I am grateful to those members who signed my motion allowing the debate to take place. I am also grateful to Daniel Hale of the Marine Conservation Society for his very helpful briefings.
Scotland boasts one of Europe’s most expansive and ecologically rich marine environments, fringed by more than 18,000km of coastline. These waters support a wealth of biodiversity, from seals and whales to seabirds, and they sustain critical sectors such as fisheries, aquaculture and offshore renewable energy. The Marine Conservation Society’s “State of our beaches” 2024 report offers a detailed and sobering assessment of Scotland’s coastal and marine environments. Compiled from the society’s beachwatch programme, which is a year-round citizen science initiative that was launched in 1994, the report draws on one of the United Kingdom’s most comprehensive marine litter data sets. More than a third of this year’s 1,262 surveys took place in Scotland: 467 surveys, representing a 28 per cent increase on the previous year.
The significance of this evening’s members’ business debate is underscored by two timely events: the 99th birthday of Sir David Attenborough last week and the release of his latest documentary, “Ocean”, which is a powerful tribute to the beauty and fragility of our seas. As always, Attenborough’s voice brings moral authority and urgency, calling on us to reconsider our relationship with the natural world, particularly its most expansive and endangered domain.
The report paints a picture of paradoxes. Although the Scottish Government is making progress, persistent challenges, particularly plastic pollution, continue to erode the resilience of marine ecosystems. Encouragingly, public engagement is gaining momentum. In 2024, more than 4,100 volunteers took part in formal beach clean-ups across Scotland, removing a total of 527,460 individual pieces of litter. There were also many more informal clean-ups, including those that I organised myself, and yet the scale of the issue remains sobering. An average of 204 littered items were recorded per 100m of coastline, which is significantly higher than the UK national average.
Litter linked to public behaviour was the most common type found on Scottish mainland beaches, accounting for 40 per cent of all recorded waste. Certain regions saw especially sharp increases in litter density. Fife recorded an increase of 124.9 per cent, while Dumfries and Galloway experienced a shocking 287 per cent rise, which I am sure that Mr Carson will want to comment on in his speech.
Sewage pollution presents another urgent threat. In some areas, the situation is particularly severe. The national average for sewage-related debris is 1.5 items per 100m, Falkirk and Inverclyde reported figures of 212 and 237 items respectively. Wet wipes have emerged as a particularly troubling pollutant: more than 22,000 were collected from fewer than half of the beaches that were surveyed in Scotland. Often made from synthetic fibres, wet wipes degrade very slowly, posing serious risks to marine ecosystems. They can clog waterways, contribute to microplastic pollution and threaten marine life.
Scottish Water has expanded monitoring of combined sewer overflows from just 7 per cent in 2020 to 32 per cent last year, which is a welcome step forward. However, the majority of discharges still go unmonitored. To address those environmental pressures, the Scottish Parliament passed the Circular Economy (Scotland) Act 2024, a critical move away from single-use culture. The act empowers ministers to impose charges on select disposable items, including wet wipes and takeaway cups. That legislative progress builds on the success of Scotland’s carrier bag charge, which was introduced a decade ago. Within its first year, that modest charge led to an 87 per cent reduction in plastic bags found on beaches.
Further measures are on the horizon. Scotland’s deposit return scheme, which is scheduled to launch in October 2027 as part of a UK-wide initiative, will add a 20p deposit to most single-use plastic bottles and cans. Consumers can reclaim the deposit by returning empty containers to participating retailers. Meanwhile, the Scottish Government has implemented wide-reaching protections for marine environments, with more than 37 per cent of Scotland’s territorial waters now designated as marine protected areas. These include the sea of the Hebrides—the world’s first protected zone for basking sharks and minke whales—as well as the South Arran MPA and numerous protected sea lochs. More than 2,000 square kilometres of inshore waters are now permanently safeguarded from destructive practices such as bottom trawling and mechanical dredging, in line with the Marine (Scotland) Act 2010.
In my constituency of Cunninghame North, the UK’s first no-take zone was established in Lamlash bay in 2008. It has been a resounding success that should be repeated elsewhere in Scotland. Spearheaded by the Community of Arran Seabed Trust—COAST—the area has seen remarkable biodiversity recovery, including notable rebounds in scallop and lobster populations. In 2021, the initiative was recognised by the United Nations Convention on Biological Diversity as one of the world’s top-20 outstanding practices.
Building on that success, COAST partnered with the Arran outdoor education centre in 2023 to launch a free marine science education programme. Delivered to more than 375 students from across North Ayrshire, the programme integrates sea bed cameras, remotely operated vehicles and plankton sampling with classroom learning, enhancing environmental literacy and supporting student wellbeing. Elsewhere, targeted conservation efforts have spurred the recovery of the critically endangered flapper skate in the legally designated MPA that spans Loch Sunart and the Sound of Jura. That success is bolstered by the use of artificial intelligence-powered monitoring, which has helped to identify nearly 2,500 individual fish, illustrating the powerful synergy between legal protection and technological innovation.
Overall, since 2022, the Scottish marine environmental enhancement fund has invested more than £3.8 million in 54 projects, restoring seagrass meadows, salt marshes and native oyster populations. Those projects not only improve biodiversity and coastal resilience, but contribute to blue carbon sequestration, which is a vital climate mitigation tool.
As we reflect on the findings of the “State of our beaches” 2024 report, it is clear that Scotland stands at a critical juncture. Our nation’s marine environment is one of the richest and most diverse in Europe, and it remains both an extraordinary asset and a fragile inheritance. While the report paints a sobering picture, marked by rising plastic pollution, sewage-related debris and the enduring impacts of public littering, it also speaks to the power of progress.
We are seeing tangible steps forward, with record volunteer engagement; new legislation, such as the aforementioned Circular Economy (Scotland) Act 2024; expanded marine protections; and the steady integration of cutting-edge technology in conservation efforts, yet we cannot be complacent. If we are to preserve the integrity of our marine ecosystems for future generations, our actions now must match the scale of the threat. That means continuing to strengthen legislation, accelerating the roll-out of initiatives such as the deposit return scheme and supporting a ban on single-use plastic wet wipes by next year.
The challenges before us are significant, but they are not insurmountable. Although the journey is far from over, with further preservation and sustained effort, the environmental tide may finally turn.