Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Subordinate Legislation

Social Security Information-sharing (Scotland) Amendment Regulations 2025 [Draft]

Wednesday 2 April 2025 Education, Children and Young People Committee About 09:30–10:45 Subordinate legislation 279 contributions · 10 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

279 contributions · showing 1–200
Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

The next item on our agenda is consideration of a piece of subordinate legislation subject to the affirmative procedure. The committee will take evidence on the instrument from the Cabinet Secretary for Education and Skills and her officials, and the cabinet secretary will then move the motion to approve it.

I welcome to the meeting Jenny Gilruth, the Cabinet Secretary for Education and Skills; Alison Taylor, deputy director for improvement, attainment and wellbeing; Laura Meikle, head of the support and wellbeing unit; and Nico McKenzie-Juetten, a lawyer at the Scottish Government legal directorate.

I invite the cabinet secretary to speak to the draft instrument.

Jenny Gilruth SNP The Cabinet Secretary for Education and Skills · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

Good morning, and thank you for inviting me to discuss the draft Social Security Information-sharing (Scotland) Amendment Regulations 2025.

The regulations will, if approved, establish a legal gateway for the sharing of certain data between Social Security Scotland and Scottish local authorities, for the purposes of providing free school meals to pupils in primary 6 and 7 whose families are in receipt of the Scottish child payment and of providing certain data to support the test of change in secondary 1 to secondary 3 on the basis of being in receipt of Scottish child payment. That step is essential in supporting local authorities to maximise uptake in the next phase of delivery of the free school meals programme to those in receipt of SCP in primaries 6 and 7.

For members’ clarity, the information that would be shared will be: the child’s name; the dates of birth of the child and of their parents or carers; the names of parents or carers; their contact details, including their address; and their national insurance numbers. Those details are to be shared only in order to confirm, within each local authority area, which pupils are entitled to free school meals as a result of their parents and carers being in receipt of the Scottish child payment.

We know that the current practice and legal framework are acting as barriers to some families obtaining free school meals, hence the legal change we seek to make. For example, we are aware that the City of Edinburgh Council has written to more than 7,000 parents whose children may be eligible for free school meals but, to date, has received only 401 applications.

Therefore, if approved, the regulations will enable local authorities to proactively offer free school meals and thereby maximise the number of children who are able to access nutritious meals. As a result of that new legal gateway, there would be a significant improvement, which we estimate will benefit up to 25,000 children and their families across Scotland.

The regulations also allow for the same data to be shared for pupils in S1 to S3. Members will be aware that we have agreed to a further phase of the programme as part of the budget process, and this test of change phase will support those whose families are in receipt of Scottish child payment in S1 to S3 in eight local authority areas. The inclusion of those year groups in the regulations, if passed, will ensure that the participating local authorities can access the data that they need to allow eligible pupils to access free meals from August.

Social Security Scotland and my officials have liaised with the office of the Scottish Information Commissioner to ensure that the proposed data-sharing arrangement complies with data protection law, including in relation to data minimisation and proportionality. We have also completed equality and child’s rights impact assessments and the necessary operational data protection impact assessment is under way. The assessments found that there would be positive impacts on the rights and wellbeing of children, through the provision of support for healthy eating habits and potential improvements in educational attainment.

I thank members for their consideration of this important legislation and my officials and I will be happy to answer any questions.

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

We have a number of questions on the issue, and I will start. Can you tell me why 53(7) of the Education (Scotland) Act 1980 does not need to be amended?

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

I might defer to my officials on the question about the 1980 act, but, as I understand it, the regulations are required today because, at the current time, and as I outlined in my opening remarks, different local authorities across the country are using different ways of gathering data. The legislation will allow a new approach to data sharing. We have worked with Social Security Scotland over the past year to allow that to happen.

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

I understand all that and you explained it well in your opening statement, but the second page of your own policy note says:

“It is not intended that section 53(7) is amended at this time. However, this may be revisited in due course.”

I am just wondering why it will not be amended at this time, how that would be revisited and what the trigger for a revisit in due course would be.

Laura Meikle Scottish Government
link

Section 53(7) of the 1980 act provides the requirements for providing free school meals. That approach is delivered through an agreement between Scottish ministers and the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities. The trigger for consideration of any amendment to the 1980 act would be if there were concerns about implementation of the expansion to primary 6 and 7 on the basis of the Scottish child payment, but because the implementation is being worked through by agreement, there is no need for us to consider amending the act at this point. However, we might consider it if there were concerns down the line.

