Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 18 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Section 22 Reports

“The 2014/15 audit of NHS Tayside: Financial management”

Wednesday 2 December 2015 Public Audit Committee About 11:30–11:45 Committee business 66 contributions · 7 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

66 contributions
Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

The next section 22 report on the agenda is on the audit of NHS Tayside. We will have a brief opening statement from Audit Scotland.

Fraser McKinlay
link

The second report in front of the committee is on NHS Tayside. This is the first time that the committee has seen a section 22 report on the Tayside board. The Auditor General has made the report for a few reasons. In 2014, NHS Tayside received £14.2 million in brokerage, in two instalments. It received an initial payment of £8 million to cover retrospective holiday pay enhancements and some overspends in workforce costs and primary-care prescribing. The board later required an additional £6.2 million following an accounting adjustment identified by our colleagues, as auditors of the board, in recognition of the sale of land—formerly Ashludie hospital—in the 2014-15 accounts. This is the third year in succession that the board has required brokerage.

The report says that the board’s reliance on brokerage stems from overspends and an on-going difficulty in selling a number of surplus properties, which means that the board has been unable to generate income from planned sales. The board has agreed with the Scottish Government that it will repay the brokerage from the proceeds of the sale of those properties. The board is currently engaging with the Scottish Futures Trust to develop plans for the main sites for disposal in an attempt to sell those properties more quickly and reduce the risks associated with planning permission applications.

Having said all that, the timing of the disposals remains uncertain. The Scottish Government has indicated that it will discuss repayment options with NHS Tayside should disposal not happen as planned.

In addition to the brokerage repayments, in 2015-16 the board is required to find £27 million of efficiency savings in order to break even. As at 31 July this year, the board had yet to identify £11.2 million of those savings. In the first six months, the board overspent by just over £5 million. As the board continues to rely on the sale of property to address the issues, there continues to be a risk that it will not break even in financial year 2015-16.

I am happy to take questions on the report.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

The first question is about the inclusion of the land disposal in the accounts. How unusual is it for a board to include a proposed land sale in its accounts when final sign-off on the sale has not taken place?

Fraser McKinlay
link

I will ask Kenny Wilson to talk to the detail of that. It is unusual, and it was the auditors that required it to be changed. Kenny, would you give more detail on exactly what happened there?

Kenny Wilson PricewaterhouseCoopers
link

NHS Tayside signed an agreement with Miller Homes in December 2014, in which it agreed in principle to sell the property, depending on a number of conditions. The main condition was achieving planning permission. I think that the board felt that the likelihood of getting planning permission was extremely high and that the risk of not getting it was very small. However, from an accounting standpoint, it is quite right that we should not recognise a disposal until all conditions are met. While the risk of not meeting such an important condition was deemed to be small, we know that these things often take longer than expected to resolve. However, on 23 October, the board concluded the transaction, with planning permission.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Are you saying that, at the annual general meeting, the accounts were proposed to and accepted by the board on the basis that the transaction had taken place? Were any caveats attached to the board’s papers? I take it that you uncovered the issue, rather than it being presented to the board.

Kenny Wilson PricewaterhouseCoopers
link

Yes, that is correct.

11:30

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

We have had that with other boards. The committee has made inquiries about information that has been provided by managers to board members to ensure that they can take decisions. For example, we have had an inquiry on brokerage in relation to NHS Highland. Is it acceptable that board members were not made aware that the disposal had not taken place?

Kenny Wilson PricewaterhouseCoopers
link

Why that was the case is possibly a question for the board, but it was certainly unhelpful that the board members were not totally aware of or did not recognise the real position.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Is there an argument to be made that the issue is one of poor governance? Board members were presented with a set of accounts that included a disposal that had not taken place.

