I thank members of the public for their patience during the slight delay. Petitions PE1261 and PE1281 deal with issues that arise from houses in multiple occupation. We will deal with the petitions separately when we discuss recommendations, but will consider them together today, given their similarity.PE1261, by David Middleton, on behalf of Sustainable Communities (Scotland), calls on Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to promote better regulation of houses in multiple occupation by the following: by giving licensing authorities clear powers to refuse to grant HMO licences where they would affect the amenity of the local area, or would breach planning policy or the requirement for planning permission; by ensuring that planning permission is a prior condition for all HMO licensing; and by introducing more rigorous enforcement of penalties for illegally operated HMOs, including powers of closure and substantial financial penalties to contribute to the cost of enforcement.PE1281, by Graham White, on behalf of North Kelvin Residents Group, calls on the Scottish Parliament to do the following: to urge the Scottish Government to make planning permission a prerequisite of the granting of an HMO licence; to amend or enact laws to control the density of HMOs; to give councils full powers of closure in instances of non-compliant multiple occupancy operation and to increase the fines for that; and to deem local residents' multiple objections to an application to be sufficient reason to refuse or refuse to renew an HMO licence.A number of members whose areas are most directly affected by HMOs have expressed interest in speaking to the committee. I welcome Mike Pringle, Sandra White and Margo MacDonald. Pauline McNeill cannot make it. We also have—I am having a senior moment—Ted Brocklebank. Laughter. I thank the clerk for helping me out there. Pauline McNeill has had to move on, but she left a written statement, which we can consider later. Sandra White has requested to speak first because she had to be somewhere else 10 minutes ago. I invite her to comment on the petitions.
Official Report · Committee
New Petitions
Houses in Multiple Occupation (Regulation) (PE1261 and PE1281)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Frank McAveety Lab 11
- Margo MacDonald Ind 7
- Ted Brocklebank Con 2
- Mike Pringle LD 2
- Bill Butler Lab 2
- Sandra White SNP 1
- John Wilson SNP 1
The record
26 contributionsThank you, convener. It is good of you to hear me first. I am happy to speak in support of both petitions.First, I put it on the record that Graham White is not related to me, in case anyone thinks that he is, but I have worked closely with the tenants associations and residents group in the area. The situation in Kelvin and the west end of Glasgow is becoming quite horrendous. I do not want to promote nimbyism—I am not against students, migrant workers or others who live in the areas, but they contain a large concentration of HMOs for which planning permission is often granted only retrospectively. Sometimes it is difficult to get planning permission for HMOs even though they have been granted a licence. That is one of the biggest issues. Also, the three sets of legislation on HMOs do not complement one another. I hope that the committee will pick that up and ask the Government to look closely at the legislation.I mentioned the west end, but the situation has also arisen on the south side of Glasgow. In some cases, residents say that their lives are in great danger because of the types of flats that they have been made to live in. That should not be tolerated any longer. Residents who live in HMOs, particularly students in the west end, move in thinking that they will have a decent place to live, but sometimes, as I said, their lives are being put in danger because landlords—not all landlords, but a minority—do not look after their properties. They have an HMO licence and they can seek planning permission retrospectively. It is illogical that a licence can be awarded for an HMO even if the premises do not meet the planning criteria. That must be examined.Another concern is that, when officers are sent out and landlords are caught, the fines are paltry and it takes a long time to get them paid. I know that the Scottish Government will address that in the forthcoming housing bill, but I hope that the committee will raise the matter with the Government as well. We need to introduce much greater fines.In conclusion, I fully support both petitions because action is long overdue. In certain areas, the problem is private housing. That was not considered in 2006, but the minister has said that he will do so through the forthcoming bill. I ask the committee to consider and flag up the petitioners' concerns and requests and to send the petitions to the minister. People should not be allowed to flout the law in the way that is happening at present. We should also consider the fact that amenities cannot cope with overprovision of HMOs in such areas, which affects everyone in the local community, including those who live in HMOs.Thank you for letting me have my say.
I invite the other visiting members to comment.
