Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 12 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Continued Petitions

Fatal Accident Inquiries (Deaths Abroad) (PE2085)

Wednesday 12 November 2025 Citizen Participation and Public Petitions Committee About 11:15–11:45 Petitions 19 contributions · 6 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

19 contributions
Jackson Carlaw Con The Convener · Eastwood
link

Welcome back. I highlight to those who are joining us this morning or watching online that—as I said some moments ago, before we heard evidence in relation to the previous petition—Parliament will dissolve in April next year. The final sitting will be in March, and the committee still has a huge number of open petitions before it. Our focus, therefore, is now on trying to identify the areas where we feel we can make progress in the time remaining. Any judgments that we come to about whether we feel that we can keep a petition open are a reflection not of the importance of the subject but of the committee’s ability to make progress in the limited time remaining.

To accommodate colleagues’ diaries, I intend to upset the order of the continued petitions and move to PE2085, which is on introducing a statutory definition of residency for fatal accident inquiries into the deaths of Scots abroad. I understand that the petitioner, David Cornock, is with us today in the public gallery. We last considered the petition at our meeting on 2 April, and we agreed to write to the Cabinet Secretary for Justice and Home Affairs.

We are joined by MSP colleagues Michael Marra and Tess White. Michael Marra has spoken to us in relation to the petition on a number of occasions. Good morning to you both.

I have quite a bit to say in relation to the petition. I hope that colleagues will bear with me.

The committee is aware that the system of coroners’ inquests that is used in England and Wales is significantly different from the Scottish system of death investigations. Coroners’ inquests mainly determine how, where and when someone died; they rarely make wider recommendations in relation to the circumstances of the death. In Scotland, fatal accident inquiries aim to establish what happened and to prevent future deaths from happening in similar circumstances. In addition to determining whether someone was ordinarily resident, the Lord Advocate must consider, first, that the death was sudden, suspicious, unexplained or gives rise to serious public concern; secondly, that the circumstances of the death have not been sufficiently established in the course of other investigations, such as by the country in which the death occurred; thirdly, that there is a real prospect that a fatal accident inquiry could sufficiently establish the circumstances of the death—for example, if evidence about the circumstances of the death is available; and, finally, that it is in the public interest to hold a fatal accident inquiry.

There were 43 fatal accident inquiries carried out in Scotland between April 2022 and March 2023. The cabinet secretary’s response states that it has always been anticipated that inquiries under the legislation into deaths abroad will be rare. The response states:

“an investigation into a death abroad faces formidable hurdles without the cooperation of the domestic authorities. Neither Police Scotland nor the Lord Advocate has jurisdiction to conduct investigations overseas”.

The cabinet secretary points out that those challenges are also faced in England and Wales. On that basis, the cabinet secretary has stated, there is

“no intention to change the current system in Scotland.”

On the substantive matter of defining the term “ordinarily resident”, the Law Society of Scotland, the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service and the Scottish Government have all previously advised that they consider the definition of “ordinarily resident” to be widely recognised and accepted in common law. The leading case on the matter put the question:

“has the applicant shown that he has habitually and normally resided in the United Kingdom from choice and for a settled purpose throughout the prescribed period, apart from temporary or occasional absences?”

The Cabinet Secretary for Justice and Home Affairs reiterated in her most recent written submission:

“The term ‘ordinarily resident’ that is contained within the legislation is viewed as sufficiently flexible and workable by the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service”.

She went on to say that the definition

“is sufficient to allow the Lord Advocate to conduct an assessment into ordinary residence depending on the facts and circumstances of each particular case.”

The petitioner has provided two written submissions to the committee. He states that,

“With an estimated 1000 deaths of Scots overseas”

since the Inquiries into Fatal Accidents and Sudden Deaths etc (Scotland) Act 2016 was passed, he does

“not believe that anyone can justify the effectiveness of the current system.”

He reiterates his view

“that the current process does not work and that the ordinarily resident test is not applied correctly”.

The petitioner’s second submission highlights a recent round-table meeting attended by a number of representatives, including members of Parliament, MSPs, Police Scotland, Victim Support and the Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Office. The submission includes a contribution from the director of instrumentation and control at Chart Industries, who highlights that employees can undertake assignments for a number of years. He states:

“Given the ... length of these postings, it is essential to have a clear and practical definition of ‘ordinarily resident.’”

