The next item on our agenda is also with the Minister for Public Finance, who is joined by Scottish Government officials Cara Woods, senior policy adviser on aggregates and landfill taxes, and Laura Wilkinson, lawyer. I welcome our witnesses and invite the minister to make a short opening statement.
The Scottish Government’s intended introduction date for the Scottish aggregates tax is 1 April 2026. When it is introduced, Revenue Scotland, Scotland’s tax authority for devolved taxes, will be responsible for the collection and management of the Scottish aggregates tax.As part of on-going work to commence the Aggregates Tax and Devolved Taxes Administration (Scotland) Act 2024, the Scottish Aggregates Tax (Applicable Rate of Tax) Regulations 2026 make the required provision for the practical application of the Scottish aggregates tax. The regulations provide that, from 1 April 2026, the applicable rate of tax will be £2.16 per tonne of taxable aggregate.The Scottish aggregates tax rate in 2026 will align with the United Kingdom aggregates levy rate for the same year. That approach will ensure stability and certainty during the transfer of power. The decision was influenced by the block grant adjustment process and it has enabled agreement on a novel method for setting the Scottish aggregates tax block grant adjustment baseline, which reduces risk to the Scottish budget.I am happy to take questions.
In 2016-17, the tax was £2 per tonne and it is now £2.16 per tonne. That is 8 per cent more than it was a decade ago, but prices have inflated by 41.5 per cent during that period so less tax is being raised proportionately.I note that the Scottish Fiscal Commission forecasts that the tax will raise £42 million in 2026-27. As you know, minister, committee members visited a place in Pumpherston that recycles aggregates and were told that moving aggregates is so expensive because the lorry, fuel and driver all have to be paid for, but that company does not even sell to Edinburgh. So, I do not understand why you are maintaining the same price as down south. If it was put up from £2.16 to £3.24 per tonne, that would generate another £21 million per year in revenue. People who are involved in recycling have said to us that that would boost investment in the recycling of aggregates.
Those are fair points, convener, and that will be a valid conversation for us to have next year. The point of keeping the tax rate at the same as the UK’s this year is to give us the data that would allow us to calculate the block grant adjustment. Without that, we would not have a level baseline that would allow us to understand what the block grant adjustment should be as we transfer the tax from UK to Scottish management.
I understand what you are saying, but we have had a couple of years to work that out. It has been a long time since the issue was before the committee. It just seems that we are missing an opportunity to stimulate investment in recycling and generate additional taxation, given that there is no likelihood of anyone saying that, because it is an extra £1 per tonne, they will ship the aggregate an extra 50 miles, with all the costs that that would incur.I understand what you said about the block grant adjustment, but I wonder why the Government is being so timid about this.
That is not the issue. As I said, that will be a perfectly valid conversation to have next year, but the issue this year is that, if we were to have different rates of tax, it would make it difficult to agree what the block grant adjustment should be to enable the tax to be transferred in the first place.
I would have thought that, at this time, a couple of years after the committee went through all this, we would know the amount of aggregate that is being used in Scotland and its movements.I will let colleagues come in. John Mason is first, to be followed by Liz Smith.
I was interested in what the convener was saying. Looking at the impact assessments, when we first discussed the bill, the situation was thought to be more difficult for island communities because they do not have the same choice about where they get aggregates.We are told that“No new impacts have been identified for Island Communities”,but perhaps there were existing impacts that could be dealt with. Has it been suggested that we could consider different rates for the islands?09:15
I will let my officials talk about the specifics of that, but, as I said, the policy intent this year—and the purpose of the regulations—is to set the tax at the same rate as that for the rest of the UK to give us a BGA baseline. Next year, there will be scope to look at varying the rate and other factors that could impact on that.My officials might be able to say a bit more.
We engaged with stakeholders, including aggregates industry bodies, representatives of the recycling sector, the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities and tax professionals, on setting the tax rate, as that was a key issue during the parliamentary scrutiny of the bill. They supported the Scottish aggregates tax initially being aligned with the UK aggregates levy to avoid complexity, added costs to business and issues of competitiveness.We also asked them about a variation in rates within Scotland, and their view was that, with other taxes such as the landfill tax, variation in rates within Scotland could cause issues such as waste tourism. A variation in rates might make people look for different ways to circumvent having to pay the tax. There was a view that, if the rate was lower in one part of Scotland, some companies might make sure that their business was done in that area. They would find ways to get round having to pay more tax.