I concur with Sandra White. It seems to me that the current laws have proved to be ineffective in controlling or remedying the problem. The petitions offer a way forward that respects the interests of all who are involved.As a member for Mid Scotland and Fife and a resident of St Andrews, I will touch briefly on the specific problems in that community, where students now comprise almost half the population. The town centre is almost entirely given over to student flats, many of which are HMOs. It is difficult to overstate the effect that the concentration of young and exuberant residents has on that part of the town.We are not being anti-student, and we are certainly not being nimbyistic. Many of the houses in that historic quarter of the town are listed, but as a large proportion are owned by absentee landlords, there is growing concern about the lack of maintenance of buildings and gardens in what is, after all, not only Fife's top tourist centre but one of the most important tourist towns in the whole of Scotland.I wrote to the minister in June this year, raising some of the problems, and he was kind enough to include a section on HMOs in the consultation paper on the forthcoming housing bill. We welcome what we see as a possible suitable vehicle for changes that are essential if the serious social effects from the concentration of HMOs are to continue. However, we do not believe that the proposals that we have seen go far enough. We are not convinced that the draft legislation is strong enough to counter the illegal operation of HMOs.It is right to say that the community's perspective is that the current approach favours the landlord who is prepared to operate illegally. Such landlords can generally do so with little or no fear of detection.
I think that Mike Pringle is going to speak mainly about the HMO petitions PE1261 and PE1281. The one that I have perhaps more information on is petition PE1249. Do you want me to speak to that now, convener?
We will not deal with that one right now.
Apart from just backing up what Ted Brocklebank said just there, I say that the remedies for the malfunction of well-intentioned legislation have proved to be quite ineffective. I think that the matter does have to be revisited.
We are considering PE1261 and PE1281. I know that Margo will speak on the other petition later.
I am here to speak to the two petitions on behalf of David Middleton, who is the petitioner for PE1261. As I see it, the problem is not that HMOs exist; it is that they become concentrated in certain areas. One such area is the Marchmont and Sciennes community council area, which has a very high concentration of HMOs. I think that Ted Brocklebank alluded to such a situation in Aberdeen, but it also happens in Edinburgh. In Edinburgh, 54 per cent of HMOs are concentrated in two areas, although many other community councils support the petition.It is slightly paradoxical and it does not serve anyone's sense of rational government to have one arm of a local authority—planning—trying to control density, while the licensing arm refuses to implement the recommendations from planning because the legislation is not clear or is very contradictory. The only alternative, which is obviously very expensive, is for local authorities to go to court on a case-by-case basis in order to test the interpretation of aspects of the legislation. Moreover, it is also, as we all know, extremely time consuming to go to court, and it does not necessarily solve the problem, or perhaps does so very seldom.The lack of clarity and confusion have led to serious problems in various areas, as can be seen from the number of community councils that have been affected by the issue right across Scotland. Not only are communities suffering, but responsible landlords, who are the majority—we have heard about lots of irresponsible landlords, but they are the minority—get penalised and lumped in with the irresponsible ones. Should they therefore bother going through planning hoops when it is not compulsory and other landlords do not bother, and particularly when the planning departments often do not have the resources to enforce any breaches? Petition PE1261 is driven by plain common sense and a wish to retain balanced and sustainable communities. There is an element of desperation because community councils cannot make sense of the law and have failed, either by using local arguments or by offering a different interpretation of licensing laws, to find a way to get the protection that they need for their communities.It is, I suggest, universally accepted that successful communities are mixed, balanced and sustainable. The Scottish Government has an opportunity to resolve the issues here equitably and simply through minor alterations to legislation, particularly to housing legislation that is currently out to consultation. I support both PE1261 and PE1281, and I hope that somebody upstairs in the Scottish Government is listening and will act on the recommendations in the petitions.
