Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 12 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Section 23 Reports

“Accident and Emergency: Performance update”

Wednesday 7 October 2015 Public Audit Committee About 10:00–10:45 Committee business 75 contributions · 10 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

75 contributions
Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Agenda item 3 is the section 23 report entitled “Accident and Emergency: Performance update”. I welcome our panel of witnesses. Paul Gray is director general of health and social care and chief executive of NHS Scotland; John Connaghan is the NHS Scotland chief operating officer; Catherine Calderwood is the chief medical officer; and Alan Hunter is NHS Scotland performance director in the Scottish Government.

I understand that Mr Gray would like to make a short opening statement.

Paul Gray Scottish Government
link

Thank you, convener. I am conscious of the time, so I will keep my statement brief.

We have faced some very challenging times in relation to accident and emergency performance, especially last winter. I acknowledge that, along with the effect that there has been on patients and their families, and the fact that staff have worked exceedingly hard through the challenges. Last winter, the key factors that affected performance included unprecedented levels of activity, which we can say more about later if that would help the committee, and lost bed days as people awaited care in their communities and therefore had delayed discharges.

Scotland’s unscheduled care performance last winter deteriorated, but it was in line with performance in other parts of the United Kingdom and was, indeed, similar to the performance of similar health systems across the world. Our core A and E performance was about 1 per cent better than that of England in the winter of 2014-15, whereas in the previous winter it was about 1 per cent worse than that of England.

I accept that we are not at the standard that we are striving towards, but performance against the four-hour A and E target increased to 95 per cent over July and August from a starting position of 86.1 per cent in the week ending 22 February, when we started to publish weekly. In the past three months, performance has reached 95 per cent on seven occasions, and it was above 94 per cent on a further six occasions during the same period. There was also a significant reduction in long waits of over 12 hours by 99 per cent from January to the week ending 27 September.

In order to ensure that we have a structured approach as we go into this winter, we have launched a new improvement approach to unscheduled care using six fundamental actions—again, we can speak about that if the committee would find that helpful—and invested a total of around £55 million in this year to address issues that affect performance, particularly over the winter. I can give a breakdown of that figure if the committee would find that helpful. That is significantly higher than the £29 million investment last winter. We have also issued winter guidance to national health service boards two months earlier than normal.

We are focusing on tackling unscheduled care from a whole-system perspective. I assure the committee that we are well aware of the complexity of the issues that affect performance. We are working hard with our partners to deliver sustainable benefits to ensure that patients receive timely treatment and safe, person-centred and effective care.

We are happy to answer questions from the committee. If we do not have information immediately to hand, we will provide it in writing as quickly as we can after the meeting closes.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Thank you.

You refer in your written submission to examples of key national programmes and unscheduled care. I note the bullet points in your submission. For example, one bullet point refers to

“senior clinicians and managers working together at site level to ensure better accountability for performance”.

Another refers to

“using the best available data to develop patient capacity and management plans which are regularly updated by site based teams to ensure good flow and to minimise delays”.

I have not done so this morning, but I am sure that, if I did a Google search, I could probably find similar terms in previous health board documents. They are pretty generic terms that have been used over a number of years. How is what is being done any different from what has been done before? Should those things have been happening anyway?

Paul Gray Scottish Government
link

Taking your last question first, convener, I believe that there ought to be close working between managers and clinicians, and I absolutely agree that if that has not been happening, it should have been.

What is different about this year is that we have started the process earlier and are very thoroughly checking that boards are following through on this. Boards will be publishing their winter plans on their websites by the end of this month. We are two months ahead of the game and we have put in more money. If you want more detail about our direct engagement with boards, I think that Mr Connaghan will be the best person to provide it. However, I personally assure you that I have been engaging directly with chief executives and senior clinicians through the chief medical officer to ensure that we make clear the importance that we attach to doing better this winter than we did last winter.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Why would managers and clinicians not have worked together before? I saw exactly the same things being said back in the acute services review in Glasgow, and in every meeting that I have had with senior officials at your level over the past 15 years, they have said, “Clinicians and managers will be working much closer to deliver the targets that they need to meet.” Are you saying that that has not happened before and that it should happen now? How will we know whether it is happening?

