link
I could go on, but I will leave it there.
Official Report · Committee
This is the draft Official Report. The final version may differ.
link
I could go on, but I will leave it there.
link
There is another instalment of Ms Chapman to come, so do not worry. I will now hand over to Ms Bland.
link
Good morning. I have three questions about the third sector that I will direct to Mr McKee. I will put them into context for you. Based on the evidence that we have heard across the panels at committee, I would argue that the Scottish Government cannot achieve meaningful public service reform without a sustainable, independent and influential third sector. The third sector must be given the financial security, recognition and decision-making powers that are necessary to fulfil their vital role in supporting our statutory agencies and the communities that they serve. Do you agree?
link
I see that every week in my own constituency, where organisations are doing fabulous work.
link
I was heartened by your opening statement, in which you talked about reducing avoidable demand and about prevention, joined-up services and early intervention. There are many organisations within the third sector, and the committee can see an intricate web across the statutory and third sectors.My first question is this: how will you ensure that public service reform translates into a genuine commitment to sustainable investment in the third sector?
link
If you read the strategy, you will see that we are very clear about the important role of the third sector. We have workstreams that focus specifically on how the third sector can be given its proper place within the wider system.It is important to recognise that both my job title and the work that we are taking forward use the words “public service reform” not “public sector reform”. That is done specifically to recognise the wider role of the third sector. We have individuals with third sector experience sitting on the public service reform board, which directs and drives the work that we are taking forward, and I meet frequently with representatives of the third sector. I am absolutely seized of the need for the third sector to take a critical role in delivering that activity.
link
We heard last week from Karyn McCluskey of Community Justice Scotland. I am going to quote from what she said because she represents many voices from the third sector. She said:“Funding has not kept pace with inflation, and the funding that is there has not increased year on year. I volunteer in a number of third sector organisations, and I know that we give people redundancy notices every January, because we do not know whether the funding is going to increase. They are a critical part of all of this. I came before the committee a few weeks ago with Sheriff Pattison, and it is clear from what he said that sheriffs rely on the services out there so that they can sentence people properly and with efficacy.”—Official Report, Criminal Justice Committee, 28 October 2026; c 52.I used that quote because I have heard that time and time again from charities in my own region of Central Scotland. What do you say to Ms McCluskey and to people from other charities to reassure them?
link
You are absolutely right. I have met Karyn on a number of occasions. She has done great work in the past and continues to do so.That goes to the heart of the preventative agenda, because third sector organisations are often best placed to deliver on that agenda in a cost-effective way and are also often able to join up and integrate services in the way that the PSR work seeks to deliver. That is because they meet individuals and families to address their needs, instead of working on a siloed basis. Those organisations are an exemplar of what we want to roll out more extensively—
link
So what have they got to look forward to?
link
I will come on to that.They are an exemplar of what we want to roll out more extensively as part of the public reform work.You are absolutely right that those organisations should not have to take the steps that you identify when they come to the year end, so more stable funding is important. Part of the work that we are doing—and this is also set out in the PSR strategy—is to look at the grant funding schemes for third sector organisations. That is because there are too many; they are too complicated; and they are not necessarily integrated, because they are driven through silos within Government rather than being coherent across the piece. There is some work at the moment to understand what the grant-funding schemes are, how they can be better joined up and integrated, and how reporting and assessment within those schemes can be more effectively targeted so as to be less burdensome for third sector organisations and to give them more stability.My final point is that when we are under budget pressure we are always in danger of looking to cut the things that are easiest to cut instead of protecting the things that are delivering the preventative and integrated agenda in a cost-effective way. The budget process must take its course, but recognising and prioritising the work that the third sector does across portfolios is really important.
link
That leads me to my next question. Last week, Audit Scotland was very clear about the lack of available data. What evidence does the Scottish Government use to assess the effectiveness, impact and outcomes of its funding for the third sector? What I see is a complicated web, and I am not convinced that we have data that can guarantee that public money is being spent in the right places at the right time. I need to understand what evidence you base decisions on, given that the area is so complex.
link
Are you asking on what evidence we base decisions about where to allocate funding to the third sector?
link
Yes.
link
You are right to say that it is complex. We will never get a perfect answer to this, because understanding the impact of a preventative intervention somewhere else in the system at a later point in time will always, by its nature, be complex. It is always going to be difficult to understand the impact of a third sector intervention before we make it and to be 100 per cent sure about that, but—
link
So, you cannot guarantee that you are always achieving value for money.
