Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 17 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Section 23 Reports

“Efficiency of prosecuting criminal cases through the sheriff courts”

Wednesday 7 October 2015 Public Audit Committee About 10:45–11:30 Committee business 56 contributions · 8 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

56 contributions
Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Agenda item 4 is evidence on the Auditor General for Scotland’s report “Efficiency of prosecuting criminal cases through the sheriff courts”. I welcome our panel of witnesses—Caroline Gardner, the Auditor General for Scotland; Angela Cullen, assistant director at Audit Scotland; and Mark Roberts, senior manager at Audit Scotland. I understand that Caroline Gardner has a short opening statement.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

On average, 88,000 people appear in criminal cases in Scotland’s sheriff courts each year, and many thousands more interact with the sheriff court system as victims, witnesses, jurors, lawyers and members of the judiciary. It is important for all those people, and for society more widely, that the sheriff court system works efficiently and effectively. Our report finds that there is mounting pressure on the sheriff court system and that it comes from two main sources: financial pressures and the nature of the cases that are entering the system.

As with many parts of the public sector, budgets have fallen. The Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service and the Scottish Court Service both saw their total budgets and their operating budgets fall by proportionately more than the overall Scottish budget did in the period 2010-11 to 2014-15.

The nature of the cases that the sheriff court system considers is changing. There are more cases that involve domestic abuse and historical sexual abuse. That is a good thing, as it means that the focus on those crimes by the Scottish Government and all the organisations that are involved is having an effect and giving more victims the confidence to come forward. It also adds to the pressures on the system. Those cases may date back over many years, and victims and witnesses may need additional support and time to allow them to give evidence.

One key measure of the system’s overall performance is publicly reported: the percentage of cases that are completed within 26 weeks. In 2010-11, 73 per cent of cases were completed within that time, but by 2014-15, the figure had fallen to 65 per cent. The data that we present in exhibit 8 on page 26 of the report show that there is marked variability in performance against that measure across the six sheriffdoms. We also report that there can be marked variation within a sheriffdom, as we highlight in case study 3 on page 28.

A range of factors affect how individual courts function. They include the mix of types of cases that are considered; the preparedness of procurators fiscal; the culture and behaviour of defence agents and the accused; and the way in which sheriffs principal and sheriffs manage their courts.

Inefficiency in the system is known as churn. That is not always a bad thing; although it causes an immediate delay, it might allow a case to be concluded earlier in overall terms. In many cases, however, court appearances do not proceed as planned because of problems with the correct citation and availability of witnesses, the readiness of the prosecution and the defence or the availability of court time. Based on our costing model of court appearances, we estimate that churn that should have been avoidable cost about £10 million in 2014-15.

A fundamental challenge is that although the system is made up of individual organisations that have to—for good reasons—operate independently, the system has to be managed collectively in order to improve its overall performance and efficiency. We found that the establishment of the justice board by the Scottish Government in 2011 brought together the chief executives of the various public sector bodies in the justice sector and has improved joint working at a national level. We would now like that to be replicated at a local level, where joint working has been less successful.

We have made four detailed recommendations that aim to improve the management and performance of the sheriff court system as an integrated system and to improve public reporting of the performance of the sheriff courts.

As ever, we are happy to answer the committee’s questions.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Thank you. You spoke in your statement about how sheriffs manage the courts. Can we be realistic about the challenge that we face? Sheriffs are there to ensure that justice is carried out properly through the judicial process. It is difficult for them to consider the associated costs if they must also ensure that there is a fair system that is implemented properly. Are there examples of where improvements could be made without compromising the judiciary or the judicial system?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

We have some very good examples, and I will ask Mark Roberts to highlight a couple for you. It is worth being clear that we are not asking sheriffs to focus just on the costs of the system. The costs are quite good indicators of the system’s overall efficiency and of how good it is at delivering justice as quickly as possible for everyone concerned—not just the accused but victims, witnesses and others. There is a public interest in ensuring that the system works as well as it can.

