To ask the Scottish Government what its position is on whether there should be parity of access to justice for all former patients affected by the actions of Sam Eljamel, regardless of whether treatment was received through NHS Tayside or privately. (S7O-00018)
Angela ConstanceSNPThe Cabinet Secretary for Health and Care · Almond Valley
The Scottish Government expects any legal cases raised by former patients of Eljamel to be considered fairly and on a case-by-case basis. All claims brought by former patients will ultimately be determined by the courts. The judicial process in Scotland is independent and ministers do not have the power to instruct private companies or entities in relation to their approach to litigation. However, Scottish courts have discretion to disapply the time bar when it is equitable to do so.
I thank the cabinet secretary for her understanding of the issue. The time bar was set aside by NHS Tayside, which is allowing victims to have the chance of justice. Will the cabinet secretary meet me, victims and Willie Rennie MSP to discuss how we can get to the bottom of the legal culpability relating to the private patients and to ensure that we can make the case that the same should be done, with the time bar being set aside, to allow those patients who have suffered over a period of decades to access justice?
I appreciate the member’s advocacy for the former patients of Sam Eljamel. He raised a point of principle that I am sure the chamber will understand.
The Scottish Government was very encouraged by NHS Tayside’s decision in February this year to reset the time bar for former patients. It is for independent care providers to determine whether to plead the time bar, but it is important that Mr Marra has had the opportunity to put his concerns and his appeal on behalf of his constituents on the parliamentary record. The courts retain discretion to set aside time limits when it is equitable to do so, which ensures that cases can be considered fairly on their individual merits.
Although my powers are limited in that regard, I do not think that it will cause any harm to have a discussion with Michael Marra and Willie Rennie, as long as we are clear about the ministerial boundaries to which I must adhere.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.