Paul Gray Scottish Government
link

The committee might recall a Healthcare Improvement Scotland report on NHS Lanarkshire that was published in December 2013, which highlighted the capacity of clinicians and managers to work together as a result of governance structures that were too complicated. As a result, each of the three main hospitals in NHS Lanarkshire now has a tripartite operation involving a senior administrator, a senior nurse and a senior doctor. That sort of arrangement was not there before, and I and my colleagues can give you examples from other hospitals, if you so wish. Indeed, each of the hospitals in Glasgow now has an identified site director, which was not the case before.

We have actually changed the system. We are not simply hoping that this will happen as a result of instructions or guidance—the system itself is different.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

As a member of the health committee in 1999, I remember that even back then we were asking managers and clinicians to talk to each other. I retire in a few months, and I find it quite sad that 17 years on we are still recommending that managers and clinicians work together.

My first question is about increased demand. We have received a briefing from Audit Scotland, and I find what says very disappointing. For example, it says:

“The percentage of patients seen in A&E departments and”

minor injury units

“within four hours fell to”

87 per cent

“in January 2015, the lowest ... since ... April 2008.”

I had hoped that what we would get today would be a better understanding of the increase in demand. We all accept that that has happened, but I had hoped that you would address some of the issues involved. A couple of weeks ago, eight of the questions for the health portfolio at question time were on the shortage of general practitioners; as we all know, if people cannot get a GP, they go to accident and emergency. We have not had serious winter pressures for many years, but I note that a report that came out yesterday found attendance rates in Ayrshire and Arran to be twice as high as those in Tayside and the number of those attending in the most deprived area to be twice as many as the number attending in the least deprived area.

I had hoped that given all this time, all the pressures on A and E and, indeed, the fact that this Audit Scotland report came out in May 2014—we are actually discussing a report that is 18 months old—we would be getting, instead of a recommendation to ask clinicians and managers to work together, a bit more of an analytical and forensic understanding of why we have these pressures on A and E and what is being done about them. I would like you to address that issue. I hope that you do not share my disappointment without addressing those challenges, which we all know exist in the system.

10:15

Paul Gray Scottish Government
link

You make two important points, Ms Scanlon. The first is about the need for clinicians and managers to work more closely together, and the second is about the demand on the system. The chief medical officer will be able to give you some details about both those issues, if that is acceptable to the committee.

Catherine Calderwood Scottish Government
link

As you rightly say, it sounds obvious that clinicians and managers should work together, but we recognise that that does not seem to happen automatically or just because it should. We are, therefore, introducing much more formal paired training of managers and clinicians with groups of formal educators throughout the health boards in Scotland. Instead of expecting it to happen—you are right to say that it has not—we are formalising that education, and we now have examples in every health board of different departments having taken that on. It is in its early stages, but we are progressing it.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

Clinicians and managers are being educated and trained to talk to each other.

Catherine Calderwood Scottish Government
link

It is about understanding each other’s work within the system. They already talk to each other, but we now require a more formal understanding—

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

You are asking them to work together, so they are being educated and trained to work together.

Catherine Calderwood Scottish Government
link

Absolutely. I am speaking to the Institute of—

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

That is sad in a country of 5 million people.

Catherine Calderwood Scottish Government
link

They do work together, but perhaps not as effectively as they could, probably because of a lack of understanding of each other’s vital role within the service.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

You have not addressed the major issue, which is the exponential increase in demand.

Catherine Calderwood Scottish Government
link

We have a huge increase in our older population and we expect the number of people aged over 65 in Scotland to increase by 62 per cent by 2035. The number of people with comorbidities is also rising exponentially. That figure would include, for example, someone with diabetes and heart disease who has had a stroke or is on long-term medication.