I ask Mark Roberts to give us examples of where sheriffs and sheriffs principal have had such an impact on their courts.

Mark Roberts Audit Scotland
link

In the case study on page 36 of our report, we highlight the extent of court management that goes on at Aberdeen sheriff court. Sheriffs work together in small groups there and focus on specific areas of legal activity, be that summary or solemn business. That has helped to secure earlier resolution of cases in the sheriff court. The sheriffs in Aberdeen have taken a very active approach to improve the process of managing business through the court. Of course, that is entirely separate from the legal considerations that sheriffs must deal with, which are equally important.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Another challenge that is faced lies in the availability of witnesses. I know from constituents’ experiences that that can vary, with police officers retiring or perhaps being abroad and difficult to locate, and with other witnesses being difficult to contact. What can be done to improve that? If someone is clearly making things difficult by not making themselves available, even though there is a legal process to deal with that, it can ultimately be difficult to improve things.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

You are absolutely right. Not everybody who is involved in the court system has the same interest in making it work smoothly, for obvious reasons. We are not saying that there is a magic wand that can take away the problems at a stroke. Equally, we have found examples where practical ways of working can help to improve the planning and management of cases.

Mark Roberts Audit Scotland
link

I highlight one of the examples that we quote in our report. Under the making justice work programme, there have been initiatives by Police Scotland, the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service and the Scottish Court Service to find innovative ways of reminding people that they have been cited for witness appearances, whether by sending text messages or by having a record of mobile phone numbers and so on.

The convener mentioned the importance of police witnesses being able to attend court appearances. A court witness stand-by system is now being instigated. It ensures that police officers are called at the specific time when they are required in court, rather than being required to be present all day, as sometimes happens, just in case they are called. The system provides a bit more precision as to when their appearance will be. That has assisted with the amount of police time that officers spend waiting to be called to act as witnesses.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

At paragraph 5 on page 7, you state that you

“did not consider the impact of ... court closures”,

which are on-going. I presume that you will return to cover them at some point, as they will affect the dynamics of costs and so on. A lot of the costs that we are talking about now might not be absolutely relevant a year or two down the line.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

We did not explicitly consider the court closures mainly because of timing. The report focuses on the period that finished in 2014-15. Most of the court closures were scheduled to happen during that year.

We have examined the data as far as it is available. It is fair to say that there is no clear evidence of an impact from the court closures on the efficiency issues that we are considering. That is partly because most of the affected courts were dealing with quite small numbers of cases—that can be seen in the data that we present. We absolutely recognise that local courts are important to local people, but there is no evidence of a direct link to an impact on the efficiency of the court system.

We know that the Scottish Courts and Tribunals Service is conducting its own evaluation of the impact of closures. We plan to examine that evaluation and decide whether further work could be done on the back of it to add value. We are keeping an eye on the issue, but it is not a key part of the report that is in front of you.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

The number of cases is relatively small, but the overheads might be disproportionately high. Will you do a fresh analysis of all this later and produce a fresh report?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

We will consider the Scottish Courts and Tribunals Service’s evaluation and the data and see whether there would be value in doing that.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

There are some significant percentages in the report. Paragraph 39 on page 25 states that the criminal justice targets are being exceeded, which is quite interesting. The pressure seems to be coming from summary cases. In paragraph 13 on page 12, you state that there was a 25 per cent increase in the volume of cases going through justice of the peace courts, mainly because of road traffic offences—as a motorist, that is obviously a concern to me. Do you agree that the primary pressure seems to be coming from summary cases rather than more serious cases?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

I will ask Mark Roberts to talk about the specific cases, because he is absolutely on top of them. Your point recognises one of the messages that we want to get across, which is that the sheriff court system has to be managed as a system. Decisions that are taken in one part of the system, whether that is in Police Scotland or in the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service, have impacts that need to be understood to ensure that the flow works smoothly.

