The statement expands on some of the issues that have been raised.I am a chief superintendent with 26 years of service. As the convener said, my full-time role is currently as the elected president of the Association of Scottish Police Superintendents. I was elected to the position in 2023 and re-elected this year.The association is 102 years old. It is a staff association that provides the professional voice for all police officers of superintendent ranks in Scotland; that is, the senior operational leaders in policing. For clarity, although superintendents and chief superintendents are officers of very senior rank, where I use the term “senior officers” during this evidence session, I am referring to senior officers in terms of the regulations, being officers of assistant chief constable rank and above.I have been a chief superintendent since 2021, and I have served in two other roles previously to this one. I have served in the superintendent ranks continuously since 2015. Prior to taking up this role, I carried out the role of chair and assessor in misconduct hearings on several occasions, being among the most experienced officers in those duties.I have been involved in the dismissal of several police officers for gross misconduct. Conversely, in my current role, I have represented officers subject to allegations of gross misconduct, and supported officers making allegations of misconduct about others. I believe that those experiences allow me to put the association’s position in a uniquely balanced way.The association recognises the damage that has been done, and that is done, to the reputation of policing by misconduct of police officers. That has been most apparent in high-profile cases in which police officers have broken the law. In every one of those cases, it is the hard work of honest police officers that results in those criminals being brought before the court. It is those honest officers who represent the vast and overwhelming majority of the faithful public servants in Scottish policing, and not those who disgrace the uniform through vile criminal acts.Although those crimes loom large in public consciousness, it is nonetheless necessary to draw the clear distinction between internal misconduct processes and the criminal justice system. Misconduct processes exist to manage breaches of the standards of professional behaviour—put simply, that means the rules that govern how police officers are expected to act, in the workplace and at all other times. That includes where crimes are committed; however, the vast majority of misconduct cases do not, in fact, involve criminal behaviour. It is important to recognise that, and not to conflate misconduct and criminal processes.The highest sanction available to a misconduct chair is dismissal. That is worth remembering when views are expressed around what is said to be officers escaping justice by resigning early. If their behaviour is egregious, the sooner that they leave policing, the better, and the greater the saving to the public purse, both in wages and procedural costs. To repeat, the worst sanction that they would encounter is the loss of their job.In any case, the Association of Scottish Police Superintendents recognises the public interest, and the Scottish Government’s objective of ensuring that modern, fit-for-purpose regulations are in place to deal with misconduct. Critical in our system of policing by consent, those matters speak to the heart of public trust and confidence. However, we are not entitled to that trust—we must earn it. It must be won, and it must be maintained. As such, we must do everything that we can to ensure that the conduct of Scotland’s police officers is beyond reproach.It is against that backdrop that we consider the new regulations. The association supports some of the measures in the new regulations, and has concerns regarding others. I will explain both of those positions to the committee now.The association supports the transfer of responsibility for the assessment and investigation of complaints of misconduct by senior officers from the Scottish Police Authority to the Police Investigations and Review Commissioner. Although such complaints are always few in number, the impact on individuals, including the officers who are the subject of the complaint, is always considerable. Given that, in England and Wales last year, five chief constables were all suspended from duty at one point, although the numbers might be small, these are not simply theoretical matters.11:15Within policing, given the cultural and actual power that is afforded in the hierarchy, the expectation of compliance with orthodoxy is such that raising a complaint against a senior officer is very much a last resort. It has been the recent experience of the association that such complaints, when made by our members, have not been managed in a fair, timely, consistent, transparent or appropriate manner. I am limited by what I can say in detail, due to ongoing legal processes that the association has had to raise, but the cases include allegations made by our members of discrimination, abuse of position, misuse of police resources and bullying and harassment. In one case, the association is supporting a member who has made allegations that are protected under the Public Interest Disclosure Act 1998.We have a belief amounting to certainty that all those alleged matters are breaches of the standards of professional behaviour, and that, had those allegations been made against an officer in the more junior ranks, such as one of our members or a member of the federated ranks, they would have been subject to a misconduct investigation and likely placed under duty restrictions. Where the SPA has chosen not to investigate such matters—without speaking to witnesses—that has astonished us.The association recognises legally distinct processes for senior officer misconduct versus misconduct in all other ranks, but we do not accept a differential application of the standards of professional behaviour. The code of ethics applies equally to all ranks, and it cannot be the case that the most powerful people in the organisation are the least accountable for their conduct. Indeed, it might reasonably be argued that the higher the rank an officer holds, the greater their responsibility to uphold their professional standards of behaviour and lead by example. The failure to administer the processes in a manner that commands the confidence of our membership leads us to conclude that the PIRC is the more appropriate organisation to take up this responsibility.The effect of the current situation that I have described is to create a two-tier experience of misconduct, and that is potentially exacerbated by some of the provisions of the new regulations. The matter of independent qualified legal chairs is key to that difficulty. The regulations suggest that only senior officers would be dealt with in that manner in respect of gross misconduct matters. For ASPS, and I am sure for our colleagues in the SPF, that raises several concerns.First, the association recognises the public interest associated with ensuring that hearing chairs are demonstrably impartial. After all, the suggestion that police officers may be lenient or act in a biased manner towards other police officers is damaging to public confidence. We note the position taken by the Women’s Rights Network Scotland that the scrutiny of independent chairs is necessary for victims of abuse to have confidence. We support that position, which has also been taken by other victims’ rights organisations. The association believes that it is a necessary step. Moreover, on the topic of abuse and violence against women and girls, we are absolutely clear that any such allegation against a serving officer must be vigorously and thoroughly investigated, regardless of the rank of the officer in question.Secondly, over the past three years, the association has supported four colleagues who had allegations made against them, from a cohort of 145. In three of those cases, the conduct was assessed as gross misconduct; two of those cases then went on to be disposed of through non-sanctioned improvement action, while the other is ongoing. That disparity in initial assessment versus eventual outcome has been noted by hearing chairs.The current threshold for assessment of gross misconduct seems irrationally low. A former colleague, now retired, who served in the professional standards department has stated that, in the current climate on police misconduct,“No one wants to be the least offended person in the room, in case it is suggested that you are part of the problem.”The effect of that is an up-tariffing—