The final continued petition for consideration today is PE2133, on which members will have received some late submissions. The petition, which was lodged by Andrew Wedge, calls on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to ensure that all cities in Scotland have a direct express rail connection to each other by expanding ScotRail’s Inter7city routes to include Scotland’s newest city, Dunfermline.
Again, we last considered the petition on 19 March. We wanted to find out whether the position of the proposal to reopen the Alloa to Dunfermline line for passenger services would be reviewed in the light of a significant housing development in the west Fife area. We also asked what consideration had been given to using existing connections to provide rail services linking Dunfermline with Glasgow and Stirling without the need to go to Edinburgh.
The response from Transport Scotland indicates that there remains a path for regional or local rail projects to come forward, subject to a strong business case and suitable funding. If sufficient future travel demand from west Fife is identified, Transport Scotland would consider that within the appropriately developed business case.
On the second point, the response explains that the railway in Fife is not yet electrified, so any direct services between Fife and Glasgow would need to run diesel trains on a mostly electrified route. That would have a negative impact on speeds and reliability. Transport Scotland suggests that the question of a direct service could be revisited once the partial electrification of the Fife route is more advanced.
Members may recall that the Scottish Government’s position on the ask of the petition is that it is reasonable, that it was given detailed consideration in recent years and that rail connectivity in Fife will be kept under review as travel patterns evolve.
Are there any suggestions for how we might proceed?