Mark Roberts can talk about the specific factors that are driving change.

Mark Roberts Audit Scotland
link

Paragraph 39 on page 25 talks about the targets being exceeded. Police Scotland has 28 days to submit a prosecution report after someone has been charged. Following that, the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service has a further 28 days in which to decide what to do with the case. Both organisations have targets for the proportion of cases that meet those timescales and, as Colin Beattie said, those targets are being exceeded.

Performance against those measures dropped over the period that we looked at. That has put more pressure on the Scottish Courts and Tribunals Service, which has the ultimate end-stop of the 26-week overall target to meet. The more cases that take slightly longer to go through the initial stages, the greater the pressure on the Scottish Courts and Tribunals Service at the end.

Colin Beattie’s second point was about the impact of business going through JP courts. As the Auditor General said, because this is very much a system, if there is a big increase in business in JP courts, that occupies courtroom time and courtroom availability, and that squeezes the availability of courtrooms for summary and solemn business in the sheriff courts. As we highlight in the map in exhibit 1, a lot of court buildings are used as both JP and sheriff courts.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

The key point that I am trying to make is that, if serious criminal cases are being dealt with reasonably expeditiously, the bad guys are not feeling the impact of an inefficient system, and it is the summary cases that are forming the bulk of the problem. The report shows that the detection and reporting of sex crimes are up by 80 per cent and that domestic abuse cases that are entering the system might well be taking longer to process. That is important because I presume that those figures lead through into the criminal side. If that is being contained and the targets are being exceeded, I would have thought that that side is doing okay.

11:15

Mark Roberts Audit Scotland
link

The pressure is coming from the overall 26-week target, which is a combined measure of the work of Police Scotland, the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service and the Scottish Courts and Tribunals Service. Having more cases coming through the JP courts adds to the pressure in the criminal side on summary and solemn business, and those cases occupy available court time for doing other JP work.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

From an audit point of view, it is important to understand where the pressure is coming from. If it is coming from summary cases, that is a concern. We need to understand what that means and what the knock-on effect is.

The Auditor General said that, for understandable reasons, courts have to work separately—or, at least, cases have to be handled separately. The second-last sentence of paragraph 58 on page 35 states:

“Existing legislation means if an individual is being prosecuted in the sheriff courts for two different crimes in two different sheriffdoms ... these cases”

cannot be combined. The indication is that some thousands are impacted by that. If I have got it right, the Auditor General is saying that such cases cannot be combined and have to be taken separately but that perhaps a way should be found of combining them.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

Not quite. I was making the point that we recognise that, within the judicial system, there has to be an independent judiciary and safeguards to ensure that the police can carry out their work independently, and that all those players need to play their roles independently but must come together to manage the system. For example, Mark Roberts described how people get together in the Aberdeen sheriffdom to manage the courts better, which is a good example of people managing the business in ways that do not compromise the independence of their operation and decision making.

We said in the report that there might be scope for combining cases in the way that you are hinting at. However, what the Aberdeen sheriffdom has done is an example of being much clearer about where people can work closely together to improve the working of the system and about where they need to operate independently.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

I was rather tantalised by paragraph 65 on page 37, which states:

“The strategy estimates that £20-£25 million could be saved each year by operating a fully digitised justice system.”

Was there not an attempt some years ago to put in place a digital solution, which got at least partially scrapped? Is my memory right about that?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

We like tantalising MSPs, so I am glad that that point has been helpful in that respect. Laughter. Would Mark Roberts like to respond to Mr Beattie’s question?

Mark Roberts Audit Scotland
link

I might have to rely on Angela Cullen for this, but I think that Mr Beattie is referring to an information technology project that existed in the Crown Office, which we reported on a number of years ago. Can you confirm that, Angela?

