Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 17 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Hyperscale Data Centres

First Minister’s Question Time

Thursday 17 September 2026 Meeting of the Parliament About 14:01 First Minister’s Questions 6 contributions · 2 speakers Watch on Scottish Parliament TV

This is the draft Official Report. The final version may differ.

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

6 contributions
Ross Greer Green West Scotland
link

I pass on the Scottish Greens’ condolences to Cathie Craigie’s family and her friends in the Labour Party. Her work in establishing a register of landlords in Scotland started an important journey, which the Parliament is still on, to protect those in this country who rent their home, and it has made a real difference to people across the country.

I start by congratulating the community groups across the country whose campaign against hyperscale data centres has forced the Scottish Government to act. There is still some confusion, however, over what the Government’s position now is. Ministers say that they will produce new guidance for councils by Christmas. That is welcome—it is what the Greens called for. However, ministers have also said that no decisions will be taken before then.

I struggle to reconcile that with the reality of the timeline. The proposals for data centres for Larbert, Greenock and Auchtertool could all be decided before then. The deadline for determination on the Larbert application is 4 October, and the developers in Greenock are working towards a deadline in November. The Scottish Government has said categorically that no decisions should be made before the guidance is produced, at Christmas. Has it, therefore, instructed Inverclyde, Falkirk and Fife councils to pause their determination of those live applications?

John Swinney SNP The First Minister · Perthshire North
link

We do not anticipate that any applications will be determined by planning authorities before our planning guidance is issued later this year.

Ross Greer Green West Scotland
link

I struggle to reconcile what ministers said yesterday with what they voted for and what the First Minister has just said today. I and the Greens, and communities across the country who were celebrating last night because they thought that there was a pause—a formal pause—are trying to accept the Government’s position in good faith. However, MSPs across this Parliament left the chamber last night confused because they could not reconcile what ministers said with what they voted for.

The Minister for Business and Fair Work said that no decisions are expected before Christmas, based on discussion with council officials—that is similar to what the First Minister has just said. However, there is nothing in the public domain to confirm that. Today, the Falkirk Council website still has the deadline for the determination of the Larbert application as 4 October. Is the First Minister saying that, if a decision on any hyperscale data centre is made before Christmas, which some councils are still on the record as intending to do, the Government will step in, stop that and make the final decision itself, based on the new guidance that it is producing?

John Swinney SNP The First Minister · Perthshire North
link

As I said in my first answer, we do not anticipate that any applications will be determined by planning authorities before the planning guidance is issued, later this year. Through the notification direction that we issued during the summer, we are closely monitoring live applications and their intended timescales for determination, hence the statement that I just made to Parliament.

Although Scottish ministers have call-in powers, we use them sparingly, recognising and respecting the important role of local authorities in making decisions in their areas. We can, however, take steps to call in any application where that is necessary and deemed to be a matter of national importance.

Ministers can also recall any planning appeal rather than have the decision made by the Scottish Government reporter, and we have used that power recently in relation to the live planning appeal for a data centre in Edinburgh. I hope that that provides the clarity that Ross Greer is seeking.

Ross Greer Green West Scotland
link

The First Minister’s answer does not provide clarity. It hints at something—it strongly hints that the Government would be willing to recall those decisions—and I welcome that in good faith. However, I say again that Falkirk Council still states that the determination deadline is 4 October. The Government’s private discussions with local councils appear to be quite different from what is currently on the public record. That needs to be reconciled if our communities are to have confidence in the process.

It is welcome that we have President Connolly of Ireland here in Scotland this week, not just for her leadership on solidarity with the people of Palestine, but because Ireland is a stark example of what happens when greedy technology companies are allowed to build whatever they want. A third of Ireland’s entire domestic energy supply goes to powering data centres, but that pales in comparison with what is proposed for Scotland. The first 24 applications here would require one and a half times our entire national energy demand. Our Parliament was warned, earlier this week, that that could push up energy bills. That is exactly what has happened in Ireland. Because of data centres, the energy bills of consumers and households in Ireland have gone up by the equivalent of £300 a year. Councils cannot take that issue into account when making piecemeal decisions on individual applications. Therefore, will the guidance that the First Minister’s Government is producing include a clear national strategy on how much of our electricity supply can be used by hyperscale data centres before they damage our climate and push up our energy bills?

John Swinney SNP The First Minister · Perthshire North
link

The national guidance will set out all the relevant issues that have to be taken into account in the determination of applications. To reiterate one of the points that I made earlier, I state that, through the notification direction that we issued during the summer, we are closely monitoring live applications and the intended timescales for their determination.

Mr Greer raised the role of tech companies. The Government insisted, in its amendment yesterday, that there has to be regulation in the space around tech companies. That was a central part of the Government’s amendment to the Green motion last night. I am pleased that the Government’s amendment was carried, because it strengthens the representations that my Government can make to the United Kingdom Government to ensure that we are pressing for the appropriate regulatory environment, given the concerns that have been expressed over the weekend, particularly about tech companies. I was a bit surprised that the Greens abstained on that particular vote at the end of the debate, because that regulation is necessary. It is at the centre of the concerns that my Cabinet is wrestling with about violence against women and girls, as, because of the online environment, there is a greater need for regulation. As we make progress on some of those questions, there are big issues for us to wrestle with, and I hope that the Greens will be partners with us in that respect.

As Mr Greer made reference to the presence of President Connolly, I note that it was an absolute pleasure for my wife and I to welcome President Connolly and her husband to Scotland yesterday. President Connolly represents outstanding leadership in the world. She is a voice for peace, for dialogue and for respect. She has much to say to Scotland, and Scotland is listening very carefully to what she has to say.

  1. 12:30 General Question Time Questions · 1
  2. 12:30 Royal Mail (Festive Season) Questions · 6
  3. 12:30 Cladding Remediation Programme Questions · 8
  4. 12:30 AI Data Centres (Guidance) Questions · 10
  5. 12:30 NEET Statistics Questions · 8
  6. 12:30 Youth Unemployment Questions · 10
  7. 12:30 Additional Dwelling Supplement (Repayment Period) Questions · 5
  8. 12:30 Bus Fare Cap (Dundee and Tayside) Questions · 10
  9. 12:30 Childcare (Rural Areas) Questions · 7
  10. 14:01 Party Leaders First Minister’s Questions · 2
  11. 14:01 Government Priorities First Minister’s Questions · 8
  12. 14:01 Scottish Government Scrutiny First Minister’s Questions · 8
  13. 14:01 Hyperscale Data Centres First Minister’s Questions · 6
  14. 14:01 Independence Referendum First Minister’s Questions · 10
  15. 14:01 Thirlwall Inquiry First Minister’s Questions · 5
  16. 14:36 Programme for International Student Assessment 2025 Statement · 43
  17. 15:09 Health Misinformation Debate · 51
  18. 17:06 Ferguson Marine Statement · 35
  19. 17:36 Decision Time Decision time · 20
  20. 17:46 Policing, Crime Prevention and Mental Health (Mid Scotland and Fife) Members’ business · 33

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.