Good afternoon, everyone. I bid a good new year to visitors to the Parliament. Welcome to the Public Petitions Committee's first meeting in 2009. We have received no apologies. I inform members of the public that all mobile phones and other electronic devices are to be switched off.Agenda item 1 is consideration of six new petitions. All the papers have been provided for committee members. The first petition is PE1223, from Ron Beaty, which calls on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to take all appropriate action—whether through amending guidance, contracts, agreements or legislation—to require local authorities to install proper safety signage and lights on school buses, to be used only when necessary when schoolchildren are on buses, and to make overtaking a stationary school bus a criminal offence.I welcome to the meeting Ron Beaty and Janet Beaty. A letter from Scotland's Campaign Against Irresponsible Drivers has also been provided to committee members. Ron Beaty will make the three-minute introduction. I ask him to make himself comfortable. The opportunity for questions and answers will follow.
Official Report · Committee
New Petitions
School Bus Safety (PE1223)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Ron Beaty 19
- Frank McAveety Lab 8
- Nigel Don SNP 5
- John Wilson SNP 5
- Nanette Milne Con 4
- John Farquhar Munro LD 4
- Robin Harper Green 3
- Janet Beaty 2
- Bill Butler Lab 2
- Marlyn Glen Lab 2
- Bashir Ahmad SNP 1
The record
55 contributionsGood afternoon, everybody. Thank you for allowing me to speak to the committee. I speak especially on behalf of the families who have recently lost children—the Oldham and Milne families—and other families who have been in the same position in the past 30 years.I ask members to imagine being told that their child will rely totally on others for the rest of their life or that their child was killed when coming home from school. School transport can and does have deadly consequences. In this room in 2006, I brought a similar school transport problem before the committee, but nothing was done. Alex Neil raised the matter with the Scottish Executive, but nothing was done. He said:"I beg the Scottish ministers to take the matter seriously and to produce an action plan early in the new year."—Official Report, 23 November 2006; c 29818.However, still nothing was done.I was three weeks home from speaking to the committee in 2006 when a young lad from Crossgates in Fife was killed while getting off a school bus. Still nothing changed. In September 2008, Robyn Oldham and Alexander Milne were, tragically, killed within weeks of each other. Nothing has changed. I now appear before the committee again. Surely members will not let me leave this time without things changing.Parents are right to ask how safe their children are on school transport. Children are our most precious commodity. If we cannot pass laws to protect our schoolchildren, something is seriously wrong. Regardless of where they live, every child needs the same level of safety.I will describe doable measures that can be introduced to save lives. I am sure that the Scottish Parliament could introduce at least some of them under devolved road safety laws. The safety sign on school buses has been abused for years. It is displayed on old-age pensioners' runs, on tours and on minibuses that are used as taxis at night. Legally, the sign must be displayed when children are on board a bus, yet no law says that it must be removed when children are not on board a bus. That is ridiculous. Advertisements on school buses are larger than the safety sign. Should the situation not be the other way round?Dustcarts are more visible than school buses. Is that common sense? Buses need extra hazard lights that are set higher on the vehicles, as with all ambulances. The Department for Transport allows that, yet no council insists on that in its contracts, just as no council insists that the safety sign should be removed when no children are on board.Each bus could have a flashing scrolling message on the back window that said, "Caution—schoolchildren crossing."Strobe lights could be fitted. Just as undercover police cars have blue strobe lights fitted in radiator grilles, the same lights could be fitted to the back window of a school bus. They can be bought easily—they are certainly not expensive—and they would draw attention to the fact that it is a school bus. School buses should be instantly recognisable as such.We cannot have service buses also used as school buses with different laws; we need the same laws for all buses that carry children. We need dedicated school transport with trusted drivers and better safety education at school on a regular basis. Those are doable short-term measures that the Parliament can take.Stewart Stevenson and Aberdeenshire Council recently met the families involved. The one measure that all the families agreed with—as do many other families to whom I have spoken since—was stopping other vehicles passing school buses as they load and unload. It works in North America, and if that were made a criminal offence here, the law would save lives. Passing vehicles kill children who are leaving a school bus. If we stop them passing, we