Angela Cullen Audit Scotland
link

Yes—Mark Roberts is right. I think that Mr Beattie is referring to the information and communications technology project in the Crown Office that we reported on in 2012. The justice board of senior people in the justice sector was set up in 2011, and one of the things that it has done is develop the justice digital strategy, which was published in 2014. That sets out how all the bodies will work together as part of the making justice work programme, and IT across the sector is one of the solutions that they are looking to.

We identify on page 37 a range of on-going initiatives, including bringing wi-fi into courts and ensuring that there are videoconferencing links in prisons so that prisoners can speak to their lawyers. A lot is going on, and the Government has estimated that improving the digital world in the justice system could bring savings of £20 million to £25 million.

Nigel Don SNP Angus North and Mearns
link

Good morning, Auditor General and colleagues. I want to concentrate on exhibit 10 on page 27 of the report and unpack the graph. There are four different spaces within the graph. I will start with the top-left, which shows the courts that had a small number of cases. Understandably, they might not appear to be terribly efficient, but I propose to discount that view.

The packed bottom left-hand area of exhibit 10 shows that a large number of sheriff courts seem to work reasonably efficiently. By definition, some will be performing above average—that is how you get a national average. However, the interesting spaces on the exhibit are, first, those that show the contrast between the performance of Paisley sheriff court and the performance of the likes of Falkirk, Dundee and Kilmarnock sheriff courts and, secondly, the top right-hand corner, which I will come back to. When I turned the page, I noted that Paisley sheriff court is considered in case study 3, but I am not sure that the case study tells us what you think the answer is; it is just a more detailed description of what you have observed. Back in the days when I had a different salary, if I was running two factories that had such different levels of efficiency I would have been dispatched by the appropriate director to work out why. Surely somebody somewhere is having a look at why those courts are performing so differently.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

You are absolutely right, Mr Don. In my opening remarks, I said that, as well as there being marked variations between the six sheriffdoms, there are marked variations within each sheriffdom, and you have put your finger on an example of that. Case study 3 talks through what the team found when it looked at Paisley and Kilmarnock sheriff courts, in the north Strathclyde sheriffdom.

First, there are no simple answers. We recognise that these are complex systems with an awful lot of factors going on. Secondly, we know from our audit work and from looking at places that are doing well that some things make a difference. Mark Roberts will talk you through the detail of that, and we can come back on the response to the report.

Mark Roberts Audit Scotland
link

While doing the fieldwork, we heard a lot about the impact that the culture and the behaviour of all the individuals who are involved in the sheriff court system can have on overall performance. We refer to the culture of the defence in its attitude and approach to, for example, not guilty pleas, and the behaviour of the accused. Those were emphasised again and again, with people saying that they were key factors associated with the performance of the court—in this case, Paisley sheriff court. We included case study 3 because it focused on two courts within a single sheriffdom, and we tried to get two courts that were as close as possible in their volume of business and the distribution of crime types while noting a sharp difference in their performance. As I say, during the fieldwork, we heard about the culture of the defence agents and accused that was associated with Paisley sheriff court.

Nigel Don SNP Angus North and Mearns
link

Let us not get too parochial about it, but would it be fair to suggest that the sheriff principal has some responsibility for changing what happens there? Who is responsible for it, please?

Mark Roberts Audit Scotland
link

The sheriffs principal are responsible for all business in the sheriffdoms, with sheriffs being responsible for the management of individual courts and the effective discharge of business through them.

Nigel Don SNP Angus North and Mearns
link

Does the sheriff or sheriff principal have the power to tell defence lawyers—if those are the people who are making the difference—that they should proceed differently?

Mark Roberts Audit Scotland
link

I guess that the way in which they approach cases is an on-going matter for discussion between sheriffs and the legal profession, but I cannot point you towards any definite examples of where that is happening. You might want to ask that question of the Scottish Courts and Tribunals Service.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

It is fair to say that “power” is a less useful word than “influence”. Case study 4, on Aberdeen sheriff court, describes how the sheriffs meet to discuss their professional practice and ensure that they are consistent. That discourages defence agents from asking for adjournments on the basis that they might get a different sheriff the next time. That sort of thing is within the power and responsibility of the sheriffs and the sheriffs principal. It comes back to the need for people to understand the challenges that are faced at a local level and to think about what actions would make a difference in any particular set of circumstances.

