I am grateful for the opportunity to have this issue discussed in the chamber. The first principle of policing is not complicated. Sir Robert Peel’s model was built on prevention of crime and disorder, the maintenance of public order and the protection of the public. Police legitimacy comes from doing those things effectively, with the consent of the public. However, in Scotland, that basic purpose has become blurred.
Police Scotland is increasingly expected to be a mental health service, a social work service and, under new housing legislation, even part of the homelessness prevention system. That is not right. Yes, those issues matter, but that does not make them policing responsibilities. The police must have the ability to say, “This is not our role,” and other services must step up to the mark, because those added burdens are putting immense strain on police resources, especially front-line resources.
HM Inspectorate of Constabulary in Scotland found that, at times, at least half of deployable front-line uniformed officers—which is a smaller number than the total number of police officers—were dealing with mental health-related calls. Its conclusion was blunt:
“Police Scotland is filling gaps in the health and social care system”.
Figures that have subsequently been given to Parliament are extraordinary. The number of mental health-related calls rose from just under 400 a day in 2018 to 666 a day in 2024. The officer time absorbed was calculated to be the equivalent of 612 full-time officers. That is police capacity on a massive scale being taken away from preventing and investigating crime, patrolling communities and responding to victims.
The chief constable herself now says that that “cannot continue”. In her submission of 16 September, Jo Farrell said that Police Scotland recorded more than 230,000 mental health-related incidents in 2025-26—around 18 per cent of all incidents—and that approximately 85 per cent of those incidents involved no crime. She said that policing’s role had grown
“beyond what is best for vulnerable people, what is intended in legislation and what is financially and operationally sustainable”.
So, why are police officers still going to these calls? Part of the answer to that question is mission creep. The Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Act 2012, which gave birth to Police Scotland, says that the main purpose of policing is to improve the
“safety and well-being of persons … and communities”.
That is an unusually broad statutory formulation. Elsewhere in the United Kingdom, the core legal duties of police remain much more closely centred on protecting life and property, preserving order, preventing offences and bringing offenders to justice. In Scotland, the idea of wellbeing has helped to blur the boundary, and has expanded over time. I do not doubt that the use of that wording was well-intentioned. However, in practice, it has helped to create an open-ended expectation that the police will pick up whatever other public services cannot or will not deal with. It has contributed to a culture in which the police become the service of first and last resort whenever another public service cannot cope.
Another part of the reason is risk aversion. Officers are understandably concerned about the consequences for them personally of making the wrong judgment call, leaving a person in crisis, putting the phone down or deciding that there is no more that they can do to help. That is not healthy. Officers are being asked to do work that they were not trained for and did not sign up for and which properly belongs to other services. We do not expect doctors or nurses to tackle crime. Why, then, do we expect police officers to respond to mental health incidents?
This situation cannot go on. If somebody is committing a crime or poses an immediate threat to life or serious harm, or if police powers are needed, the police must act. Mental illness alone should not turn a person into a police matter.
The minister who is responding to the debate needs to answer three questions. First, will she redefine the boundary of policing in Scotland so that health, social care and housing responsibilities sit with the professionals who are trained to deliver them? Secondly, will she review section 32 of the 2012 act and clarify that wellbeing does not create an open-ended welfare duty for Police Scotland? Thirdly, when will front-line officers see the benefit of any changes to their responsibilities?
While ministers talk about collaboration, police resources are being consumed, crime is rising, victims are left waiting and visible policing is disappearing. The police cannot be everybody else’s emergency stop.
There is one fundamental question that the minister should address in her response to the debate: where does policing end? If the Government cannot define that boundary, mission creep will continue to occur, front-line capacity, which is already stretched, will continue to disappear and police officers will spend less and less time doing what we all want to see Police Scotland doing: preventing crime, protecting the public and pursuing those who break the law.