have a cure. Nothing will prevent every accident, but that measure will prevent most.Such a law cannot be passed by the Scottish Parliament. You need to take a stand and test your own powers in relation to transport laws. If a new law is needed in Scotland, it should be created. If Westminster does not agree, that is its problem. You must be forceful about this and say that we need this law to benefit our children, even if they do not wish to benefit theirs down south. If our MSPs voted on the matter and secured a majority, that would surely be enough to take it forward regardless of what Westminster thinks. If our Parliament has the will, it will happen—you can fight for it.It appears that some motorists have so little time that they cannot stop to save a child's life. Is a few minutes really that important? We have 20mph limits around schools and 30mph signs that flash as motorists enter a town. There must be something that we can do. We must get rid of the cheapest form of school transport for children—which many buses are—and replace it with the safest form of school transport. The families whom I represent all expect that the law can be changed and that lives can be saved. In fact, that is what is expected by every parent and every child. Do not make the mistake of saying, "It can't happen to my family." We all thought the same. It will happen again to another family unless legislation is introduced.I ask the committee one simple question: can you put a price on a child's life? We cannot.
Do you want to add to that, Janet?
No, thank you. Everything has been said.
Okay. Thanks very much.This is the stage at which I invite questions from members of the committee. You should both feel free to respond to the points that are made by committee members.
Mr Beaty, one cannot help but be moved by what you have said. Is the evidence from other legislatures and other countries that do not allow overtaking wholly positive? What evidence do you have to support your contention that if, in co-operation with Westminster, we were able to introduce such a change to the law, it would be advantageous and would save lives?
In North America, the system is very successful, although there are still accidents—with the best will in the world, we cannot stop every accident—and it is enforced strongly. In America, it is a serious crime to pass a bus that is loading or unloading school children. California provides the best example. The buses there are also fitted with video cameras so that, if the bus stops and a car passes, an image is taken and the enforcement officer is sent out.California has a slightly different system from the one that is used in other parts of America in that, at a double road crossing, the driver can get out of the bus. There are eight lights that flash on their buses, the stop signs come down and the driver gets out, holds up a sign and sees the children across the road. Under health and safety regulations, drivers in this country are not even allowed to leave their seat.
Mr Beaty, you have mentioned North America. I understand that they have yellow school buses there. Am I right in thinking that the use of such buses has been trialled in Aberdeenshire? I confess ignorance, as I do not know the results of any trial that there has been or whether there are any plans to introduce such buses in Scotland.
I do not know what the outcome was. David Blunkett runs the Yellow School Bus Commission, and trials were conducted in various areas throughout the United Kingdom—down south as well as in Scotland. By all accounts, the buses were great and the kids were happy on board because they knew that they were safe. The buses are big and yellow and you cannot miss them. The problem is that, if such a bus were forced on the private coach contractors, they would have a bus that was used for school contracts but nothing else. They would have to find a financial way of getting round that. As far as I and many other people are concerned, that would probably be the way ahead, but it would need a lot of investigation.
Are any councils in Scotland forcing bus companies to remove the school bus safety signs by putting that in their contracts?
Not as far as I know. The Department for Transport tells them that they can insist on the removal of the signs. We have told Aberdeenshire Council that on numerous occasions, but there are photographs of buses at various times of the night being used as taxis with their schools signs still up. The contractors are not obliged to take them down. Councils have been told that it is not a problem for them to write that into their contracts but, for some reason, they will not to do so. Perhaps that is an area in which the Parliament could act to take away councils' flexibility as, when it comes to child safety, everybody should operate on the same basis and at the same level. There should not be different levels for different councils; they should all do the same.
There is now some movement on the introduction of seat belts in school buses. I have been pushing for that in Aberdeenshire, and I know that it has happened in other council areas. We could perhaps find out what the position is in different council areas regarding the various safety measures.