I will use diabetes as an example. In the past 20 years, the number of people in Scotland who have diabetes has risen from 22,000 to 237,000, so there has been a more than tenfold increase in the incidence of that condition alone. Diabetes is a good example, because diabetes puts people at increased risk of cardiovascular disease, heart attacks and strokes. It also causes neurological and eyesight issues and is linked with chronic kidney disease. The fact that our population is living longer is a success story, but such comorbidities are partly behind the increase in demand on both elective services in hospitals and emergency services.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

We all know that the silver-haired brigade are now living longer—I am grateful for that—but you have not addressed the two issues that I raised. First, in Ayrshire and Arran, emergency departments’ attendance rates are twice as high as the rate in Tayside—why is that? Secondly, why is the number of attendances among people from the most deprived backgrounds twice as high as that among the least deprived? I would have thought that it is only by understanding that that we can address the huge increase in demand. It cannot all be down to older people.

Catherine Calderwood Scottish Government
link

We know that multiple comorbidities are much more prevalent in our most deprived communities, partly because of so-called lifestyle diseases of smoking and substance misuse but also because access has not been as good or efficient as it could have been. There is a definite propensity for the more deprived communities to require emergency services. A lot of the demand at the accident and emergency department in Glasgow royal infirmary, for example, will be caused by deprivation. Mr Hunter might be able to talk about the differences in Tayside.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

I would point out that Dundee is quite a poor city with very poor areas, yet it has the lowest emergency department attendance rate.

Catherine Calderwood Scottish Government
link

I visited the Tayside A and E department in August. Alan Hunter will talk you through the detail.

Alan Hunter Scottish Government
link

The attendance rates in Ayrshire and Arran are higher per head of population, as Ms Scanlon said. The reasons for such variation are different across Scotland; in part, that is about underlying morbidity in the community and deprivation, but it is also to do with how the services have been profiled over the years.

Tayside has redirection policies, which we have now adopted. Through the programme that Ms Scanlon referred to earlier, we are promoting redirection and making sure that patients are signposted to the right locations. Tayside has been doing that for about 15 years.

Other initiatives are being promoted and their benefits are being shared across the various health systems. For example, frailty models, which are services for elderly patients attending A and E, are designed to get support in place quickly and identify problems before patients are admitted. It is better to keep elderly patients in their own community, if possible. For example, Fife has identified that 20 elderly care admissions on average per week are being avoided, and that service is being built up. Such models are being shared across Scotland. For example, Ayrshire and Arran is also putting in a frailty model, and Dumfries and Galloway has put in weekend discharge teams to try to get the weekend discharge rates to match normal weekday rates.

All those things are designed to address the type of problem that Ms Scanlon has highlighted.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Our discussions today are all about comparing statistics and figures. In the past, we have had considerable difficulty in collecting statistics about the NHS. To what extent has that situation improved and to what extent are the figures accurate?

Paul Gray Scottish Government
link

The figures that are published weekly are reviewed by statisticians to ensure that they are as accurate as they can be. The longer-term published figures go through a more thorough system of checking and validation. The weekly figures are management information, which is checked by statisticians for consistency, and the monthly and quarterly publications go through more thorough checking. We take as many reasonable steps as we can to ensure that the figures are as accurate as they can be. We also ensure through our statistician colleagues that the formal processes that are set out for national statistics are followed for those that are published as national statistics.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Clearly, we are measuring ourselves against the notional figures or targets that we produce in Scotland. Do we benchmark how we are doing against overseas figures? Do we compare ourselves with, for example, UK or European figures?

Paul Gray Scottish Government
link

Yes, we do. We compare ourselves with the other nations in the United Kingdom and with those in Europe and beyond that have similar systems. We can give a brief overview of that now, if that would be helpful, or provide a more detailed overview in writing. I am happy to do whatever suits the committee.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

It would be useful to have that information.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

If you could provide it in writing, that would be helpful.

Paul Gray Scottish Government
link

We can do that.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

We are looking at statistics, which are fairly dry, but the important thing is the outcome for the patient. How are we measuring what actually comes out at the other end?

Paul Gray Scottish Government
link

I will turn to the chief medical officer on the clinical matters and to the chief operating officer on any detail that is required. However, as we are talking about A and E performance, there is good clinical evidence to support the value of having a 95 per cent target. It is not appropriate for some patients to be moved out of A and E within four hours; it is better for them to stay there either to be discharged later or to be treated in the same place because they are acutely unwell and it would harm them to move them.

