Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Continued Petitions

Social Care (Charges) (PE1533)

Thursday 16 March 2017 Public Petitions Committee About 09:00–09:15 Petitions 41 contributions · 8 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

41 contributions
Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

I welcome everyone to the fifth meeting in 2017 of the Public Petitions Committee. I remind members and others in the room to switch their phones and other devices to silent.

The first agenda item is consideration of continued petitions. The committee will take evidence on PE1480, by Amanda Kopel, on Alzheimer’s and dementia awareness, and PE1533, by Jeff Adamson, on behalf of Scotland against the care tax, on the abolition of non-residential social care charges for older and disabled people. I am delighted that we are joined by the Cabinet Secretary for Health and Sport and her officials David Fotheringham, head of adult social care, and Mike Liddle, policy manager. Welcome to the meeting.

As we have limited time, we intend to move straight to questions, if that is acceptable. I will start. In your submission to the committee of 2 November 2016, you explained that the Scottish Government is conducting a feasibility study on expanding free personal care and nursing care to people with dementia who are under 65. I understand that that is due to be completed in the summer of this year. The committee would welcome a copy of the study when it is published.

You will recall that you gave evidence on PE1480 to the session 4 Public Petitions Committee on 6 October 2015. At that meeting, you explained:

“We are absolutely trying to avoid lists of conditions, because we will always miss one, and that will be the condition that will form the basis of the next petition to this committee”.—Official Report, Public Petitions Committee, 6 October 2015; c 42.

It would seem from the details that we have on the feasibility study that you are focusing on dementia. The petitioners for PE1533 argue that the scope of the study should be extended to include people with disabilities.

Can you explain why you have decided to focus on a specific condition while acknowledging that that approach will be criticised?

Shona Robison SNP The Cabinet Secretary for Health and Sport · Dundee City East
link

Thank you for giving me the opportunity to give evidence. I must clarify that the feasibility study will look at the feasibility of extending free personal care to all those under 65 who need it. During the members’ business debate that took place on 6 December last year, that issue was explored and members asked us to look at all conditions. As I have said previously, it would be difficult to look only at one condition. We have taken into consideration the views that members expressed during that debate and how challengeable it would be to look only at one condition, not to mention the issue of basic fairness, and we have agreed that the scope of the feasibility study will look at all those under 65. I hope that that provides the clarity that you seek.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

So you have extended the scope of the feasibility study beyond people with dementia.

Maurice Corry Con West Scotland
link

Good morning. Calls have been made to establish a cross-party working group to consider what a fair social care charging system would look like and what it would cost. Have discussions on that taken place? What has been the outcome?

Shona Robison SNP Dundee City East
link

We need to proceed in an orderly manner. The feasibility study will give us a lot of important information so that we can make informed choices about the way forward. The point at which to have discussions with members of other parties is when we get that feasibility study, and I would be very happy to have those discussions. I think that I gave that commitment during the members’ business debate, and I am happy to give it again today. Rather than talking before we have that information in front of us, we would then have something to talk about. I think that that would be the best process. Once we have the feasibility study, I will be happy to engage with members from other parties.

Maurice Corry Con West Scotland
link

Are any stakeholders represented in producing the feasibility study? Is it on track to be completed by summer this year?

Shona Robison SNP Dundee City East
link

Yes, it is on track. It is being taken forward by Scottish Government officials and analysts, and it involves talking to local authorities and ensuring that we get the right information. However, I am happy to ask my officials to meet stakeholders who want to discuss the feasibility study further and to keep them informed of the work that we are undertaking.

Obviously, I would be very happy for the feasibility study to be brought to the committee once it has been published. The convener asked for the committee to receive a copy of it, and I am very happy to agree to that and to confirm that copies can be sent to stakeholders. If they want to discuss it further once they have seen it, I would also be happy to agree to that.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

A slightly different proposal to having a meeting with folk who are interested in looking at the report is having a cross-party working group, perhaps with stakeholders, to look at it and see what the challenges of implementation are. Would you at least consider that?

Shona Robison SNP Dundee City East
link

I am happy to consider that. I hope that the information that we get in the summer will give us clearer options for the way forward. Obviously, they will have to be deliverable, affordable, fair and consistent. First of all, we need to have the information on which to be able to make informed decisions about what is possible. I will not rule out an initial cross-party meeting to look at that and the view being taken that we should continue cross-party discussions. I would be happy to consider that further.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

At this stage, should stakeholders and the petitioners simply contact your officials about feeding into the feasibility study?