Nigel Don SNP Angus North and Mearns
link

I do not want it to get too personal, so perhaps that is where I should leave it. I recognise that sheriffs’ clerks also have some influence in that environment, particularly, perhaps, in Aberdeen.

I would like to explore the situation that is illustrated in the top right-hand corner of exhibit 10, where we find the sheriff courts in our two biggest cities. There is clearly some kind of constraint at work, but the inefficiency cannot come from their dealing with only small numbers of cases; it appears to be because of their dealing with large numbers of cases, which one would not have expected to be the cause in itself. Does it come down to a lack of space, a lack of sheriffs or the interaction with all the other business that is going on? Do we know what it comes down to?

Mark Roberts Audit Scotland
link

It probably comes down to a combination of all those factors. There is a large volume of business, and we have talked about the increasing complexity of the cases that are being heard. We spoke to Mr Beattie about the competing demands of JP business and fatal accident inquiries in occupying court rooms, for example. There are also issues to do with scheduling different courts to take different approaches to the number of cases that are scheduled for any given day, which seems to have an impact on how long it takes for cases to get through the system as a whole. You referred to the role of sheriff clerks in the management of business and that is a key factor.

There is no simple answer. When we did the fieldwork, a recurrent theme was how complicated the system is and no single driver could be easily picked on to try to untangle what causes the problems.

Nigel Don SNP Angus North and Mearns
link

I guess that those in Edinburgh would argue that they are just as efficient as those in Aberdeen and Inverness. Therefore, maybe I should not pick on them, and I will not do so. Is there somebody in the Glasgow system who has responsibility for what is going on there? Again, I do not want to be personal, but is the system so diffuse that it is no one’s responsibility?

Mark Roberts Audit Scotland
link

One of the challenges that the system faces in managing itself as a system is that not everyone who is involved seeks the same outcome, as the Auditor General has said. The culture that is adopted by defence agents and the accused can have an impact on how well the system performs as a whole.

There is also the necessary independence of the judiciary, the police and the Procurator Fiscal Service in making their decisions. At the same time, they all have to operate together. I do not think that there is one person who is responsible for all of that. The system is very large and, as you said, slightly diffuse, but people are working better together at the national level, certainly, to make things flow through the system.

Sandra White SNP Glasgow Kelvin
link

Good morning. I want to raise two issues, one of which is a very slight one and the other of which is churn. The Auditor General’s submission states:

“There is limited information on the full costs of prosecuting criminal cases through the sheriff court system”,

so the costs have to be estimated. Is that because there is not joined-up thinking? Obviously, we are talking about data and previous witnesses. How do you estimate a cost? Why can you not get the full information?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

That is difficult because the costs sit in the budgets of the various organisations involved. Part of the budgets of Police Scotland, the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service and the Scottish Courts and Tribunals Service are for prosecution, and parts of their budgets also cover other things. Therefore, estimating how much relates to each is not as straightforward as you might think.

Mark Roberts’s team did a good job of coming up with a good estimate and using that to estimate the cost of things such as churn; he will briefly talk through how that was done.

Mark Roberts Audit Scotland
link

In collaboration with the various public bodies involved, we estimated how long an individual member of staff would spend on a particular component of the system, whether in preparing a prosecution report, marking a case or appearing as a witness. We then took salary data from each of the bodies involved and added everything up to come up with an overall estimate of £203 million. Rather than looking at the matter from the perspective of the budgets of the individual bodies, we tried to build from the bottom up by costing the activities of the individuals involved. We tried to build from their salary and time costs.

