Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

New Petitions

Judicial Office-holders (Age of Retirement) (PE1276)

Tuesday 6 October 2009 Public Petitions Committee Petitions 31 contributions · 9 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

31 contributions
Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

We have six new petitions in front of us. We will hear presentations by two petitioners. PE1276, from John Ferguson, calls on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to remove the requirement for judicial office-holders, including justices of the peace, to retire at the age of 70. I welcome Mr Ferguson, who is here today with Mr James Strang. I understand that Mr Strang will make a few opening remarks. I declare for the record that I know both Mr Ferguson and Mr Strang, who have key responsibilities in a local housing association in my parliamentary constituency.

James Strang
link

Good afternoon, ladies and gentlemen. On behalf of Mr Ferguson, those over 70 and those approaching 70, I thank you for giving me the chance to highlight the inequality that is enshrined in Scotland in the 21st century. That inequality is supported by the Scottish Parliament when it passes and enacts laws that set arbitrary age ceilings.In our submission, which you have read, we highlight the legislation that the Scottish Parliament passed in which it was decided that, when a person reaches 70, they are no longer capable of understanding, making value judgments and reaching conclusions. It seems that, as soon as we reach 70, which we will all do at some point—looking around the room, I should say that some will reach that age sooner than others—the life skills, experience and common sense that we have gathered over the years are judged to evaporate into thin air and that, when it comes to playing our role in society, we are no longer welcome. That is exactly what happens in this country in the 21st century. At 70, a person must stand down from the justice of the peace bench, as Mr Ferguson has had to do. Others before him have had to do that, and others after him will have to do so, too. They must also stand down from a health board and they can no longer take part in the various appeal panels for organisations such as the Department for Work and Pensions and employment tribunals.When you made the law, how did you come to the conclusion that, at 70, people are incapable of reasoning? What is it in the biochemistry of the human body that means that, at 70, people's brains automatically cease to function? On what empirical evidence are these age barriers set? The answer is that there is no biological, biochemical, genetic or statistical evidence that you can point to when setting those age barriers. It is a randomly selected age that suits a very outdated and totally irrelevant concept of what age means.You will be aware that the population is ageing. The life expectancy of a human in this country is rising year on year and, coupled with an overall reduction in the birth rate—this year might be an exception—we will have more older people longer. By 2031—some of us will be around then—there will have been a 40 per cent increase in those aged between 64 and 74, and a staggering 81 per cent increase in those over 75. Are we seriously suggesting that none of those people is capable of making a contribution to the governance of our country?It would seem that age is not an issue for this building. There is no upper age barrier for standing for election here. What would you do if, at 69 years, you were told that, the minute that you reached 70, you could not participate in this legislature? I am sure that you would seek to change the situation. When doing so, your arguments would include your life experience, the experience that you have gained in politics over the years and the commitment that you have to public service. Mr Ferguson and his peers are exactly the same as you. They have given huge amounts of personal time to public service.There is no age limit for membership of the House of Commons or the House of Lords, so why should there be one for other essential roles in the governance of our community?There is no age limit for being a member of a community-based housing association—of one of which I have the privilege of being the chief executive. Of the 243 regulated housing organisations in this country today, the vast majority are governed—I use that word deliberately—by people who are over 60, many of whom are well into their 70s. You will know that to be the case in your constituencies. Those organisations have a combined value of billions of pounds and, even in today's economic climate, are considered blue-chip organisations, yet they are governed and controlled by people of a certain age. The skill, experience, common sense and good judgment of those board members have been demonstrated time and again.Who would suggest that our head of state—Her Majesty the Queen, who sometimes occupies the building across the road—is, at 80-odd, no longer capable of giving advice to the Prime Minister every second or third Tuesday afternoon?The law provides another good example. Many of our judges sit well into their 70s, stepping down when physical impairment becomes an issue, or if the Lord Advocate assesses that their judgments have become problematic. That system could be used in the JP courts up and down the land. The new rules could include regular assessment of the JP. That would highlight poor-performing JPs of all ages—the fact that someone is younger does not mean that he or she will perform better than an older person.As the world moves on, the effects of age are reducing. From personal experience, I know what it is like to turn 50. Indeed, I see 50 as the new 40. At 60, I fully expect to feel the same as I do now. I am sure that everyone in this room, including those in the public gallery, will hope to feel like that too, when they reach that age. I sense that the committee—and perhaps the Parliament generally—knows that it is right to change the law to remove the age barrier. In the 21st century in Scotland, parliamentarians know that it is morally wrong to deny equal opportunity to all in our society, yet they let that happen when they passed the Criminal Proceedings etc (Reform) (Scotland) Act 2007. However, all is not lost. Parliamentarians in this legislature can do something about that.Ageism is very high on the public agenda. Earlier this afternoon, the committee discussed equality rights. The age limit is a similar equality issue. Ageism is very high on the public agenda, from the JP courts in Glasgow right the way through to "Strictly Come Dancing". We in Scotland claim that our Parliament is the best in the world. Let us prove that once and for all by tackling the issue of ageism by amending the 2007 act and any other legislation that similarly imposes an age barrier. Let us ensure that our communities gain from the skills, experience and common sense that people such as John Ferguson have acquired over many years of public service.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

