I am a Mid Scotland and Fife MSP.
Official Report · Committee
Additional Support Needs
Speakers
Showing Liz Smith only · show everyone- James Dornan SNP 30
- Sylvia Haughney Glasgow City Council 15
- Professor Riddell 15
- Sharon Veelenturf 11
- Colin Crawford Glasgow City Council 9
- Liz Smith Con 8
- Johann Lamont Lab 6
- Kenny Graham Scottish Children’s Services Coalition 6
- Sally Cavers Enquire 5
- Carol Gilmour 5
- Richard Lochhead SNP 4
- Daniel Johnson Lab 4
- Samreen Shah 4
- Ross Greer Green 3
- Clare Adamson SNP 3
- Ross Thomson Con 2
- Colin Beattie SNP 2
- Tavish Scott LD 1
- Professor Sheila Riddell University of Edinburgh 1
Liz Smith’s contributions
8 contributionsConstituents have written to me about mainstreaming for a long time. I agree entirely that inclusion is desirable, particularly from a social angle. Notwithstanding that, in my experience, many local authorities absolutely refuse to send a child, or to make provision for the child to be sent, to a special school, although that is the best educational outcome for the child. That disturbs me a lot.
Do we need to have a bigger debate about mainstreaming and whether the 1 per cent or fewer of pupils for whom a special setting is undoubtedly the best educational outcome are best catered for in special schools or in the kind of unit that Sharon Veelenturf spoke about—in which case, should we do more to develop those units? I am interested in the evidence on that because I could name several cases in which constituents have clearly had great difficulty and faced a lot of angst in getting the right educational package for their children. Too often, that has been because the local authority has refused to provide that package because it has not assessed the child’s needs properly. I ask for advice on that.
Yes, but that brings us back to what Sharon Veelenturf said, which is that people are not always aware of that and do not always know how to react.
They do.
I will go back to something that Sylvia Haughney mentioned. You talked about a lack of training for the professionals and the worry about cascaded training, as you described it. How serious is that problem? Is the expectation that issues will be passed on to someone who has the knowledge to deal with them, instead of all staff receiving the appropriate training? Is that a serious problem?
You said that that was not the case before.
There has been a significant change, as you describe it.
Is that because the definition has changed, which means that we are identifying many more children who have such needs and we are having to spread our resources much more thinly? Alternatively, are there problems with the nature of teacher training? What is the reason for the change that you just described?
11:15
In this meeting
Everything on 1 Mar 2017 →- 10:00 Decisions on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 3
- 10:00 Additional Support Needs Evidence session · 134
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.