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

Good morning. In previous evidence, you have explained that there are various models that could be implemented to make the charging regime fair. One approach that you have mentioned is to reconsider the threshold at which people start to pay charges. You have explained that the income threshold that determines when people will begin to pay charges will rise from 16.5 to 25 per cent. The PE1533 petitioners are concerned that a blanket increase in the social care charging threshold will not reflect relative costs of living in different parts of Scotland. What is your view on whether applying blanket thresholds promotes a fair charging system?

Shona Robison SNP Dundee City East
link

We have taken action on the threshold. We raised it from 16.5 to 25 per cent above the pension credit guarantee, or the income support personal allowance and disability premium, because we thought that, in making charging fairer, which is our aim, starting with those on the lowest incomes was the fairest thing to do. That is why we took that step to raise the threshold.

We have also taken action to ensure that members of the armed forces have their war pensions disregarded in income assessments, and it was already the case that local authorities were not charging for people with a terminal illness in the final six months of their life. Steps have already been taken on that.

On the question of whether there should be different thresholds in different parts of Scotland, we would also want to listen to stakeholders who tell us that they want greater consistency in charging policies throughout the country. That issue has been raised with me by a number of MSPs over the years and more recently. It would seem to run counter to the idea of greater consistency to move to different charging thresholds in different parts of the country. As we take forward the information that the feasibility study will give us in the summer, I hope that achieving greater—as opposed to less—consistency will be one of the principles. Having different thresholds in different parts of Scotland would lead to greater inconsistency, and I think that, on balance, members are asking me to ensure that there is greater consistency rather than less consistency.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

In the debate on 6 December, you explained that the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities had implemented a new standard financial assessment tool that should reduce the variation in local authorities’ charging regimes. The petitioners for PE1533 have been very critical of the tool’s ability to meet that aim. They argue that there is evidence that variation continues and that some local authorities have increased their social care charges despite the tool being in place. What assessment has been carried out of the tool’s impact and its effectiveness in meeting that aim?

Shona Robison SNP Dundee City East
link

COSLA’s standard financial assessment tool is in its first year of operation. COSLA has said that it will monitor its impact, and we expect it to do that.

I want there to be greater consistency and fairness in the system, as I said in answer to the previous question. Although we have powers to require local authorities to charge or not charge for any particular aspect of social care, the partnership agreement that we have with local government means that local authorities should retain local accountability. They are keen that that remain the case. That is where we are as we seek to make progress on fairer charging, and that is where we want to remain. Although we have the power to mandate such things, we have worked with local government to reach agreement so that we can tackle matters in a different way. That is why the standard financial assessment tool is important. I will continue to discuss with COSLA the monitoring and implementation of that. We need greater consistency, and the local authorities should use the tool to achieve that.

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

Good morning. You have explained that, if the variation in local authorities’ charging regimes does not improve, you might consider using legislative powers to ensure that it does. At what point would you consider introducing such legislation? How would you use that approach to diminish the variation in charging?

Shona Robison SNP Dundee City East
link

As you say, that power has existed for a number of years. However, the approach that we have taken has been one of partnership. We have attempted to achieve greater consistency, and COSLA has worked with us on that through the assessment tool. We have taken action on raising the threshold, on terminal illness and on armed forces veterans receiving the full value of their war pension. We have taken an incremental approach to improving the system and making charging fairer. I see that continuing, and I hope that the feasibility study that will be published in the summer will help us to reach a consensus—one that involves local government—on the way forward. I would rather take that approach than tackle the issue in a different way. For me, that represents a better route forward.

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

But would legislation be used as an absolute last resort?

Shona Robison SNP Dundee City East
link

That option has always been there—I think that the power in question was brought in when free personal care for the elderly was legislated for in 2002. It is there as a backstop, but we want to avoid taking such an approach by working with local government to get to a fairer charging position.

We have already made progress—I have outlined some of the progress that we have made on the threshold, armed forces veterans and those in the final six months of their lives—but there is more to be done, and I expect us to do that in partnership with local government, which will be heavily involved in the feasibility study that will be published in the summer.

09:15

Angus MacDonald SNP Falkirk East
link

Good morning, cabinet secretary. You have mentioned the standard financial assessment tool and your commitment to work with local authorities on that. The petitioners for PE1533 raise concerns about the democratic accountability of social care charging. In their view, the integration of health and social care has made it less clear which body is responsible for setting policy in the area. What is your view on that? How should councils and integration joint boards work together on the issue in practice and communicate clearly with members of the public who use social care services?

