Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 17 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

New Petitions

Changing Places Toilets (PE1270)

Tuesday 8 September 2009 Public Petitions Committee Petitions 29 contributions · 12 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

29 contributions
Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

PE1270, by Linda Burke, on behalf of the Profound and Multiple Impairment Service and the Learning Disability Alliance Scotland, calls on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to request that local authorities use British standard 8300:2009 to ensure that at least one public toilet built to the changing places standard is provided in the centre of every town with a population greater than 15,000 and in every new larger and publicly accessible building and complex.I welcome Linda Burke to the meeting. She is joined by Joyce Burns from PAMIS and Ian Hood from the Learning Disability Alliance Scotland. Linda has three minutes to comment on the petition.

Linda Burke PAMIS
link

I thank the committee for giving me the opportunity to speak to it about the need for more changing places toilets in Scotland. I will begin with some background information about my circumstances.My husband and I look after our 30-year-old daughter, Jenny, at home. I work full time; my husband is retired, but is involved in all aspects of caring for Jenny, as I am. I have been a parent member of PAMIS, which focuses on people with multiple or complex disabilities, for around 15 years.The term "complex disabilities" is used for a range of conditions. People with complex disabilities can have severe neurological and sensory damage, often accompanied by physical disabilities. Jenny had a brain haemorrhage shortly after she was born; as a result, she has severe learning difficulties and very little speech, and she uses a wheelchair to get about. She will always need to rely on other people for her personal care and to help her to live a full and complete life. All that sounds a bit negative, but Jenny is an extremely engaging and sociable person. She has a great sense of humour, and she loves music, shopping and just being out and about.Jenny attended a special school until she was about 19; she now attends an adult resource centre five days a week. Facilities vary from centre to centre, but staff take personal care requirements for clients very seriously. However, because changing facilities are centre based, any activities that she does outwith the centre are time limited to a couple of hours.When Jenny was young, all of us used to be able to go out to the beach for the whole day, visit relatives or go on holidays. However, now that she is an adult, we can no longer lift her without the right equipment. The lack of suitable changing facilities in the community has had a huge impact on her life; in fact, it has had a huge impact on everything that we can do as a family.Most people I know think that standard disabled toilets—I prefer to call them accessible toilets—are suitable for anyone with a disability, but that is simply not the case. Accessible toilets are totally unsuitable for people such as Jenny. For example, Jenny cannot transfer herself independently from her wheelchair. Our choices are limited to staying at home, only going out for a few hours—and not going too far away from home—or only going out for the day to places where there is a changing places loo.PAMIS and a range of other organisations have been campaigning for changing places toilets for more than 15 years. The toilets are not complicated, high tech or difficult to design. The basic requirements are: plenty of clean, safe space with room for two carers, a height-adjustable bench, a tracking hoist, a centrally placed toilet and a non-slip floor. I do not think that that is a lot to ask for, and it would make the difference between people being stuck at home and their being able to get out and about and do the things that most people take for granted. Changing places toilets are not only for people with complex disabilities such as Jenny; they are for anyone who cannot self-transfer to a toilet. Standard accessible loos simply do not have enough space to allow a carer or carers to work safely. On 3 September the new British standard 8300:2009 was adopted for changing places toilets, and it was launched here in the Scottish Parliament with a number of MSPs attending. BS 8300:2009 sets out the design standards for changing places toilets in public buildings and venues, and it has been drawn up with the help of architects, planners and carers. Most important, the new British standard recognises the rights of severely disabled people to be able to use the loo like everyone else.Providing public toilets is a local authority responsibility, and every authority in Scotland currently provides toilets with standard disabled access. However, very few of them provide changing places toilets. Some local authorities have taken the issue on board. For example, Dumfries and Galloway has three changing places toilets, with three more planned.Provision is far from universal, however. Nationwide, only 10 local authorities have changing places toilets. According to a recent survey by the Learning Disability Alliance Scotland, one local authority said that such toilets were only for "extreme types". Given that, according to estimates in a University of Dundee study, 25,000 people with disabilities in Scotland would benefit from such facilities, that seems a very odd thing for a group of decision makers to say.I am happy to report that the Scottish Parliament has a fully accessible loo, but I would like members to note that the facility came about only as a result of lobbying by PAMIS.We lodged our petition because we want your help: help in encouraging all local authorities to live up to their responsibilities under equality legislation; help in making changing places toilets available throughout the whole of Scotland; help for thousands of people throughout Scotland who are stuck at home unable to access their community because of a lack of suitable facilities such as those that most people take for granted; and help for Jenny, who would like to be able to spend a whole day at the seaside instead of just having an ice cream at the local cafe and then having to go home again.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

Thank you very much.I should have introduced Jackie Baillie, who has had an interest in this subject over a number of years—in fact, since the start of her tenure in the Parliament, and probably before that. I invite her to add a few comments before we ask questions.