Kenny Wilson PricewaterhouseCoopers
link

I think that it was possibly more a case of the wrong judgment being made by the finance team in recognising the disposal at that time, rather than any attempt to mislead the board.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

I appreciate that, but the matter would have had ramifications for other decisions that the board might have had to take. Is there any record that the board was kept up to date on whether the transaction had taken place and what progress had been made? It is quite a significant omission to say, “These accounts include the disposal” and to make them available for the public record, only for the auditors to come in following that and say, “Actually, this disposal has not taken place.”

Kenny Wilson PricewaterhouseCoopers
link

You are probably best asking the board why that happened.

Fraser McKinlay
link

Convener, you drew a couple of comparisons, but we see some important differences from the likes of the NHS Highland case that you mentioned. I should also say that adjustments to the accounts after they are signed are not in themselves unusual—that happens all the time. The issue at NHS Tayside is significant due to its scale. There is always judgment and debate between a finance director and an organisation and the auditors, because they come from a position of managing the finances, whereas we come from a perspective of accounting standards and other matters. As I say, there is always a bit of adjustment, which is why there is a period between, in this case, the board signing its accounts and the auditor signing the opinion three or four months later. That is what happens in the process.

I do not think that the issue was necessarily about the board being kept in the dark. You mentioned brokerage. In fact, the evidence that we have, which is set out on page 5 of the section 22 report, demonstrated that a good process was in place. The finance officers kept the board up to date about the financial position and the potential requirement for brokerage, which happened way back in November 2014. That was much earlier than, for example—

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

To be fair, I am not raising the issue of brokerage in relation to the NHS Tayside issue. The board was told that the accounts included the disposal—the disposal was clearly in the balances that were made available to it. The main issue is whether it was made aware of the fact that the disposal had not taken place before the auditor found that out. I appreciate that that question should be raised with the board directly, but there must be governance issues if board members were not kept aware. I think that the standard practice with disposals is that the money is not put in the bank until the developer gets planning permission. Is that not quite a common arrangement?

Kenny Wilson PricewaterhouseCoopers
link

I am not aware that the board was aware of that fact until we raised it at the audit committee.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Therefore, decisions that the board took once the accounts had been presented to it may have been impacted. If I were a board member and I was not made aware that the land disposal may not take place or had not taken place, would that not have an impact on my decisions and that of the board? Is that not a governance issue?

Fraser McKinlay
link

Yes, and the—

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

That is the comparison that I am making.

Fraser McKinlay
link

Sure—

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

I appreciate that there are brokerage issues in NHS Highland, but the concern relating to NHS Highland is primarily about how the board was provided with information to allow it to take the decisions that it needed to take.

If I were a board member and the set of accounts put before me made it clear that the disposal had taken place and there were no caveats—I appreciate what can happen afterwards—that would be a significant omission. If I had seen those accounts, I would be pretty relieved to be able to say at the board meeting, “Yes, that looks very good now, because the land disposal that we’re expecting has actually taken place”—but that would only be because nobody had made me aware of the caveats. I appreciate that that is a discussion that must take place directly with the board.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

How do you expect any health board to make £27 million of cuts in one year? Paragraph 13 of the NHS Tayside section 22 report has the nitty-gritty bit—on top of brokerage, the NHS Tayside board is required to make £27 million of cuts. Is that possible and who decided that that would be done in one year?

Kenny Wilson PricewaterhouseCoopers
link

The board is required to meet the 3 per cent efficiency savings target annually. Last year, NHS Tayside made £22 million of efficiency savings. The key point to draw out is that 60 per cent of those efficiency savings came from non-recurring items, so it will become increasingly hard for the board to make further efficiency savings. There is no doubt that making £27 million of savings will be difficult.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

I have definitely been here too long because I have to correct Fraser McKinlay. It is not the first time that NHS Tayside has come to the attention of the Parliament in this regard. I do not know whether there was a section 22 report, but I remember that back in 2001-02, NHS Tayside had a £16.5 million deficit. The matter came to the Audit Committee and believe it or not, the chief executive resigned, something that does not happen now. He was a chap called Tim Brett, but that is all history.