Sandra White SNP Glasgow Kelvin
link

That must have been a long and laborious exercise. That question followed on from Colin Beattie’s question about the various levels of court cases.

I want to pick up on churn. I know that the Justice Committee, which I have been a member of, looked at churn and spent some time visiting the courts, and we also heard from witnesses, the police and defence lawyers. There are challenges, including where there are not guilty pleas. Some cases can last a year or a year and a half, and churn is obviously a huge issue in that respect.

You say in your report that the system at Aberdeen sheriff court works because sheriffs there

“challenge requests for adjournments and encourage cases to be resolved early”.

They are challenging the defence lawyers. Could that approach be made mandatory in other courts or does it have to be just an option that they might take up?

11:30

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

We recommend that a joint working approach, rather than each sheriff simply managing the cases that come to his or her court on the day, would make a difference, although that difference will vary in different parts of Scotland, depending on the challenges that they are facing. Mr Don talked about the likelihood of different types of cases in Glasgow. People need to understand the make-up of cases and the extent to which things such as the attitude of defence agents affect that, and then to decide together on the best approach to dealing with it.

The key recommendation in the report is that joint working has made a difference nationally and that there is a real opportunity to get the same difference locally using this sort of analysis and the better information that we believe is needed about not just cost but all the other things that make up the system.

Sandra White SNP Glasgow Kelvin
link

That is a good recommendation. You also mention the important role of individuals—I presume that that includes defence lawyers—in certain areas.

I know that the police have looked into recommending weekend courts. If that recommendation was made and accepted, would it stop some of the churn?

Mark Roberts Audit Scotland
link

I am not sure that it would necessarily stop churn. It would certainly generate greater availability of court days, but that would come with increased costs given the greater number of days on which courts would have to be supported by all the bodies that are involved. It would, perhaps, be interesting to explore whether that would generate additional efficiencies in the truest sense. However, it might help to address performance against the 26-week measure that all the criminal justice bodies have.

Sandra White SNP Glasgow Kelvin
link

You estimate that churn costs £10 million. Having weekend courts to alleviate churn might save money in the long run.

Angela Cullen talked about the new digital systems that have been put in place. You spoke to lawyers and went to courts and so on, and you found that only a third of the defence lawyers have signed up to the secure email system. You also discuss the installation of videoconferencing facilities in every prison to alleviate churn and you mention that only 40 solicitors—less than 3 per cent—have signed up to use that system. Did you get any answers on why the take-up of those two systems has been so low?

Mark Roberts Audit Scotland
link

The simple answer is no. We did not get any evidence on why there has not been a better uptake of those systems.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

I looked at exhibit 5 to see whether there has been a huge increase in the number of presentations, as we would call them, or the number of accused people in cases. I think that you say that there has been variance of about 10 per cent over the past five years but, to be honest, between 2010-11 and 2014-15, there has been a reduction in the number of accused at sheriff courts.

I then looked at exhibit 8, which shows the reduction in the percentage of summary cases that are concluded within 26 weeks. Across Scotland, there has been a reduction of 8 per cent. It is not like accident and emergency services, where we have thousands more people; we actually have fewer people. The figures for Glasgow and Strathkelvin show that the percentage of summary cases that are concluded within 26 weeks was 72 in 2010-11, whereas it is now 52, so that area is getting significantly worse. The other outlier, which Nigel Don mentioned, is Lothian and Borders, where the percentage has reduced by only 3 per cent.

My second question is about the 26-week measure. I realise that, on its own, it is not a measure of efficiency but, given that there were the same number of or fewer presentations over five years, the drastic fall in performance by 20 per cent is surely very concerning. Is there something behind that figure?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

We think that it is clear that the sheriff court system is under pressure. The two factors that we draw out in the report are, first, the increasing complexity of cases and the growing proportion that involve either domestic violence or historical sexual crimes and, secondly, reducing budgets. We think that both of those are having an effect. You are right that, as we say, the 26-week measure is not a good measure of efficiency on its own, but a number of other measures that we looked at show the same sort of pressure overall.