Good afternoon, folks. I was interested in your comments, Mr Beaty. I am sure that everybody around the table sympathises with the parents who find themselves in that situation. You talked about having illuminated signs on dedicated school buses. That could be done easily and without too much cost. How would that apply to buses that run as service buses as well as school transport? Would there have to be an exemption for them or would the same criteria apply? Would they still have to display illuminated signs?
To be honest, I cannot see how we can differentiate between the two. To my way of thinking—and probably that of the parents whom I represent—a bus is either a school bus or it is not. How an operator can run a service bus with children on board and call it a school bus is beyond me. That will not work on the ground of safety. The laws that apply to school buses will have to apply to public service buses—there is no way round it. Either we protect children or we do not.
You are suggesting that, if a percentage of the passengers on the bus are schoolchildren, the vehicle should have an illuminated sign, just as a dedicated school bus does.
Exactly. Yes.
I confess that I am looking for a bit of help in understanding how we can make rules for bus companies—I am not worried about who makes them or the legalities that are involved. If an ordinary scheduled bus happens to go in the direction that pupils want to go and goes past a school gate at a sensible time, the local authority will say, "We don't need to run a separate school bus," and it would be right, because doing so would be ridiculously expensive. However, you are, understandably, asking for buses to be marked as school buses from a point onwards so that drivers and others will understand that they are school buses. I am struggling to see—dare I say it—the practicability of that. I am struggling to find a simpler solution in such an environment than buses having large electronic boards fore and aft that can be switched on to say the right things. Do you have any other suggestions about how things can be done simply?
Is that not a simple solution? The driver could switch a sign on and off. Signs near schools flash up to say that the speed limit is 20mph so that people will—I hope—slow down to that speed when they pass the school. If a driver can switch on and off a sign on a school bus that will say "Caution—schoolchildren crossing", surely that will tell people who is on board. Regardless of who is on board the bus, children will still get on and off it. The only way to stop accidents is to stop traffic passing buses.You mentioned costs. Please do not get me wrong. The other families who are involved with the petition and I probably see things in a different light from how you see them. How can we cost things? How do we price a child's life?There is another issue. Do the drivers of buses that both children and fare-paying passengers use have disclosures? There may be drivers and others on buses whom we know nothing about.
I accept that there is an issue to do with bus drivers and children, which applies regardless of whether the children are going to or from school or are out at any other time of the day. However, if I understand you correctly, you are looking for all our buses to be designed in such a way that there will be things like big electronic scoreboards fore and aft—above head height, I presume—that can display the signs that you want to be displayed and which can be changed over time. I take your point. That would not be hugely expensive, but it would certainly involve a significant amount of money, as none of our buses has those things. Is that the way forward?
That is only one way forward. I am not being cheeky, but I simply cannot grasp why people do not understand that school transport should be dedicated school transport. I do not see why there should be a mix on buses of children and people who are paying fares. There must be safety for schoolchildren, which there will be by using yellow school buses. Perhaps I am not picking up correctly what you are saying.
I think that you are absolutely right and that there could be an extended discussion on the matter, but surely it is not difficult to conceive a run on which only one child lives. That is fair enough, but we will not know whether that child will be in school on a particular day and we can quickly imagine other folk saying, "Why is that being done? A service bus goes past their house—can't they use it?" I see where you are coming from and understand what you are saying, but there is another side to the coin.If we are looking for a thing like a big electronic scoreboard that a driver can switch on and off at the appropriate stage, it sounds as if we can put up the signage and warning lights that you are looking for in a standardised way and that every bus in every fleet in the country could have such signage.
When you speak about a large sign, you frighten me—it does not have to be a large sign. Signs with strobe LED lights are so effective now that they can be seen in broad daylight at a great distance. All that is needed is something that says "Caution—schoolchildren crossing". Strobe lights could be placed in the corner of each window—that kind of electronic gadget is exceptionally cheap. Even switching the lights off and on can be done from the driver's dashboard.
And in your view those would be small enough to fit in the front window and the back window of the bus?