link
I think that that is a given due to the nature of the third sector, but that should not prevent us from doing the right things, which are, as you identified, joining up the processes and the funding streams and providing certainty on funding.It is a complex environment and, to be honest, the problem is possibly the opposite. We sometimes take too much of a belt-and-braces approach in seeking assurances rather than understanding that the work that the third sector does in providing local services is almost like providing essential infrastructure. We need to simplify the mechanisms whereby different parts of Government ask for different forms to be filled in or for different information and the process is not necessarily co-ordinated. It is important to reduce that burden on the third sector and streamline the processes whereby we provide funds so that that is done in a more integrated way.
link
I will bring in the deputy convener briefly before we go back to Ms Chapman.
link
To build on the point that Ivan McKee just made, during the pandemic, we managed to make the processes much more expedient without opening up the public sector to additional risk of fraud. There is plenty of learning from that that we can build on to give trusted organisations resource in a more efficient way.The Government has—commendably, in my view—made commitments to three-year funding cycles for the third sector, which should make a huge difference both on the ground and to the security that those organisations have. It will remove the risk that my colleague mentioned, and which Karyn McCluskey spoke to the committee about, of organisations having to issue redundancy notices only to withdraw them again because of the uncertainty, or of losing staff and then having to rehire and retrain them, with all the waste that is involved in that process.How far away are we from securing three-year funding cycles for the sector, even to some extent? That will make a transformative difference.
link
I do not have the specifics on that aspect of the work. I think that I am right in saying that Ms Somerville is leading on it, but we will get back to the committee on that. However, your point about how the process operated during Covid is a good example of how, working with trusted organisations, we can deliver.One of the fundamental challenges that we have lies in breaking out of the traditional siloed approach that has been taken. Money goes to portfolios, which then allocate it to third sector organisations through a plethora of schemes that are focused on what is important to that portfolio rather than what is important across the whole system. Tackling that part of the challenge requires us to do things very differently in how we allocate resources and monitor their use, but that is essential if we are to have a relationship that will allow the third sector to deliver effectively.
link
If the Government could follow up on that and provide the committee with as much information as possible and indicative timescales, we would welcome that. We would encourage the Government to move as swiftly as possible on it, because it would make a big difference in both the justice portfolio and others.
link
I will bring in Ms Chapman. We are still on the topic of the third sector and victims.
link
I will carry on with questions to Mr McKee about grant funding and support for the third sector. In response to Amanda Bland, you said that the third sector should be treated as essential infrastructure. Why is it then that, through the various grant funding systems or because of various Government priorities, third sector organisations are repeatedly asked to reinvent themselves—to create a new project and start something new—even if we know that what they have been doing for the past five years works? How is that sustainable? It is a huge waste of resource and time and, frankly, it is really frustrating for those people, who are just trying to do their jobs.10:15
link
You are absolutely correct. That is why the public service reform strategy has a workstream on grant funding that addresses those issues. It is why we have pulled together, for the first time within and across Government, a list of the grant funding that is delivered to the third sector. Such a list did not exist previously. Around 500 grant-funding relationships are on that database.
link
I am sorry to interrupt, but the issue is not just about the number of funding organisations; it is about what they are seeking.
link
That is absolutely correct.
link
The funders are always looking for innovative new projects and asking, “How can we do this differently?” What if we do not need to do it differently, because what we are already doing works?
link
Yes—I am agreeing with you. You are absolutely correct. The first step is to understand the scale of all this, which is the aim of the work that we have undertaken so far, and the next step is to understand how we can streamline those asks.You are right that there is a conceptual issue. Silos in Government often feel that they need to be seen to be doing something different. You are absolutely right that, very often, it is better to just do more of the same and to do it consistently and effectively. It needs to be recognised that, because of the nature of the services that those organisations provide, they should be integrated and joined up and not made to fit into the specific silos of the funding mechanisms.
link
Do you agree that, if third sector organisations are undertaking vital and often life-saving work that complements and supports public sector agencies, they should receive funding that covers the costs for delivering those services? I am talking about a full-cost recovery model, rather than funding for just a project, which does not recognise that the infrastructure of the organisation needs to exist for the project to exist.