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Do you mean concerns that local authorities were not delivering the policy?

Laura Meikle Scottish Government
link

Yes, anything around implementation. We do not have any concerns at the moment. We are working through the process of delivery just now.

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Tell me about the reason why there has been no islands community impact assessment.

Laura Meikle Scottish Government
link

We considered all the impact assessments, as we are required to do. There is a pre-process that we are required to undertake, which is to consider whether there should be an impact assessment. We evaluated the system that will be introduced as a result of the regulations to establish whether islands would have to do a different or additional set of work that other local authority areas would not have to do. In that process, we established that there was nothing additional for islands to do.

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Capacity is an issue that you have raised, cabinet secretary. Are there no issues with smaller local authorities and schools in the islands meeting the extra demand?

Laura Meikle Scottish Government
link

The impact assessment relates to the regulations.

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Surely we have to consider whether the regulations can be implemented.

Laura Meikle Scottish Government
link

Yes, absolutely. We did that. The impact assessment is about whether the impact on islands is different from that on any other authority, and it was established that that was not to be the case. To confirm our position, we engaged with island authorities to ensure that it was not just officials’ view that that was the case, and they, too, confirmed it.

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Cabinet secretary, can I ask you about the data protection impact assessment?

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

What would you like to ask about the data protection impact assessment?

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Tell me about it for the regulations.

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

In terms of the data-sharing benefits or the—

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

No, the data protection impact assessment.

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

Are you asking about the practical impacts of the impact assessment?

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Why has it just been developed and not been done yet?

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

My understanding is that it will be engaged in with local authorities. As I understand it, if the regulations are passed, they will allow us to move at pace with local authorities on that data-sharing arrangement, but some of the timescales associated with that need the Scottish statutory instrument to be passed to allow that work to be undertaken.

I see Laura Meikle nodding at that.

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

You wrote to us a couple of weeks ago about data sharing, because you know that the committee has considerable concern about the issue, and said:

“For any new or proposed data sharing arrangement, each organisation must complete a data protection impact assessment”.

For the negative instrument that we just considered, the data protection impact assessment had been done, because the instrument is now in place. Why are these regulations coming before the committee when the assessment for them has not been done? Why is it still being developed? If issues arise, how will they be brought to the committee or to Parliament as a whole?

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

My understanding is that the committee needs to take a decision on that before we can process the assessment.

Laura Meikle Scottish Government
link

I can answer the question specifically. The data impact assessment that has been undertaken is for the operational aspects after the—

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

So it has been undertaken.

Laura Meikle Scottish Government
link

It is in development at the moment. Social Security Scotland is working with the Scottish local authorities to complete that process as we go.

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

So, it has not been done.

Laura Meikle Scottish Government
link

It is being done now.

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

It is being done but it has not been done.

Laura Meikle Scottish Government
link

It is currently in development. There is a draft. We were advised that we did not require to do a data protection impact assessment in advance of the regulations.

Laura Meikle Scottish Government
link

Yes, but we are required to do it for the operation of the SSI once it is in force.

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

And it will not come into force until 19 May.

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Is it that you cannot do it, or that you do not have to?

Laura Meikle Scottish Government
link

We do not have to.

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

We do not have to at this stage, but it will have to be in place by 19 May when the data-sharing agreement is in place.

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Given that it was quite a significant part of your letter to the committee, what happens if issues arise from that? The letter says:

“A DPIA will typically identify both the lawful basis and legal gateway for processing any personal information.”

If issues are raised as a result, how will they come back to this committee or to Parliament? Are you saying, “Do not worry about this—we think that everything will be fine”?

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

I have not been advised that that would be the case, because the DPIA is already being developed by Social Security Scotland. It is planned to be completed by 19 May, but I take your point, convener, and I am more than happy to write to the committee on that point.

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

I am just wondering what the point of it is. If issues were to be raised, how would we then be able to scrutinise them? That is what I am trying to get at.

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

Indeed. No issues have thus far been raised with me or been presented to me by officials, but I would be more than happy to engage with the committee on that. As I understand it, there was no requirement to have that process completed by the laying of the SSI today, but there will be for it to come into force on 19 May.

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

I want to check that point, because it is slightly different. You suggested that you could not do it until the SSI had passed, but, Ms Meikle, you were saying—

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

It is partly under way, but it has not yet been completed.

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Could it have been done before today?

Laura Meikle Scottish Government
link

Not for the SSI. We are not required to do a DPIA for the laying of the SSI.

