Parliament Workbench
Data: Votes to 12 Nov 2026

Vote · 6 Dec 2017

Justice

Amendment Motion S5M-09378.2 Lodged by John Finnie Green
Defeated by 108
6 For 114 Against 0 Abstained 9 Did not vote

What this amendment would do

This vote was on a Green amendment (S5M-09378.2) to the Liberal Democrats’ motion (S5M-09378). It was defeated, so it did not change the motion. The final vote on the motion was defeated 35–85.

If agreed, the motion would read:

That the Parliament
80 words removed by S5M-09378.2does not have confidence in the structure of both Police Scotland and the Scottish Police Authority to deliver resilient and accountable policing at a strategic level; believes that the Scottish Government should take responsibility for this; considers that the Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Act 2012 has proven to be defective and requiring repair, and calls on the Scottish Government to establish an independent commission with a view to this presenting proposals for change to the Parliament by summer 2018.
S5M-09378.2 Green recognises that Police Scotland can address strategic issues such as organised crime, human trafficking and terrorism but that, while some progress has been made in facilitating more local policing methods, the more routine deployment of armed officers has shown a frailty in local consultation and accountability; calls on Police Scotland to adopt greater openness and transparency in all its work; calls on the Scottish Police Authority to start meeting its legislative requirements to scrutinise Police Scotland and to liaise with local committees, and calls for the early and comprehensive devolution of resources, including finance, and autonomy to deliver genuine local policing reflecting community needs, which can be robustly scrutinised by democratically elected committees.

Worked out by this site by applying the amendment to the motion as lodged. It is not an official text.

The amendment as lodged

leave out from "does not" to end and insert "recognises that Police Scotland can address strategic issues such as organised crime, human trafficking and terrorism but that, while some progress has been made in facilitating more local policing methods, the more routine deployment of armed officers has shown a frailty in local consultation and accountability; calls on Police Scotland to adopt greater openness and transparency in all its work; calls on the Scottish Police Authority to start meeting its legislative requirements to scrutinise Police Scotland and to liaise with local committees, and calls for the early and comprehensive devolution of resources, including finance, and autonomy to deliver genuine local policing reflecting community needs, which can be robustly scrutinised by democratically elected committees."

All amendments to S5M-09378

  1. S5M-09378.4 SNP Michael Matheson Defeated vote, 59–61
  2. S5M-09378.1 Conservative Liam Kerr Defeated vote, 55–65
  3. S5M-09378.3 Labour Claire Baker Defeated vote, 20–100
  4. S5M-09378.2 Green John Finnie Defeated vote, 6–114

How the parties split

Every party voted as a bloc
PartySplitForAgainstAbst.AbsentMajority
SNP 0 59 0 3 ✗ Against united
Con 0 30 0 1 ✗ Against united
Lab 0 19 0 3 ✗ Against united
Green 6 0 0 0 ✓ For united
LD 0 5 0 0 ✗ Against united
Ind 0 1 0 1 n/a
NPA 0 0 0 1 n/a

Party is the MSP's party on the day of the vote. Majority is how most of the party's voting MSPs voted.

Every MSP

129 MSPs

For (6)

Against (114)

Ind 1

Did not vote (9)