link
Conceptually, I understand what you are saying. Clearly, the mechanics of that—who is funded to do what—is a separate bit of work that needs to be done within the budget constraints, but I understand your point. You need to recognise, though, that third sector organisations receive funding from a variety of sources and not just from Government. As you know, those will often be complementary arrangements, such as matched funding and other funding from the public sector that can give confidence to other providers to fund services.However, you are right that, in general, that should be as simple as possible and organisations should not have to patch all those things together to continue operating.
link
That is helpful.Services such as the victim support services and advocacy services that we have heard about in this committee should be considered to be core justice infrastructure. If they are to be treated as essential and core justice infrastructure, the Scottish Government is beholden to ensure that they have the funding for appropriate premises. It is much the same situation as when we challenge you on ensuring that there are premises and facilities for the fire and rescue service. It is almost as if the Government’s position is that it will fund the salaries of the staff who do the work but not the things that need to exist for the staff to do that work. I just ask you to reflect on that in your conversations.I have a question for Mr Gray on support for victims and survivors. How will your budget asks and decisions ensure that victims and survivors receive timely and sustained support throughout their engagement with the justice system, rather than it just being counted as a success if a successful referral is made and someone moves from one agency to another?
link
The organisations that Ms Chapman is speaking about in the community and voluntary sector provide a significant amount of support in that space. Victim Support Scotland, Rape Crisis Scotland, Scottish Women’s Aid and others provide substantial support in that regard, and we give them funding to support that endeavour. She will be aware that we are currently working on ensuring that some of those organisations are given the funding that they need to respond to the demands that have been illuminated, partly through this committee’s sessions, but also through events that took place in the summer.
link
Given that you have mentioned Rape Crisis Scotland, I should probably remind folk that I used to work for a rape crisis centre.When you say that you will provide the resources to meet demand, what is an acceptable waiting time for somebody who has been raped and who is looking for advocacy and therapeutic support?
link
Obviously, we want to ensure that that support is provided as quickly as possible. The evidence that has been provided on waiting times in certain parts of the country is the reason why we are looking to provide additional support to those organisations. We would expect to come forward with that following discussion with the organisations, while getting their financial needs properly assessed and worked on. We would expect to be able to provide that in short order.
link
Do you have an idea of what an acceptable waiting time is, or how long waiting lists should be?
link
That is a very difficult question to answer.
link
But it is the question that those organisations grapple with every day.
link
Of course they do—I understand that. The point that I am making is that the Government wants to ensure that those organisations can provide their services to individuals as quickly as possible. The level of waiting that has been set out by some organisations, which was put in the public domain over the summer, is what prompted the Government to look to intervene and provide additional support. We recognise that some of the waiting times are clearly unacceptable, as is the fact that, in some cases, we have closed waiting lists. That is not where we want to be. That is why we are reviewing the situation and working with the organisations to assess what it would take to speed up the processes.
link
My final question on this topic is for Mr McKee. Your strategy talks about“organising services around people … rather than around organisational boundaries”.What needs to change in public sector agencies to enable that to happen, so that there is a through-flow or coherence between the public sector and the third sector, in the way that currently works well in some places but does not work at all in others? How will that principle apply in the interconnection between the public and third sectors?
link
I recognise that that principle should inform the other work that we take forward. You are right that it will work better in some places than in others. Clearly, there is a wide range of activity right across all the portfolios in the public sector where that can apply. Some of that comes back to the culture, which is important when it comes to public sector leaders recognising the importance of the third sector. Some of it will come down to how we design services.As we work our way through the landscape review and the understanding of what effective public services could and should look like in their structural design, streamlining things and ensuring that as many things as possible are integrated at local level is really important. That is where third sector organisations can often add significant value.
link
Thank you. I will leave my third sector questions there.
link
I hand over to Ms McNair.
link
Good morning, cabinet secretaries and officials. It is good to see you.The Wise Group stated in its written submission for last week’s meeting that poverty has been treated separately from justice spending. How are you addressing the link between poverty, deprivation and justice demand? You touched on that in your opening remarks, Mr McKee, but I ask you to expand on that a wee bit.
link
I have visited the Wise Group, and its approach and the work that it does are commendable. It has an effective model for addressing that issue. It recognises many dimensions of the challenges that, unfortunately, can lead people to an interaction with the justice system, and it is able to unpick and address those.The issue comes back to the fundamental point about not thinking or budgeting in silos and understanding that, within Government, the money needs to be joined up effectively on the ground, if I can put it that way, so that it addresses the systemic or holistic issue, where everything, or many things, are joined up and influence other parts of the system. It comes back to the point that we made about siloed funding and the fact that the way in which we have traditionally done things is not helpful in delivering solutions on the ground.