I understand the logic that we should keep things steady this year, but it would be worth looking at varying the rate for the islands in the future. We know from the evidence that we took that it is very expensive to move aggregates around, so it is unlikely that people would take aggregates on a ferry to or from the islands. I will not be here next year, but perhaps someone in my place will ask that question.Under “Impact Assessments”, there are two separate paragraphs on sustainable development. One of them is very brief. It says:“The instrument will have no impact on sustainable development.”The other one is a bit longer. It ends by saying:“the instrument will have no impact on sustainable development, and no adverse effects on the environment.”This follows on from the convener’s question and, again, it is perhaps more of a question for next year. If there was a higher rate, that might have an impact on the environment, because people would use more recycled and less new material.
Those are valid considerations for us to look at as we move into next year. We will be in the position of having a level BGA, which will enable us to make decisions about how we can adapt the policy for the Scottish context. I have no doubt that you will be here in spirit if not physically, Mr Mason.
Like Mr Mason and the convener, I understand the logic of keeping the tax in line with the aggregates levy in the first year because of the complexity of the BGA adjustment. I get that. However, if it is the case that people in the sector are arguing, for the reasons that the convener set out, that they might want the tax to increase in years to come, is that not also a reason for considering different rates in different parts of Scotland? The logic is that, if there are different elasticities of demand between England and Scotland, there will also be different elasticities of demand between different parts of Scotland. Will the Government examine that?
Yes, indeed. We will look at that when we come to set the aggregates tax next year, as we do with other taxes in the budget. At that point, we will be able to take a perspective on the issue that you have raised.
This point follows on from the one that was made about the views of the different organisations that the Government will have engaged with.I wonder whether it would be helpful, in the interests of transparency, for policy notes such as this to give a very brief summary of the extent to which the Government has been lobbied by vested interests on any of these issues and whether, for example, there was a difference of view between those economically active in the industry and those seeking a policy objective such as sustainable development.
I think that any engagement and discussions that were had would be a matter of public record. Depending on the group, those minutes might have already been published or will be otherwise available, so I think that we would be very comfortable with sharing them.
A lot of that information will, ultimately, be publicly available, but it will take a lot of hunting down, whereas a brief summary in the policy note would give a little bit more transparency and let the Government say who has been pushing in this or that direction.
Thank you.Ms Woods talked about waste tourism. Where is the evidence for that? I mentioned earlier a company that we visited in Pumpherston that does not think it is viable to sell even to Edinburgh, which is only a few miles away. Given the cost of loading a lorry with aggregate, putting fuel in it and hiring a driver, and given the time taken to ship it from A to B, I have to ask: where is the elasticity? When does it become uncompetitive relative to south of the border? I just do not see how that argument works if we are talking about an extra £1 or £2, or even a fiver per tonne. In fact, I would not suggest a fiver per tonne, having thought about the impact on customers with regard to the spend on building, local authorities fixing roads and so on.We have to look at the other side of the equation. Where is the elasticity? I just do not see any argument whatsoever for that. I know that some aggregates are shipped by boat, but what work has the Scottish Government done to look at that, so that, next year—if we have to go through this again—the tax is fixed at the optimal level that benefits Scotland by encouraging investment in renewables while not impacting too adversely on the client base and those who are extracting?
As I have said, the Government’s position is that, this year, we are setting the tax at the same rate as the rest of the UK, so that we get that BGA baseline. The decisions on the tax next year will take into account all the factors that the convener and other members have raised with regard to the assessment—
From memory, no. But, as I have said, the policy decision that has been made this year is in relation to the BGA baseline. Next year, we will absolutely consider all the factors that the committee has raised, as you would expect, when we make decisions on what level to set the aggregates tax at.
As there are no more questions, we will turn to formal consideration of the motion on the instrument. I invite the minister to speak to and move motion S6M-20364.Motion moved,That the Finance and Public Administration Committee recommends that the Scottish Aggregates Tax (Applicable Rate of Tax) Regulations 2026 draft be approved.—Ivan McKeeMotion agreed to.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.