Yes.
I do not want to labour the point, but I can understand where Nigel Don is coming from. We have great sympathy with the petition, but in an urban setting there are many service buses that travel across the city and carry ordinary passengers as well as secondary pupils—I am thinking here about secondary rather than primary pupils. Do you want to say anything more about the important issue of teaching road safety and school bus safety in schools? We could perhaps push that issue. Do you have any particular examples of local authorities in Scotland that operate good practice with regard to school buses?
I will take your last question first. Most authorities try to do the best work that they can within their financial constraints. Money is spent on this, that and the next thing, but money is never spent on school transport. It seems to be the most basic transport in most cases—the oldest buses that the authorities can run.We are talking about investing in children as well as investing in safety, and they are worth investing in. I am sorry—I forgot the first part of your question.
I was asking about teaching school bus safety, and road safety in general.
Talisman Energy is currently producing a DVD that will be sent to every school and viewed by every pupil. Carla Oldham, the mother of Robyn—the young girl who was run down—is taking part in the DVD. I hope that it will reach children in the schools.We also have plans for children to design high-visibility jackets for themselves. There are a lot of things going on, but it comes down to the basics in the end. If you take a link out of a chain, the chain falls and, in my view and the view of the other parents involved, the main link in the chain is that we do not have dedicated school transport. School buses do not look like school buses. They are no different apart from having a small square sign in the back, which has been abused for years and, as a result, means nothing to drivers now. We need to up the ante and show that a school bus is exactly that. As Nigel Don says, folk could come up with hundreds of other ideas, and things could be adapted to fit buses, but we certainly cannot leave things as they are. Kids are getting killed and injured on a regular basis, and it has to stop.
Do you have any indications on whether accidents and deaths are more prevalent on the morning run, when children are being picked up to be taken to school, or in the afternoon, when they are being dropped off after school?
Most accidents occur in the afternoon, when kids are dropped off from school. Erin was just about a foot and a half from the pavement on the safe side of the road when the car passed the bus and knocked her down. Robyn Oldham was in the middle of the road when she was knocked down; and Alexander Milne stepped out from behind the bus.
You have suggested that all schoolchildren should be covered by the safety measures that are recommended in the petition. Should the measures apply to all children, in both primary and secondary schools? In my village, I see children being picked up in the morning to go to primary school. In effect, you are asking for dedicated school buses, as they have in America, to pick up every child who requires bus transport.
The system would have to cover every child. Otherwise, we would have somebody deciding that this school would have one system but that school would have another. We would end up with fragmentation, and it would not work. This may be where we are going wrong. Over the years, the Scottish Parliament has allowed councils to make their own rules. It is perhaps time for the Government to set a framework so that every council is required to operate in exactly the same way.
The school bus that I see is usually a private-hire contract bus, not a regular scheduled bus. Contracts usually go to private-hire companies. As well as the bus to the primary school, two older-style double-deckers pass my door in the morning, on the way to pick up secondary school children in another area. In many local authorities, school run services are contracted out to private-hire companies.In the past, the Parliament has discussed the introduction of seat belts on coaches that transport children on school runs. The most common argument against seat belts is cost. One of the local authorities in my area is trying to set money aside from its budget each year to give to contractors so that they can install seat belts in their coaches. It is the local authorities that let the contracts for school bus runs. Have you any figures for the costs that are associated with each yellow bus—each dedicated school bus—when services are delivered by local authorities?
I have done no costings for that whatsoever. To be quite honest, that is beyond my wit.I congratulate Aberdeenshire Council on having insisted that all school buses be fitted with seat belts, which is good news. It will remove quite a lot of buses from the present fleet. The council is also stopping double-deckers being used as school buses, which is a great idea. Even at the best of times, double-deckers are potentially unsafe for children. In our area, they can carry a whole generation of children. Further south, all the children in particular streets are probably on board the same bus.Seat belts are one link in the chain. However, without the other links, the chain is incomplete. An holistic outlook is required.
Do members have any final questions?