link
If successful anti-poverty measures were in place, what impact would you expect them to have on the police, courts and prison service?
link
I will not put a number on it. Although poverty can be a driver—
link
It is a huge driver.
link
It is not the only driver. Conversely, to say that everyone who is in poverty will be interacting with the justice system is not a fair representation. The First Minister’s top priority is to address child poverty, and considerable resources have been applied to that. The work that we are doing on preventative budget tagging in the budget process will help us to identify where money has been spent on prevention. As part of that, we will look to understand and quantify the links between interventions and how addressing poverty could have an impact elsewhere in the system, whether that is on the economy, housing, health or justice.As you can imagine, that is a complicated piece of work; it is not just a question of putting £1 in somewhere and getting X out somewhere else. Understanding those relationships is difficult and complicated, but that should not prevent us from taking those measures and recognising that poverty interventions will positively impact other parts of the public sector.
link
You are nodding, Mr Gray. Is there anything that you want to add?
link
Mr McKee makes an important point about budget tagging. We need to see housing investment as justice preventative spend and poverty preventative spend, as well as a good economic contributor in its own right. We need to see education as justice preventative spend. We need to work with that dynamic across Government and remove silos, which is a critical element of public service reform that Mr McKee is taking forward.Particularly from a budgetary perspective, we need to ensure that we are able to do that. The programme for government sets out how we will do that, with the key areas, principles and outcomes that we are looking to drive at. It is the collective responsibility of the Government and departments to look to achieve those outcomes. We want to have safer communities through a better functioning justice system, and we want to address child poverty, grow the economy and have good public services. All those contribute towards improving the picture and preventing people from interacting with the criminal justice system.
link
We will move on to the next section on community justice and workforce wellbeing. I hand over to Ms Chapman to lead on that.
link
This follows on nicely from Marie McNair’s questions. You have recognised that prevention requires up-front investment that might benefit the broader justice system, even if it accrues in a different portfolio or budget line. What practical changes have you already made to this year’s budget process to allow the investment to be made in one place and the benefits or savings to be realised somewhere else? I do not know which of you wants to answer the question first.
link
Mr McKee might disagree, but, fundamentally, that is a question for the Deputy First Minister about how she is managing the budget process.In recent years, we have seen a shift towards more outcome-based resourcing and budgeting, rather than budgeting purely on the basis of departmental spend. We are looking in the round at investment areas that could clearly be deemed to be preventative spend for the health service as well as the justice system, which Mr McKee and I have spoken about.The Deputy First Minister is taking forward that approach. I am due to have a bilateral meeting with her this week to set out some of the areas of discussion and to indicate where I would like there to be investment within my immediate responsibilities and in other portfolios.We have touched on many of the issues where there are opportunities for preventative activity; Mr Kerr spoke about the work of the police, for example. I believe that we need resourcing to allow preventative work to happen and to relieve pressure on the justice system—I have mentioned housing and social work services, as well as the community and voluntary sector, and community justice services.
link
You said that you are working with the DFM on that. Is it the DFM who has the authority to agree shared investment across different outcomes in justice, housing, local government and so on?10:30
link
We do that collectively as a Government, but as she leads the budget process, informed by the work of Mr McKee from a public service reform perspective, the answer is, ultimately, yes.
link
Who will be accountable if those systems—
link
In Government we are collectively accountable, so we are all accountable.
link
Okay. Can you give me an example of an area where the Government is prepared to spend more now in order to save somewhere else, because it knows that that will reduce harm and keep communities safer in that area and also reduce harm and demand elsewhere in the system?
link
I referenced increased investment in housing. Taking it back to my portfolio area, I note that we have substantially increased the budget line for community justice and provided increased resourcing in that space. I also referenced the need, from a public protection perspective, to ensure that social work is given the necessary resource to manage individuals and to work with families in order to prevent either the first interaction with the criminal justice system or reoffending.There are also a number of other areas. Drug and alcohol services have a clear interaction with the justice system. I point to those examples as the most immediate, but there are a range of others where we have seen an increase in resource that is important both for its own ends and as a direct contributor to preventing offending in the first place or reoffending.
