Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Subordinate Legislation

Social Security Information-sharing (Scotland) Amendment Regulations 2025 [Draft]

Wednesday 2 April 2025 Education, Children and Young People Committee About 09:30–10:45 Subordinate legislation 279 contributions · 10 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

279 contributions · showing 201–279
Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

With respect, cabinet secretary, you are not answering the question. Do you agree or disagree with the children’s commissioner?

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

I agree that our schools work every day not to stigmatise those families who are most in need. They are compelled by legislation to ensure that they do not stigmatise, and I trust that they work in our schools every day to ensure that they do not do so.

If the children’s commissioner or the committee have any examples of children being stigmatised on the issue, I am more than happy to consider those, because that would be a real challenge. I would not want that to be happening in our schools. However, I have not been presented with such evidence in the past two years, and I trust Scotland’s teachers and the staff who work in our schools not to stigmatise. They work tirelessly, every day, in a very caring profession, and I do not think that a stigmatising approach is taken in our schools. I have not witnessed such an approach in recent times.

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Do you accept that there is quite a big difference between the obligation that is put on local authorities by section 53B of the 1980 act and what the children’s commissioner is perhaps seeing in our schools?

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

We can write to the committee with further examples of how the issue is managed in our schools, to provide you with reassurance on that point, convener.

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

I was hoping to get it ahead of the commissioner’s coming in.

Clare Haughey SNP Rutherglen
link

Cabinet secretary, what are the implications for Scotland’s schoolchildren of the SSI not being agreed to?

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

The implications are that 25,000 children in Scotland would not receive free school meals—or, at least, that there would be a delay in their receiving access to free school meals.

Clare Haughey SNP Rutherglen
link

Given your evidence in response to Douglas Ross’s questions about the number of families who are not accessing their entitlement, what concerns would you have for those families, should the committee not recommend that the SSI be approved?

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

My concern would be that children would not access free school meals that they should have access to. Although we have not really talked about it today, there is academic evidence to suggest that free school meals have a role in attainment, attendance and a young person’s wellbeing. I do not think that there will be any political disagreement on the purpose behind the SSI, which is really important. It is about empowering our local authorities to identify those families.

I accept some of the challenge about the length of time that it has taken for Social Security Scotland to progress the issue, but once the SSI has been approved, the process will move at pace, with the instrument coming into force on 19 May. That will empower local authorities to deliver to the families in question, which is imperative for our children and young people.

The Government did not need to introduce an SSI on the issue. We could have sat back and allowed local authorities to do their own thing. However, that would have taken much longer and would have been detrimental to children and families.

Clare Haughey SNP Rutherglen
link

So, the danger of playing political games on this is that children go hungry.

George Adam SNP Paisley
link

You have already answered this question three or four times, but it seems that it is now our practice to ask the same questions three or four times as we go along. Is the SSI not an example of the Government seeing an issue with the sharing of data and finding a solution? When answering that question, please do not blink or shake your head, or the convener will ask you outside for a square go.

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

It is an example of the Government recognising the challenge of the fact that lots of families have missed out over the years, who should—this relates to Ms Haughey’s point—have been able to access free school meals.

I broadly agree with the convener’s point about the stigma that, historically, has been associated with free school meals. The data-sharing arrangement goes some way to overcoming that, because it empowers local authorities to reach out to families by writing to them directly to make sure that their children are in receipt of free school meals.

Politically, we should be in lockstep on the issue. I accept the challenge in relation to universality. We could have a political debate about why the Government has not been able to afford that during the current parliamentary session. However, fundamentally, the SSI is about data sharing and, as Ms Haughey said, making sure that those children who are hungry receive food in school so that they are able to attain and to attend, which there are real challenges with post the pandemic. The SSI is part of our holistic response to that situation in our schools. The Government has come forward with a solution.

I am not here to be given marks out of 10 by committee members. I do not expect praise or feedback to that end, but we need to learn from this. I accept that it has been a challenge for us to move forward at pace, but we must use this as an opportunity to have better data sharing so that we can feed more children in our schools and meet the needs of more learners across Scotland, including in relation to widening access more broadly.

10:30

George Adam SNP Paisley
link

I find it hugely frustrating that we hear about data issues, the Government does something about that, and then we seem to go down a rabbit hole at committee, instead of talking about the efforts to make sure that 25,000 children are not going hungry. That is part of the issue. Do you not agree that, when we discuss such challenging issues, we need to do so with a level of maturity so that we can talk about the end game and what we are trying to deliver?