I want to get into the details of the property disposal. I was brought up in Hillside and went to Hillside primary school, so I am very familiar with Sunnyside. Sunnyside royal hospital has lain derelict for decades. My concern is in relation to the various property disposals that are on the accounts in Tayside, such as Sunnyside. Is it possible that they appear in the accounts at an inflated value that makes the accounts look quite good, but when they come to be sold, the sum realised is much lower than that shown in the accounts? Does that not create an immediate deficit?

We all know that relying on non-recurring savings is bad, but this is a huge amount of land and property. Surely if the land and property was put on the accounts at a certain time in recent decades, given the state that it is in now and the current state of the property market, it cannot possibly be worth the original estimate? Is there not an inherent problem going back to 2001-02 in relation to overpriced properties on the board’s accounts?

Kenny Wilson PricewaterhouseCoopers
link

Every year, a full valuation is done by valuers on the properties right across NHS Tayside and we review that valuation.

Kenny Wilson PricewaterhouseCoopers
link

Sorry?

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

The valuation is regularly changed to reflect the state of dereliction and so on.

Kenny Wilson PricewaterhouseCoopers
link

That is right. The valuations held in the accounts will reflect the state that the property is in, the original cost and exactly what the valuers think might be realised from selling it, so I believe that the property values carried in the accounts are appropriate.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

I appreciate that the Ashludie hospital sale went through in April and was not included in these accounts, but was the amount that it was disposed for pretty well equal to the valuation in the accounts?

Kenny Wilson PricewaterhouseCoopers
link

The profit for Ashludie was £4 million on final disposal proceeds of £5 million. The net book value was just over £1 million, so a profit was made on the Ashludie sale.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

Right. Would you expect the same from Sunnyside? I believe that it is finally on the market after many decades.

Kenny Wilson PricewaterhouseCoopers
link

It went on the market in August this year and we hope that it will realise at least the carrying value but, of course, the amount will clearly vary depending on each property. That is one of the challenges that the board is facing—it is trying to realise its surplus estate in a difficult market.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

I have just one other question on Tayside—because I come from that area, I get a lot of anecdotes. I understand that there is quite an inflated team of directors in NHS Tayside. Did you look at the management team of executives, directors and senior managers? Is the number of people higher than in other health board areas? Are they paid more than in other board areas? Have they been given superior performance-related pay that differs from other board areas? Is that something that you looked at in your audit?

Kenny Wilson PricewaterhouseCoopers
link

I am sorry, but that is not something that we specifically looked at, and I have not done a benchmark exercise to find out how that compares with other boards.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

But you might look at doing that in NHS Tayside in future.

Kenny Wilson PricewaterhouseCoopers
link

We can certainly take on board and look at that suggestion.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

I see some mention of changes to how the public pension schemes are valued. If I am not incorrect, it appears that the additional costs to the pension are £5.5 million.

Kenny Wilson PricewaterhouseCoopers
link

That is correct.

Kenny Wilson PricewaterhouseCoopers
link

That is in effect the increase in costs that the board will be paying. It is similar to what is happening in all other boards as a result of the recent revaluation of the national pension scheme.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Okay. That, combined with the national insurance charges makes things quite challenging.

Paragraph 24 of the NHS Tayside report says that

“NHS Tayside recognises that traditional approaches”

to making savings are resulting in a decline in those savings. What are the implications of that? Does that mean that all the soft options have been used and that things are going to get a bit tougher?

Kenny Wilson PricewaterhouseCoopers
link

I think that that is right. As we have heard, the challenges that face the NHS as a whole go right across Scotland, but we need to be more strategic and look at having a longer-term plan in order to make savings that can be sustained for the long term. Perhaps, as you have suggested, the low-hanging fruit has been picked.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

I assume that the overspend of £4.549 million in the first four months that is mentioned in paragraph 27 includes staff payments.

Kenny Wilson PricewaterhouseCoopers
link

That is right. The additional staff payments in respect of the—

Kenny Wilson PricewaterhouseCoopers
link

Yes, the EDL. As those payments were accrued at the end of last year and have been taken care of in the 2014-15 accounts, they should have no impact on 2015-16.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

So the £4.5 million is separate from that.