Similarly, a written submission from Graham Duncan notes that he is unclear as to whether his colleagues in the oil and gas industry who

“work abroad for months at a time”

would be considered to be ordinarily resident.

Another individual, Julie Love, has provided a written submission in support of the petition, as she had a similar petition considered back in 2009. She shares her view that there does not appear to be a safeguard for families with loved ones abroad.

Finally, Dave Doogan MP has provided a written submission, and I understand that he has been supporting the petitioner with his campaigning work. Dave Doogan MP believes that there is an efficacy gap between the 2016 act as introduced and the impact on bereaved families who have lost loved ones abroad.

Before I invite suggestions from colleagues, I invite our parliamentary colleagues who have joined us to add anything that they wish the committee to consider.

Michael Marra Lab North East Scotland
link

I thank the committee for its continued interest in the petition, particularly given the workload that the convener has outlined. You covered a lot of ground in your lengthy introduction, convener, including some of the things that I was going to say, given the lack of progress that has been made since we last met and considered the petition, back in April.

We had the round table in Parliament, and the clearest outcome of that was the emerging cross-party consensus, which is represented in the letter that we copied to the convener and the committee members, that the law is not working.

I note the response from the cabinet secretary to the committee. The word used regarding this kind of inquiry is “rare”, but such inquiries have been non-existent since the legislation was passed—there has not been a single one. It would test the credibility of the definition to say that, of the approximately 1,000 deaths of Scots abroad, none would be able to meet that test.

I also recognise the description of the difference between the systems in England and Wales and in Scotland, in terms of process and intent. However, we have to be clear that, although they are not directly comparable, we can see some instances where people have received some level of clarity about the circumstances in which their loved ones have passed away abroad, and some level of closure for their families. That has not been available to Scots who face those circumstances.

I think that there is a contradiction in what the cabinet secretary has written to the committee in her letter. On 10 October, the First Minister signalled a willingness to look again at the legislation. He told a journalist that he had met Mr Cornock, and he said:

“I understand entirely the concerns that he has, and would want to see those addressed.”

That was in the aftermath of the round table and the emerging cross-party consensus. There is a weight of growing evidence and concern that the law has not worked.

Another issue that was not covered in your opening, convener—and it would not be—was the 30 October communication to Dave Doogan MP from Hamish Falconer MP, who is the Minister for Middle East and North Africa, Afghanistan and Pakistan. It stated that the FCDO in the UK

“can intervene in a case should concerns be raised regarding the pace, quality and/or progress of any investigation or trial”

in that jurisdiction. It also said:

“If a family have serious concerns that their loved one died in suspicious circumstances, they should raise this with the local UK police, who can contact the foreign competent authority through policing channels.”

Having taken that advice from the FCDO, the Cornocks spoke to and were interviewed by Police Scotland on more than two occasions, and Police Scotland produced a major incident report stating that it was suspicious about the younger David Cornock’s death and the quality of the investigation. On both occasions, the processes were closed down by superiors within Police Scotland. I do not think that the system is working. It is not working on the basis of process and it is not working on the basis of the law.

In closing, I have three requests that the committee might consider. The first is that the committee might write to the cabinet secretary again, in the light of that cross-party letter, and ask her for a more considered response, particularly given the words of the First Minister, which I have put on the record today.

Given what I have just said about the police, the committee might also consider lending its weight to helping me and my constituent to secure a meeting with the chief constable. Considering the committee’s meeting this morning, you clearly have better success with that than we do. It would be useful if you were able to write in that regard.

11:45

I also recognise that, in recent weeks, you have had cabinet secretaries at committee meetings to talk about a variety of petitions. If the Cabinet Secretary for Justice and Home Affairs will be in front of you at some point as part of your work programme, might we be able to put some questions to her on this issue? If she will not be, I am sure that she would agree that it would be a good use of her time to answer some questions on it, given the growing cross-party consensus.

I greatly appreciate the committee’s forbearance, considering its workload. Deaths abroad are an incredibly serious issue that affects many families across Scotland, and the committee is doing sterling work in trying to support my constituent in that regard.

Tess White Con North East Scotland
link

I will say one brief thing to support my colleague Mr Marra: if there is a discrepancy between England and Scotland, that needs to be addressed. I fully support what Michael Marra has said.

Jackson Carlaw Con The Convener · Eastwood
link

Was I? I wondered whether you have any thoughts to contribute.