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

That would certainly be my aspiration. I am old enough to remember when Mr Adam and I took evidence in this room on the Finnish approach to education, which is depoliticised. The approach that is taken by political parties in that country is quite different from the one that is taken in Scotland, which tends to be split along constitutional lines.

When we talk about children in poverty, we should all be on the same page, working towards supporting those who are most in need. The SSI will allow us to make progress on that. I accept that the Government’s aspiration in relation to universality will not be met before the next election—that is well known to members; we have debated the issue in the chamber—but the SSI means that the Government will be compelled to make progress. We have put in place the extra funding, and we now expect local authorities to deliver on it. That is exactly why the SSI is so important.

George Adam SNP Paisley
link

Since we are sharing experiences from childhood, back in my day, if you had free school dinners, you would be split up from everyone else, so things have moved on quite a bit since I was a young person who had to deal with that situation.

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

I will follow on from Mr Adam’s point. You have been very generous in accepting some of the points that have been made—you have not necessarily agreed with them, but you accept that it is right that we look at the issue. However, committees are also here to scrutinise SSIs. If we simply rubber-stamped every SSI, that would not make for good legislation. Do you accept that?

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

Mr Ross, I know that you are not here to rubber-stamp all my SSIs. You are here to challenge me. That is your job, and it is your right to do so. I respect that—of course I do.

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

My final point is about the time that this process has taken, which you mentioned a couple of times to Clare Haughey and George Adam. How long have different Government departments been working on this? What is the total period?

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

I heard a sharp intake of breath from my right, Mr Ross, so I will defer to Ms Meikle on that.

Laura Meikle Scottish Government
link

We have spent more than a year on the preparation of this work. There has been a lot of discussion this morning about the challenges of establishing data-sharing arrangements. That is true. It is absolutely necessary to specifically define the purpose of those arrangements, and it takes time to develop that. We have other data-sharing arrangements in place, which we are working with the UK Government on. They have taken far longer. The process takes more than a year—it takes a lot of time.

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

I am not making a political point here—I apologise if it sounds as though I am—but are you saying, basically, that, had the Government been able to do what it wanted to do on day 1, some 25,000 young people across Scotland would have had an extra year of free school meals?

Laura Meikle Scottish Government
link

We would not have been able to bring forward the SSI without doing all the preparatory work. It would not have been possible. I understand your point, but I am not able to agree with it.

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

My point is that it should never take a year to do the work on an issue such as free school meals. That point applies to not only the Scottish Government and Scottish bodies but the UK Government and others. If a Government has an aspiration to take action on an issue such as free school meals, on which I do not think that there is political disagreement, there must surely be a way to do so, and it should not take a year. Maybe the SSI will lead to good practice in future.

Laura Meikle Scottish Government
link

The SSI has taken quite some time to prepare. Given that I am responsible for all of it, I will mention the other part of the challenge that we face, which is the fact that there is not sufficient infrastructure in schools’ dining and kitchen facilities, and we require to build that. As much as I would have loved to have been able to have that done very quickly, unfortunately, it takes time and cannot be done quickly. There are other aspects that have also been a challenge for us.

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

We move to agenda item 3. I invite the cabinet secretary to move motion S6M-16753.

Motion moved,

That the Education, Children and Young People Committee recommends that the Social Security Information-sharing (Scotland) Amendment Regulations 2025 draft be approved.—Jenny Gilruth

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Do you have anything to add, cabinet secretary?

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Do members have any comments?

John Mason Ind Glasgow Shettleston
link

Having listened to the evidence, I think that this is definitely a move in the right direction. As I understand it, a further 25,000 children will get free school meals who would not otherwise have done so. It appears to me that that will, in fact, reduce stigma, because those 25,000 children will be taken out of being possibly stigmatised. For example, in Glasgow, every child who gets lunch gets a card. That means that, regardless of whether one is paying for one’s lunch, one has the same card. That has been a long-standing thing. It does not completely remove stigma, but it has been a good step in that direction.

We want to do more in this field, and I think that we all agree on that. If, as some parties wanted, we had reduced tax, that would have meant many more children paying for their lunches or just going without lunch altogether, but, thankfully, the Conservatives were defeated on that issue and the budget was agreed to. Obviously, the budget overrides any previous votes that Parliament had, which were non-binding. The SSI is certainly a good move in the right direction, and I am happy to support it.

