This morning, I read in the Daily Record that the decision not to pay furlough to workers at the Scottish bus manufacturer Alexander Dennis Ltd was signed off by the First Minister the day before the election. At that exact point, the leaflet that I am holding was being pushed through letterboxes in Falkirk East and Linlithgow, with the SNP pledging to protect local jobs at the bus manufacturer. Why were voters in Falkirk told that furlough at Alexander Dennis was possible before an election when ministers had already decided that it was not?
John SwinneySNPThe First Minister · Perthshire North
The rationale for the circumstances that Mr Marra narrated was that, in a pre-election period, the Government is restricted in what announcements it can make about particular policy questions. That is the explanation for the decision making and the timescales on the Alexander Dennis decision.
I am afraid that that is of little comfort to the workers, and it might be the excuse that applies in relation to Monklands hospital as well.
I am afraid that, in the rationale that he is going to set out today and in the press from his Government, the First Minister is tying himself in knots. The simple reality is that the SNP did not buy enough Scottish buses. We have been here before. As mayor of Manchester, Andy Burnham did more to support Scottish bus manufacturing than the Scottish Government did.
Today, Scottish Labour will publish details released under freedom of information laws showing that the Scottish National Party rushed through its bus order scheme in order to announce it before the election campaign, realised that it had made a mess of it and then decided to cancel the furlough offer to workers the day before Scotland went to the polls. The First Minister must understand how that looks. He surely understands how breathtakingly cynical it makes people feel—especially the 115 workers who have lost their jobs and the further 164 who look set to possibly do so, too. There is a representative of the Alexander Dennis workforce in the public gallery today. What does the First Minister have to say to them?
John SwinneySNPThe First Minister · Perthshire North
The first thing that I will say is that the Scottish Government engaged constructively with Alexander Dennis to try to protect the employment at Alexander Dennis for a sustained period of time. We offered Alexander Dennis a furlough scheme that the Scottish Government has never offered to any other employer before, which was designed to ensure that there was support for Alexander Dennis, to enable it to overcome the difficulties and challenges that the company faced. The final decision on the furlough scheme came down to the fact that the company decided to opt for a model that it was not possible to support under the furlough scheme. The very clear explanation that has been given by the Government is that we cannot change the basis of a scheme once it has been offered.
In relation to support for Alexander Dennis, I say to Mr Marra that, since 2020, through the Scottish zero emission bus challenge fund—ScotZEB—that the Government has in place, and through its predecessor schemes, Alexander Dennis Ltd has received around 483 vehicle orders, or more than 40 per cent of its orders. That includes orders proposed in the successful bids to the most recent ScotZEB funding round.
I am afraid that the point that Mr Marra advanced—that the Government is not enabling the procurement of buses from Alexander Dennis—does not stand up to scrutiny, given the detail that I have put on the parliamentary record.
The furlough scheme was dependent on the purchase of buses, and it was not enough. There were not enough buses bought by the Government to ensure that the scheme went ahead. That is where the Scottish Government always ends up. We have an industrial policy that exports Scottish jobs—buses built in China, wind turbines built in Denmark and ferries built in Turkey. The Government cannot even give Scottish kids an overpriced school bag without handing the contract to Chinese manufacturing.
Last week, the First Minister was asked seven times whether he supported Rosebank, which supports Scottish jobs, and he could not once bring himself to support it. If he does not support the projects that protect and deliver Scottish jobs, how on earth is he going to grow our economy?
John SwinneySNPThe First Minister · Perthshire North
To take one example of the schemes that Mr Marra is talking about, let us look at the ScotZEB scheme—a scheme for procuring buses. As part of that, the Government makes the funding available to organisations, because the Government does not buy buses and because we do not operate our bus network in that fashion. However, as Mr Marra will know, the Government is introducing legislation to change the way in which the bus network is controlled, and it will be interesting to see whether the Labour Party can find it within itself to support what the Government wants to do.
The ScotZEB scheme is governed by the Subsidy Control Act 2022, and that is the United Kingdom legislation under which the Government must operate. One helpful thing that I can say to Mr Marra is that, in my various constructive meetings with the Prime Minister on Friday, I encouraged the Prime Minister to revisit that legislation, because it is restrictive. It does not give us enough scope to invest in industries within our own country, and I wish the UK Government would change the legislation to enable us to do so.
The core of the First Minister’s argument is that he thinks he is not allowed to do any of that or to buy Scottish buses. I think that the First Minister is wrong about this Parliament’s ability to protect and enhance Scottish jobs through procurement and public money.
The Government has been prepared—even willing—to go against legal advice time and again when it comes to policy and legislation, repeatedly ending up in court and racking up millions of pounds in legal fees in the process because the Scottish National Party judges that to be in its political interests. It has just never done it in the interests of Scottish workers. Why is that?
John SwinneySNPThe First Minister · Perthshire North
I point out to Parliament that the courts have just found in favour of the Government in a legal case that Jackie Baillie told me I should not pursue, and they have recognised that the Government was acting lawfully and in accordance with its obligations. I simply place that on the record to refute the accusation that has been made here.
I have set out to Parliament the priority that this Government attaches to economic growth. It is about investing in our economy, investing in our infrastructure and investing in the skills of our country. That is the economic strategy of the Government and that is what will deliver growth for the Scottish economy. We could, of course, do a great deal more if we had more financial powers and a greater ability to invest, but we are held back in that respect by the United Kingdom.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.