Item 5 is an evidence-taking session with the minister, Ivan McKee, on the Scottish Landfill Tax (Administration) Amendment Regulations 2026. For this last session, the minister is joined by the following Scottish Government officials: Jonathan Waite, aggregates tax bill team leader, and—once again—Laura Wilkinson, lawyer. I welcome Jonathan to the meeting and invite the minister to make a short opening statement.
These amendment regulations remove entitlement to tax credit for new qualifying contributions to the Scottish landfill communities fund from 1 April 2026. From that point, the fund will enter a managed wind-down period of up to 24 months. The regulations include clear transitional projections, and all contributions made before 1 April 2026 will remain qualifying, will continue to attract tax credit and will be spent on community and environmental projects, as intended.Throughout the wind-down period, Revenue Scotland and the Scottish Environment Protection Agency will continue to administer and regulate the scheme, ensuring continuity of oversight until the fund is formally closed. Members may wish to note that the decision to close the fund followed a public consultation in 2025 and extensive engagement with Revenue Scotland and SEPA. The regulations will ensure that an orderly and responsible conclusion to the fund will fully meet existing commitments.I am happy to take questions.
Thank you very much for that opening statement, minister. According to the business and regulatory impact assessment, Scottish landfill tax revenues have declined from £149 million in 2015-16 to £56 million in 2024-25, and contributions to the Scottish landfill communities fund have halved over the past decade and are estimated to amount to around £1.4 million. That is why, because of the associated costs of administering the fund in future years, they will breach legally permitted limits. Can you tell us what those legally permitted limits are?
They are associated with the costs to SEPA, which is the regulator of the fund, for the regulation team in SEPA. There are also administration costs for approved bodies that distribute the funds to community organisations. So, there are two levels of administration, in a sense.
Sorry—I am not sure how that answers my question. I asked what the legally permitted limits are, and you talked about them without saying what the costs are in pounds, shillings and pence.
The reason I ask is that, next year, the fund will be £1.4 million, which, for many community organisations, is still a substantial sum of money. It would be helpful to know how much is being used to administer the fund, because the whole idea behind the instrument is that the fund is becoming less viable. It would give members an opportunity to assess what they feel. The fund is very geographic—we know that. Not everywhere in Scotland can apply for it. That clearly means that it disproportionately benefits certain communities, and they might be somewhat aggrieved if the fund is closed and not replaced.
I do not want to quote a percentage, because I do not have the exact percentage for SEPA, but if the SEPA regulation costs were capped at 10 per cent and SEPA has a fixed number of staff for the fund, there could be a situation where the fund becomes really small. If you have a £1 million fund and the SEPA percentage can be only 10 per cent of that fund, SEPA cannot employ enough staff to do the regulation for £100,000. That is the issue that you run into.
Some of the responses that we have received say that there will be less support for local infrastructure, environmental accessibility and community engagement projects. The most frequently cited concern is that community-led initiatives will be lost—for example,“play areas, skate parks, youth clubs and educational programmes.”Respondents also expressed concern that that will“disproportionately affect communities that are already experiencing social-economic disadvantage.”Given that that is the case, what will happen to the money that is not being allocated to those community organisations? Will it go into the general tax fund? Is the Scottish Government thinking of an alternative fund, so that organisations that would be disadvantaged by the removal of the fund can still look to receive funding?
On the fund, it is important to recognise—officials can keep me right here—that the operators themselves benefit from the tax advantage. Many of them are signalling that they would not want to take part in the fund because, from their perspective, it does not add up commercially, even with the tax benefits that are in place. The size of the fund would reduce significantly—much more significantly than has already been indicated—with those operators not being part of it any more.Obviously, the fund will have to be wound up at some point, because, as you have indicated, the amount of revenue coming from landfill tax continues to reduce. We have reached the tipping point whereby, if the operators are not supporting the fund any more, it starts to not be viable any more.
Will there be a gap? I think that folk would be concerned if the fund ended and there was nothing else put in place to replace it for a year or two, because it could mean that projects that local community organisations might have been working on for months, if not years, would not proceed.
On that point, it would be helpful if the Government considered that, because it strikes me that the fund is being closed largely for economic reasons, whereas those who have expressed their concerns to the committee are looking at the social impact—particularly if, as the convener said, their projects relate to youth engagement in the local community and so on. Those projects have a very important impact when it comes to stimulating community engagement, particularly if they are in a disadvantaged area. Losing them is a potential problem, so it would be very helpful if the Government was to consider introducing a replacement fund in order to ensure that infrastructure provision is not lost altogether.