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

The question is, that motion S6M-16753, in the name of Jenny Gilruth, be agreed to.

Motion agreed to,

That the Education, Children and Young People Committee recommends that the Social Security Information-sharing (Scotland) Amendment Regulations 2025 draft be approved.

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

The committee must now produce a report on the draft instrument. Is the committee content to delegate responsibility to me, as convener, to agree the report on behalf of the committee?

Members indicated agreement.

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

That concludes the consideration of the instrument.

Before I release you, cabinet secretary, there are a couple of quick questions about the University of Dundee. I go to Willie Rennie.

Willie Rennie LD North East Fife
link

When the announcement about the job losses came out, cabinet secretary, you and Graeme Dey indicated that you would explore all options to protect jobs, and he said that you would “manage down” the number of job losses, accepting that there would be some. However, this week, we have been told by the university’s interim principal that there is no change in the 632 job losses, and that as many as 700 jobs could be affected. Will you update us on what work is being done to manage down that number and do everything possible to protect jobs?

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

I am meeting the Scottish Funding Council later today, along with Mr Dey. I was somewhat surprised by the correspondence that the committee received in relation to that number, which had not been shared with ministers in advance. I recognise the concern, and I share that concern very much.

The committee is aware, as we have stated this publicly, that there has been no further financial ask of Government beyond the £22 million of liquidity, which has been met. However, Mr Dey and I have been very clear that we are open to additional asks from the university, under the auspices of the SFC, recognising the legal need for that in this space.

We have also been very clear that, although it is not palatable to ministers, that is the number that we expect. However, the university said in evidence to the committee two or three weeks ago that it was looking at alternatives. We have not yet been presented with those alternatives. I expect them to be presented to the SFC in the coming weeks, and I would be more than happy to, and I expect to, give an update to the committee on that.

Willie Rennie LD North East Fife
link

You were surprised by the letter this week, but you are hopeful of receiving an alternative model in the next few weeks.

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

I have had a lot of discussion and engagement with the university—with the senior management, the trade unions and, last week, the student union. The community of Dundee is very concerned about all this. Mr Rennie and I know, because our constituencies border Dundee over the water, how important the university is to Dundee and the wider economy.

We expect the university to consider alternatives. It is a very challenging time for the University of Dundee in relation to its finances. We have made available that liquidity support, and we are looking at what more we might be able to provide to the university. However, we have not yet had a further ask from the university, and we remain open to such asks.

Willie Rennie LD North East Fife
link

Inaudible.—driving down, or managing down, as Graeme Dey said, the number of job losses.

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

Very much so. I need to be mindful of what I say here as cabinet secretary.

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

The committee will understand the role of the Scottish Funding Council in this, and that the Government is unable to direct funding in this space. We have to do that under the auspices of the SFC, as set out in the Further and Higher Education (Scotland) Act 2005.

Willie Rennie LD North East Fife
link

You will have seen in The Courier today reports about the finance that the Government was going to make available to the SFC through loans. It is reported that the figure was initially £20 million, and that that was signed off by the First Minister, but it was later reduced to £15 million. However, no explanation was given for that last-minute change. Can you shine some light on why it changed?

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

The total ask from the university was £22 million. The Government has made £25 million available, as Mr Rennie knows, which is £15 million through the budget and an additional £10 million of capital that I announced more recently, so that funding gap has been met.

As I understand it, there were negotiations about the amount required as part of the budget process and from financial transactions at that time. I do not think there should be any surprise, because the ask of £22 million has been met by the £15 million in the budget and the additional £10 million that I announced.

Willie Rennie LD North East Fife
link

You are right that the university has got what it has asked for so far, but I am intrigued as to why it went from £20 million in financial transaction support down to £15 million at the last minute, after the First Minister had signed it off. I am puzzled by that.

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

I think that Mr Rennie’s puzzlement may be informed by the release of emails in response to a freedom of information request. It is quite difficult to understand the full story but, as I understand it, two weeks ago, Richard Maconachie came to the committee and said that the Scottish Funding Council was working with the Scottish Government to identify how the £22 million could be put together. As I understand it from having been on the copy list, there were negotiations at that time between the SFC and the Government to identify how the £22 million could be made available, and that was done through £15 million in the budget and the extra £10 million that I made available, giving a total of £25 million, so the full funding ask was met.