I thank members for their comments. Pauline McNeill MSP was here, but had to leave because of a pressing commitment in Glasgow. Key points have been identified by members and she has emphasised some of them in a brief note, which I will pass to the clerk. Essentially, she asks for urgent implementation of part 5 of the Housing (Scotland) Act 2006, particularly in relation to targeting HMO operators that are operating illegal HMOs or individuals operating HMOs illegally, to try to get intervention in respect of fines for such activities. She has met some key individuals in Glasgow City Council departments to try to address the issue.Five elected members have come along today, which demonstrates that there is serious concern. I hope that that is reassuring to the petitioners. I invite questions or comments from committee members about how we wish to address the concerns that the petitioners have raised.
It would be good if you could stretch a point and hear one of the people who are here from Edinburgh because there may be a difference in emphasis. Pauline McNeill emphasised illegal operators, but there are people in Edinburgh who are operating legally but badly. They are neglectful rather than acting illegally.
I do not want to be difficult, but we have clearly defined rules about who is able to make a direct contribution to the meeting. I want to explore the issues that have been raised by the petitioners. I hope that they understand the process and that members who know the areas well can perhaps amplify points in the discussion.From what we have heard, committee members have a broad awareness of the issue. We want to see whether we can help with the petitions, so comments from committee members about how they want to progress matters may be useful.
There are obviously serious problems across the country, so it might be helpful to get an overview from the Scottish Government, given its recent consultation and the fact that it issued HMO guidance. In our correspondence with the Government, we might wish to ask a number of questions. Will it reissue its guidance to make it clear to planning authorities that they must adopt policies to manage HMO concentration and protect communities? If not, why not? Will it make prior planning permission a condition for HMO licences? If not, why not? What measures are in place to ensure that HMO accommodation is properly maintained? Those are three issues to start with, but obviously there will be others.
Members who have particular issues in their areas may want to raise their concerns.
Bill Butler's last point is the one that I was trying to make. The people in Edinburgh would probably agree that the big issue is landlords who are neglectful and do not maintain their properties. In a common stair, that impacts on all the dwellings. I am not sure whether that is the point that Pauline McNeill was making.
A number of us have pockets in our areas—whether it is in a parliamentary constituency, a city, a town or wherever—in which issues are now emerging. My big concern is that, no matter the legislative framework that is in place, the ingenuity of some of the individuals involved in property development and property letting means that they are always ahead of whatever we put in place. Problems will continue unless we pull things together better and drive matters forward through a combination of enforcement, the legislation and perhaps some of the consultation that the minister has undertaken on the provisions of the Housing (Scotland) Act 2006. It is clear that in all our areas in the past four or five years there have been substantial shifts in the way in which properties are being deployed in our communities, whether as a result of pressure from students or, as in the area of Glasgow that I represent—other members have also raised the issue—as a result of the pressures that new communities emerging unexpectedly in a city can put on the housing stock.
The panel of MSPs who came along to participate in the debate have highlighted the differences that exist in respect of the operation of HMOs. Ted Brocklebank gave the example of St Andrews being taken over by students. In some respects, the fact that we have a large student population in St Andrews is to be welcomed, but the problem is to do with how landlords operate the accommodation and whether they flout the current HMO legislation.Sandra White and, I believe, Pauline McNeill have raised the issue of landlords flouting the current regulations and not registering themselves as suppliers of HMOs. The convener was also right to make that point; I am sure that he is aware of the number of landlords in his constituency who rent out properties without declaring them as HMOs. To bypass the requirement to register properties that have three or more tenants, they get only two tenants to sign the lease. We must bring together the examples that Ted Brocklebank and Sandra White highlighted in order to address the issue of how landlords are operating.Reference has been made to the 2006 act. It might be worth our asking the minister when he intends to bring into effect part 5 of the act and to implement the regulations relating to it. We could ask what work will be done with other agencies and which agencies will be involved in monitoring. We must ensure not only that there is proper provision of HMOs and that those who rent the flats are not abused, but that we deal with landlords who flout the regulations through their failure to register flats that should be registered under the HMO legislation. The point has been made that such landlords are putting tenants at risk. The HMO legislation was designed, in part, to stop some of the horrific incidents that had occurred in large cities throughout Scotland. Tenants were in danger of death—and some actually died—because landlords were flouting the regulations for the operation of flats.