There is good evidence that the outcomes for most patients who present at A and E will be better if they can be either discharged or moved on to another place for care and treatment. That is why we strive to meet the standard—it is not merely an arbitrary decision.

Our standard is higher than the standards in some other countries, on which we can provide written evidence. Nonetheless, after consulting the Royal College of Emergency Medicine and taking on board other emergency department advice, that is the standard on which we have settled, based on clinical evidence that it produces the best outcomes. The chief medical officer will be able to say more about that.

Catherine Calderwood Scottish Government
link

We have evidence that longer waits in A and E lead to increased morbidity and mortality for a range of conditions. It is the point of definitive care that is important. If someone needs a specialist cardiologist, the sooner they can be seen and triaged in A and E and moved to a specialist ward with other facilities, the better.

John Connaghan Scottish Government
link

I would like to comment on management and clinicians working together. Previously in Glasgow, we had matrix management, with one manager and one clinician managing the surgical service across a number of sites. That was fine, and it was effective for planning purposes.

However, the latest approach to ensuring that managers and clinicians work better together highlights the question who is in charge of a particular site on a particular day. While matrix management is good for planning, it is not all that effective at ensuring that people take quick decisions on, for example, what will happen in the afternoon if there is a problem in the morning. That is one of the aspects that lies behind the recommendation.

With regard to measuring the impact on patients, the guidance that we published on 6 August 2015 is the most comprehensive that we have ever issued on winter planning. We have asked boards to look at a checklist of more than 100 items, which includes aspects such as the effectiveness of the respiratory services that we make available for cases that present at accident and emergency units.

All boards will reflect that guidance in their winter plans, which are due for publication at the end of this month. We already have draft winter plans from boards and we are engaging with them on those plans. The whole process is now taking place two months earlier than ever before. We want to try to get ahead of winter and ensure that our measurement systems are appropriate for patients.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Just before I bring in Nigel Don, I want to come back to the point that you raised regarding the relationship between clinicians and management. A clinician obviously has a responsibility to their patients, but who is in charge? Is the manager in charge of the clinician, or is the clinician in charge?

John Connaghan Scottish Government
link

That depends on how the local management is set up. I have been a chief executive in three health boards and have had both managers and clinicians in charge of services. I like to encourage clinicians to take charge of services. I ran a system in which we had a clinical director in charge of each of the major components of service provision in the health board. The decision on who is the best person to be in charge depends on the nature of the task.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Is that allied to the challenges that are faced? There is no consistency in the system because nobody really knows who the manager is; it is different in each locality. Another problem is that some clinicians are in charge and other clinicians are not. Does that lead to local problems?

Paul Gray Scottish Government
link

I will come in on that, convener. It is a fair question. I will use the example of Glasgow. There is a rota there for a lead director to cover weekdays and weekends. Sometimes the lead director will be an administrator and at other points the director will be a clinician. That is a good thing, because it means that clinicians and administrators are dependent on one another.

To put it positively, if an administrator is in the role on Friday and leaves a good well-flowing system for the clinician on Saturday, that is beneficial. If either leaves a bad product for the other, that is not beneficial. The system of rotation works well because it means that everybody has to work in the interests of everyone else.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Can we be honest about this? There are senior clinicians who do not want to be managed because they are looking at the situation from their own perspective, which is that they have a responsibility to their patients, which is their absolute priority. That culture has existed for a long time, and it is difficult to manage, is it not?

10:30

Paul Gray Scottish Government
link

I am saying this with a smile on my face, convener: I will not be drawn into criticising administrators or clinicians. The top ones in either profession are people who are committed to delivering safe, person-centred and effective care.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

I am not saying that they are not.

Paul Gray Scottish Government
link

I apologise, convener: I did not mean that you were trying to get me to criticise them.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

I am just being realistic about the situation in which we find ourselves. Senior clinicians have a responsibility to their patients, and they do not always like to be put in a position in which somebody is saying to them that they have to look at diverting their resources to somebody else. That is a clinical decision that sometimes has to be made. Not every clinician wants to be a manager, do they?

Paul Gray Scottish Government
link

The point is that, by having clinicians and managers working together as we do, we are fostering joint working in a way that we have not done previously.