link
If we get prevention right, it will be a different way of funding services. As Ivan McKee said, it involves putting the person at the centre and getting the right services around them, regardless of who provides those services or which budget line they come out of.Does the conversation about prevention and the different way of thinking require us to shift our thinking on what we measure? Last week, we heard powerful evidence from the Wise Group that measuring stability is better than just recognising that somebody has completed an intervention or that a certain outcome or output is complete. Actually, what matters is whether the person has genuinely moved away from the circumstances that brought them into contact with the justice system, rather than whether they have completed a short-term programme. How do you see what the Government does having to change in response to that?
link
Mr McKee might have more to say on that, but I am familiar with the Wise Group. I have met it repeatedly both in my current role and in my previous role. It does phenomenal work, both in my constituency and elsewhere.What you are asking for is difficult to measure, as Mr McKee said earlier. Some of those things are not data points but overall outcome assessments, which are more challenging for us to pull together on a consistent methodological basis. However, that is the type of area that Mr McKee is speaking of when he says that the Government is looking to put the person at the centre and have whole family support as a priority in order to tackle and eradicate child poverty, as well as to support people away from substance dependency, support people to ensure that they are complying with bail conditions or their licence conditions, and to ensure that we stop the escalation of antisocial behaviour into serious criminality. All of that fits into this work, and justice social work and social work services in general have a central role to play in that, as do the police.The wider public protection landscape, which includes some of our community and voluntary organisations and the information that they are able to pass on, including information that is given not as a data point but on a free-form basis, will be critical to ensuring that we get better outcomes for individuals and their families.
link
I want to ensure that justice social work—and wider social work services—is given the resource that it needs to manage its case load and to do the preventative work that I was speaking about in my previous answer.We are working with Joanna Macdonald, the chief social work adviser at the National Social Work Agency, on what we need to have in order to support the workforce properly while also growing it to meet the increasing demand, especially as we are seeking to shift from managing so many individuals within custody towards providing more services in the community to prevent offending happening in the first place and to prevent reoffending occurring. That is a key piece of work that Joanna Macdonald is taking forward for us.
link
You have hinted at my final question on community justice. Karyn McCluskey was clear that we cannot expect the same number of people in community justice to deal with increasing complexity and increasing demand if we are genuine about our desire to see a shift away from custody. How will you balance the pressing needs around our custodial facilities and the investment that is so desperately needed, given how stretched community justice and justice social work services are already?
link
I understand that point. That is part of the discussion that Government is currently undertaking, and which Parliament will need to engage with, around ensuring that we have the space within the Scottish Prison Service to manage those offenders who pose a risk to the public and for whom serious sentences have been laid down.I do not apologise for the fact that there has been a 37 per cent increase in sentence lengths over recent years, nor do I apologise for the fact that there is a rising number of long-term prisoners in incarceration—which is because we are better able to investigate, through the police, and prosecute, through the work of the courts, very serious offending, particularly sexual offending, both historic and current, as well as offending involving serious organised criminality. I commend the work of the police, the courts and the Scottish Prison Service in seeking to disrupt and deal with that.However, we need to have a conversation to ensure that we have the space to manage those very serious individuals and that we have the capacity in play in the community to support offenders when they are released from custody in a way that reduces reoffending, while preventing offending from happening in the first place and looking to utilise the community disposals better so that we can better manage individuals, rather than seeing custody as being the only answer in some cases.
link
I think that we still need a little bit more recognition that community justice and justice social work should be seen as equal partners in the justice system. I am not sure that that is always the case. However, I want to move on.
link
I totally understand that. That is a key thread of work, which is currently being taken forward by the Social Work Agency to inform the budget position.
link
I have a question on workforce wellbeing. This applies to community justice, to justice social work and to the police—I think that it applies across the board. We are losing staff who are very experienced and skilled, because of the stresses and pressures of their jobs, either because they do not have the number of colleagues that they need or because they are dealing with increasing complexity without appropriate support and supervision. What is your plan to retain experienced staff across the justice portfolio, and how will that be reflected in the budget?