Shona Robison SNP Dundee City East
link

As you know, the integration of health and social care has established a new relationship between health, local government and other partners around the table. We expect that, when the provision of social work services is considered, all those partners will be in dialogue and those discussions will be taken into account when decisions are reached on social care charging.

The framework for the setting of charges is clear. Social care charges will continue to be set by the local authority, taking into account the guidance that has been produced by COSLA, which we discussed earlier, and the other guidance that has been produced. The guidance makes a number of things clear, including—importantly—the need to ensure that people have good, clear information about the available services and the types of charges that might apply. It recommends that all councils provide charging information in a standard format on their websites and that information about benefit entitlement should also be available.

Ultimately, it is for local authorities to decide and, if they make decisions that local people do not like, it is for local people to make their views known about that, and there is an opportunity to do that through the ballot box. If a local authority has a policy on charging that local people do not favour, that is where democratic accountability is exercised.

In the new integrated landscape, local authorities will retain authority over charging.

Angus MacDonald SNP Falkirk East
link

Dr Kopel has raised concerns about the six-month end-of-life guidelines, arguing that it is often difficult for practitioners to assess whether someone is in the final six months of their life. You have previously explained that, once a DS1500 form has been completed, a person will not be chased by the local authority if their prognosis continues beyond six months. What written guidance is there to support that policy? Are you aware of any complaints that that guidance is not being followed?

Shona Robison SNP Dundee City East
link

That is an important issue. COSLA’s charging guidance recommends that local authorities use their discretion to extend the waiver of charges beyond six months. We would expect all local authorities to follow that guidance, and I am not aware of any evidence that it is not being followed. If members have any evidence of the guidance not being followed, I would be happy to look into that and, if need be, work with COSLA to clarify the guidance.

It is important that no one who is in the last stages of a terminal illness is charged for the personal care that they receive at home. If there is any evidence that that is happening, I would be keen to see that and to take action accordingly. It is important that we continue to monitor the situation and, if there is any such evidence, I would want to see it.

Angus MacDonald SNP Falkirk East
link

If the committee receives any such evidence, we will forward it to you.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

I have a couple of questions. First, on disability-related expenditure, you will be aware that in England it is a legal requirement that any additional expenditure related to a person’s disability is taken into account. That is not the case in Scotland, and it seems that the overwhelming majority of local authorities in Scotland make no allowance for additional costs. That, in turn, raises issues with regard to people’s ability to fulfil their potential, for example to work. Will you be looking at the fact that that issue is simply not recognised in the charging regime?

Shona Robison SNP Dundee City East
link

We will want to continue to discuss with local authorities what is disregarded and what is taken into account as we take the issues forward. There is variation in practice across these islands. The approach of disregarding income and having a buffer on top of that is designed to try to ensure that the income that people are left with is adequate not just to pay care charges but to meet other needs. I guess that we will want to keep the matter under review.

Does Mike Liddle have anything to add about the difference?

Mike Liddle Scottish Government
link

Not really; David Fotheringham might have something to say.

David Fotheringham Scottish Government
link

Obviously, the disability benefits that people get should take into account their relative needs, and we will be getting additional powers in relation to some of those matters.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

In England, it is a legal requirement that additional costs as a result of a person’s specific disability are taken into account and properly assessed. That is what I am talking about, not the general situation in which a person with a disability ticks a particular box and therefore comes under a particular charging regime. The person is specifically assessed with regard to the extra expenditure that comes with their particular disability. For some people, that expenditure can be very significant.

Shona Robison SNP Dundee City East
link

So it would be more of a needs-based assessment.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Yes. Would you at least look at that?

Shona Robison SNP Dundee City East
link

It is something that we can take into consideration and explore further. I come back to David Fotheringham’s point about the devolution of some welfare benefits, which will enable us to look at all these things and perhaps take a different approach. We will certainly give further consideration to the matter.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

PE1480 focuses on the issue of people under 65 who have dementia not having access to certain supports; that is clear, and I acknowledge that your feasibility study is looking at that. However, PE1533 is really about whether access to such services should be free at the point of need, which, as I understand it, your feasibility study is not looking at. What is your view on what I think is quite a compelling argument that this is a human rights issue? According to that argument, we should all be entitled to achieve our potential and have the supports to allow us to access work, education and whatever else, but at the moment we have a care and funding regime that actually denies people that entitlement. Disability-related expenditure is part of that, but do you see the argument that a system of support and care that is not very closely connected to people’s individual needs could be a human rights issue?