You are right that there are points at which an administrative decision on the availability of a bed and a clinical decision on the needs of a patient can conflict. However, we are now having conversations—there is not simply a battle in which somebody from on high says, “Do this” and it is done. The conversations are actually happening. That is why we are training clinicians and managers together. I am clear that getting people to work together and talk to one another is the way to resolve the issue. I or the CMO can give any amount of instruction, but the system really works when people work together.

I totally accept your point about the potential conflict between administrative decisions and clinical decisions, which is why we have to get better at working in that area. We cannot just let it stay as a conflict.

Nigel Don SNP Angus North and Mearns
link

Good morning, colleagues. I would like to pick up on a couple of points. You have suggested that winter pressures next year will, as I understand it, be addressed not only by getting guidance—and instruction, dare I say it?—out a little bit sooner, but by putting some money in the appropriate places. I am quite prepared to believe that you will put that money in the appropriate places, but money buys you people—in this context, professional people. As MSPs, we all know that it is difficult to get the right people, and there are not spare people hanging on skyhooks. How is that money actually going to buy you more medical resource in the winter months when those people are more likely to suffer from flu and we are far more likely to fall over in the street and break a wrist?

Paul Gray Scottish Government
link

Of the money that I have mentioned, £30 million is going towards addressing delayed discharge, which does not, by and large, require us to buy hospital-based services but rather requires that we support the integrated joint boards in delivery of services outwith the hospital. The CMO, along with my colleagues at the table, will be able to tell you in more detail how that money might be deployed effectively.

We have put £9 million into unscheduled care—again, we are trying to stop the flow coming in rather than dealing with it once it gets there. Valid points have been made about primary care, and we are working hard to strengthen the resource and development there.

In fact, the amount of money that is going straight into hospitals—if I may put it as crudely as that—is not a large proportion of the money that we have. The CMO may want to say something about the availability of staff and how that issue is addressed over winter.

Catherine Calderwood Scottish Government
link

The A and E departments expect an increased flow, as they do throughout the year during festivals and public holidays and on new year’s eve, and there is always a group of doctors—I will talk about doctors initially—who will be available to do extra shifts. There are locum shifts, but the doctors are usually people who already work in the department. That capacity is built in at times of expected high pressure, and it can be sustained for a number of days and weeks—for example, if the weather is particularly cold.

Similarly, with regard to nursing staff, the boards plan to use the available agency and bank staff who are on their books. If they are not available, the boards look elsewhere. That is part of the planning structure. People are not just “hanging on skyhooks”, as Nigel Don said—although perhaps they are to a certain extent given that there are people who are available to work specific hours.

Nigel Don SNP Angus North and Mearns
link

That answer was very helpful. I am interested to note that you are putting in money to try to ensure that people do not come into hospital in the first place and to try to get them out at the other end. That makes sense, because your constraint is the limited resource in the middle.

I will ask about the other side of statistics. You have spoken about the 95 per cent target for moving patients on. I encourage you to find a better way of describing that. I listen to people who tell me that people have not been seen within four hours. I know perfectly well from experience that triage is more or less instant, unless there is a queue, which is rare. The problem is in getting people moved on within the four-hour target. I encourage you to find words to describe that better, because the press does not understand it, and therefore the public do not understand it.

You said that the 95 per cent target makes clinical sense. I suspect that there might be an increasing trend of folk who come in under the influence of drugs and alcohol. Although you could triage and do some medical things to those people, you could not conceivably move them on within four hours, because you could not finish the process. Do you have any statistical understanding of what fraction of those who present are in that category? Does it vary in different places? I suspect that there must be some variation. Should you present that aspect of the statistics to us? If it is significant, there will be no way that you can get to the 95 per cent target.

John Connaghan Scottish Government
link

I can answer some of that. We split the population that presents at accident and emergency departments into two age groups: 0-64 and post-64. For presenters in the 0-64 age group, by far the biggest single cause of presentation is poisonings. That is how it is coded—“poisoning” usually means overindulgence in alcohol, drugs and so on. The next biggest cause is chest pain. In the post-64 age band, the biggest cause is chest pain, with respiratory failure and so on coming thereafter.