The technology is there to put any notice that you like in the back of a bus. That notice would be stored on a chip and could be altered at the flick of a switch. Buses are large and they obstruct views, so for safety reasons there should certainly be a campaign for such technology to be adopted on all public transport. It would not be only for children; other kinds of messages could also be displayed on the backs of buses.
We have a gentleman who is working on various inventions. In the argument about seat belts in buses for children, some people say that children would not put them on, or they ask who would be responsible. The answer to that is easy.
An electronic chip, which Robin Harper mentioned, can be used to point out when a seat belt is not fitted. The bus would not move until the child put on their seat belt. The rest of the children on the coach would get on at the child, who would put on their seat belt and that would be the end of that. Eventually, people get used to such things. For example, people eventually got used to the 70mph limit on motorways and the 20mph speed limits.Before I leave the committee, I ask members please to think about our proposals and save children's lives.
I have a small question. There is a lot of sympathy for your petition. The idea of illuminating buses that are on the school run so that people can identify them immediately is fine. You said that you want a restriction on traffic so that it cannot pass such buses when they stop—the restriction would make passing them an offence. How would we amend the legislation to control traffic that passes school buses? Would we do that at local authority level through byelaws or would there have to be national legislation?
It would have to be a national law, because byelaws that are set by councils tend not to work. Somebody has to be there, and if a national law was passed, the forces of law—the police—would be involved, so anything to do with that law would then become important. There could be video cameras on buses. Many buses already have cameras that record what happens in front of them. Down south, a car driver who is in a bus lane can have their photograph taken by a bus. A ticket then is issued, and the car driver is fined for being in a bus lane. Many Stagecoach buses in Scotland have video cameras on board. It sounds like new technology but, in this day and age, there is no problem with electrical gadgets.
So you think we should have national legislation for the traffic offence.
National legislation is the only way.
Parents and teachers can play a major role. When a child leaves in the morning and the parents take them to the car or bus or whatever, they should remind the child to be careful and to take extra care when they cross the road or leave the bus. That kind of reminder will stay with the children. The same applies to teachers. When children leave the school to go home, the teacher in charge of the last class should give the same message and tell the children to take extra care when they cross the road. I would hope that if that message was given to children twice a day, in the morning and when they leave school, there would be a lot of improvement.I am from a backward world, where no transport to school was available for children. When we walked to school and back to the house, we saw lots of bricks and small bits of concrete here and there on the footpaths. The teachers told us to put aside whatever we saw on the road, so that the footpath could be cleared. That happened a lot.
You have to tell drivers who are passing school buses to look out, too. It is not always just down to the child. You have to draw attention to the bus and let drivers know that children are there. I agree that we have to tell children about road safety at every level, but you have to tell the drivers, too. There has to be a warning sign to draw attention to the school bus.
When Robyn Oldham was run down, she was in the middle of the road. Regardless of what the teacher said to her, she obviously thought that the road was safe to cross at that time. Erin was three quarters of the way across the road when she was run down. I understand what you are saying and I agree with a lot of it: road safety needs to be taught better in schools.After Erin's accident, we found out that a child's perception of danger changes radically with age. Even at 10 to 12-years-old, when children get off a bus and look to the right and see the parked bus, their assumption is that it is safe to cross, because the parked vehicle is preventing anything from passing. It does not matter what you tell them—that is what they perceive to be the case. They look one way, see that the road is clear and step out.Erin knew her road safety; Alexander Milne knew his road safety; and Robyn Oldham knew her road safety. There are problems teaching road safety in schools. However, the biggest problem is that when it comes to passing a school bus, drivers could not care a toot. They do not slow down. The "Highway Code" tells them that they should take care, but they do not have time to take care. They see the bus; they see a small square sign in the back window, which means virtually nothing; and they pull out and pass the bus. To them, it is not a school bus; it is not marked as a school bus or coloured as a school bus. All it has is a small, square sign, not much bigger than a piece of A4 paper, in the back window. Until something is done about that, I am afraid that children will continue to be killed and injured.