Shona Robison SNP Dundee City East
link

I agree with you to the extent that a person’s ability to live life to the full and their being supported to do so is a basic right; indeed, we have recognised that in some of the policies that we have taken forward. Let us step outside charging for a second and look at things such as self-directed support or the independent living fund, which, unlike elsewhere, is being continued in Scotland. I think that those are examples of resources that are being used very much to enable people to live the lives that they want to live, for example by continuing to work. The ILF supports people to remain independent at home, hold down a job and go about their daily lives, while the principle behind SDS is very much about personalised support to allow people to live life as they would wish to instead of perhaps being restricted by having to fit into the services that are available. All of that is based on empowerment, personalised care and the ability to live an independent life. To that extent, therefore, I have sympathy with what you are saying.

The fairer charging policy is being taken forward with a view to maximising people’s independence and improving the quality of care that they receive, as well as ensuring that they are not in a position in which they do not accept support because of charges. We want to assess issues such as unmet need in that regard, and the feasibility study will examine that. There might be people who currently do not accept support because of the charging regime. That is a concern, because it means not only that they might not be living life to the full but that they might be encountering severe difficulty in their day-to-day lives.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

I note what you say about the independent living fund, and I appreciate that you have continued it for those who are already in it, but the fund is not accepting new applicants.

Shona Robison SNP Dundee City East
link

It will. Resources—£5 million—are available for new applicants to the ILF, so new applicants will be able to apply. The focus has been on establishing the infrastructure around that, and it has taken some time to ensure that the application processes are in place.

As some of the welfare benefits are devolved, there is an opportunity to join the dots a bit more effectively around the supports that are available, whether they involve mainstream care support through local authority or third sector providers, self-directed support, the independent living fund or some of the other benefits that will be devolved. Over time, we will have an opportunity to bring more coherence to those benefits so that we can focus more on what the person needs to be able to live a fully independent life.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

I suppose that the human rights approach would mean that saying, “It’s too expensive,” would be an unacceptable answer. The campaigners who submitted PE1533 are exploring that issue, as are some members. For example, you would not say that universal education is too expensive so we will just educate our boys. That is the kind of issue that is being explored.

My final question concerns your understanding of the definition of care. Some of the evidence that we have received on the kind of support that people require suggests that people need not only physical care but support that enables them to be active citizens, to work and so on. Such support would not be included in a narrow definition of care. Local authorities, obviously, have quite significant constraints with regard to what they are doing. Are you concerned that, generally, our definition of care does not recognise people’s entitlement to support that enables them to achieve their full potential and, instead, because it is so narrow, inhibits what they do?

Shona Robison SNP Dundee City East
link

As part of the free personal and nursing care policy, it was necessary to define what was meant by “care” in terms of entitlement. Finances are not infinite, so there has been a focus on support needs around personal care and a prioritisation of needs, with those who have the greatest needs getting support, particularly in relation to dignity and the ability to remain living in their homes. Without that personal care, many people would not be able to remain in their homes, or their families and carers would have to provide all that care without any external support, which would put huge pressure on them.

We will always need definitions. Personal care has been given that level of priority because it has been recognised that it is, by nature, personal. Personal needs—washing, dressing, getting up, going to bed and so on—are about dignity.

I would be cautious about whether there is a need for a redefinition. We live with finite resources, and the focus of our attention at the moment is on what we can do around the personal care needs of those who are under 65. I would like to keep our focus on that and try to see whether we can resolve that issue in a fairer way before we consider the definition of personal care more generally.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

From the point of view of the petitioners, the issue is clearly not one that will be resolved by a feasibility study, even though that study will provide a lot of information. A strong and compelling case has been made in relation to the under-65s and issues such as the variation across the country, the definition of need and the comparisons around disability-related expenditure. We might want to examine those issues further, and we appreciate the evidence that the cabinet secretary has given us.

Do members have a view on what we should do now? We will want to reflect on what the cabinet secretary has said. Clearly, the publication of the feasibility study will be a critical milestone and perhaps the committee can consider the issue further at that point. Do we agree to do that?

Members indicated agreement.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Okay, we will do that, and we will take the opportunity to reflect on the cabinet secretary’s evidence. Obviously, the petitioners will also have a view, and that will help us decide on a course of action at a later meeting.

I thank the cabinet secretary for her attendance.

09:31 Meeting suspended.

09:34 On resuming—

  1. 09:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 41
  2. 09:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 67
  3. 10:00 New Petition Petitions · 56
  4. 10:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 8
  5. 10:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 13

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.