Petition PE1179 is by Helen Moran, on behalf of the Brain Injury Awareness Campaign, and calls on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to introduce a separate and distinct health and community care client category of "acquired brain injury" to ensure that people with acquired brain injury and their carers, in particular, get the services and support that they need and that agencies can plan and deliver services more effectively. David Whitton and Paul Martin are here to speak on the petition because of constituents' concerns. I invite David Whitton to speak, followed by Paul Martin.
Official Report · Committee
Current Petitions
Acquired Brain Injury Services (PE1179)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Frank McAveety Lab 4
- Paul Martin Lab 2
- Bill Butler Lab 2
- David Whitton Lab 1
- John Wilson SNP 1
- Nigel Don SNP 1
The record
11 contributionsI will say a few words in support of the petition. Just over a year ago, a constituent, Dr Mark Ziervogel, came to see me to inquire about the treatment that is available to people with a brain injury once they have left hospital. Dr Ziervogel and his colleagues from the Brain Injury Awareness Campaign, who are responsible for the petition, are in the public gallery today.Dr Ziervogel's wife suffered a head injury in an accident, and there were concerns that her follow-up treatment was not as connected as it should have been. On his behalf, I wrote to the Cabinet Secretary for Health and Wellbeing and she replied, outlining the work of the national managed clinical network for acquired brain injury. As the committee will know, the network receives funding from NHS Scotland for its administration costs.The objectives of the network, as the cabinet secretary outlined to me, are to map out services for people with acquired brain injury who are aged 16 to 65; to promote the adoption of recognised standards of care; to identify the educational needs of the health groups that are involved in the care of people with brain injuries; and to identify the information requirements of patients, families and carers. The cabinet secretary emphasised that it is important to ensure that the standards of care are the same throughout Scotland, no matter where a patient happens to live. I am sure that we all agree with that.The committee has received the responses to the petition and the Brain Injury Awareness Campaign's response to the views that have been expressed. I do not need to go over that ground again. Suffice it to say that it is clear from the responses to the petition that there is still a case to be made for recognising people with acquired brain injury as a distinct health and community care category.I will highlight three of the responses to the petition. Headway Scotland said:"As long as the status quo prevails whereby there is no separate and distinct health and community care client category of acquired brain injury, people with this condition and their carers will continue to lose out in relation to the services and support they require."The Princess Royal Trust for Carers said:"The Trust would request that the Petitions Committee make recommendation to the Scottish Government to give particular consideration to this group to ensure improved mainstreaming of services to better meet the needs of this very complex caring situation."The Scottish head injury forum said:"If ABI were a separate category for the purposes of planning, funding, and delivering NHS and local authority services this would make it easier for everyone to recognise and co-ordinate the pathway of care, and would improve the clinical and social outcome for many people with ABI."The type of brain injuries that we are talking about affect, in the main, young men who have been involved in car accidents, but there are many others. People who have suffered such trauma often have violent mood swings and become aggressive, and they can become alcoholics and suffer deep depression, which affects not only them but their families. It has been shown that, where a proper aftercare policy is in place—in countries such as Australia and New Zealand and in parts of the USA—the patient outcome is much improved. It is important to understand that those who are affected by acquired brain injury may need a lifelong follow-up process.If the Scottish Government accepted that there is a client group of acquired brain injury patients, it would bring social services and health services together behind a coherent treatment and policy procedure. At present, as we see in the response from the Scottish Government primary and community care directorate, there are"no plans to introduce a separate and distinct … client group".Indeed, the Government seems to suggest that setting up such a group would require extra resources. The Brain Injury Awareness Campaign disputes that. As you can see from its reply, it suggests instead that what is required is a reorganisation of the resources to obtain a better outcome for patients with the condition through setting up an identifiable category of care for people with acquired brain injury. I hope that the committee agrees that the petition should be kept open and forwarded to the Scottish Government for further investigation, to allow such a group to be established as soon as possible.
