link
To ask the Scottish Government what actions it will take to help ensure clear and transparent sentencing. (S7O-00015)
Official Report · Chamber
General Question Time
This is the draft Official Report. The final version may differ.
link
To ask the Scottish Government what actions it will take to help ensure clear and transparent sentencing. (S7O-00015)
link
Sentencing decisions in individual cases are a matter for the sentencing judge. The sentencing of offenders is usually announced orally in court. The judge will often give reasons for imposing a particular sentence at the time of sentencing and may also publish a sentencing statement regarding certain cases of particular public interest or those that raise wider issues.
The Scottish Sentencing Council, which is a statutory independent advisory body, aims to promote greater public understanding of sentencing and has published a range of online information to help the public to understand different aspects of sentencing.
link
Fundamentally, it is us, in this Parliament, who decide and determine the law, and the reality is that Scotland’s sentencing system is deliberately dishonest. Offenders can be released after serving only 50, 40 or 30 per cent of the sentence imposed. Put simply, sentencing often does not mean what it says, and the public get that. Does the cabinet secretary agree that prisoners should, by default, serve the full sentence handed down by the court?
link
I am sure that Mr Kerr will know and understand that the custodial sentence imposed by the court is generally not the same as the length of time that a person will spend in custody. That does not mean that the sentence has changed. Rather, it reflects that a sentence will last for the length of time that a court has imposed but may be subject to enforcement both in custody and in the community. That long-standing part of Scots law has operated under many different Administrations, with a lot of the existing infrastructure originally set up in the mid-1990s by the then United Kingdom Government.
link
As the efficient and fair function of Scotland’s justice system is a priority for all in this chamber, does the cabinet secretary agree with me on the importance of the Scottish Sentencing Council and the courts working independently to ensure that objective?
link
That is a fundamental principle of the rule of law within our country. The independence of our criminal courts is a vital feature of how justice is delivered. One way in which an independent sentencing council can assist the operation of the courts is through the production of sentencing guidelines covering particular types of offence, such as rape, or particular categories of offender, to make clear the factors that a sentencing judge is required to consider in determining the appropriate sentence. Those guidelines must be agreed by the High Court before they come into effect and, once they are in effect, the court must have regard to any relevant guidance when sentencing.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.