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

I would be delighted to do so, and I thank you for the opportunity, convener. Linda Burke has described far more eloquently than I can her daughter's circumstances and the reasons why the availability of such facilities is absolutely essential. This is a question of access for all. I am delighted that the Parliament has an award-winning—I believe—changing places toilet, but that is a rarity, and we need to ensure that people have access to such facilities throughout Scotland. Far be it from me to focus the committee's discussion, but if we agree that the new BS 8300:2009 provides us with the right way to proceed, we should start with Linda's plea to the Parliament to help her make its achievement a reality.Rather than telling local authorities what to do—that is not the nature of the relationship that we have with them—I wonder whether anything might be achieved through the single outcome agreements that would allow the Parliament and local authorities to measure progress. That would allow local authorities not just to keep control of the process but to have a level of external encouragement and inspection. It would also allow them to reflect on their local circumstances. I am delighted that Dumfries and Galloway is heading for six changing places toilets, but how many should a city such as Glasgow have? Given that the Government is fond of providing guidance, could we ask it to provide guidance to local authorities and to local access forums about what they can do locally? If the committee could see its way to providing such support, we could all make the achievement of BS 8300:2009 a practical reality, with a changing places toilet in every part of Scotland.

Jamie McGrigor Con Highlands and Islands
link

The petition calls for a changing places toilet to be provided"within the centre of each town with a population greater than 15,000".I represent the Highlands and Islands, which does not have many towns with a population of more than 15,000. There are some, but not many. Is that threshold adequate? Should it be lower in some areas? Otherwise, big regions might not have any cover at all.

Ian Hood Learning Disability Alliance Scotland
link

I think that that is right. We struggled a bit to choose a figure. We chose 15,000 because that figure is used in some of the census definitions of city areas or large urban areas. As you say, areas such as the Highlands and the Borders will have a difficulty with that. However, Dumfries and Galloway, which is a similar area, is working around that difficulty. As Jackie Baillie said, it has already created three changing places toilets in Dumfries and it is looking to provide other toilets in other parts of the region. The petition sets out an ambition, but local authorities need to decide what suits their area. That would be far better than having a simple prescription.

Anne McLaughlin SNP Glasgow
link

It is useful that you have come here today to draw this issue to our attention. So many people do not realise that accessible toilets—I do not like calling them disabled toilets, either—are not suitable for everybody who has a disability. I am aware of that, because I worked with Sense Scotland for a couple of years, but the majority of people are not and they probably think that we are doing all right in that respect. However, Linda Burke coming here today to talk about her daughter Jenny makes us stop and think. We understand that she cannot just go out for the day in the way that everybody else can. We have to do what we can to support what Linda is asking for. She is not asking for anything to be compulsory; she is asking the Parliament to urge the Government to request that local authorities look into using BS 8300:2009.Did you say that your daughter was 13 or 30, Linda?

Linda Burke PAMIS
link

Jenny is 30.

Anne McLaughlin SNP Glasgow
link

When you said, "after her 19th birthday", I thought that she must be 30, but I had already decided that she must be 13, because you could not possibly have a 30-year-old daughter.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

Stereotypically, is it not my job to flatter blondes?

Robin Harper Green Lothians
link

I am not saying that there should not be a lower limit of 15,000—perhaps it could be 10,000—but it could be helpful to mention areas of cities where there is high footfall. You could define an area through which 60,000 or 40,000 people a day pass as an area with high footfall. Such areas are areas where people with disabilities are likely to want to go, or to be taken. Do you agree that some mention of footfall could be useful?

