When this Parliament passed its first piece of climate legislation, the Climate Change (Scotland) Act 2009, I warned that we had consensus on the destination but not on the actions that were necessary, and I have continued to say that. However, in recent months, it has become increasingly clear that the Conservative Party has detached itself even from that consensus on the destination.
The 2045 target was set a little more than five years ago, and the final Tory speaker in the debate in which Parliament agreed that target said:
“The Committee on Climate Change outlined how Scotland can go faster and further in achieving net zero emissions. I support the principle that we need to go further and faster, for the good of both the economy and the global environment”.
Further, he closed that debate with these words:
“we are confident that it lays the foundations for a climate change plan that will support innovation, create jobs and use technology, as well as addressing the undeniable climate change emergency that we face.”—[Official Report, 25 September 2019; c 103-4.]
It is inconceivable that a member of the Conservative Party would make such a speech now, railing as they do against renewable infrastructure, whether that is transmission infrastructure, storage infrastructure or anything else. Further, it now looks as though the future direction of travel is even worse, with Andrew Bowie, the acting shadow Secretary of State for Scotland, openly describing the IPCC as biased.
Today, the Conservatives say that they want an evidence-based debate. Mr Bowie had no evidence for what he said. In fact, when he said,
“There’s quite a few scientists that say we don’t need to get to net zero by 2050”,
he was, of course, unable to name any. He also said:
“There’s no scientific rationale for choosing 2050 as the point to which we should reach net zero.”
That is utterly at odds with the evidence that the scientific community has provided from around the world.
What do we need in order to reach net zero through a just transition? First, we need political leadership. That means not just backing targets but not blocking the actions that are necessary. Far too many politicians have voted for targets and then blocked the actions that are necessary, whether on transport, heat, land use or something else.
We need urgency from the Scottish Government. The energy strategy and just transition plan has been delayed for far too long, and it must include a strong presumption against new fossil fuel extraction. There must be urgency when it comes to the new climate plan, too.
For far too long, the 2030 target was slipping out of reach as a result of inaction over the first 15 years of this journey. If the track record of the past 15 years is repeated in the final 20 years of the transition, we will fail; however, we need not fail if we apply the urgency that is needed now.
Finally, and most crucially, we need accountability of the fossil fuel industry, which has made vast profits, including from the North Sea, over many years. It spent decades covering up what it knew about the climate change that it was causing. It then spent decades more funding and seeding climate denial conspiracies around the world. More recently, it has moved to a position of climate delay and is abandoning its workforce. If it had invested a fraction of those vast profits in the transition and in the workforce to which it owes a moral responsibility, the situation would be very different.
The industry has made negligible—