A slightly younger age group presents with poisoning. It is significant, because it is the biggest cause of their presenting. When we analyse the figure, we see that most of those presentations are in and out and dealt with in about a day: they do not tend to stay all that long in hospitals. They stay in the front end of the hospital and are probably kept under observation until they can go home.

Nigel Don SNP Angus North and Mearns
link

That is helpful in a medical sense. I am concerned about the statistic, as I am sure you are, because people keep bashing you over the head with it. Is it fair to say that those who come in with what we will now describe as “poisoning” are less likely to be moved on within four hours, or are am I barking up the wrong tree? Are they as easy to deal with as everybody else?

Alan Hunter Scottish Government
link

We will get you the statistics. Clearly there are big difficulties in splitting things out exactly when somebody has an alcohol presentation but also has a serious problem that needs to be dealt with. I do not think that people who present under the influence of alcohol or drugs are the biggest issue for performance, which is partly about how we get patients into the hospital and how we get the flow. Over the summer, performance has been at around 95 per cent of target: we managed to get 95 per cent of patients through within four hours over the past two months.

Building hospitals’ resilience for winter is critical, which is why we have been working earlier with boards on planning for winter.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Paul Gray can come in briefly, then we will need to move on.

Paul Gray Scottish Government
link

I was going to ask the CMO to talk about the point in principle that Nigel Don made about the types of patient whom it is not appropriate to move out of A and E in four hours. That was the core of the question that was being asked.

Catherine Calderwood Scottish Government
link

I think that Nigel Don is concerned that we will never get to 100 per cent, because that is not appropriate. That may be because patients are very significantly injured—it would often be something such as major trauma—so they will need many hours of working up, if you like, until they are stable enough to be moved on. There are also a smaller number of people who would be deemed to be poisonings—that is the way that it is coded—but let us call the cause alcohol. They might be considered to be fit within a period longer than four hours, but would not need to be admitted. Such patients who do not recover well enough would be admitted to a short-stay or observation ward, from which they would be expected to be discharged within less than a day or would not need an overnight stay. The figure for patients who cannot be moved on within four hours is about 2 per cent.

Sandra White SNP Glasgow Kelvin
link

I will continue on the theme of data, which seems to be so important. Everyone else has mentioned the gathering of data, but can the data be broken down further?

My questions follow on from Nigel Don’s theme. It is good that it is recorded that, in 2015, just under 96 per cent of patients across Scotland have been seen within four hours. However, in relation to waiting times of over four hours and so on, are patients who present at accident and emergency asked questions such as, “Why did you come to A and E? Could you not get a doctor’s appointment in time?” Are they asked if their doctor’s surgery is closed because it is a bank holiday? Are those questions asked when people present at A and E? I receive feedback from constituents that they could not get a doctor’s appointment, so they just went to A and E, or that their doctor’s surgery was shut on the bank holiday, so they went to A and E. Do you gather such statistics?

Catherine Calderwood Scottish Government
link

There is recognition that more engagement with other parts of the service is required. The know who to turn to campaign—which was run very effectively in relation to the new hospital build in Glasgow—signposts people to NHS 24, to the opening hours of their local GP surgeries and to minor injury units, which may be geographically closer as well as more appropriate. In the longer term, NHS Tayside has put in place extremely good education for its local population. Attendances at A and E in NHS Tayside are extremely low proportionally compared with the number of people who have been sent by their GP. NHS Tayside’s system seems to work well.

It is partly about education, because people are not necessarily aware of what is available and the times at which it is available. People can go to their pharmacist, and we are encouraging increased pharmacy input. In fact, we are investing in an extra 140 pharmacists to be placed alongside GPs in GP practices. That is being done partly because it is appropriate for medicines management, but it is also designed to help the throughput in GP practices.

Sandra White SNP Glasgow Kelvin
link

I take your comments on board and I have read your report about Tayside. I have noticed on a couple of occasions in my area that when a GP surgery has been closed, the pharmacy next door has also been closed. That is a bit of a concern—I certainly noticed that over the September holiday weekend. You are gathering data, but you do not gather data about that. It is about education.