Every member of the committee has asked a question. That has not happened for a while, so perhaps we have addressed the concern that was expressed at the beginning about our understanding the importance of the petition.I think that the petitioners have heard members' willingness to try to explore the issues that they have raised. We would be frustrated—although it would be nothing compared with what the families have experienced in having to deal with difficult consequences—if they did not think that things were moving on at all.At this stage, I invite members' views on how to take forward the petition. I do not want the petitioners to leave today feeling that they have not achieved something in relation to finding solutions to the difficult problems that they have raised. I invite suggestions from members, after which we will try to explain what we want to do next with the petition.
In the first instance, we should ask the Scottish Government a number of questions, such as what specific actions it is taking to make routes to school safer for children and how it promotes best practice among local authorities in how they handle contracts, especially with regard to better signage and lights on school buses. We should also ask the Scottish Government whether it supports in principle the change in the law that the petitioners have been asking for, which would ban the overtaking of a stationary school bus. If the Scottish Government supports that change in principle, let us ask whether it will make representations to Westminster to see whether Holyrood and Westminster acting together can affect that change in the law.
I wonder whether we might take a step slightly beyond what we have normally done in the past year and a bit that I have been on the committee and agree that we think that the proposal is important and we want to see a change, as the petitioner does. Rather than just asking questions about what people are doing—although we need to do that, and I support what Bill Butler said and would also suggest that we write to some local authorities for their views—perhaps we could frame those letters in a way that says, particularly to the Government, "We would like to see a change on this and can you advise us how that change can be brought about?" We could ask the Government to address each of the issues that the petitioners have raised and clarify what would need to be done to make the change so that we are not unsure about how to proceed. If the Government says that the matter is reserved to Westminster—I believe that some of it is—it ought to be encouraged to write to Westminster. It might tell us that the best way forward for the committee is to write to Westminster, too. Alternatively, we could ask the Government to tell us what to do. I have certainly got the message from the petitioners that the matter needs to be addressed. This is not a paper exercise, and I believe that we need to make some progress.
Although the petition talks about drivers of motor vehicles overtaking stationary school buses or buses that are identified as transport for schoolchildren, there might be a wider issue about how we transport children. I refer particularly to the point that was made in response to my question about the incidence of accidents when children are dropped off and then cross the road. Although it might be fair to say that such buses should not be overtaken, there is also an issue about on-coming traffic being able readily to identify that a bus in the distance is dropping off schoolchildren.There has been some discussion of warning lights at both the rear and the front of buses. As with pedestrian crossings, drivers would then be made aware that they were approaching an area where pedestrians might be on the road or about to cross it. There is a wider issue about how we deal with the safety of passengers coming off school buses. As Nigel Don mentioned, we could ask the Scottish Government to ask the UK Government about what measures can be put in place to safeguard children getting off buses not only from traffic coming up behind the bus, but from other traffic using the road. As a road user, it scares me when I see buses, particularly school buses, dropping off children at blind bends, where other road users cannot see what is going on in front of them. We need to bring all such measures into play so that we create the safest possible environment for all children getting off buses and an environment in which other road users also feel secure. The trauma to any driver involved in a road accident, particularly when a child is involved, can be debilitating. I hope that the Government will take on board our concerns to safeguard the environment not just for children but for other road users.
I think that Mrs Beaty said that drivers need to be aware, which is so right. When I was a councillor, we dealt with an issue of speeding beside a school. We looked into the matter carefully and found that the people speeding were mums on their way to pick up kids from school—even they were not really aware of the possible consequences of their actions. I would like to find out whether councils are doing anything to educate children and parents about road safety.I would also like a bit more detail on the yellow bus trial. We should find out how successful that has been in the trial areas, what the costs are and whether it might be rolled out across Scotland.
I accept Nigel Don's point about the way in which we should approach the Department for Transport. I think that we should do so by providing a list of specifics.We should also note—this applies to cities rather than to small villages—that other physical steps can be taken. Near my local primary school, the railings are positioned in such a way on both sides of the road that the children can proceed conveniently only to the controlled crossing point. In other words, it is not easy—or even possible—for the children to run out into the road from either end of the bus.
