PE1267, by Richie Venton, on behalf of the Glasgow save our schools campaign, calls on the Parliament to urge the Government to conduct a public investigation into the impact of the proposed closure of schools and nurseries by local authorities on education policies, class sizes, children's health and safety, social inclusion and jobs; and into the question whether the process of consulting parents and wider communities on education provision complies with local authorities' statutory duties and democratic principles. Committee members have expressed views in the past, either to the petitioners directly or in parliamentary motions, in which case their views are a matter of public record.
Official Report · Committee
New Petitions
School and Nursery Closures (Public Inquiry) (PE1267)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Frank McAveety Lab 5
- Paul Martin Lab 2
- Anne McLaughlin SNP 2
- Bob Doris SNP 1
- Bill Butler Lab 1
- Nigel Don SNP 1
- John Wilson SNP 1
The record
13 contributionsThe petitioner's request raises real difficulties about the outcome of the public consultation. It would not be unfair for us to request some form of inquiry into the impact that school closures have had. The remit of any investigation and the criteria under which it would be carried out would be a matter for further discussion, but the principle aim would be the identification of the challenges that the schools closure programme has presented to local communities. We should not forget the impact that the programme might have had on pupils. An investigation would be a worthwhile exercise.The committee would need to have further discussions on how any inquiry would progress and how we would ensure that lessons were learned from the outcome, whatever it was. As the convener knows, school closure programmes have taken place recently, as well as in the distant past. No doubt they will revisit us at some point in the future, no matter the political make-up of the various authorities. The petitioner has set out some important points about how lessons may be learned, and we should at least identify what processes might be followed to ensure that that happens.
link
I have been asked by the petitioners to make some comments. I am thankful for the opportunity to address the committee on PE1267. I will speak about some of the detail, but first I put on record the fact that the petitioners and many parents at the schools that have now been closed are disappointed that the committee was unable to find time to allow them to make representations in person. They are well aware how busy the Public Petitions Committee is. Today's consideration of and evidence taking on the petition regarding disabled toilets are of course important. However, throughout the schools closure consultation, parents at the affected schools have felt powerless and isolated from the process that has been conducted by Glasgow City Council—a process that resulted in almost 8,000 submissions to the consultation, with 96 per cent of people opposing the closure of the 11 schools and nine nurseries that eventually closed.Petitioners look at the Public Petitions Committee as a way of empowering communities. Indeed, I know that the committee excels at that, and I pay tribute to it for its work. The fact that the schools campaigners were able to petition Parliament in the first place is empowering in itself.I feel strongly that parents and others in the community demonstrated passionate, enthusiastic, tireless and knowledgeable campaigning. For many, it was a real learning experience and the type of hands-on active citizenship that we should all encourage. The petition empowers those parents and campaigners further, and they, rather than me or any other politician here today, are best placed to bring it to life through speaking face to face with Scotland's Public Petitions Committee.I ask that during your deliberations, you consider holding the petition over and attempt to find a space in your incredibly busy work programme for the petitioners to attend the committee. I know that they would very much like that and would feel empowered by it.The petitioners are not trying to overturn a decision that has been made democratically by the local authority. The schools are closed, and parents are attempting to make the best arrangements for their children at their new schools. They have no choice but to get on with their lives. However, they have, during the entire campaign, used every method at their disposal, and the Public Petitions Committee—and any subsequent action by Government and, potentially, by another committee—may be their last opportunity to feel that they have done all that they can to stand up for their communities.I ask that the committee empowers those parents by placing on hold any decision on action points arising from the discussion of the petition until the petitioners have the opportunity to attend a committee meeting. I think that I have outlined fairly well the strength of feeling and the reasons why ordinary parents, including the petitioners, feel that they should attend to discuss the petition. Of course, that is for the committee to decide.I turn to the detail of the petition. I note that it calls on the Scottish Government to conduct a public investigation. As a member of the Scottish Parliament, I am relaxed about that, and I am sure that I would support any action or investigation that the committee required the Scottish Government to carry out. However, I note that the Education, Lifelong Learning and Culture Committee, given its general remit and its consideration of the Schools (Consultation) (Scotland) Bill, may be better placed than the Government to conduct an investigation.I suspect that councils in general do not consult very well on changes to council services, whether those are schools or other services. They do not—irrespective of which local authority we are talking about—do well at listening to the electorate. There is perhaps a role for the Local Government and Communities Committee to examine how local authorities engage with communities before they rationalise any service.The