Some sheriffdoms and some areas within sheriffdoms are doing better than others. I mentioned the two sources of the pressure. What seems to make the difference is how well people can respond to them locally by understanding what is happening for them and then putting in place the measures that they can to influence and manage the pressures.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

Have there been greater budget cuts in Glasgow compared with other sheriffdoms, and has that led to the 20 per cent fall? Have there been more of the complex domestic abuse and sexual abuse cases in Glasgow that would help us to understand the figure?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

I ask Mark Roberts to pick up the detail of that.

Mark Roberts Audit Scotland
link

We do not have a breakdown of the budgets by sheriffdom. The Scottish Courts and Tribunals Service might be able to help with that.

On the types of cases, as you say, we have reported at national level. I do not have to hand the breakdown of case types by sheriffdom. It is important to note that domestic abuse is not identified as a separate crime type. We had to identify all the cases in which domestic abuse was an aggravator—that is the technical term—which could span the seven crime types that we highlight in exhibit 6. I cannot answer your question immediately and disentangle the data to say whether, in Glasgow and Strathkelvin, there has been any variation in the budgetary pressure or in the crime-type pressure.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

In Edinburgh, the reduction was 3 per cent whereas, in Glasgow, it was 20 per cent, which is quite incredible.

I move on to my second question. I was surprised by the key messages on page 5, because I know how precise Audit Scotland always is. Paragraph 2 states:

“We estimate that Police Scotland, COPFS”

et cetera

“spent at least £203 million”.

You say “at least”, but normally you are very precise. Do you not know how much they have spent? What I really mean is: do they not know?

You say that the measure of 26 weeks for cases is not necessarily a measure of efficiency. What is a measure of efficiency? Do we truly not know exactly how much money is spent? I have read quite a few Audit Scotland reports, so I know that a figure with “at least” before it is not normal Audit Scotland-speak. What can be done to better understand how the money is spent, given that there has been a 7 per cent cut? Has that cut led to the increases such as those in Glasgow that I have just mentioned?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

The reason why we have used the wording that you identify is that we cannot be more precise than that and nor can the bodies that are involved. As we said in response to an earlier question, the budgets are held by a number of bodies, including Police Scotland, the Scottish Courts and Tribunals Service and the Crown Office, and they all do other things as well as prosecuting through the sheriff court. Therefore, as Mark Roberts described, we built a bottom-up model that came up with our best estimate. We have discussed that with the bodies and have used their starting data. I think that we agree that it is the best figure available and that it is not a precise cost. We would like the bodies to work together to understand their costs and activity better, which should give better ways of managing and better public reporting of performance.

I ask Mark Roberts to pick up the question about what information is needed to manage the process better.

Mark Roberts Audit Scotland
link

On Mary Scanlon’s question about the measure of efficiency, the 26-week measure gives an important indication of performance on the overall time taken from charge to verdict, but it is not related to any form of input—it is purely an output. As the Auditor General said, we recommend that there be a better understanding of the activity costs—the unit costs that are associated with, for example, different types of case and different types of crime—so that the inputs can be related to the overall output and performance. We are keen for the Scottish Government and the other justice bodies to look at our recommendation and explore how best to do that.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

Have you had a response from those bodies to say that they will work with you and respond to your recommendations to try to get a better understanding?

Mark Roberts Audit Scotland
link

I have already been in discussion with the Scottish Courts and Tribunals Service and the Government on that.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

On behalf of the committee, I thank the Auditor General and her team for their contribution.

As agreed, we now move into private to consider agenda item 5.

11:41 Meeting continued in private until 13:00.

  1. 09:30 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. 09:30 Major Capital Projects (Update) Committee business · 53
  3. 10:00 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 75
  4. 10:45 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 56

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.