As Gillian Mackay will know from the various legislative instruments that have been put in place by the Government and its policy programme, we have a commitment to reach net zero and to improve the public health and the natural environment of our country.
The issue that we have wrestled with in relation to the human rights bill is that the proposed legislation that is put to Parliament must be clear, coherent and effective in practice. The issue in relation to the specific measures that Gillian Mackay raises is that the right to a healthy environment is not yet grounded in an international treaty or well-established body of interpretative guidance, unlike the other rights that are proposed for incorporation in the bill. The challenge is that we might jeopardise the strength of the legislation by legislating in a way that does not have a satisfactory basis of interpretation for our courts to judge on it. The Government is concerned that that would delay the implementation of the human rights bill.
This is an important issue, and I appreciate the strength of feeling about it. I have responded today to a letter from a number of organisations that have written to me about the issue. It is not that there is a lack of will on the Government’s part; we fear that, in the absence of such a body of interpretative guidance, there is a vulnerability that the legislation that we pass in this Parliament may not be able to be implemented effectively or to deliver the rights and protections that the Government wants to see in place.
If members are sceptical about what I am saying, I would simply cite my experience. I was the legislating minister on the incorporation of the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child into Scots law. I took a maximalist position on the implementation of that legislation, which was supported unanimously by the Parliament. The Government lost its case in the Supreme Court when we were challenged by the United Kingdom Government.
I do not say that any of those things to be difficult; I say them to set out the legislative realities that the Government must consider when we are proposing legislation to Parliament.