Kenny Wilson PricewaterhouseCoopers
link

Yes.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

And it is not part of the additional staff costs that were accrued as a result of EDL.

Kenny Wilson PricewaterhouseCoopers
link

That is right.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Okay.

Obviously NHS Tayside is in quite a difficult position. Given the sheer size of the deficit that has to be covered, will its approach be practical on an on-going basis? After all, whether it sells Ashludie or not, that is a one-off, non-recurring asset sale.

Kenny Wilson PricewaterhouseCoopers
link

It certainly faces challenges and it needs to move away from its reliance on non-recurring items and the dependence on disposals of surplus properties. I know that the board is looking at that situation and is coming up with a detailed plan for addressing it, but it will certainly be challenging.

Fraser McKinlay
link

The report is interesting, not only with regard to the specifics of what is happening in NHS Tayside but because it presents in microcosm the issues raised in our earlier discussion on the overview report. It shows us all the pressures in one board and, as Mr Beattie said, it looks for sure as if it will be very difficult for that board to break even this year.

Dr Richard Simpson Lab Mid Scotland and Fife
link

I have two questions, the first of which is about the sale that was put on and then taken off the accounts. Was that sale declared as part of the board’s efficiency savings for that year?

Kenny Wilson PricewaterhouseCoopers
link

I think that it was declared as one of its non-recurring savings.

Dr Richard Simpson Lab Mid Scotland and Fife
link

That is what I am talking about. The sale was included in not only the board’s accounts but the report that we received on efficiency savings.

Kenny Wilson PricewaterhouseCoopers
link

That is right.

Dr Richard Simpson Lab Mid Scotland and Fife
link

It is a fairly significant amount and I presume that it will not appear again as an efficiency saving for this year, even though the sale itself went through this year.

Kenny Wilson PricewaterhouseCoopers
link

Yes.

Dr Richard Simpson Lab Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Right. I hope that someone has taken a note of that and that we do not get it again.

The issue of the enhancements during leave payments is very interesting. They total four point something million pounds and go back over four or five years, but the staff themselves have said that the situation is inadequate. Is either Mr McKinlay or Ms Gardner comfortable that this is a one-board event? Are we fairly certain that it is not occurring in other boards?

11:45

Caroline Gardner
link

As you would expect, Dr Simpson, that is exactly the question that I asked when I received the auditor’s annual report. We have done checks with all the auditors that I appoint to NHS boards and we are confident that it was simply one board where an error took place in the treatment historically.

Dr Richard Simpson Lab Mid Scotland and Fife
link

That is probably the one piece of good news that we have had today. I have only just joined the Public Audit Committee, but one of the elements that came up when I was a member of the Health and Sport Committee and we were looking at the future finances of the health service was ensuring that equality of pay was implemented. I think that you qualified accounts in previous years on that issue. I do not see anything in the report before us referring to equal pay issues. Previously, it could not be quantified what equal pay would cost. Has the equal pay issue been dealt with in Tayside?

Caroline Gardner
link

There is a provision for liabilities relating to equal pay in just about every health board’s accounts. The situation in the NHS is now very different from that in local government. At the end of 2014-15, it was possible to quantify the liabilities for the first time. In its accounting treatment equal pay has moved from being an unquantified contingent liability to being a quantified provision, and the amounts involved are coming down quite markedly. That is why I did not draw attention to them in the “NHS in Scotland 2015” report that the committee took evidence on earlier or in the three section 22 reports that the committee is looking at just now.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

There are no further questions from colleagues on the Tayside report.

  1. 09:30 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. 09:30 Section 23 Report Committee business · 93
  3. 10:30 Section 22 Reports Committee business · 139
  4. 11:30 Section 22 Reports Committee business · 66
  5. 12:00 Section 22 Reports Committee business · 38
  6. 12:00 Section 23 Report Committee business · 12

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.