link
I think that I have already covered the point about where we are with social work services. I recognise that that is a challenge in social work, because we are seeing more complex individuals and more individuals who require support across social work, whether in children’s services, adult services or, indeed, justice services. That work is under way.I also recognise some of the points that have been raised around the police in relation to modified and reduced duties. I understand that work on that is ongoing with Bex Smith and the police service at present. In response to Ms Chapman’s earlier point, I referenced the work that is being done to provide training and support to the fire service, to ensure that the necessary PPE and other elements are in play, and to ensure that the service is given the requisite support that it needs.Across our workforce, including in our court service, we are looking to ensure that we have the capacity to be able to deal with the demands that are on it. Ensuring the welfare of those who work in our justice system is paramount, too.To take the prison service as an example, I hear directly from the Prison Officers Association Scotland, as I do from Linda Pollock, about the challenging environment that prison officers are operating in at present. It is my ambition to make the prison service an attractive place in which to work and do life-changing work with individuals, turning their lives around and ensuring that they return to communities reformed and rehabilitated. That is part of why we are looking at how to provide greater capacity for them to do their work; how to create more space in the prison system; and what potential there is for penal reform, which we consulted on over the summer. It is to ensure that we give our prison officers the space to do the work that they want to do—that is the greatest challenge that they face at present.
link
Across the board, however, it is not just a numbers game. If you lose prison officers, police officers or third sector workers with years—sometimes decades—of experience, you leave behind workers who do not have that level of experience, and, although they might be very skilled and expert at their jobs, they will not have seen as much as somebody who has been there for 20 years. How do we ensure that we give those staff sufficient time for support and sufficient training?We have heard stories that certain staff do not have proper appraisal systems, because there is not the time to do that. Others do not have an experienced mentor to whom they can go to sense check everything, because the mentor has resigned due to the stresses. How do we ensure that we build in not just the number of staff but the time and capacity for training, support, supervision and appraisal?
link
It is not an either/or situation. The numbers clearly help to provide the capacity for people to do their jobs well, but having workforce support is critical. Whether we are talking about the justice system or any other part of public service, looking after our number 1 asset—our workforce—making sure that they are able to do their jobs well and looking after their wellbeing is a priority. Police Scotland is investing significant amounts in ensuring workforce wellbeing. I made the point in response to Mr Kerr that, when officers are on modified or reduced duties, we must support individuals to be able to return to full duties, instead of taking punitive approaches.Whether we are talking about the police, the Prison Service, the Fire and Rescue Service or the court service, we are looking after individuals’ wellbeing and ensuring that—to pick up on Maggie Chapman’s point—they are in the best possible place to provide the incredible service that they provide. Regardless of which part of the public service they are in, we want to ensure that they are able to do the best job that they can.
link
That is not the evidence that we have heard. I have another small question.
link
I will come back to you during the wash-up, because I want to bring in Mr Kerr for a very brief question—if we can have a brief answer—before moving on to the final section.
link
I want to come in on what Maggie Chapman has just said about that not being the evidence that we have heard. In fact, it is not the evidence that we heard from His Majesty’s chief inspector of constabulary in Scotland, Craig Naylor, who, in response to questions from me and Maggie Chapman, made it clear that we are letting down the workforce, particularly in Police Scotland, which is in his purview. He said that “psychological support is patchy”. He said that only a small number of people get the support that they need to help them through the psychological issues that arise from policing due to the things that they deal with. He went on to talk about gaps in “day-to-day supervision”, the absence of objectives, performance management and checks on matters to do with wellbeing, conduct and discipline. He talked about an information technology platform for all of that that is more than 20 years old. It is clearly not a priority, cabinet secretary.
link
We will put that down as a comment rather than a question, because I want to move us on. It is important that Mr Kerr has put that on the record, but I want to go on to the final section, which is our wash-up, and to come in to land on some of the issues.10:45If Police Scotland and the Scottish Fire and Rescue Service are the poster children for public service reform—this question is directed specifically to Mr McKee—I note that the reform under the Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Act 2012 took place prior to your entering the Parliament. What are your candid reflections on how the move to a single service has been for the police and fire services? With the benefit of hindsight, what lessons could we learn from that?
link
There will be individuals who are better placed to reflect on that than me. I would not call those services “poster children”, but I would say that they are examples of what can be done.Looked at simply from the perspective of resource allocation, or the effectiveness of that allocation, it is important to recognise that significant costs have been taken out from areas of duplication in the services, which continues to be the case each year, and that resource is available for investing in front-line service delivery. Some aspects are very effective, such as the ability to co-ordinate more effectively—whether facing into organised crime or cybercrime—technology and sharing data. There are always things that you can do better and there will be lots of details that we can learn from, and it is valuable to take those lessons in terms of both the opportunity that is there and as we move forward to roll out restructuring across other parts of the public sector.