John Wilson has made some important points. When we write to the Scottish Government, we should ask it to include both petitions in the consultation on the proposed housing bill. Furthermore, what recourse is available to tenants who have complaints about HMOs? How effective or ineffective are those mechanisms?
I will answer Bill Butler's question immediately. I am not aware of one HMO application in Edinburgh that has been rejected by the council's regulatory committee, despite the fact that on many occasions large numbers of residents come to the committee with serious concerns, sometimes about HMOs that are properly registered.John Wilson makes a good point. The City of Edinburgh Council tried on numerous occasions to take to court someone who was operating an illegal HMO, but the court system repeatedly rejected the case because it was not important. Finally, after some persuasion—I will not say from whom—the courts accepted the case and the landlord was fined about £3,000 for running an illegal HMO. The following week, the council received 800 or 900 applications for HMOs, because everyone suddenly thought that the issue was being taken seriously. That was the result of one court case.The nub of the problem is the relationship between the licensing authority and the planning authority, neither of which knows how to talk to the other. How the law applies to HMOs and, therefore, to planning is a real issue. The Scottish Executive must examine the relationship between the two. If we can sort out that problem, we may sort out many of the problems in HMOs.If a week goes by in my constituency without someone complaining about an HMO that is causing a problem for residents, I wonder why. That is how often complaints come in—sometimes more often. The problem of illegal HMOs is massive in some areas, and people's lives can be seriously affected. Indeed, people even complain time after time about residents in recognised HMOs. The licensing authorities receive the same complaints, but I cannot think of one HMO application from my constituency that has been turned down. That is also part of the problem.
I am aware of the time, so I will bring in Ted Brocklebank and Margo MacDonald and then try to pull everything together.
There is much in what Mike Pringle said. The problem is that different local authorities appear to apply the rules in different ways; there is uneven treatment across Scotland. Some streets in St Andrews have eight permanent residents and 35 HMO flats, which means that there could be as many as 140 bed spaces in one street. Those are the levels of density that we are talking about. Dundee City Council's system is entirely different to that which is operated by Fife Council, so we really must grasp the lack of clarity and encourage even dealing by licensing authorities throughout Scotland.
As Mike Pringle has pointed out, there is a contradiction in the approaches of those two council departments. The shortage of accommodation all over is exacerbating the situation, and it is difficult to pursue the law and all the strength that it can muster. For example, if you close down some HMOs on planning grounds, we will find ourselves with all sorts of social problems. No one is willing to take that action. The problem is that there is a housing shortage in Edinburgh and what could be good housing for families goes to students—and, indeed, young single people—simply because they have nowhere else to go.
Committee members have raised a number of points that we will want to pursue and explore with the relevant Government officials and departments, so we will keep the petition open. We will also summarise the contributions from the five MSPs from the areas of the country that are affected by the problem. We will respond back in due course and, of course, everyone will receive notice of that.I thank everyone for their time. I know that members who are not committee members are sticking around for other items. Our meeting is going to be quite long, so I cannot guarantee exactly what time we will get to particular petitions.
I am sticking around for the party flats.
Okay. You have often been described as the life and soul of the party, Margo. Some would say that you have also been kicked out of quite a few.
I do not know who you have been talking to, and I remind you that I have only ever been in one party.
In this meeting
Everything on 6 Oct 2009 →- Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Tuesday 6 October 2009 Petitions · 1
- Current Petitions Petitions · 46
- New Petitions Petitions · 31
- New Petitions Petitions · 26
- New Petitions Petitions · 26
- New Petitions Petitions · 10
- New Petitions Petitions · 7
- Current Petitions Petitions · 1
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 5
- Current Petitions Petitions · 1
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 2
- Current Petitions Petitions · 14
- Current Petitions Petitions · 20
- Current Petitions Petitions · 2
- Current Petitions Petitions · 13
- Current Petitions Petitions · 17
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 5
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- New Petitions (Notification) Petitions · 3
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.