Fergus Ewing Ind Inverness and Nairn
link

I started off somewhat sceptical. However, having listened to what Mr Marra said and having refreshed my memory of what has been said, I believe that it is apparent from the evidence that—as the petitioner has made clear from the outset—there have been between 200 and 400 investigations in England each year into deaths abroad, whereas, in Scotland, there have been zero investigations. I looked again at the cabinet secretary’s submission of 26 May, to see whether there was any explanation for that, and the only explanation was that, in essence, it is difficult to hold an inquiry when you do not have jurisdiction. However, that is the case for England and Wales as well, so it is not an explanation.

The petitioner wants there to be a statutory definition of residency, which may be one solution. The Law Society of Scotland says that that is not necessary. However, I wonder whether the wider problem is that the authorities in Scotland are simply averse to having such investigations altogether for practical reasons—and there are practical reasons; we recognise that.

For the people for whom this matters, it matters greatly. When someone loses a loved one abroad in circumstances that are unexplained, that will linger forever. It is a serious matter, and the cabinet secretary has not really answered the points that have been raised, so we should go back to the cabinet secretary. It is a bit like being asked to do an exam paper and saying, “Well, I don’t agree with any of the questions, but will you give me a pass mark?” It is not on.

We are here again and again, in the same situation with cabinet secretaries, Mr Marra. It is unlike Ms Minto this morning, who I thought was excellent in her responses. I am not making a blanket criticism, although it is not rare for me to criticise the current Government. However, on this occasion, the lack of a basic answer is an insult to the petitioners and to the committee. I certainly do not think that the petition should be closed—I am sorry if that is not the view of other members—but I am not sure whether we should go so far as to take evidence, because we just need some clarity.

If we are going to approach the chief constable, we should also approach the Lord Advocate, because, if I am correct, she has the final say in such matters—I could be wrong about that. I had a meeting with the Lord Advocate about the inadequacies of the FAI system in Scotland, and she was very aware, attuned and involved in trying to improve the process. I would certainly want to involve the Lord Advocate as well as the chief constable if the committee were to agree to that approach.

Davy Russell Lab Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse
link

Bearing in mind the significant numbers that are involved—1,000 deaths is a lot of deaths, and they affect whole families, so the number is multiplied by the people who are affected—I think that we should dig a bit deeper.

Jackson Carlaw Con The Convener · Eastwood
link

We face the fact that the Law Society of Scotland and the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service want to do nothing further. The Cabinet Secretary for Justice and Home Affairs has made it perfectly clear that the Scottish Government does not intend to do anything further. At the same time, the committee is of the view that the issues that the petition raises are more important than the dusty response that we have received implies.

As the responses that we received came before the roundtable discussion that took place, and as there appears to be wider cross-party support and understanding of the failures on the issue, I suggest that we write to the cabinet secretary to say that we would like her to consider the matter further, given that there is considerable disquiet for the reasons that Mr Marra has articulated. As Mr Ewing has said, it seems extraordinary that there have been no inquiries in Scotland when, irrespective of the system being different, the authorities in England and Wales have been able to progress inquiries in the face of the exact same challenges that any inquiry led in Scotland would face.

I am perfectly content for the committee to write to the chief constable, saying that it is an issue with which it would be helpful for Police Scotland to engage—my mother would correct me on my grammar if I got that the wrong way round. We can ask whether the Government would be prepared to meet Mr Marra and the petitioner with a view to progressing the matter. Are there any other suggestions from the committee?

Fergus Ewing Ind Inverness and Nairn
link

We also need to write to the Lord Advocate.

Jackson Carlaw Con The Convener · Eastwood
link

Yes. Notwithstanding the wall of negativity that we have received from officialdom, with a view to penetrating that wall with further efforts, are members content to keep the petition open?

Members indicated agreement.

Concessionary Bus Travel Scheme (Asylum Seekers) (PE2028)

Jackson Carlaw Con The Convener · Eastwood
link

PE2028, lodged by Pinar Aksu on behalf of Maryhill Integration Network and Doaa Abuamer on behalf of the VOICES Network, calls on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to extend the current concessionary travel scheme to include all people seeking asylum in Scotland, regardless of age.

Paul Sweeney, our MSP colleague, joins us for our consideration of the petition, as he has done previously. Good morning, Paul.