link
I have a final question for Neil Gray before I hand over to Ms McNeill; other colleagues might want to catch my eye, too. We heard from Karyn McCluskey about the lack of a long-term vision for justice. We have heard that a couple of times. Tell me if that is wrong. What is your long-term vision for justice?
link
The first thing to say is to supplement what Mr McKee has said about police and fire reform. If we had not done that more than a decade ago, we would certainly be doing it now.On a vision for the justice system, before the summer recess, I clearly set out to the Parliament where I viewed the justice system in general; the interaction of the prison population with not just the prison system but the wider system; and how we must look at what prison is for, who it is for and how those interact. That is clearly looking to set out the changes that are required to ensure that we have a sustainable justice system that serves the needs of victims, witnesses and the public by providing safety, which is the first duty of Government.
link
We are into the final 10 minutes or so, and I want to give colleagues the opportunity to come in for one last bite of the cherry, as it were. Let us keep questions and answers brief.
link
I thank both cabinet secretaries for coming along today. Ivan McKee, you responded to the convener by saying that there is definitely something to be learned from the centralisation of the police and fire services. I agree with the centralisation—I wanted to say that for the record. However, some would say that the centralisation of both police and fire has gone beyond that; I will give you some examples to illustrate it. We have lost nearly 1,000 fire officers and nearly 1,000 police officers, give or take—there is a variation in numbers between 900 and 1,000.This is why I think that it is an important starting point for the budget, and I will give three examples. Police cars in Scotland—to my knowledge, and I have been in one recently—do not have access to the police national computer when on the road, so officers cannot check a number plate. It seems to me that, in the centralisation and in avoiding duplication, there has been a serious level of cuts over the past 14 years and, in my opinion, some of that money should have been held back. I know that you cannot account for your predecessors, and I am not trying to make you accountable for that.Ours was the last police service in the UK to roll out body-worn cameras, which I think is because we took too much money out of the service.A report a couple of years ago said that police offices were in such a state of disrepair that it was causing depression among police officers, who were coming to work and not having the basic things that people would expect. The fire service would probably say the same. I want you to acknowledge that, in the past 12 or so years, we have gone beyond efficiency savings. There have been serious cuts over the years—the lack of investment in some areas is testament to that. I wanted you to think about that.
link
There are two separate issues there. One is that, if we had not done the reforms, we would be content to spend significant resources on things that were—
link
I agree.
link
That resource has been made available more widely.There is a separate question about how much money is spent on the items that you have identified. If we had not done the reforms, we would be in a worse place, because we would be starting three steps back from the starting line before we even started to have that conversation. We would be spending money on duplication and the aspects that were taken out as a consequence of the reorganisation. It is important to consider those issues separately.
link
Yes. Whatever figure you accept—for example, the chief constable’s—the money does not really matter, because those were savings. What I am saying is that some of them were cuts, and there is no getting away from the fact that that was spent elsewhere in the budget.
link
I have a question for Mr Gray. Let us return to the issue of Barlinnie prison. You talk about a long-term vision and forward planning in penal reform and prison staff welfare. We all welcome that, but the evidence that we hear does not match it. What alarms me, and what I am confused about, is how you could consider keeping Barlinnie prison open, because of the Government’s lack of forward planning and long-term vision, when it is well documented that Barlinnie is not fit for purpose, and that it should be bulldozed and the staff and prisoners moved to more humane conditions. Why, in one breath, are you talking about penal reform and staff welfare, and, in another, considering keeping the building open and in operation?
link
As I said in response to a question from the convener, no decision has been taken in that space. It is still the intention that Barlinnie prison will close on the opening of HMP Glasgow. The investment that has been made in Glasgow will provide more modern and up-to-date standards, including the provision of facilities for an ageing cohort, who require additional social care in our prison system.That being said, our responsibility, which His Majesty’s chief inspector of prisons holds us to account for, is to ensure that, whatever facility we have available to us, it meets the highest possible standards. That would be the case regardless of any decisions on keeping Barlinnie prison open or what we need to do to provide additional prison capacity. We need additional prison capacity, and work is ongoing in Government to establish where that capacity can be generated. I have spoken to the committee previously about modular units, the potential for new house blocks and what we need to do around penal reform to ensure that prison is there and available for those who the public need to be protected from. We need to ensure that the significant serious escalation—
link
You do see my way of thinking.