With age comes the allowance to go well over the time limit. However, I thank James Strang for that presentation.

Anne McLaughlin SNP Glasgow
link

When I first read the petition, I was minded to support Mr Strang and Mr Ferguson on a point of principle—although the use of the Queen, MPs and members of the House of Lords as examples does not necessarily push me in that direction—but I want to make three points. First, I do not think that having an upper age limit suggests that people over that age are incapable, although I was interested to hear James Strang's argument on that. Secondly, I want to ask whether the petitioners would abolish all upper and lower age limits for everything. For example, should 16 and 17-year-olds be allowed to vote, given that they are required to pay taxes if they work? Thirdly, I note that the petition argues that removing such barriers"would save the country a fortune in recruitment and training in the next few years".I am concerned that that would mean fewer opportunities for younger people who are looking for jobs.However, we live in ageist society, and I agree with the point of principle that we are guilty of wasting years of experience. The arrogance of the young shines through in most of what we do, not just in this country but in the western world.

John Ferguson
link

On the issue of ageism, the age of 70 was chosen by the Government some years ago. I do not know why it was felt that people were finished at 70. When I spoke to the president of a tribunal down in London, I was told that in some organisations people can continue in post until 75 if the regional chairman puts up a case for them. If that can be done sometimes, why can it not be done all the time?For some reason—I do not know why—we have started to move forward because, as folk come to the end of their service, they are now assessed every year. Since the new Scottish Court Service was set up—as one of the biggest courts going, the Glasgow court, where I worked for 14 years, was previously on its own—things have moved on and people are assessed every year. Why can people not continue to be assessed at 71 and 72? If they were then told, "Sorry, you're past it," that would be fine. At the moment, people can work in court today but, if they turn 70 tomorrow, they are required to retire because they are considered too old. That just does not make sense. The tribunals do the same thing. People are required to stop at 70. I worked my last day on Friday 3 April—my birthday is on 5 April—and that was me retired. After 14 years, I was required to finish up just like that.On the issue of age limits for young people, I think that it would be fine if a law came in giving young people the right to vote. Let them vote. They can be sent to war and can get married, so why can they not vote?

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

We will take other questions from members and then we can consider some of those points.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

Just for the record, I should say that Mr Strang is known to me from a previous existence. He is always combative and, when pushing a good argument, persuasive—but sometimes he is prolix.As the member for Glasgow Anniesland, I am mindful that my constituency has the highest concentration of retired voters in western Europe, I believe. I am naturally sympathetic to the case that has been put forward.Should there be no cut-off point at all? If there should be some type of cut-off point, and if it is not age, what should the criterion be for excluding someone from the offices that we are discussing?