The committee last considered the petition in March, when we agreed to write to the Scottish Government. We received a response from Transport Scotland, which states that the working group that is responsible for designing a pilot scheme to progress free bus travel for all asylum seekers has reconvened this year and was due to have its first meeting in May. It also indicates that officials are considering, and would discuss with the working group, whether it is possible to include people seeking asylum in the statutory national concessionary travel schemes in the longer term.

In August, in a response to a written question, the Minister for Agriculture and Connectivity said that it was

“anticipated that the pilot will commence in the Autumn.”—Written Answers, 19 August 2025; S6W-39566.

However, in an additional submission, the petitioners indicate that they are still waiting for the pilot to begin, and they continue to urge the Scottish Government to commit to a sustainable and long-term solution.

I recall that we raised the issue directly with Humza Yousaf, the then First Minister, at an earlier stage. The scheme was agreed and then disrupted. We were then told that the petition’s aims were once again being pursued, but although the will is supposedly there to make it happen, the matter seems to be going on for a little bit longer than we were told. Before the committee considers what further it might do, I invite Mr Sweeney to comment.

Paul Sweeney Lab Glasgow
link

As you know, the petition has been part of a long-running campaign that began in December 2021 around the extension of free concessionary travel to people seeking asylum, who are often the most destitute members of the community, with an income of less than £50 per week. The rationale for extending the existing concessionary travel schemes to a relatively small group of the population made sense. The Government accepted that rationale but, as you have said, convener, we have been caught in the teeth of the logistics of how to best implement such a proposal.

The preferred solution is a straightforward extension of eligibility under the existing concessionary travel schemes. The Government intimated that it was piloting a project, and I believe that a pilot in Aberdeen was very successful, but that was based on the ad hoc issuing of bus passes through charitable organisations, which is not really the systemic approach that would be the ideal.

Jackson Carlaw Con The Convener · Eastwood
link

Might I just come in here? I recollect that the cabinet secretary at the time was concerned that the extension of the scheme in the way that you have identified might have had a knock-on effect on the Home Office’s subsequent consideration of the level of support that asylum seekers were receiving, and that it could have proved counterproductive if it was implemented in that way.

Paul Sweeney Lab Glasgow
link

Yes—the Government at the time identified a risk that the rules on no recourse to public funds, which contain an explicit list of prohibited benefits, could be extended to include such a scheme if it were introduced. That comes across as being a bit of a bad-faith and vindictive thing to do. I do not think that, politically, it is a real risk now, certainly with the change in Government.

I think that it is worth exploring the matter again. The Government previously said that it would extend the scheme, and it then rescinded that commitment. It has now reinstated it, but we are still stuck on the issue of when an extension is going to be implemented through a statutory instrument. It would be helpful if the committee could press the Government further on its timetable for the statutory instrument. There is no real rationale for further delay and hindrance—let us just get on with it.

I pay tribute to Maryhill Integration Network and the VOICES network for their persistence in that regard; Doaa Abuamer and Pinar Aksu have been excellent advocates on behalf of their membership. The need for such an extension is well established, from a health perspective as much as for any other reason. I hope that we can get on with it without further delay, and I think that there is the political will to do so.

Jackson Carlaw Con The Convener · Eastwood
link

I hope that the commitment on behalf of the UK Government does not prove to be a cross that you have to bear and subsequently repent in relation to.

Jackson Carlaw Con The Convener · Eastwood
link

Notwithstanding that, we have been engaging on the petition for some time, and we have raised it with the First Minister. Are colleagues content that we ask the Minister for Agriculture and Connectivity for a progress update on the pilot scheme that was due to commence this autumn and see what efforts we can make to direct the thing and move it forward? I would just note that we hope that it will materialise in the lifetime of the current session of Parliament, given the duration of the petition and the acceptance from Government at various stages of the aims that it seeks to secure.

Are colleagues content with that?

Members indicated agreement.

Jackson Carlaw Con The Convener · Eastwood
link

That is what we will do. I thank Mr Sweeney for attending.

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report
  1. 09:30 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. 09:30 Emergency Cardiac Care Evidence session · 68
  3. 10:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 100
  4. 11:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 19
  5. 12:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 5
  6. 12:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 5
  7. 12:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 3
  8. 12:00 New Petitions Petitions · 1
  9. 12:00 New Petitions Petitions · 5
  10. 12:00 New Petitions Petitions · 4
  11. 12:00 New Petitions Petitions · 4

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.