link
Of course I do. I perfectly understand the premise of Ms Bland’s question, convener. That is not in dispute. Barlinnie is a Victorian jail—I have seen inside it and it is clearly not up to modern standards. The point that I am making is that, regardless of the decision that is taken on Barlinnie or anywhere else, we need to ensure that the facilities that we have available to us meet modern standards. That will be our consideration in decision making on where capacity can be generated.
link
Cabinet secretary, you talked about penal reform. We are aware of the need for the reform in the court system that Malcolm Graham has set out. I know that you are well acquainted with that. If you wanted to say anything on that, I am sure that the committee would be interested.I want to touch briefly on police and fire, and follow up on what some of my colleagues have said. Notwithstanding the fact that there is always room for improvement, have we reached a position where the police and fire services have done their public service reform? You said that, if we had not done that centralisation during Parliament’s past, we would be looking to do it now. What concerns the committee, based on the evidence that we have heard, is that the police and fire services feel that they have more than done their bit to find savings, modernise and do what has to be done. However, the pressure on both services with respect to risk, resilience and public safety seems to be the most acute that it has been during my time in Parliament, so can you reassure us that you are mostly looking elsewhere when it comes to public service reform, because those two services have really played their part?
link
I know that the deputy convener understands the point that public service reform is about outcomes and not only about generating savings or making efficiencies. The police and fire services have, of course, generated savings: we have established the savings generated by the police service in the past decade and a half, so they have done their bit, in that sense.To say that public service reform has been completed in those areas would be to miss the opportunities that are available from digitisation and from the data-sharing arrangements that can be put in place. That takes me back to the deputy convener’s first point, because the modernisation of the courts service is an opportunity, as is the work on data-sharing arrangements and joined-up justice that has been taken forward by Malcolm Graham. Those elements are still there for us to work on because they are still aspects of public service reform. We cannot see that work purely in terms of savings or efficiencies, because that is not the driver of public service reform: it is about how to generate better outcomes so that we have better public services at the end of the process. I know that that is the driving force behind Mr McKee’s work. Mr Macpherson’s point about the police and fire services generating savings is well made, but we will not stop doing the work of public service reform that will improve their ability to provide better services. That work is on-going.
link
I appreciate your putting that on the record.The thematic focus of today’s meeting is pre-budget scrutiny. I appreciate that you cannot talk about specific discussions, but is there an understanding within the Cabinet of the sheer demand and increasing complexity faced by the services in this portfolio? Is there an understanding that others may have to tighten their belts to make resources available for this area of society and of Government delivery?
link
Mr McKee is free to contradict me, but I have not been shy in coming forward about the challenges that the justice system faces and I do not think that I am betraying Cabinet confidence in saying that.
link
I would not contradict that. Mr Gray has been forthcoming on that subject, because that is his job.I have a couple of important points to make about your earlier question and to reinforce what Mr Gray said. It is clear that a lot of structural reform has taken place in this area and similar work has been done in other areas, such as colleges regionalisation. Mr Gray will also be familiar with work in other areas. For example, in the economy portfolio, the enterprise agencies have done significant work to reduce costs, share services and work together.There are good examples and it is important to learn from what has been done as we take the work forward. I understand that some portfolios have moved forward faster than others, but it is important to say that more can be done. Members have given examples today of opportunities that still exist to make services more effective and efficient and of work that is still to be done. That is all part of public service reform.I know that we are at the justice committee talking to the justice secretary about the justice budget. However, the final point that I will make goes back to the point that I made right at the start. If we cannot get ourselves into a place where we are able to join up budgets and get them to deliver more effectively, and where we stop looking at it through a siloed lens, we will not succeed in relation to the broader public service reform work.
link
That goes back to some of the points that colleagues raised around the need for the NHS, with its enormous resource, to do more to assist justice services in relation to mental health.
link
Yes. That is one example. There are also many others. However, Ben Macpherson is right that it is important to join that up; otherwise, none of it will succeed.
link
I am grateful for the time that you have given us this morning. We have covered a lot over the past two hours.The committee will next meet on 11 November, when we will consider a draft report on our pre-budget scrutiny for 2027-28. Do members agree to consider that draft report in private at next week’s meeting?Members indicated agreement.
link
I will suspend the meeting for around five minutes to allow for a changeover of witnesses.11:00Meeting suspended.11:07On resuming—
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.