You are not alone. There are a number of people who do not specialise in the area who are just trying to understand it, and I appreciate that it is very difficult to explain it to constituents as well.
You referred to a paper that I think is private for committee members, so I am unable to address any particular things that you refer to in it, although I will be happy to look at it afterwards and come back to you if that is useful.
The point about the Office for National Statistics is that it is actually a statistical body. Ultimately, it is there to set out in statistical terms the size of the private economy and the public economy in the United Kingdom. It starts at a very high level.
The reason why the ONS is part of our considerations in relation to the projects is that Eurostat has set out new standards for assessing projects, which the ONS must work to. Those new standards came in very late in the day—in September 2014—and that is why the issue is particularly nudging up against the Aberdeen western peripheral route contract, which was signed in December, with the long lead times that it has.
09:45
The Treasury has chosen to use the European standard as an indicator of a measure when it asks Whitehall departments and devolved Administrations to budget for these things. The approach changed in 2009, at which time the accounting and the budgeting were absolutely aligned. When the United Kingdom Government changed to international financial reporting standards, it realised that that would sound the death knell for any PFI, public-private finance initiative or non-profit-distributing project, because they involved conflict between the two aspects.
Until 2009, everything was really straightforward. However, when the accounting arrangements changed, the budgeting was out of kilter and all PFIs and PPPs would not have continued. The Treasury, therefore, found another reference point for determining how we score activities against the Treasury budget and decided to use the statistical indicator.
The reason why we are having to consider the issue now is that that statistical indicator has changed materially and at short notice. The interpretation document that was designed to help us understand the new standard came out in August 2013. It gave us no particular cause for concern. The Treasury held a session for experts in the field, which was attended by Peter Reekie and others, in March 2014, and there was no cause for concern.
It was only when Eurostat revised its own interpretation in August 2014 and published the standard in September 2014 that it was understood that there were some material changes that started to call into question the private classification of not only the things that were well under way—the lead time for building any road is long—but also things that the UK Government was considering. The private finance initiative private finance 2 was something that was under scrutiny early on.
Irrespective of the type of model that is being used to get, in effect, additionality over and above the usual capital programme, the latest changes have caused not only we in Scotland but also the UK arm, which is called infrastructure UK—I am trying to remember the full names rather than just use the initials—to pause and think about things again. The same thing is happening across Europe.