It is important to put on record that Helen Moran, in partnership with others, has put forward a very constructive case for change. I am sure that other members share that view. That must be taken into account when the issues are considered by the Parliament.I am an avid reader of the Glasgow Evening Times, as, I am sure, are other members. A powerful case was made in the Evening Times, not just by Helen Moran but by another individual who had experienced difficulties with an acquired brain injury. The powerful case was made that, although the care that he received for his condition when he was treated in hospital was exemplary—he made that clear on a number of occasions—he had concerns about the care that he received after he left hospital. Helen Moran and others have, on many occasions, raised the issue of the support that is provided to those with the condition following their release from hospital. We must take that into consideration. The points have been well made by David Whitton and others.
Do members of the committee have any comments, observations or questions?
We are obviously trying to achieve a reorganisation of resources, as David Whitton put it, so that what the petitioner requests—a separate and distinct category of ABI patients—is ceded by the Scottish Government. We should, therefore, write to the Scottish Government on that basis. We must ask how people with ABI will be prevented from falling through gaps in provision, as there is no distinct and separate ABI category to lessen the danger of that. As Paul Martin suggested, we must ask the Government how it will ensure that carers of people with ABI get the services and support that they need. We must convey to the Scottish Government the petitioner's case that there will be a better chance of the various agencies delivering in a planned way the services that citizens with ABI require if there is a distinct and separate ABI category.
In their responses, the Scottish Government and NHS Quality Improvement Scotland refer to a draft report that will be available in early 2009 and a final report that will be published in May 2009. As Bill Butler indicated, we must try to ensure not just that people do not fall through gaps in the system but that we get uniform delivery for ABI sufferers throughout Scotland. We do not want excellent services to be delivered in some health boards—as reporting has shown—while others are declassifying and downgrading support services. If ABI services are to be delivered throughout the NHS in Scotland, they should be delivered at the same level—there should be no postcode or health board lottery that results in people in different areas getting different treatment. Ensuring uniform service delivery throughout Scotland is a common thread in petitions that have come before the committee.We should continue consideration of the petition. As Bill Butler indicated, we need to write to the Scottish Government for further information. It will be interesting to find out what is contained in the draft report and in the final report, when it is published in May. We want to ensure that some of the fears and concerns that have been expressed are addressed by NHS Scotland when it rolls out the new programme for the delivery of services.
I draw members' attention to the letter of 21 November from the primary and community care directorate, which is signed by Jean MacLellan. The last paragraph on the first page states:"The Government has no plans to introduce a separate and distinct health and community care client group category of acquired brain injury."If that is the position at the moment, collectively we are challenging the Government to say why such a group is not needed. The evidence appears to point in another direction. Given the large number of pieces of paper that we have received, we should ask the Government to explain its position.
I agree with Nigel Don. We could also ask the Government whether the NHS carer information strategies will include ABI training for health staff, which would be helpful.
I know that Paul Martin and David Whitton are familiar with the process, as they have appeared before the committee before. I ask them to inform the petitioners with whom they have been dealing that we will discuss the petition further once we have obtained answers to some of the points that have been raised.
Would it be appropriate for the committee to ask the Cabinet Secretary for Health and Wellbeing to respond to its inquiries?
No problem—that will be done. Thank you for your time.
In this meeting
Everything on 13 Jan 2009 →- Scottish Parliament Public Petitions Committee Tuesday 13 January 2009 Petitions · 1
- New Petitions Petitions · 55
- New Petitions Petitions · 34
- New Petitions Petitions · 3
- New Petitions Petitions · 20
- New Petitions Petitions · 24
- New Petitions Petitions · 5
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 15
- Current Petitions Petitions · 11
- Current Petitions Petitions · 5
- Current Petitions Petitions · 7
- Current Petitions Petitions · 7
- Current Petitions Petitions · 6
- Current Petitions Petitions · 1
- Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- Current Petitions Petitions · 6
- Current Petitions Petitions · 14
- Current Petitions Petitions · 5
- Current Petitions Petitions · 4
- Current Petitions Petitions · 4
- Current Petitions Petitions · 10
- New Petitions (Notification) Petitions · 4
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.