Willie Rennie LD North East Fife
link

I am not going to get any more out of you but I am intrigued as to why all that changed. Perhaps you will tell us at some point. At the end of the day, the university has got the money that it asked for, which is important, but I always like to find out the full story. Maybe you will feel able to tell us at some point.

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

The £22 million has been made available. As I understand it as cabinet secretary, I think that there was a negotiation between the SFC and the Government regarding how funding could be made available through the budget process. It is very clear that we acted at pace to provide that extra funding—we had to act at pace when the full quantum of job losses became known to the Government. That is why that funding was made available through the budget and it is why I announced the extra funding.

There are ways in which funding can be made available. Part of the funding—the £15 million—came through the budget process, but the other part of it came through £10 million in capital that I announced later. The important point is that the £22 million liquidity ask from the University of Dundee has been fully met and that there have been no further asks since.

Willie Rennie LD North East Fife
link

Perhaps the £5 million that is still in the kitty might be used to provide extra support for Dundee.

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

I am not necessarily sure that it is “in the kitty” per se. However, I take Mr Rennie’s point on the optics of that and go back to the overall quantum that has been met by Government.

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

You said that you acted at pace but the university told us that the request for £22 million went in, I think, a month before the Government received the recovery plan that included the figure of 632 full-time-equivalent job losses. Was there an opportunity to provide that liquidity funding at an earlier stage?

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

Not as I understand it. On 19 February, the SFC notified the Government of the university’s request for urgent liquidity support, and on 25 February we announced that £15 million of financial transactions would be made available to the Scottish Funding Council to support universities such as Dundee. Those dates—19 and 25 February—show that we acted at a pretty urgent pace.

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

But you knew then that that was not enough.

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

We knew that we would have to meet the liquidity request and we worked at pace to provide that additionality.

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Was that all before you knew that 632 FTE jobs were at risk?

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

I would have to go back to the draft financial recovery plan, which I do not have in front of me.

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

I think you became aware of that only on 7 March.

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

You were providing that funding. When the university was telling you what it needed and asking for £22 million, did it make you aware that it was also going to announce hundreds of job losses even if you gave it that money?

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

No. The university was engaging with the SFC, because it had to engage directly with the SFC rather than the Government. The engagement was undertaken with the SFC.

On 14 February, the university requested urgent liquidity support from the SFC and on 19 February the SFC notified the Scottish Government. On 25 February, we provided the extra £15 million more broadly and on 6 March the SFC received the draft copy of the FRP, which, on 7 March, was sent to the Scottish Government. That draft included details of the proposed reduction in the number of staff. That is the chronology. The £15 million was made available and, at a later date, we found out the actual number of job losses and met the asks in relation to the £22 million of liquidity support.

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Were you always aware, when the Scottish Government signed off on the original £15 million and then the additional £10 million, that, although you were meeting the financial request, you were not going to save any jobs with that money? Was that always your understanding?

10:45

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

I would need to check back on that, convener. From memory, at that point in February, the total number had not been communicated to us as ministers because the draft FRP had not been shared with us, and it is the draft FRP that sets out the quantum of job losses.

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

That is what I am asking.

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

As the committee knows, the liquidity support allows the university to continue, but it does not bring the job loss number down. We need to work with the SFC on next steps in that regard, while remembering and respecting the independence of that institution. I am mindful of Office for National Statistics classification in all of this, and we need to be careful about that.

On Mr Rennie’s point, we have met the liquidity request. We are open, as a Government, to working with the SFC on any further requests. None has thus far been made. However, we expect an alteration to be made to the draft FRP, because, as the committee heard two weeks ago from the interim principal, the university is looking at alternatives. When that alteration comes forward, the Government will consider what further support we can provide under the auspices of the SFC. We will be completely transparent with the committee on how we do that. We need to be really careful about ONS classification in all of this.

This is a challenging time for the University of Dundee and for the city of Dundee. Yesterday’s reports will not have helped. It is the Government’s job in this situation to help support the university and its staff—all the people who work there—and its students. We are absolutely committed to doing that and will continue to engage with all those people.