Another issue that I want to raise about the data is that, although it is good that just under 96 per cent of patients across Scotland are seen within four hours, two of the four worst-performing hospitals when it comes to the four-hour target were hospitals in Glasgow—Glasgow royal infirmary, and the Western infirmary and Gartnavel general hospital.

I will pick up on Nigel Don’s question about the people who present at A and E. If someone is in a state of inebriation—to put it that way—it may take more than four hours for them to be able to be seen or treated. Data should surely also be available on those patients. Is there any reason why we have no statistics that tell us why the four hospitals in question—the Royal Alexandra hospital in Paisley, Wishaw general hospital, the royal infirmary, and the Western infirmary and Gartnavel hospital—are the worst-performing hospitals when it comes to that target? We have no information on why that is the case.

10:45

John Connaghan Scottish Government
link

We are keen to ensure that each board has its own hospital site plan, because it is also important for there to be good site management.

We have spent quite a bit of time setting up not just a statistical gathering exercise but a process through which we can roll out improvements. In order to do the latter, we need to know what improvement is being targeted. We know that there is variability in the ability of some of our hospital sites to discharge patients before noon. There is also variability in their ability to turn around beds in an appropriate time—if someone leaves a bed, is there an appropriate response from domestic services to ensure that the bed is turned around and available? That is particularly important for sites with single rooms.

We have a fair idea of what the issues are. The guidance from 6 August to which I referred is the most comprehensive that we have ever issued. It has well over 100 different reference points for boards to look at in addressing the differences between the sites. In summary, the work is a mix of improvement and statistical analysis.

Sandra White SNP Glasgow Kelvin
link

I have a follow-up question. When the data on the various hospitals is presented—Mary Scanlon mentioned the deprivation in some areas of Dundee—it must be made quite clear that Glasgow royal infirmary is not just a local hospital; rather, it is a national hospital, just as the Yorkhill children’s hospital was for children’s services. Do you take account of that when you produce the data? People do not just present at the hospital—there may be other areas in which clinicians are under pressure.

John Connaghan Scottish Government
link

That is a fair point. I have mentioned a lot of things to do with what goes on inside hospitals, but there are many things that we need to do outside hospital. On seven-day services, for example, it is important to have staff available in the community and the hospital site to ensure that discharges are just as effective at the weekends as they are during the week. It is also important to understand how to appropriately plan for demand and capacity at each site, because things change—for example, attendance patterns change.

I cannot remember which colleague mentioned this but, over the past 12 years or so, we have seen a significant increase of about 200,000 in the over-60 population. That brings its own demands and creates extra requirements for hospital and community-based services. Understanding how all that fits together is important, so we emphasise whole-system planning.

Alan Hunter Scottish Government
link

It might help if I mention something about Glasgow royal infirmary. A number of years ago, it introduced an assessment area and, a month ago, it expanded that to include surgical GP-referred patients. It is adapting its services and models to address some of the problems.

Ayrshire and Arran NHS Board is investing £34 million—I will confirm the figure—to realign its front-door services. It is creating GP assessment areas that are adjacent to the A and E departments. Those developments are happening as we speak. The service in Ayr will open in January 2016; the one in Crosshouse will open in summer 2016.

Services have to evolve; some of the buildings are older than others and they need to be adapted. Services must be shaped as best they can be.

Stuart McMillan SNP West Scotland
link

Catherine Calderwood mentioned the know who to turn to campaign in Glasgow. Will that be rolled out across the NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde area?

Catherine Calderwood Scottish Government
link

As far as I know, partly because of the new hospital, the campaign spread widely to the areas of other hospitals that were changing their services. I am afraid that I do not know about the campaign in wider Clyde.

Alan Hunter Scottish Government
link

At the end of November, a national know who to turn to campaign will be launched. There will be radio and various other media opportunities. That is part of the winter plan. It sits in with the redirection and signposting plans of each of the boards. Local events will be tied into the national programme.

Stuart McMillan SNP West Scotland
link

I must admit that when I heard Ms Calderwood talking about the campaign earlier, I had not heard of it, even as a West Scotland member. I am glad that work is going to take place on it, but is that work going to focus on the winter period or will it continue post the winter period?