Joyce Burns PAMIS
link

I am an occupational therapist who works with PAMIS. We have done some work on that point, which I think answers the previous point about how to capture the best place to put changing places toilets. That is why we propose that they should be located in main hubs such as large public buildings and venues that have a high footfall. People with disabilities want to go to such places in the same way as everybody else does. We are supposed to be opening up the community for everybody. It is helpful to look at the matter in those terms rather than thinking, as people sometimes do, that facilities are provided but nobody uses them.We sometimes have the problem that providers put in changing places toilets but say that nobody uses them. I would make two points in response. First, people have to know that they are there. Secondly, people want to go and use the facilities that exist around them, such as shopping centres, tourist attractions and travel centres. Those are all heavily used anyway, and if facilities are provided, they will be further used by the population of people whom we are discussing.I think that Linda Burke mentioned that 25,000 people would benefit, but the figure that was identified in the research is actually 250,000 people. It is not just people with profound multiple learning disabilities but people with a wide range of disabilities who benefit from the provision of changing places toilets. That puts the matter into perspective.

Marlyn Glen Lab North East Scotland
link

When the Equal Opportunities Committee took evidence from the Equality and Human Rights Commission this morning, we heard about the equality measurement framework that the commission has developed. It seems to me that the provision of changing places toilets could be an important indicator in measuring the performance of local authorities and other providers of public places. Have you thought about that and talked to local authorities? Could we help with that, perhaps by examining the equality impact assessments that are being considered in relation to local authority single outcome agreements?

Joyce Burns PAMIS
link

That approach is helpful and I think it is the route that we have to go down. I am looking at Ian Hood because I know that that area is covered in some of the paperwork that he has worked on. Some local authorities have looked at equality impact assessments but others have perhaps not understood their value yet. Guidance that helped EqIAs to become standard practice would be a helpful outcome.

Ian Hood Learning Disability Alliance Scotland
link

Equality impact assessments are still relatively new. A number of local authorities that have looked at them in relation to their public toilet provision have done so principally in relation to their existing accessible toilets; they did not know about or understand the possibilities of changing places toilets. That is why we were so encouraged by BS 8300:2009 and Jackie Baillie's idea of letting access panels and others know about the guidance note. They need that information so that, when there is local input, they can say, "How would this fit? How could we provide these facilities?" Local authorities regularly review toilet provision and they are aware of the need for better facilities, but they need to continue to review their provision. Once they all have the information, we are confident that Dumfries and Galloway, North Lanarkshire and South Lanarkshire will not be the only local authorities to set standards and that many others will follow.

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

Convener, I am conscious that we are putting the onus on local authorities, but I am also aware that many disabled people use out-of-town retail centres, which are not owned by local authorities but are developed by other agencies. At present, such centres are not obliged to implement the changing places standard. Do the witnesses have any comment on how we can influence the major retail outlets? Disabled people are consumers as well, and they have the right to attend, to shop and to participate in retail activities. As we heard earlier, if someone can only go out for an ice cream and then has to go back home, that restricts their ability to participate fully in normal activities, including retail activities.

Ian Hood Learning Disability Alliance Scotland
link

The first changing places toilet in Britain was provided in a shopping centre in Milton Keynes as part of a commercial decision, and the shopping centre at Braehead at the corner of Glasgow and Renfrewshire is building a changing places toilet because it makes good commercial sense to do so. The more we establish that the provision of such facilities is something by which we measure equalities, as Marlyn Glen said, the better.I will let Linda comment, but we hope that local authorities and shopping centres will provide changing places toilets as one way to show that they value all their customers—that what they do is not simply about money signs and that they value all the people as part of the community.

Linda Burke PAMIS
link

It is easy to see why retail places were the first to spot that they were on to a good thing by installing a changing places toilet; after all, retail parks are used not only by people with disabilities but by whole swathes of people who accompany them, so it makes good financial sense. Like Ian Hood, I do not necessarily want to shame local authorities into installing these toilets, but, as Ian says, if such a move sends the message that all citizens in an area are valued, the other local authorities that have not put in a changing places toilet might start to think that they look a bit bad.

Nigel Don SNP North East Scotland
link

Having listened to the earlier discussion about the importance of this issue, which I readily understand, I hope you will forgive me for raising a very mundane matter. Do you have any clue about how much extra a changing places toilet costs over and above the cost of a normal accessible toilet? There must be some extra cost for the lift and so on, but there does not seem to be a huge amount in it.

Joyce Burns PAMIS
link

The additional costs are generally associated with the hoist and the hydraulic height-adjustable changing bench. The overall cost of a changing places toilet is £8,000 to £12,000, but that obviously includes the cost of putting in the walls, drainage, plumbing and so on that is incurred in installing a standard accessible toilet. I am afraid that I do not have the difference in cost between the two, because it depends on the type of hoist, the changing bench and the other facilities that are installed.