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

I agree with the point about yesterday’s news. It will be extremely difficult for those who are currently at the university and for those who are looking to go to it in the future, and those people are crucial for the sustainability of the university.

On Mr Rennie’s point, who made the suggestion to cut the announced allocation from £20 million to £15 million?

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

I do not have the email chain in front of me—I think that Mr Rennie’s point was informed by that chain, as well as perhaps the report in The Courier. Without seeing that, I am not sure that there was a suggestion in it to cut the figure per se. I think that there was a negotiation between the SFC and the Government—this is just my memory, so I will have to check back, convener—to assess what was required at that moment to assist the university.

I appreciate that some of those emails have been released and that some of them are redacted, which does not help to shed light on the issue—I accept that. However, I can say that there was a communication between the SFC and the Government at that time, during the budget process, to move at pace to provide that extra funding. That was provided, and then there was the £22 million liquidity request. I do not necessarily accept that there was a decision to reduce the amount. From memory, this would have been advice that was given to ministers by the SFC at that time.

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Given our interest, would you review some of the information that is in the public domain and the discussions, and update the committee?

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

I am more than happy to do that. I accept the committee’s on-going interest in this issue and I very much share it. I am happy to share as much as I am able to with the committee. We will meet the SFC later today, and if I can shed further light on our engagement with the SFC and the next steps, I will do so. Timescales are important here and we need to move at pace. I am happy to provide that information in writing to the committee.

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Finally, you said that the figure of 700 in the SFC’s letter took you by surprise. Did you ask what the full figure would be? The reason why the interim principal wrote to the committee was that I asked, if 632 FTE jobs were to be lost, what was the number of people who would lose their jobs. That letter is how we found out.

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

Mr Dey and I have interrogated the draft FRP with the principal and the senior management team—

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Are you saying that you asked but did not receive that?

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

We have asked and we have engaged with the interim principal and the senior management team. There was no movement from the 634 figure in that engagement, so we were surprised by yesterday’s reports. We will continue to engage with and support the senior management team at the university as best we can via the SFC, but that figure was not shared with ministers in advance of the committee receiving it yesterday, which is concerning. I, along with Mr Dey, will discuss that matter with the SFC later today. I am happy to share further updates with you, convener, and the committee.

Miles Briggs Con Lothian
link

Willie Rennie pursued some of the questions that I had about the University of Dundee, cabinet secretary. However, because we have you here, I have to ask, as an Edinburgh MSP, about the University of Edinburgh. I have received hundreds of emails from concerned students and staff there because it is proposing to make £140 million in cuts. What engagement and communications have you and other ministers had with the University of Edinburgh specifically to look at the similar pattern that is now unfolding for members of staff at that university?

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

The committee knows that there are challenges across the higher education sector. We can go on to talk about what some of those challenges are, if the committee would like, but I am conscious that you are taking evidence from someone else following my session.

There are challenges at the University of Edinburgh. We have been engaging with that university under the auspices of the SFC. Remember that the funding that we provided to the SFC was for institutions—plural—in relation to some of the challenges. We very much recognise that the University of Dundee at the current time has a unique challenge that in no small part relates to its own finances and decisions that it took. The University of Edinburgh is in a separate space, but it still has its own challenges, and its principal has set out some of those. We have been engaged with that institution via the SFC, which we will continue to engage with on how we can support the institution more broadly.

Miles Briggs Con Lothian
link

I know that staff are asking for that transparency and are not receiving it. Has there been a financial ask from the University of Edinburgh? If there is only £5 million left in the pot, will that be the total that is available for other institutions? The University of Edinburgh is not the only institution expressing financial concerns, as you have mentioned.

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

I am not aware of a financial ask from the University of Edinburgh. However, as I have said, I am meeting the SFC this afternoon, so I can interrogate that matter further with the SFC on Mr Briggs’s behalf.

In the update that I provide to the committee in relation to Mr Rennie’s line of questioning, I will be more than happy to include details about the University of Edinburgh as well.

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

I thank the cabinet secretary and her officials very much for their evidence this morning.

I suspend the meeting for about 10 minutes before we move on to our next item of business.

10:51 Meeting suspended.

11:01 On resuming—

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report

No recorded division on this motion that day: decisions taken without a vote are not in the divisions feed.

  1. 09:30 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 1
  2. 09:30 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 279
  3. 10:45 Children and Young People’s Commissioner Scotland Evidence session · 189

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.