James Strang
link

It would be done by an assessment process. As Mr Ferguson pointed out, assessment processes are in place under the new rules to ensure that the performance of the justice who is sitting on the bench is up to current standard. If that person is not up to current standard, there is training. If that does not work, there will be questions about the future viability of that individual, regardless of age.In addition, there is a ceiling in the legislation. Think of someone who is 69 years of age, two days before their birthday. When they turn 70, they are the same thinking, logical, upright citizen that they were five minutes previously, yet as from that point they are no longer deemed to be capable. I am indeed suggesting that there need not be an upper limit, and that the assessment process could be used. On the question that has been mentioned about a lower limit, I strongly believe that if someone can become a tenant of mine, can fight for their country or can get married at 16, they should be entitled to vote at 16. However, that is a personal opinion.On the point about MPs and the Queen, I meant no disrespect to anybody, but I must point out that people are eligible to stand for Parliament at any age. In Glasgow, there was a candidate of 79 years of age—an erudite, sophisticated individual, who put up a good campaign. He was not elected, but he was in the fray. It is important that people with the ability and the skill should be given that chance.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

So you are arguing for a kind of MOT test. Of course, MSPs and MPs—not the Lords—go through an MOT test with about 60,000 electors every four years. Is that what you are arguing for? If so, that would seem reasonable.You just have to say yes. Laughter. I know that it is difficult for you, Mr Strang, but on you go.

James Strang
link

I honestly do not know why Mr Butler is adopting this sort of attitude with me. I am very hurt, I really am.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

We won't go there, Mr Strang.

James Strang
link

It is correct that you go through the election process every four years. You might wish to consider the practicalities of having elections to the judiciary and the justice of the peace bench and do some research on that. It might be useful to have elected justices. I understand that that is done in certain parts of America. It might be a way round the problem, and it is a valuable suggestion. However, to save all the expense, we have some very strong people who have been disfranchised but who can step up to the plate.Ms McLaughlin raised the question of younger people and the job. Justice of the peace is a non-salaried post, and the work is carried out purely on a voluntary basis.

Robin Harper Green Lothians
link

If the rules were different for Parliament, I would be declaring an interest. On Mr Strang's observations about not assuming that the brain begins to cease to function at the age of 69, I say that there are days.I wish to pursue a point that Bill Butler made. Some airlines, for instance, have a cut-off at the age of 60, when pilots are automatically retired. Others are happy for their pilots to carry on until 65. An annual medical check is required whatever the pilot's age and, if they do not pass, they lose their licence.A medical check is easy, in that a person either passes or fails it. Are you confident that you currently have a set of assessments that cannot easily be challenged? In other words, once the assessment is made, will people accept its conclusion that the individual is no longer fit to be a justice of the peace?

James Strang
link

Under the current legislation, a process is set down in the guidelines—it was introduced in 2007. I am not aware of the outcome of the process, because the new system just started towards the tail-end of last year. It will be interesting to see how that assessment process works.Remember that we are talking about mental faculties and reasoning. Justices of the peace are not similar to pilots, who need certain physical attributes. When lorry drivers reach 60, they have to go through an annual test. The situation for justices of the peace is not quite the same as that, but I take the point that you are making.I would hope that an evaluation of the current arrangements would bear fruit. However, there is still the arbitrary age limit of 70. Someone can be the fittest person at 70—they can run marathons and have a photographic memory, but they cannot sit on the bench in Scotland.

Robin Harper Green Lothians
link

I am not saying that I am not sympathetic to your cause.

John Ferguson
link

We are not just talking about the age limit of 70. If you try to join some organisations at 65, they will not take you, because you will not be there long enough before you are 70. I phoned up the chairman of Greater Glasgow and Clyde NHS Board, whom I know, and asked whether it was worth my while filling in the application form. His first question was what age I was. When I said 69, he said no. He said that the board might have taken me at 64 or 65, but not at 69. Discrimination starts long before you are 70. We have a list of other public organisations that have positions open but which are the same—they all have an age limit.

James Strang
link

We have a list of several organisations. One of the arguments is that they would have to go to the expense of training someone who would be able to sit on the bench, or the board, for only a very short time indeed. John Ferguson is right: ageism starts a lot earlier than 70. If we did not have that arbitrary age limit, perhaps we could attract even more talented individuals from the citizenry to participate in these organisations.