The committee will now try to pull together those points into a course of action. Once we have agreed that action, the petitioners will be kept informed of any progress. When the committee reconsiders the petition to look at the responses, the petitioners will be notified. I hope that we will be able to make progress on the issues that have been raised.We have absolute agreement from committee members that we should raise the issue with the Scottish Government, the UK Government's Department for Transport and the education and support mechanisms that provide advice here in Scotland. We are also agreed that we should explore with a number of local authorities how to create good guidance frameworks for school transport contracts and the operational conduct of bus operators that provide school transport.I agree with Nanette Milne that we should explore the issue with the UK Yellow School Bus Commission. Initiatives have also been undertaken by local authorities and others with FirstBus, which I think is the major bus operator that has tried to deal with the issue. Such initiatives could produce further welcome developments if resources were made available for them.Nigel Don asked whether, as a matter of principle, the committee could agree with the petitioners by supporting this safety initiative and calling for the overtaking of school buses when they are in operation to be banned. The committee took a position on a matter of principle—curiously enough, on seat belts, which Nanette Milne mentioned—in a previous parliamentary session when dealing with a similar situation. Therefore, it would not be remiss of the committee to take an in-principle position by recommending a particular course of action. We could ask both Governments as well as other agencies to make progress on addressing the issue to the satisfaction of the petitioners. Would that be worth doing? Is there a consensus among committee members on that? If there is, we can move forward.
For the sake of clarity, it might be wise to add "while the bus is unloading or loading children", given that a school bus that has no children on board could stop.
I am not too worried about the semantics; I think that we should just agree the broad principle. A lot of lawyers will probably give us 10 reasons why we cannot put a certain sentence together, but we will see what happens. I mean no disrespect to anyone in the legal trade—I probably was disrespectful, but there we go—but, essentially, we first need to achieve a consensus on the matter. According to the information that I have in front of me, the issue has popped up a couple of times both in this Parliament and in the House of Commons, but it has not got any further. We need to create some momentum on the issue to meet the petitioners' aspirations. If we can agree most of that and pull those points together, we can move forward.I hope that John Wilson is about to give me a conciliatory contribution.
I am aware that local authorities can introduce 20mph speed limits on the roads outside school buildings. As has been mentioned, the issue is whether local authorities can introduce byelaws on the operation of school buses, as that might offer a way forward. Given that they can put up speed reduction signs outside school buildings, they might be able to introduce byelaws on the safe transportation of schoolchildren, for whom they have a duty of care. Although we need to go to the Department for Transport to get the regulations changed, we should investigate whether local authorities can make changes locally.
That is a positive suggestion, which we can raise directly with the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities and a few specific local authorities. Perhaps we could choose a city authority and a rural authority, because the experience of road use will be different in those areas.Members have made helpful suggestions, which we will pull together and raise with the agencies that have been mentioned. I have explained the process. We have managed to get to the heart of the issue that the petition raises. All that I can say is that I hope that we can make progress on it on behalf of the petitioners and those who have supported the petition, and that today's consideration has been useful.
In this meeting
Everything on 13 Jan 2009 →- Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Tuesday 13 January 2009 Petitions · 1
- New Petitions Petitions · 55
- New Petitions Petitions · 34
- New Petitions Petitions · 3
- New Petitions Petitions · 20
- New Petitions Petitions · 24
- New Petitions Petitions · 5
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 15
- Current Petitions Petitions · 11
- Current Petitions Petitions · 5
- Current Petitions Petitions · 7
- Current Petitions Petitions · 7
- Current Petitions Petitions · 6
- Current Petitions Petitions · 1
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 6
- Current Petitions Petitions · 14
- Current Petitions Petitions · 5
- Current Petitions Petitions · 4
- Current Petitions Petitions · 4
- Current Petitions Petitions · 10
- New Petitions (Notification) Petitions · 4
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.