Nigel Don SNP North East Scotland
link

But if the figure were, say, £5,000, that would not be a large figure as far as building work was concerned. I suppose that my point is that the issue is more the desire to do this rather than any concerns about the marginal cost.

Joyce Burns PAMIS
link

Yes. As an occupational therapist, I have been involved in the conversion of many buildings and I have found that if this particular British standard were built into the design from the start, the overall cost would be minimal. Of course, costs increase if the standard is incorporated later on. However, we are trying to encourage moves to make the standard part of building standards, because if it is considered early enough at the design stage, the costs are not onerous.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

From members' questions, I get the impression that they want to support the petition and explore issues such as parity and how to ensure that not only the public sector but commercial and publicly owned service providers have some kind of vision and direction. As a result, I think that we will want to take forward consideration of the petition. There is, as you know, a caveat: the Public Petitions Committee's process takes some time. However, I think that members very much support the suggestion that we explore the options.We have taken note of the various suggestions made by the petitioners and Jackie Baillie. It would be helpful if, in light of those remarks, members discussed the specific steps that we should take next.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

We should certainly ask the Government about the points that Jackie Baillie raised on single outcome agreements and Government guidance to local access forums. My information is that the Government was involved in developing British standard 8300:2009, so perhaps we could start by asking it about its expectations with regard to implementation, particularly in relation to the construction of buildings that it funds directly.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

Okay. As Ian Hood and Linda Burke suggested, the Scottish Retail Consortium might be the major body to explore this issue with. Perhaps we should communicate with the consortium and find out whether it can put the issue on its development agenda.We should also follow up Bill Butler's point about exploring public access issues with other public bodies. Historic Scotland sites are a perfect example of places that people want to visit but feel that they cannot because the facilities are limited—if there are any at all.

Robin Harper Green Lothians
link

It strikes me that, along with recommending that the Government consider requiring there to be such toilets in towns of at least 15,000 people or whatever figure it considers to be appropriate, we should ask it to consider scoping what help could be afforded by using footfall guidance. Local authorities could be encouraged to use such guidance under equalities legislation in giving planning guidance to large supermarkets when they put in a bid for buildings. The footfall guidance would introduce the possibility of the supermarkets being politely but firmly requested separately, under equalities legislation, to install toilets of this nature.

Marlyn Glen Lab North East Scotland
link

It would be worth writing to a selection of local authorities as well as the Scottish Government, under their equalities duty, about their plans to provide changing places toilets. It might also be worth writing to the Equality and Human Rights Commission for its comments on whether the new measurement framework takes that kind of thing into consideration.

Frank McAveety Lab The Convener · Glasgow Shettleston
link

Okay. I understand that local authorities have legal requirements to make their buildings accessible, but we need to broaden it out beyond local authorities. We should touch on the points that have been raised. We have a clear agenda to take matters forward. If the witnesses have any further information that they want to provide to us on the points that have been raised, that would be useful. If, once you have reflected on the debate, you feel that three or four other points might be worth exploring, we would be happy to take them on board as well.Thank you for your time. I hope that it was not too arduous a task for you this afternoon. I hope that we will make progress on an issue on which, as you can sense from the agreement among all members, we feel that we should do better in Scotland. I hope that we can make that progress over the next period.

  1. Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Tuesday 8 September 2009 Petitions · 1
  2. New Petitions Petitions · 1
  3. New Petitions Petitions · 29
  4. New Petitions Petitions · 8
  5. New Petitions Petitions · 10
  6. New Petitions Petitions · 26
  7. New Petitions Petitions · 13
  8. New Petitions Petitions · 11
  9. New Petitions Petitions · 14
  10. Current Petitions Petitions · 14
  11. Current Petitions Petitions · 5
  12. Current Petitions Petitions · 1
  13. Current Petitions Petitions · 6
  14. Current Petitions Petitions · 14
  15. Current Petitions Petitions · 2
  16. Current Petitions Petitions · 6
  17. Current Petitions Petitions · 9
  18. Current Petitions Petitions · 2
  19. Current Petitions Petitions · 2
  20. Current Petitions Petitions · 9
  21. Current Petitions Petitions · 4
  22. Current Petitions Petitions · 4
  23. Current Petitions Petitions · 5
  24. Current Petitions Petitions · 8
  25. Current Petitions Petitions · 2
  26. Current Petitions Petitions · 7
  27. Current Petitions Petitions · 9
  28. New Petitions (Notification) Petitions · 12

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.