Alan Hunter Scottish Government
link

It is focused mainly on the winter period, but we recognise that we also need to take the work forward. The guidance on redirection or signposting is getting rolled out, and it is not just NHS Tayside but other health boards such as NHS Fife and NHS Grampian that are doing it. Most boards and hospitals are doing it to a degree, but they are building up their own and the staff’s confidence in that respect. It has taken Tayside about 15 years, but it now has evidence that the local population knows that if they go to the hospital with something that they could take to their GP or the pharmacist the following day, they will be told as much. That is helping with the situation.

We have agreed those types of processes with the Royal College of Emergency Medicine, and the six essential actions, which include site management and planning, have been agreed with the Academy of Medical Royal Colleges and Faculties in Scotland, which is the collective organisation. We have clinical engagement in this area not only at the top level but at a local level, with lead consultants in each of the sites looking at these issues. We are building a process that is now gathering momentum. That is the right way to go about this, because the fact is that short, sharp shocks do not always work. After all, it is a programme of change.

Stuart McMillan SNP West Scotland
link

I also imagine that NHS Tayside has collected a huge amount of data over that time and will have estimated the number of people that it has managed to prevent from presenting at A and E. I am keen to hear the estimates for other health board areas.

Alan Hunter Scottish Government
link

Nationally, it is estimated that somewhere between 10 and 15 per cent of patients can be dealt with elsewhere. It is necessary to ensure that the links with community services are in place, and we are doing that through a range of initiatives.

Stuart McMillan SNP West Scotland
link

That was helpful.

I have to say that, as far as presentations at A and E are concerned, I had not thought of the issue of festivals, which were mentioned earlier. The number of festivals has been increasing, and the tourism sector in Scotland is a huge part of our economy, with more people coming to Scotland every year. How important are festivals in the number of people who present at A and E as a result of accidents or, as they say, poisonings?

Paul Gray Scottish Government
link

Boards make plans to, in effect, staff up on the basis of known events such as festivals or football matches, because it is a fact that with certain events you are more likely to get A and E presentations. I will ask the CMO to respond in a second, but to be honest with the committee, I am less worried about festivals than I am about other types of events that, I am afraid, tend to produce a regular throughput of seriously injured people. Alcohol plays a part, but there can also be quite serious physical injuries, some of which arise from violence. The spread of domestic violence after certain events is also a big issue on which our colleagues in the police and fire and rescue services are working very constructively. For example, the violence reduction unit in Glasgow is a major contributor to that work, but the fact is that certain events produce higher throughput.

Catherine Calderwood Scottish Government
link

The planning is very detailed. I have visited NHS 24 and the Scottish Ambulance Service; they have call centre-type software and will have different staffing for shifts. Of course, for a major event such as a football match or something more prolonged like the Edinburgh festival, which lasts for more than a month, the manpower and ambulance availability are set out in 15-minute slots 24 hours a day. Similarly, emergency departments are staffed with local events in mind.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

I have a brief final question. As we have said, people present at A and E because when they phoned their GP, they were told, “You’ll have to wait three weeks before you can get an appointment.” What do we tell people who cannot wait those three weeks when they arrive at A and E?

Paul Gray Scottish Government
link

I will turn to the CMO in a second, but one of the things about the NHS in Scotland is that, if someone presents at a place with something that can reasonably be treated there, we will do our best to treat them. There is a redirection policy, but NHS Tayside—which, as we have said, has been doing this for 15 years now—has the infrastructure to allow it to redirect people to something that is available. If someone is in need of help or clinical intervention, we do not at any point refuse them just on the grounds that they ought to have gone somewhere else.

Catherine Calderwood Scottish Government
link

All I will add is that the growth in minor injury units is an example of that.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

I thank the panel for their evidence. Anything that needs to be followed up can be arranged via the clerk.

I suspend the meeting for five minutes.

10:56 Meeting suspended.

11:01 On resuming—

  1. 09:30 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. 09:30 Major Capital Projects (Update) Committee business · 53
  3. 10:00 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 75
  4. 10:45 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 56

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.