I wonder whether the issue goes a little bit deeper than the need for a replacement fund. This is a problem that arises due to the purpose of environmental taxes. If you levy an environmental tax with the purpose of changing behaviour or reducing environmental harm, you should not rely on it as a future on-going source of revenue, because, if it is successful in achieving its environmental objective, the revenue will inevitably go down and, ideally, disappear completely, because you will have eradicated the environmental harm.In its overall tax strategy, should the Scottish Government not follow the principle that, where it is using environmental taxes to achieve an environmental objective and is getting some benefit, for the time being, from the revenue, there must be a plan to shift the tax base to other forms of environmental harm as that revenue declines? The presumption should be that that will, at least, be explored. As the projected reduction in revenue is expected, the Government should look at shifting the tax base to other forms of environmental harm, in order to achieve more environmental good while also sustaining revenues.
I think that there already is such a principle. The projections, whether they are from the medium-term financial strategy or whatever, show that the revenues from the tax were expected to reduce over a number of years. It is absolutely the case that that will have been factored into the longer-term calculations for tax and spend, and it is clearly compensated in the round by decisions that are taken on other taxes. Everyone knew that that was the situation. The numbers would have been planned over the medium term, and those taking other tax policy decisions would have done so while fully cognisant of that fact.On the other side, it is clear that it would have been known that the fund’s community benefit would not continue forever. Everybody would have been well aware of its time-limited nature. At the outset, the question was, “Do you want to take the community benefit for that period of time, or do you want to take no community benefit?” Clearly, the answer was that they would take the community benefit for a period of time.
Are you saying that the Government has already considered alternative forms of environmental harm on to which the tax base could be shifted, to ensure that there is sustained revenue in the future? What alternatives have been under consideration?
What I said is that it was considered as tax policy in the round. When we calculate tax revenue in the future, the fact that this tax is tapering down will be factored into the numbers and projections.
My suggestion was that the Government’s tax strategy should look specifically at environmental taxes, which are, by definition, not intended to be permanent sources of revenue, and shift the tax base from one form of environmental harm to another in order to maximise the benefit and revenue.
I hear what you are saying, but tax policy is considered in the round—we look at total revenue versus total spend and do not have a separate line for environmental taxes per se. We consider each environmental tax on the basis of the behavioural change that we are driving, the impact that it will have on revenue and its longevity, rather than starting with a number and basing our policy on that. We start with the policy and work it that way round.
If you put up the aggregates tax by £1 a tonne, that would generate £20 million—more than enough to cover any loss. So, when you get around to making that change next year, some of that money can go to those communities.Before I let in John Mason, I will give Revenue Scotland a wee advertisement. This week, I am sponsoring an exhibition for it at the bottom of the members’ block in the Parliament. Revenue Scotland estimates that administering the Building Safety Levy (Scotland) Bill will cost around 1 per cent of the revenue collected, which I expect to be more complex than this tax. Perhaps some thought should be given to transferring the responsibility of the fund to Revenue Scotland, with SEPA perhaps providing some oversight. Perhaps that would save a few bob.
As others were speaking, a thought came to my mind. Presumably, the idea of the fund was to, in some way, compensate communities that live adjacent to a landfill site—including in my area, as the minister probably knows—for the upset, smell and so on that they have suffered. I take Patrick Harvie’s point that the tax would always be time limited, so the grant was a one-off in many ways. However, the timing does not quite match, because money will stop going into the fund this April but the landfill site will still operate. Even if it closes, which is what the community wants to happen, it will still give off gas for many years into the future. The suffering of the local community, if you like, will continue even after the landfill site stops operating. I am not asking for a commitment right now, but I would like that to be factored in by the Government if it considers transitional relief or something like that.
I think that I asked this question earlier, but I do not remember getting a response. Will the money that no longer goes to the community organisations just go into the Scottish consolidated fund?
If you are not giving the money—£1 million or £1.4 million a year, or whatever it happens to be—to community organisations, will it go into the general fund?
Officials can keep me right on this. To be clear, the money that comes into the fund would be spent through the fund. No more money would come into the fund, because a tax benefit would incentivise companies to put money into it. With many of them opting out of contributions through that mechanism, that money would remain with Revenue Scotland rather than going into the fund.
Yes. The landfill site operators, as taxpayers, have an option to contribute to the fund. If they did not contribute to the fund, they would just pay 100 per cent of their landfill tax liability. At the moment, a number contribute, but, if they chose not to do so, all the money would just come to Revenue Scotland and the Scottish consolidated fund and not go into the separate communities fund.
Thank you very much for that.No member has any comments on the Scottish Landfill Tax (Administration) Amendment Regulations 2026, and no member has recommended annulment. Therefore, do members agree not to make any further recommendations in relation to the instrument?Members indicated agreement.
Although the committee is not required to report on a negative instrument, it can do so if it wishes to draw attention to any issues that have been discussed. We will, no doubt, discuss that in our private session.That was the last item on our public agenda, so I will now move the meeting into private. We will have a five-minute break to allow the minister, his officials, broadcasting and the official report to leave.09:40Meeting continued in private until 10:44.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.