Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 18 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Section 22 Reports

“The 2014/15 audit of NHS Highland: Update on 2013/14 financial management issues”

Wednesday 2 December 2015 Public Audit Committee About 12:00 Committee business 38 contributions · 8 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

38 contributions
Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

We move to “The 2014/15 audit of NHS Highland”. Stephen Boyle, the assistant director of Audit Scotland, has joined the Auditor General and the assistant auditor general. I understand that Mr McKinlay will make an opening statement on this report.

Fraser McKinlay
link

I will try to be brief, convener. The issues around NHS Highland probably need no introduction, but for consistency I will provide one for the committee.

The committee will be well aware that the 2013-14 audit report on NHS Highland by Stephen Boyle highlighted weaknesses in financial management that were a major factor in the board requiring brokerage of £2.5 million from the Scottish Government to break even. As you will know, the need for that brokerage was mainly due to an overspend on operating costs at Raigmore hospital. The auditor, and this committee subsequently in its inquiry, identified significant concerns about governance in the board and the decision making around the decision to go for brokerage.

The Auditor General decided to bring a section 22 report back to the committee this year as an update. After we did our work on the board and the committee had its inquiry, NHS Highland developed an in-year financial recovery plan that detailed how the board expected to address projected shortfalls against its budget and achieve its planned break-even position at the year end. The committee will also be aware that the Scottish Government brought forward £3 million of NRAC money in January 2015 to help the board reach a break-even position in 2014-15.

Based on a review of the work undertaken by the board in 2014, the auditor, Stephen Boyle, concluded that NHS Highland has strengthened its financial management arrangements and scrutiny of financial performance. In 2014-15, NHS Highland achieved its two key financial targets and broke even against its revenue and capital budgets, and 40 per cent of savings made in year were on a recurring basis. Raigmore hospital reduced its budget overspend to £6.9 million, but that fell short of the £6 million target, which adds to the continuing pressure that the board is experiencing this year.

I am very happy to take questions on the section 22 report.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Clearly, there has been tremendous improvement here. It is clear from the Auditor General’s report that a great deal of work has been done. Obviously, it is still a worry that there is such a high level of non-recurring savings, which we also commented on when the previous report was issued. The big problem still appears to be Raigmore hospital. It has reduced its budget overspend, but are you satisfied that adequate steps are being taken to bring the hospital, which contributes such a large proportion of the deficit, back into financial equilibrium?

Fraser McKinlay
link

As you say, Raigmore has responded well to the audit work and to the committee’s inquiry in the past 12 months. As we mention at paragraph 17, an important part of that is the hospital’s three-year recovery plan, which takes it through to 2016-17. I will ask Stephen Boyle to give you a little of the flavour of what is in that plan, but it looks to us as if it covers all the right things.

The issues that the committee raised with the board during its inquiry to do with the way in which clinicians and others at Raigmore were spending money without any real control or reference to their budgets have provided a particular focus for getting the situation under control.

Stephen Boyle Audit Scotland
link

We have certainly seen an improvement in the control environment in Raigmore hospital. We note at paragraph 22 some of the practical steps that the hospital is taking. For example, the director is overseeing and taking control of the authorisation for locum doctors and temporary staff. That oversight is factored into the financial projections for the hospital.

All that said, the financial environment for Raigmore remains challenging. The board’s most recent set of in-year financial projections for period 7 suggests that it is still looking at a potential overspend of £6 million for the year. Given that the hospital, which dominates the board’s overall spend, is not quite making its savings target, and given that the financial environment remains challenging, it will remain challenging for the board to continue to deliver on the financial recovery plan.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Can you remind me of the overall budget, or the overall financial spend, at Raigmore? I am just wondering what proportion of that £6.9 million amounts to.

Stephen Boyle Audit Scotland
link

As exhibit 5 sets out, the hospital’s budget for the current financial year is £145.8 million.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Paragraph 64 of the Auditor General’s report on “NHS in Scotland 2015” states:

“NHS Highland reported that its policy is to hold corporate services vacancies open for at least six months ... to allow it to generate non-recurring savings.”

Those almost become recurring savings if the board does that all the time. How significant a contributor is that element to reducing the deficit? Is it desirable? If a post is empty for six months, does the board need that post?

Fraser McKinlay
link

Stephen Boyle might know what proportion of the total such savings represent.

Stephen Boyle Audit Scotland
link

I am sorry, but I do not have that figure to hand. Flipping a non-recurring saving into a recurring saving has been part of the process that NHS Highland has used over a number of years. If a post is vacant for such a long period of time, the board will—exactly as you suggest, Mr Beattie—take a judgment on whether it is still required.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

It would be interesting to know how much that contributes as a proportion of the savings that the board is trying to achieve.

I have one last question. Paragraph 22 of the NHS Highland report highlights an increase in temporary staffing and overtime, and there seem to be additional controls around that. Does the figure of £9.859 million seem disproportionate, or is it a reasonable spend?

