The next item on our agenda is consideration of a draft Scottish statutory instrument that has been laid under the affirmative procedure, which means that it requires approval by resolution of the Parliament before it can become law. The purpose of the instrument is to increase the value of payments for personal care and nursing care by 2.23 per cent. The Delegated Powers and Law Reform Committee considered the instrument at its meeting on 3 February 2026 and made no recommendations in relation to it.We will have an evidence session on the instrument with the Minister for Social Care and Mental Wellbeing and supporting officials. Once any questions have been answered, we will proceed to a formal debate on the motion. I welcome Tom Arthur, the Minister for Social Care and Mental Wellbeing, and the following Scottish Government officials: Christina McLaren, unit head for fair work in adult social care; and Ian Turner, deputy director for the adult social care workforce and fair work.I invite the minister to make a brief opening statement.
Tom ArthurSNPThe Minister for Social Care and Mental Wellbeing · Renfrewshire South
Good morning. I thank the committee for the opportunity to speak about a proposed amendment to the Community Care (Personal Care and Nursing Care) (Scotland) Regulations 2002.The draft regulations will make routine annual increases to the rates for free personal and nursing care. The payments help to cover the cost of those services for self-funding adults in residential care. This year, we are again proposing to apply an uplift based on the gross domestic product deflator, which has been used historically as the inflation measure to increase the rates. That means that the weekly payment rates for personal care for self-funders will rise from £254.60 to £260.30 and that the nursing care component will rise from £114.55 to £117.10.The most recently available official statistics show that a reported 10,920 self-funding residents aged 18 and above were in receipt of free personal and nursing care payments in 2024-25. Those residents should all benefit from the changes.
I have a couple of questions. I declare an interest as a practising national health service general practitioner.First, have you engaged with providers to see whether the uplift will actually cover the costs?
As you will understand and appreciate, we have on-going engagement with providers. When taking such decisions, we must balance a range of considerations relating to the overall affordability of public finances. As we have done in previous years, we have taken the approach, through the regulations, of basing the inflation uplift on the GDP deflator. Ultimately, wider considerations are for providers and residents who have a contract with those providers.
I understand how you have come up with that figure, but my question was not about that. I asked whether you have engaged with providers to see whether the uplift will actually cover the cost of care.
I appreciate that there will be a range of circumstances, depending on the provider. We have wider engagement, but, in this specific case, we are making a contribution by providing an inflation uplift based on the GDP deflator.I do not know whether Christina McLaren wants to come in.11:00
A working group works with us every year on the process for such regulations. Scottish Care is part of that group, alongside COSLA and other local authority representatives, so a wide range of interests are represented. We are comfortable with the process that we have gone through and the arrangements that we have made.
Funding for the uplift will be committed. Ultimately, the level of funding will depend on overall uptake, but funding will be provided to ensure that the uplift can be delivered.
The formula is based on analysis of what we expect uptake to be in the coming year. The allocation will cover that, and there is on-going dialogue to ensure that the numbers meet the figures that we transfer to local authorities for the uplift. In all previous years, take-up has been less than the amount that we have allocated.
They are obliged to use the money for everyone who claims it as part of the financial assessment in relation to the overall picture of how someone pays for their care.
It is usually a very small amount of money, so we are pretty sure that the funding is accurate. There is on-going discussion with COSLA, but I am not aware that the money goes back to the Scottish Government.
There have been significant increases in the cost of delivering personal and nursing care, so any increase in funding is valuable and welcome. Minister, you indicated the potential financial constraints on delivering any more funding. My worry is that not delivering more funding is a false economy, because the costs will appear on another page of the ledger if we do not get this right. What work has been done, not just on this specific issue but across the wider portfolio, to assess the impact of not delivering what could be delivered?