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

You are aware that people under the age of 18 are not allowed to go to war, so the British Government is not allowed to send 16 or 17-year-olds to take up arms to fight in wars.On the legislation that applies to retirement, are the petitioners aware of the recent decision by the High Court—the Heyday decision—that the UK Government and employers can still set a retirement age of 65? The High Court has supported the UK Government, despite the challenges that were led by a number of organisations, including Age Concern and Help the Aged.Decisions on whether someone can continue to sit on the bench are arbitrary. John Ferguson said that the regional tribunal chair can arbitrarily decide whether someone of a certain age can continue to sit on tribunals, regardless of whether that is fair or just. James Strang's face might fit at 70, but John Ferguson's face might not fit at 70. We could get into the situation of trying to impose something that might not be as fair as we expect it to be if we do not have a fixed age or period in which people can serve.I remind the petitioners that the European courts decided that we could not have elected justices. The elected members of local government who were justices of the peace had to step down from the bench two years ago, because the European courts decided that we could not have elected members serving on the bench, because that was seen to be in conflict with the justice system that should prevail, in which there should be no political interference with the decisions of the bench.

John Ferguson
link

But that was not for age reasons; it was because the justices of the peace were also councillors. The law was changed so that they could not sign warrants and other things. They can still sign passports and so on, but they cannot sign warrants. That was the difference.

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

I am aware of that; the point that I was making is that it was because of a desire to separate the judicial system from the political system that local elected members had to step down from doing bench duties in the court system.

James Strang
link

We are aware of that.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

You can tell from the questions that members are exploring some of the implications of the present policy and the challenge that would have to be overcome if that policy were changed.I will now take suggestions on how to progress our consideration of the petition.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

I congratulate Mr Ferguson and Mr Strang on putting forward a compelling case. I am extremely sympathetic, as I suspect other members are, to the point of view expressed in the petition and to the terms of the petition. I think that we should write to the Scottish Government to ask it to review its current practice with a view to changing it. If it is willing to review and change the current practice, which is arbitrary, we should ask it when it will do so and, if it is not willing to do so, we should ask it why not. That would be a reasonable start, but colleagues will have other suggestions to make.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

That is a useful suggestion to explore. We should also write to a range of legal organisations and representatives about the implications of any shift and how it could be facilitated, should there be such a desire. I know that the petition has been passed on to a number of organisations, but it might be useful to get clarity on the views of organisations that represent older people and of the older people's assembly. Mr Strang deployed challenging arguments based on the demographic trend and the changing age profile and so on.On behalf of the committee, I thank Mr Ferguson, who is already seven years beyond the life expectancy of people in Glasgow Shettleston, for the tremendous commitment to his community that he has shown in coming here. Many of us are fed up of having such statistics thrown back at us. Mr Ferguson is testament to the fact that someone from the east end of Glasgow can do something for their community and still be fully alive and kicking and wanting to make a contribution at the age of 70. We should emphasise that point, because it is missing from much of the narrative on older people and the ageing process in this country.I think that a few other members have final comments.

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

I suggest that we write to the Scottish Consumer Council to seek its views on the issue.

John Farquhar Munro LD Ross, Skye and Inverness West
link

I strongly support the petition because I reached the magic age of 70 and never thought about it until I got a letter from the department saying that I was no longer required as a JP. That was the first time that I realised that age might be catching up with me. It had the decency to send me a wee plaque and to say thank you very much. I very much support the petition.

John Ferguson
link

The department disnae gie you plaques now; they gie you nothing—you just go.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

John Farquhar Munro is a demonstration of the fact that the Liberal Democrats do not apply the same rules to elected parliamentarians.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

We want to make progress with the petition. We know that it raises some fairly challenging issues, but I give an assurance to Mr Ferguson and Mr Strang that we will try to explore those issues to your satisfaction and, we hope, change things for the better so that you and many others like you across the country can continue to make contributions to your communities. Thank you very much.

  1. Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Tuesday 6 October 2009 Petitions · 1
  2. Current Petitions Petitions · 46
  3. New Petitions Petitions · 31
  4. New Petitions Petitions · 26
  5. New Petitions Petitions · 26
  6. New Petitions Petitions · 10
  7. New Petitions Petitions · 7
  8. Current Petitions Petitions · 1
  9. Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  10. Current Petitions Petitions · 5
  11. Current Petitions Petitions · 1
  12. Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  13. Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  14. Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  15. Current Petitions Petitions · 2
  16. Current Petitions Petitions · 14
  17. Current Petitions Petitions · 20
  18. Current Petitions Petitions · 2
  19. Current Petitions Petitions · 13
  20. Current Petitions Petitions · 17
  21. Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  22. Current Petitions Petitions · 5
  23. Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  24. Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  25. New Petitions (Notification) Petitions · 3

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.