petitioners have asked me to highlight a couple of matters. One is the issue of class sizes, which I acknowledge is a political hot potato. However, I merely state as a fact that the national Government has a particular class size policy to which local authorities respond, and that if a local authority conducts a schools rationalisation or closure programme, it will impact on local class sizes and on national policies. The committee should certainly think about that.The average class size at all the schools—not the nurseries—that were involved in the programme was roughly 21.88, if my basic arithmetic serves me well. Under the proposals, that would potentially rise to 24.9, which is a notional increase of three extra children per class. I make that as an observation rather than as a political comment, and it is flagged up in the petition.Furthermore—with your indulgence, convener—the council proposed that children from one closed school would go to another, but that is not always how families conduct themselves. They vote with their feet, depending on the most appropriate school for their children. It was proposed, for example, that children from St Gregory's in Glasgow would go to St Mary's. The hard figures are not in yet, but I understand that three or four families eventually sent their children to St Mary's—another school with a very small roll—while other families took their children to St Charles's instead. That is only one example. I know I am taking up a lot of the committee's time, convener, but I will tell you why the matter is important.Social inclusion is another aspect that I have been asked to look at. For some deprived communities, the only time that families ever venture near the area is when they take their children into the housing scheme to go to school. If the school is taken out, the community becomes further isolated and starts to become simply bricks and mortar without the community ethos to which schools are central.I could talk at much more length—although I will not do so, convener—but I hope that I have conveyed some of the petitioners' concerns. To return to my very first comment, I make these points as a politician, but the Public Petitions Committee exists not for politicians but for communities to have their say. I hope that any decision by the committee will allow one of the petitioners or a schools campaigner to give their opinion on the issue.
For the record, the committee decides who presents petitions to it. We receive petitions, we deliberate on who can make a presentation to the committee and we try to identify when that can be done within our resources. However, I think that the key message that we would have received from the petitioners has been articulated this afternoon already—you made quite a useful contribution.I want to open up the debate for questions and observations on PE1267. I am conscious that there is a third petition—PE1268—which relates to the condition of schools that have been designated to receive kids from schools that have closed.
For the record, I point out that I signed two motions—S3M-3917 and S3M-3976—in the name of Patricia Ferguson, who is the constituency MSP for Maryhill. Those motions said things that I still believe to be true: the Parliament"applauds the Save Our Schools campaign … considers the arguments against closure to be compelling and well made"and believes that"the decision taken … to close these schools is mistaken and fails to take adequate account of the social impact".I signed those motions then because I believed those points to be correct and true, and I restate them today because I still believe them to be correct and true.On that basis, I agree with Paul Martin that we should agree to the principle that the schools closure programme and its wider impact should be investigated. That should be done not by us but by the Scottish Government, so we should write to the Government to ask it to do that.Bob Doris pointed out the wider impacts that school and nursery closures arguably have on class sizes, the quality of education, children's health and safety, social inclusion and employment. If the Scottish Government is willing to undertake an investigation, we should ask it to include all the various concerns that the petitioners have raised. Convener, that is my suggestion.
To start off with, I congratulate the petitioners and parents in Glasgow who are still involved in the campaign. As Bob Doris said, the decision has already been made, so for most of them the petition is not about overturning decisions that have been made but about looking to future decisions, which will probably—hopefully—not affect the schools that their children now attend but might affect other children's schools. What the parents are doing is incredibly important, and I congratulate them on continuing, after everything that they have been through, to push the issue.The least that we can afford the petitioners is to continue with the petition. Whether that means writing to the Government or to the Education, Lifelong Learning and Culture Committee—or the Local Government and Communities Committee, as Bob Doris mentioned—I think that there must be an investigation. That need not be an investigation into one local authority; we need an investigation into the wider impact of wholesale school closures.After Bob Doris spoke, the convener said that the Public Petitions Committee will decide on whether the parents can come and give evidence. I certainly support the proposal that they should come. The campaigners feel completely demoralised by and disengaged from the political process, so the fact that they are continuing to campaign is testament to their tenacity if not to their belief in that process. The more that we do to hear what they have to say, the better.We should also consider whether the issue is just about school closures or whether there is a wider issue with consultations in general. However, I definitely support an examination at least of the impact of school closures. We should write to the Government or one of the other committees in the Parliament to seek a proper investigation of that.
