Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 12 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Data Centres

First Minister’s Question Time

Thursday 5 November 2026 Meeting of the Parliament About 14:04 First Minister’s Questions 12 contributions · 3 speakers Watch on Scottish Parliament TV

This is the draft Official Report. The final version may differ.

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

12 contributions
Gillian Mackay Green Central Scot and Lothians West
link

Today we learned that a senior civil servant has warned the Scottish Government about the risks of data centres, including rising energy bills for locals. We know that the Scottish Government has been lobbied by artificial intelligence firms and that it is refusing to carry out a public consultation on its new guidance.

The Minister for Innovation, Technology and Tertiary Education has dismissed people who are sceptical about big tech firms’ AI promises. He said that they would have called the light bulb a “dangerous anti-candle device” when it was invented. Is that how the First Minister views those campaigners who are worried about hyperscale data centres?

John Swinney SNP The First Minister · Perthshire North
link

I believe that we should engage constructively with members of the public at all times and listen to their views. The Government has to take a considered view of all the views that it hears on a range of different topics and then set out the policy position that it will pursue, which is exactly what the Scottish Government will do on this occasion.

Gillian Mackay Green Central Scot and Lothians West
link

This week the First Minister’s Government has removed the right to a clean, healthy and sustainable environment from its upcoming Scottish human rights bill. That is despite more than 100 civil society organisations, including the Environmental Rights Centre for Scotland, Action on Smoking and Health Scotland and Asthma + Lung UK, urging it to support that right. It is not some abstract concept: it offers people protection from pollution and toxic chemicals, and it could help them to protect their communities from harmful developments, such as hyperscale data centres. It means people being legally guaranteed clean air and pure water. Why does the First Minister’s Government not think that Scots should have a legal right to clean air?

John Swinney SNP The First Minister · Perthshire North
link

As Gillian Mackay will know from the various legislative instruments that have been put in place by the Government and its policy programme, we have a commitment to reach net zero and to improve the public health and the natural environment of our country.

The issue that we have wrestled with in relation to the human rights bill is that the proposed legislation that is put to Parliament must be clear, coherent and effective in practice. The issue in relation to the specific measures that Gillian Mackay raises is that the right to a healthy environment is not yet grounded in an international treaty or well-established body of interpretative guidance, unlike the other rights that are proposed for incorporation in the bill. The challenge is that we might jeopardise the strength of the legislation by legislating in a way that does not have a satisfactory basis of interpretation for our courts to judge on it. The Government is concerned that that would delay the implementation of the human rights bill.

This is an important issue, and I appreciate the strength of feeling about it. I have responded today to a letter from a number of organisations that have written to me about the issue. It is not that there is a lack of will on the Government’s part; we fear that, in the absence of such a body of interpretative guidance, there is a vulnerability that the legislation that we pass in this Parliament may not be able to be implemented effectively or to deliver the rights and protections that the Government wants to see in place.

If members are sceptical about what I am saying, I would simply cite my experience. I was the legislating minister on the incorporation of the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child into Scots law. I took a maximalist position on the implementation of that legislation, which was supported unanimously by the Parliament. The Government lost its case in the Supreme Court when we were challenged by the United Kingdom Government.

I do not say that any of those things to be difficult; I say them to set out the legislative realities that the Government must consider when we are proposing legislation to Parliament.

Gillian Mackay Green Central Scot and Lothians West
link

I appreciate that and the things that must be balanced by the First Minister, but he claims that his Government is a world leader in so many places. This is one of those places where we could be bold and a world leader and establish what it means to have that right.

In the upcoming budget the Scottish Government has a real chance to make up for some of the climate-damaging decisions that it has made recently. If it sets a high rate for the incoming private jet tax, it could raise tens of millions of pounds. Looking ahead, a frequent flyer levy could bring in £50 million. Measures such as those, which make wealthy polluters pay, could be used to make rail travel cheaper, perhaps through a millennial railcard, as proposed by the Scottish Greens. Will the First Minister commit to making wealthy polluters pay their fair share?

John Swinney SNP The First Minister · Perthshire North
link

The Government is engaging with political parties and stakeholders on the contents of our budget, and the issues that Gillian Mackay raises will be considered as part of that process of dialogue. The Deputy First Minister is leading that work for the Government and she will set out the budget to Parliament in early December. We have taken a wide variety of actions to put into practical effect the measures to protect our natural environment. That is one of the central commitments of the Government, and we will consider the issues that Gillian Mackay raises as part of that process.

Kenneth Gibson The Presiding Officer · Cunninghame North
link

You can ask a final brief question, Ms Mackay.

Gillian Mackay Green Central Scot and Lothians West
link

We have seen from Hungary, Serbia, Brazil and, this week, the United States that, when politicians tackle big polluters, stand with communities rather than dodgy tycoons and give them hope for a fairer future, we can defeat the far right. The US has its first Muslim senator in Abdul El-Sayed from Michigan and its first black woman governor in Georgia’s Keisha Lance Bottoms, tapping into the power of the country’s diverse communities.

Kenneth Gibson The Presiding Officer · Cunninghame North
link

Will you ask a brief question, please?

Gillian Mackay Green Central Scot and Lothians West
link

Will the First Minister join the Scottish Greens in condemning those who would stir division and those who would deny the rights of Scotland’s diverse communities to live in the way that they want to, even trying to police what women wear?

John Swinney SNP The First Minister · Perthshire North
link

I am absolutely happy to associate myself with Gillian Mackay’s comments. I have championed diversity in our society. One of the hallmarks of my Government’s programme is the determination to create cohesion in our communities and to stand up to the divisive forces of the far right. I will give every ounce of political leadership that I can to protect Scotland from the scourge of racism and division. We heard a whole barrel load of it in Parliament yesterday afternoon in the debate that was led by Reform. I am delighted that this Parliament has expressed with such strength and solidarity its revulsion at the invitation to support the hard right. I will always stand up to the far right in this Parliament and in this country.

Kenneth Gibson The Presiding Officer · Cunninghame North
link

Russell Findlay has five minutes for questions and answers.

  1. 13:30 General Question Time Questions · 1
  2. 13:30 Energy Infrastructure (Planning) Questions · 7
  3. 13:30 Bonfire Night (Public Safety) Questions · 8
  4. 13:30 Voluntary Sector (Collaborative Working) Questions · 8
  5. 13:30 Rent Increases (Landlords) Questions · 6
  6. 13:30 Moray FLOW-Park Project Questions · 4
  7. 13:30 Audiology Services (Rural Areas) Questions · 8
  8. 13:30 Scotland Together Fund Questions · 4
  9. 13:30 Police Officers (Non-crime Demand) Questions · 4
  10. 13:30 Gynaecology Services (Waiting Times) Questions · 6
  11. 13:30 Public Procurement (Small and Medium-sized Enterprises) Questions · 5
  12. 13:59 Remembrance Sunday Questions · 9
  13. 14:04 Party Leaders First Minister’s Questions · 2
  14. 14:04 Alexander Dennis Ltd (Furlough) First Minister’s Questions · 11
  15. 14:04 Scotland’s Oil Sector First Minister’s Questions · 11
  16. 14:04 Data Centres First Minister’s Questions · 12
  17. 14:04 Rosebank Oil and Gas Field First Minister’s Questions · 11
  18. 14:04 Firefighters (Vacancies) First Minister’s Questions · 9
  19. 14:39 Safeguarding and Protecting Children Statement · 30
  20. 15:11 Strengthening Scotland’s Bus Network Debate · 108
  21. 17:03 Decision Time Decision time · 41
  22. 17:18 World Diabetes Day 2026 Members’ business · 19

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.