Fraser McKinlay
link

We can double-check that. The Auditor General is helpfully seeing whether she can find a number in the overview report just now. We do not have a figure in the NHS Highland report, but we can certainly check and come back to you on how that stacks up in comparison with other boards.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

As I have been quite critical of NHS Highland, it is only right for me to be fair where it has done some corrective work. It is also fair to say that Raigmore overspent its budget in the past five years, and that it is really only since Audit Scotland produced its section 22 report that the overspend has gone down from £9.9 million to approximately £5 million. As a Highlands MSP, it is quite annoying to me that, for many years, NHS Highland has not received from the Government the recommended amount of funding in accordance with the NRAC funding formula. Although it got some last year to help it to break even, it has been underfunded for many years.

As you know, NHS Highland and Highland Council were the first organisations in Scotland to integrate health and social care. They really are pioneers, and all credit to them for making that work. My concern is that, although NHS Highland has addressed its issues and the future is looking good—it has corrected a lot of things that were addressed in the section 22 report—it now relies on Highland Council doing its share. This week, Highland Council has learned that it is facing £40 million-worth of cuts. I appreciate that this is new to you but, even though the NHS budget is protected and NHS Highland is doing everything right in order to meet your recommendations, council budgets are not protected—I do not want to go into that—and, because of health and social care integration, NHS Highland has to take some responsibility for the £40 million-worth of cuts that Highland Council has to make. How difficult is the situation going to be in other areas, given the integration of health and social care services? Are you considering the situation, given that many councils have followed in the footsteps of NHS Highland and Highland Council?

Fraser McKinlay
link

We are indeed. In fact, we are publishing our first report on health and social care integration tomorrow. It is due to come to the committee in two weeks’ time, I think.

Fraser McKinlay
link

That will give you plenty of opportunity to consider the issues.

The other interesting thing about NHS Highland is that, as well as being the first health board to participate in the integration of health and social care, it is the only board to have gone for what is known as the lead agency model; all other areas have gone for the integration joint board model.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

So the responsibility for children is with the council. That is worrying, in light of the £40 million-worth of cuts.

Fraser McKinlay
link

Indeed, and that is why they have swapped those things over.

Without giving too much away about the report that we are publishing tomorrow, I can say that the way in which the money is working in all of this is one of the biggest issues that are proving difficult for NHS boards and councils to bottom out. Tomorrow’s report is really a position statement, given that it is quite early days in the new integration landscape. We are just trying to set out the facts and describe the shape of what is happening. However, we also identify some issues for the future. Certainly, Highland Council and NHS Highland have had a lot of experience of figuring out how the money works, because the model that they developed at the start of the process two or three years ago has had to be adapted as the service has levelled out.

That is the long answer to your question. The short answer is that, yes, health and social care integration will feature heavily in our work programme in the next three to five years.

Nigel Don SNP Angus North and Mearns
link

I am concerned about budgets and how they are set. Exhibit 4 concerns the situation at Raigmore hospital. With the benefit of hindsight, what justification might there have been for the budget, given that it has always been overspent and that it continues to be overspent by a significant amount? It rather looks as though it costs about £145 million to run Raigmore hospital but that the budget has never said as much. Am I being too cynical?

Fraser McKinlay
link

I would not say that you were being cynical; your observation is a perfectly fair one. Stephen Boyle can keep me right, but I believe that, between 2011-12 and 2012-13, there was a process of rebasing the budget, which is why it jumped from £130 million to £135 million. However, that still was not enough money. I absolutely agree that, along with the longer-term financial planning and thinking about budgets, the budget for Raigmore will have to be considered. Of course, the challenge is that, if the budget for Raigmore is simply raised by £5 million or £6 million, that money must be found from somewhere else. As well as considering rebasing the budget, there is a challenge to continually try to push down the costs at Raigmore.

12:00

Nigel Don SNP Angus North and Mearns
link

Which brings me to the bigger question of how on earth these budgets are set. Again, you must forgive me, but when I look at the non-recurring savings column in exhibit 3, I see non-recurring savings of £3 million for every foreseeable year. The board has no idea where those savings are going to come from, so a figure of £3 million goes in and the incredibly accurate figures to the left of that column are, of course, just the difference between the non-recurring savings and the total savings to be found. That is the way that numbers come out, but can the board do any better, or is that just the nature of this kind of budgeting? Is it simply a case of having to work one’s way through this every year and hoping that it can be made to work?

Fraser McKinlay
link

As auditors, we would always say that these things could be done better; in a sense, that is what we are all about. However, there is a point at which you have to make some assumptions and put some numbers into the budget. As we said earlier, the situation can be helped with better longer-term financial planning, better understanding of the demographics, the pressures and all of those things and, as difficult as it might be, some assumptions about the money that the board is going to get. That has to be the right thing to do, which is why—and this was one of the criticisms made in last year’s report—in-year financial management and monitoring are so important. They ensure that the savings that the board says that it is going to make in year are being delivered.