Two or three suggestions have been made by Bill Butler and Anne McLaughlin. Are we happy to explore those options and raise the matter with the Government and other partners to assess the impact of the decisions that can be made—or the likely decisions that could be made in future, because there will always be a concern about school closures?
I have one more point—it also applies to PE1266, which we have just considered. We should look at the Schools (Consultation) (Scotland) Bill, which the Parliament debated at stage 1 last week, to see whether it contains anything that the petitioners should know about. We should relay any relevant information to them.
Okay.
A further issue with the consultation process is how those who have concerns are supported to shape their alternative to the local authority's proposal. That has certainly concerned me. Traditionally, the local authority has the resources behind it to promote the proposal that it submits, but there is an issue about the resources that the local community has at its disposal to enable it to create and submit an alternative proposal. During the recent consultation process, the communities had some genuinely good ideas about how they could progress with an alternative, but it was difficult for them—and indeed for elected members, who do have resources at their disposal—to develop alternative proposals within the timescale that is set down by the statutory process. Local authorities say that they followed the guidelines, and no doubt they will do that under the new process, but unless communities have access to information and are genuinely empowered they will be unable properly to put forward alternatives.
We have now reached the generality of the issue, which is where I would like to come in. It seems to me—this reflects my experience as a councillor and, I guess, other things—that we have procedures and processes for consultation, but we all know that, once we have been through them, the body concerned can, by and large, ignore everything that has come out and carry on doing exactly what it wanted to do. I do not think that most people in Scotland would regard that as a terribly cynical thing to say. As I hear myself saying that, I realise that it is actually cynical, but that is what a lot of people believe.I am not questioning the importance of school closures, but I wonder whether, once we have considered it, the committee might examine the ways in which the public are consulted by statutory bodies, be they local or national. We should ask whether the consultation process is meaningful and what the Parliament might do to try to ensure that, in future years, consultation actually means something and the feedback is reflected on and, when appropriate, taken on board.
Nigel Don certainly has a point. The Parliament is considering the Schools (Consultation) (Scotland) Bill, which I hope will address some of the concerns that are raised not only by the three petitions on the subject that we are considering today but by other petitions that the committee has considered on school closures. We have discussed several such petitions either with or without representation. I hope that, by questioning the Government about where it is going with the bill, we can try to draw out what is meant by meaningful consultation.As Nigel Don said, public bodies have a statutory obligation to consult but, at the end of the day, they do not have to take any notice of the views and responses that they received, and they can make the decisions that everybody suspected that they were going to make in the first place anyway. It is up to this Parliament to develop meaningful consultation processes that—no matter what the issue is—enable people's views to be heard, make them feel that they have been allowed to participate, and ensure that the decisions that are made are based on those factors rather than being predetermined, prejudged decisions by the local authority or other public body.It would be worth writing to the Scottish Government to ask it exactly what it thinks will take place in relation to the issues that have been raised not only by the petitions that are before us today but by previous petitions that we have received from groups throughout Scotland.
You have touched on the key issue, John. We constantly get petitions about school closures, and certain themes keep emerging. People will never be happy about a final decision to close a school, because they are protective of their children's schools, but the issue is that some breaches of the procedure seem to occur regularly. That happens with rural local authorities, urban local authorities and local authorities that are a mixture of both.We have heard a number of points, and we should pull them together and try to explore them further.
In this meeting
Everything on 8 Sep 2009 →- Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Tuesday 8 September 2009 Petitions · 1
- New Petitions Petitions · 1
- New Petitions Petitions · 29
- New Petitions Petitions · 8
- New Petitions Petitions · 10
- New Petitions Petitions · 26
- New Petitions Petitions · 13
- New Petitions Petitions · 11
- New Petitions Petitions · 14
- Current Petitions Petitions · 14
- Current Petitions Petitions · 5
- Current Petitions Petitions · 1
- Current Petitions Petitions · 6
- Current Petitions Petitions · 14
- Current Petitions Petitions · 2
- Current Petitions Petitions · 6
- Current Petitions Petitions · 9
- Current Petitions Petitions · 2
- Current Petitions Petitions · 2
- Current Petitions Petitions · 9
- Current Petitions Petitions · 4
- Current Petitions Petitions · 4
- Current Petitions Petitions · 5
- Current Petitions Petitions · 8
- Current Petitions Petitions · 2
- Current Petitions Petitions · 7
- Current Petitions Petitions · 9
- New Petitions (Notification) Petitions · 12
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.