link
The next item is consideration of a proposed draft order. I put on record that I am a registered mental health nurse and a bank staff nurse with NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde.The proposed draft order must be laid before Parliament for a 60-day period, together with a statement of reasons for proposing to proceed by remedial order rather than by other means.Ministers are proposing to make a remedial order under section 12 of the Convention Rights (Compliance) (Scotland) Act 2001. That power allows the Scottish ministers to make remedial orders to remedy an incompatibility with convention rights.12:00The purpose of the proposed draft order is to address the judgment in X v Mental Health Tribunal for Scotland 2022 CSOH 78, which held that the tribunal’s lack of power to specify recorded matters for patients subject to a compulsion order amounted to “unjustified discrimination” under article 14 of the European convention on human rights. Following the ruling, the Scottish ministers concluded that amendments to the Mental Health (Care and Treatment) (Scotland) Act 2003 were necessary to ensure compliance with article 14 of the convention.The statement of reasons accompanying the proposed draft order states:“Scottish Ministers consider that a Remedial Order under the general procedure is the most appropriate and proportionate means of remedying the legislative defect, ensuring equality of treatment for civil and forensic patients while maintaining safeguards and flexibility within the mental health system.”The Delegated Powers and Law Reform Committee considered the proposed draft order on 10 February and noted a number of points in relation to it.As members do not have any comments to make, I propose that the committee notes the proposed draft order but does not make any recommendations in relation to it. Are members content with that?Members indicated agreement.