Nigel Don SNP Angus North and Mearns
link

Does the budget come from a build-up of known costs or from the slice that the board gets of the total budget?

Stephen Boyle Audit Scotland
link

Organisations take different approaches such as priority-based budgeting and activity-based costing but, broadly speaking, the budget is put together on an incremental basis. The organisation’s budget and the costs that it is incurring will be inflated for known and anticipated costs, known additional activity, such as work through the treatment time guarantee and so forth, and that broadly leads it to be able to strike a budget in advance of the new financial year.

Nigel Don SNP Angus North and Mearns
link

The incremental approach itself makes it very difficult for a board to make any substantial change, but if your historic costs have never been right and you have never hit your budget, there will be only marginal changes from something that was and which continues to be wrong.

Fraser McKinlay
link

That is exactly the reason why in the earlier report we make a recommendation about the need for greater flexibility and better longer-term planning. If you continue to add bits on to what you have always done, the significant change that we think is needed in the system is simply not going to come about.

Dr Richard Simpson Lab Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Paragraph 22 of the report highlights a staggering reduction of 31 per cent in the first 10 months in locums at Raigmore hospital. What effect has that had on the running of the hospital? People employ locums not because it is fun to do so or because someone needs a job but, I would think, to meet the treatment time guarantee. Such a reduction means that either Highland is going to find it difficult to meet the treatment time guarantee or the difficult question will arise of whether staffing levels are totally safe. I have experienced this situation myself. You have to make an application for a temporary member of staff almost up to chief executive level, and by the time it comes back down, your situation with temporary sickness, maternity leave or whatever is over. In the meantime, your staff sickness rate has gone up because you have put so much blooming stress on the rest of your workforce. It is all very well producing this lovely figure, but do you look at things such as sickness rates, target effects, whether staffing levels are safe or the number of staff complaints about feeling unsafe?

Fraser McKinlay
link

The short answer is yes, but we did not necessarily do it as part of this piece of work, because our focus was on financial management issues.

However, you are absolutely right. One has to be careful here and realise that a reduction in the use of locums is not necessarily a good thing in itself. That said, the last time round, the use of locums at Raigmore was very clearly identified as one of the significant cost pressures, and tightening controls in the hospital was, we think, a good thing to do. We would absolutely expect the board and the hospital to assure themselves that such a move was having no knock-on impact. The exhibit in the overview report shows that there is no doubt that NHS Highland is experiencing pressures on some of the targets. Whether we can draw a direct link between the two things is a different question.

The exhibit in the overview report shows that there is no doubt that NHS Highland is experiencing pressures on some of the targets. Whether we can draw a direct link between the two things is a different question.

Dr Richard Simpson Lab Mid Scotland and Fife
link

We might see it in future years.

What really concerns me is the focus on finance. I know that it is critical, but if you look back to the report on the Mid Staffordshire NHS Foundation Trust, that is where it all started. The staffing was cut, which made the hospitals unsafe. I just ask you to look at staff complaints in the system. Health Improvement Scotland or you should be drilling down into that. We might put NHS Highland under such pressure that we create a Mid Staffs situation.

Caroline Gardner
link

I absolutely share your concern. There have to be risks, given the pressures that are on the health system just now.

In the report on the management of waiting times that I produced back in 2012 on the back of the problems in NHS Lothian, one of our broader findings was that some boards were focusing on financial performance and quality of performance as though they were different things. We recommend that boards should have information that pulls that together in a dashboard or some other way so that they can see the interaction between financial performance and what is happening to patients. The one cannot be divorced from the other; they are two sides of the same coin.

Dr Richard Simpson Lab Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Are you satisfied that that is now happening as a result of your recommendation?

Caroline Gardner
link

It is happening to different degrees in different parts of Scotland. The annual audit reports that are produced by the auditors that I appoint to the 14 health boards give that overview of financial performance and the other key targets to which boards are working. Part of our review process in deciding what to bring to the Public Audit Committee’s attention is to look for disturbing patterns.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

The issue of vacancy rates came up in the original report and we had quite a substantial exchange when we took evidence on that. It was related to staff morale and sickness levels. Are the vacancy rates still the same as they were previously?

Fraser McKinlay
link

I do not think that we have any information to add, to be honest.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Perhaps you could provide us with that information. The impact of vacancy rates and sickness levels was highlighted in the report and it would help us to see the current position if you provided us with before and after figures.

Fraser McKinlay
link

I remember the discussion well, convener. It was about keeping vacancies open and whether that was having a knock-on impact on morale and absence. I will see what we can dig out on that.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

I thank you for your evidence.

  1. 09:30 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. 09:30 Section 23 Report Committee business · 93
  3. 10:30 Section 22 Reports Committee business · 139
  4. 11:30 Section 22 Reports Committee business · 66
  5. 12:00 Section 22 Reports Committee business · 38
  6. 12:00 Section 23 Report Committee business · 12

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.