On the broader question about financial viability, there is on-going close engagement with providers and health and social care partnerships. On this specific measure, as well as the inflation uplift this year, there have been above-inflation uplifts in recent years, in recognition of the pressures and challenges that exist. We recognise that there are financial challenges for providers, but we operate in a very pressurised environment regarding public finances, so we must balance a range of priorities. In doing so, we are providing additional funding through the uplift for the coming year.
Do you agree that, by investing in social care, we could prevent much more costly interventions, including hospital interventions? There is an issue in how we balance funding and how we measure the outcomes from inputs.
I do not disagree with your point about the value of investment in social care. Investment in social care is of tremendous benefit and value for the individuals who receive social care and for the wider health and social care system. Much of the longer-term strategic work that has been undertaken, and on which I think there is broad political consensus, is in recognition of the value of social care and ensuring that—notwithstanding the significant challenges that we operate under with regard to the public finances—we are working constructively to ensure that enough resource is going into the system.In the budget that is making its way through the Parliament, there is an increase in investment in health and social care—specifically social care—and local government. There is broad recognition and shared understanding of the value of social care and the importance of investment in it.
We move on to agenda item four, which is the formal debate on the instrument on which we took evidence. I remind the committee that officials may not speak in the debate.I believe that Sandesh Gulhane wishes to make a point before we move to the debate.
Okay. I call the minister to move and speak to motion S6M-20534.Motion moved,That the Health, Social Care and Sport Committee recommends that the Community Care (Personal Care and Nursing Care) (Scotland) Amendment Regulations 2026 draft be approved.—Tom Arthur
I declare an interest as a practising NHS GP.I support the principle behind the instrument. Personal and nursing care are fundamental for dignity in later life and uprating payments is necessary and welcome. However, we must be honest about the pressures that are facing the sector. Care providers are dealing with rising workforce costs, energy bills, insurance premiums and regulatory requirements. The question is not whether an uplift is appropriate but whether it is sufficient. If it fails, the consequences do not sit quietly in our social care sector; they present as delayed discharge, hospital pressures and workforce instability.The minister said that it was not possible to increase the payments for social care above the GDP deflator because of budgetary pressures, but then £149 million was found for resident doctors, £36 million for rolling out GP walk-in centres that GPs say will not work and £30 million was found for an NHS app that will not be rolled out until 2030 and, as we are talking specifically about social care, £30 million has been spent on a national care service that has not been delivered. Those are concerns. We should be putting money into personal care and ensuring that it is free, because that is what was said.
As I said earlier, I recognise the importance and value of investment in social care, in and of itself as a good, and a deliverer of high-quality services to individuals, and also because of its importance as part of the overall functioning of our health and social care system.We operate in a challenging and pressurised environment for public finances. In recent years, across multiple sectors, challenges have ensued from economic and fiscal turbulence. That is well understood and well documented. We are committed to engaging constructively with providers and local partners to ensure that we can maximise the resource that is available in the system.Ultimately, it is for any member to engage with the budget process in the Parliament if they wish to make representations to the Government for additional resources.
My concerns are similar to those of my colleague Sandesh Gulhane. At the end of the day, I will vote in favour of approving the instrument because any uplift is crucial. However, what we are discussing is in no way reflective of what is required. As has been rehearsed by my colleague, huge amounts of money have been spent in other areas. If we are going to tackle the issues in social care and the connections with delayed discharge and prevent people from having to go into hospital care, we are going to have to think about it much more seriously than we currently are.I will vote for the uplift, but I want to put those comments on record, because I do not think that the measures provide nearly what we need to do to tackle the issues that we have at the moment.
I recognise the points that committee members have made with regard to the financial pressures that we are all operating under, and I welcome members’ support for the instrument.
The question is, that motion S6M-20534 be agreed to.Motion agreed to,That the Health, Social Care and Sport Committee recommends that the Community Care (Personal Care and Nursing Care) (Scotland) Amendment Regulations 2026 draft be approved.
That concludes consideration of the instrument. I suspend the meeting to allow for a changeover of supporting officials.11:10Meeting suspended.11:17On resuming—
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.