Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Additional Support Needs

Wednesday 1 March 2017 Education and Skills Committee About 10:00–11:15 Evidence session 134 contributions · 19 speakers

Speakers

Showing Johann Lamont only · show everyone

Johann Lamont’s contributions

6 contributions
Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow
link

First, we should acknowledge the significant level of response that there has been to our request for evidence. The situation is shocking, and I am sure that the committee will want to do more simply because of the evidence that families have presented about the scale of the challenges that they have had to face and the consequences for young people.

We have heard about disparities between local authorities. It is Government policy to devolve responsibility down to individual schools, and it seems from the evidence that parents are at the mercy of individual schools and individual staff in schools. It is not just a question of comparing one local authority against another—the disparity can occur at school level. Is there any evidence of that?

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow
link

So is the evidence there? You talk about battling and being confident in fighting, but other families may get to the point at which continuing to exercise or push for their rights would actually have a detrimental impact on their child, so they withdraw or move the child. If that is the case, we are not really seeing the whole picture or the scale of the challenge.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow
link

Two lots of different things are going on. The idea that we need an advocacy system to enforce rights is about the individual, about systems not resisting people and about understanding. However, that does not really reflect what has come much more strongly out of the submissions that we have received. We need an advocacy system—we ought not to get into a battle, and people’s rights should be enforced—but we also need to look at patterns in the submissions.

I very much favour a presumption in favour of mainstreaming for all children, because all children benefit from learning together, but my concern is that children with additional support needs are seen as the problem—people ask what they are doing in the main stream and say that that is a problem. That comes out in material that we have received, so there is a straightforward equalities issue.

Anecdotally, I have been advised that a child has to fail in the main stream before they will be moved on to a specialist unit. I do not know whether that is true in Glasgow. If a family know that a child will not survive in the main stream, why do we put them through that process?

Another issue is exclusion in the main stream. A person can theoretically be in the main stream but be sitting in a class on their own out in a corridor. Enable Scotland has done work on that issue. The survey by the National Association of Schoolmasters Union of Women Teachers highlights those questions, too.

Can we get away from the pattern that comes out of the evidence, in which more young people are being identified as having additional support needs and there are fewer staff? That is a big question. Additional support teachers are being used for cover because there is a shortage of teachers. At what point will we confront what seems to have come out of the evidence? That is about resources. It is also about culture and all the rest of it—I am not undermining that—but, if more need is being identified, if there are fewer staff and if schools are managing the challenging curriculum process, how do we focus on the rights of the young people involved?

The presumption that looked-after children have additional support needs has been talked about. Is that also true for children who are in kinship care? I do not know whether people know about that. One of the kinship care campaigns has been about the fact that support for children who are in kinship care means not just paying carers a wee bit of extra money but giving those children the access to educational psychologists and support that looked-after children would have.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow
link

What you describe may or may not be the case. There is a danger in saying that, when we ask for evidence, the people who come to us will be the ones who would be expected to come because there have been failures. I think that the evidence is a lot stronger than that. The message that is coming from submissions across the board is that there is a major problem with the amount of time for which a child is supported, the quality of the support that they get, their ability to access the curriculum in a real way rather than theoretically and the sense of there being a constant battle. Even the most well-meaning local authorities cannot provide the support if the resources are insufficient. It comes across from the unions and parents that a pattern of problems has been identified, rather than individual breakdowns for individual families.

  1. 10:00 Decisions on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 3
  2. 10:00 Additional Support Needs Evidence session · 134

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.