are agreed that we will reflect on the evidence from the minister. At that point, we will decide what further action to take.

I again thank the minister and her officials for their attendance. It has been a very useful session.

Aileen Campbell SNP Clydesdale
link

We undertake to make sure that, as the committee undertakes its deliberations, it has an idea of when the learning from the pilot will be available. That might help the committee with its understanding of how to proceed.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

We are particularly happy with your clear view that the process will not take 10 years. That will be reassuring to everybody.

10:16 Meeting suspended.

10:18 On resuming—

  1. 09:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 41
  2. 09:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 67
  3. 10:00 New Petition Petitions · 56
  4. 10:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 8
  5. 10:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 13

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.