Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Additional Support Needs

Wednesday 1 March 2017 Education and Skills Committee About 10:00–11:15 Evidence session 134 contributions · 19 speakers

Speakers

Showing James Dornan only · show everyone

James Dornan’s contributions

30 contributions
James Dornan SNP The Convener · Glasgow Cathcart
link

Item 2 is a round-table discussion on additional support needs.

I put on record my thanks to everyone who has already contributed to the committee’s work on ASN. We have received hundreds of submissions, and the committee undertook some excellent focus groups last month in which, among other things, ASN was discussed. I also thank Dalkeith high school, which hosted a visit by me, Ross Thomson and Ross Greer.

Round-table discussions are intended to promote more of a conversational style of evidence gathering. At this stage, the committee is scoping issues that relate to ASN. I remind everyone to indicate to me or to the clerks if they would like to speak; I will then call you.

We will go round the table and briefly introduce ourselves. I am the convener of the committee.

James Dornan SNP The Convener · Glasgow Cathcart
link

Thank you very much.

Before we start on the first theme, I understand that Sally Cavers from Enquire attended a session yesterday that was hosted by the Children and Young People’s Commissioner Scotland, which focused on additional support needs, as the commissioner is considering further work in that area. Will she give us a flavour of any key points that came from that session?

James Dornan SNP The Convener · Glasgow Cathcart
link

Thank you. I will start with an issue that has arisen a number of times in our evidence sessions, which is whether local authorities are taking differing approaches, which might touch on the inconsistency that Sally Cavers mentioned. Professor Riddell submitted a briefing to the committee that included local authority variability—would she like to start the discussion?

James Dornan SNP The Convener · Glasgow Cathcart
link

Why is there such a disparity? Why are children from advantaged backgrounds more likely to get a CSP? Is it because their parents have more influence or are more articulate?

James Dornan SNP The Convener · Glasgow Cathcart
link

Please feel free to give us your reply, Professor Riddell.

James Dornan SNP The Convener · Glasgow Cathcart
link

I have heard before about situations in which the child holds it together at school and lets it all go when they get home. In that situation, would you report that to the school so that it was aware? Would it not be taken into consideration?

James Dornan SNP The Convener · Glasgow Cathcart
link

Does anybody want to come in?

James Dornan SNP The Convener · Glasgow Cathcart
link

Does Sylvia Haughney want to come in?

James Dornan SNP The Convener · Glasgow Cathcart
link

On the point about the 30-month visit from the health visitor, is it flagged up if a child is not seen at that stage?

James Dornan SNP The Convener · Glasgow Cathcart
link

Yet the parents who are likely to miss the appointments might be the parents of the children who are most in need.

James Dornan SNP The Convener · Glasgow Cathcart
link

There is no doubt about that.

10:30

James Dornan SNP The Convener · Glasgow Cathcart
link

I will bring Sally Cavers in shortly, but Sheila Riddell looks desperate to comment.

James Dornan SNP The Convener · Glasgow Cathcart
link

That is fine—you needed to do a bit of groundwork.

James Dornan SNP The Convener · Glasgow Cathcart
link

That is why they should contact their local MSPs.

James Dornan SNP The Convener · Glasgow Cathcart
link

Was that addressed by Colin Crawford’s point about using the trained teachers from special schools to train others?

James Dornan SNP The Convener · Glasgow Cathcart
link

Clare Adamson wants to come in.

James Dornan SNP The Convener · Glasgow Cathcart
link

That is a fair point. Does anyone have any comments?

James Dornan SNP The Convener · Glasgow Cathcart
link

That suggests that that should be a flag.

James Dornan SNP The Convener · Glasgow Cathcart
link

Is there a role for local authorities in ensuring that adequate training is available for teachers? I accept that you have talked about budget pressures and time pressures, but the issue is serious—as Clare Adamson mentioned, it affects 24 per cent of children.

James Dornan SNP The Convener · Glasgow Cathcart
link

That is fair enough—thank you. Does Colin Crawford want to come in?

James Dornan SNP The Convener · Glasgow Cathcart
link

Do children in kinship care have that?

James Dornan SNP The Convener · Glasgow Cathcart
link

A school in my constituency was closed, and some of the children who were then moved into a mainstream school had previously been in one and had been taken out because they were not coping with it. They were put back into the same situation. To us, to the parents and to those who were supporting the children, it looked as though that decision had been driven not by the children’s needs but by budgetary requirements or whatever. I suspect that that might not have been the case, but that was how it appeared.

Local authorities must be aware of such things. There is no doubt that budgets are tight, and the responsibility for most of the support rests with local authorities, which have to prioritise how they spend their money, just as everybody else does.

James Dornan SNP The Convener · Glasgow Cathcart
link

Earlier, Professor Riddell talked about a golden age, and I am a wee bit concerned that what we are talking about here is a golden age. People are trained differently now from how they were trained a while ago because they can now train in all sorts of technological ways. Things move on. The cascading model is used in education and in lots of organisations, so I do not think that it is bad practice in itself. If the resources are not going in at the beginning so that people are trained properly to cascade the training, that is an issue, but surely we are not saying that the cascading model is bad practice.

James Dornan SNP The Convener · Glasgow Cathcart
link

So the problem is not necessarily with the quality of the training that is coming down the line; it is that you do not have the time to get the training.

James Dornan SNP The Convener · Glasgow Cathcart
link

That is a different thing.

James Dornan SNP The Convener · Glasgow Cathcart
link

That is a good point and it has been noted—and you are not “just a parent”.

James Dornan SNP The Convener · Glasgow Cathcart
link

We are nearing the end of our discussion. Does anyone have points that they have not had a chance to make and that they consider to be priorities for the committee?

James Dornan SNP The Convener · Glasgow Cathcart
link

Before we move into private to consider the evidence, I thank all our guests today. As has just been mentioned, the cabinet secretary is appearing before the committee next week. We will certainly raise with Mr Swinney some of the issues that have come up today.

11:27 Meeting continued in private until 11:57.

  1. 10:00 Decisions on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 3
  2. 10:00 Additional Support Needs Evidence session · 134

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.