To ask the First Minister what assessment the Scottish Executive has made of the European convention on human rights in relation to the cross-examination of rape victims by the alleged perpetrator. (S1F-422)
Official Report · Chamber
Rape Victims (Cross-examination)
First Minister's Question Time SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Jim Wallace LD 3
- Malcolm Chisholm Lab 2
- Dorothy-Grace Elder SNP 1
The record
6 contributionsAs Angus MacKay outlined on 6 June in his answer to parliamentary question S1W-07543, Scottish ministers have instructed the development of proposals to prevent an accused person charged with a sex offence from cross-examining the victim personally and to strengthen provisions restricting cross-examination on sexual history. Ministers are committed to achieving that policy and work has already begun to assess ways in which we can do that.
Of course, we need to protect the rights of the accused—the European convention on human rights reinforces that—but, as I am sure Mr Chisholm and other members will agree, it is crucial that we protect the rights of victims.
Of course, we need to protect the rights of the accused—the European convention on human rights reinforces that—but, as I am sure Mr Chisholm and other members will agree, it is crucial that we protect the rights of victims.
I welcome the commitment to act but deplore the way in which the European convention on human rights has been used as a smokescreen by people who support the continuation of this totally unacceptable practice.
Is it not the case that the European Court of Human Rights has already ruled that a state can require a defendant to act through a lawyer? Could not failure to end this practice lead to a challenge under article 3 of the ECHR, on the rights of victims? That is exactly what happened to the United Kingdom Government before the law was changed at Westminster.
Is it not the case that the European Court of Human Rights has already ruled that a state can require a defendant to act through a lawyer? Could not failure to end this practice lead to a challenge under article 3 of the ECHR, on the rights of victims? That is exactly what happened to the United Kingdom Government before the law was changed at Westminster.
Victims do indeed have rights; they should not be subjected to degrading treatment. The right of an accused person is that witnesses should be cross-examined, not that they should, necessarily, be cross-examined by the accused person himself. I believe that we will be able to find a way forward that will satisfy European convention considerations. Indeed, we would be obliged to do that. I hope members agree that it is important that we get it right. No interests of justice would be served by passing legislation that failed the test, with the result that someone who otherwise would have been found guilty walked free.
Will the minister give us a timetable for ending the torture and torment of women and children in the witness box while being cross-examined by men accused of raping and sexually abusing them? Will he assure us that he feels equal shame that Scots law allows that torture of human beings to this day?
I will not give a specific date but I repeat that we have already instructed the development of proposals. A solution is actively being pursued. We all want to ensure that this is done at the earliest possible opportunity.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 15 Jun 2000 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 15 June 2000 Debate · 1
- Scottish Executive Announcements Debate · 65
- Crime and Punishment Debate · 82
- Water Industry Debate · 33
- Business Motion Business motions · 44
- SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE Questions · 1
- Holocaust Memorial Programmes Questions · 4
- Ambulance Service Questions · 6
- Voluntary Organisations (Consultation) Questions · 4
- Youth Crime Questions · 8
- Scottish National Dictionary Association Questions · 4
- Rural Schools Questions · 8
- National Health Service (Resources) Questions · 10
- Rural Transport Questions · 8
- Education Research Questions · 8
- Higher and Further Education Questions · 10
- Education (Parental Participation) Questions · 4
- Lifelong Learning Questions · 8
- British-Irish Council Questions · 12
- ScotRail Questions · 4
- Scottish Executive Priorities First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Rape Victims (Cross-examination) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Child Poverty First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Cashmere Industry First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Carers Week 2000 First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Early Education and Child Care Debate · 42
- Decision Time Decision time · 44
- Greenock Morton Football Club Debate · 26
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.