Laura Meikle Scottish Government
link

The DPIA is not required for the legislative part. For the practice that then occurs as a result of the SSI being passed, should the committee do so, we are required to prepare one, and that is why it is in preparation now.

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

But there was nothing to stop you doing it, and perhaps it would be good practice going forward. Could it have been done to allow this discussion to take place with all the available information before members voted? That is all I am asking. Could it have been done?

Laura Meikle Scottish Government
link

I am not clear what the effect of that would have been. We would have impact assessed the regulation, but as a result of the DPIA, we would establish data-sharing agreements, which is what we have done. Therefore, I find it difficult to see—

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Going back to the cabinet secretary’s letter, I note that it says that those assessments are

“to systematically analyse, identify and minimise the data protection risks of a project or policy.”

I can speak only for myself, but as a member of this committee, I would like to know whether any data protection risks of a project or policy have been identified in order to allow us to systematically analyse that. That is what it is for, and that is the reassurance that I took from your letter from last month, cabinet secretary.

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

I agree with what you have said, convener. All that I can update the committee on today is the advice that I have been given thus far, which is that the DPIA is under way. It is being developed by Social Security Scotland, and it is planned for completion by 19 May. If it is helpful, I can write to the committee with a further update. Work is taking place with local authorities, and stakeholders have raised no issues on the implementation thus far. It is a requirement that the DPIA be confirmed and completed by 19 May, when the SSI comes into effect.

Your question, convener, as I understand it, is whether we could have done that in advance of today. We need to take that away and reflect on it. It is a fair ask from the committee.

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Thank you. This is my final question, cabinet secretary. Is there a risk? I ask you to take off your Government hat, go back to the days when you were a member of this committee—although in the governing party—and consider the regulation that we are discussing. Do you accept that people could be concerned that, if we pass the SSI, we will give the Government a get-out clause from the vote on 10 September last year, when the Parliament defeated the Scottish National Party Government on a vote on enacting a policy of universal free school meals for primary 1 to primary 7 pupils? The Parliament agreed to that motion by 64 votes to 60, with two abstentions. Despite the Government lodging an amendment that said that it was still your aspiration to deliver free school meals but that you did not have the funding to do so, it is clear that you were defeated. Therefore, the will of Parliament is for there to be universal free school meals for all primary pupils.

According to your policy note, by passing the SSI, we will

“increase the eligibility for free school meals but which are not as expansive as universal provision”.

By including that line in your policy note, are you giving yourself a get-out clause so that you can ignore the will of Parliament on 10 September last year if the SSI is passed today?

09:45

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

I do not think that you will be surprised to hear that I do not accept that. The Government’s aspiration for universal free school meals in primary schools remains; I stand by that commitment.

You will have heard extensively, in last year’s debate and in other exchanges in the Parliament, about the unaffordability of delivering such provision during this parliamentary term. Last year’s debate was informed by analysis from the Scottish Futures Trust, which suggested that universality would cost in the region of £256 million. Officials reminded me this morning that that figure is now two years out of date, so we can expect the cost to now be far in excess of £256 million. In the budget and in budget negotiations, we committed to a broader expansion that is focused on those receiving the SCP. If anything, I would argue that the regulations commit us to going more quickly than we otherwise would, because we would give the example—

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

I was—very much so. On page 1 of your policy note, it says that the regulations will

“increase the eligibility for free school meals but which are not as expansive as universal provision.”

Those of us on the committee who, only a few months ago, voted for universal provision, which was agreed to by the Parliament, will find it difficult to agree to the regulations because of the inclusion of that line in your policy note.

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

The Parliament also voted for a budget that committed the Government to expanding free school meals to those in receipt of the Scottish child payment. The regulations will allow us to move at pace on that commitment, which was set out in the budget. I recognise that your party did not vote for the budget—

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

But you are not delivering on your commitment to provide universal free school meals.

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Sorry, but you made that pledge in the 2021 election and were then defeated in the Parliament on 10 September last year. Now, you are asking the committee—and, when the regulations go to the chamber, the Parliament—to agree to something that will allow you to deliver less.

The Children and Young People’s Commissioner Scotland, who is sitting behind you, is giving evidence after you. At the time, she said that the rollback on universal free school meals was a “broken promise to children”. She said that children going to school hungry could

“severely impact development in childhood and into adulthood”.

She also said:

“One of the greatest barriers to the take up of school meals are feelings of shame and stigma, and only providing meals to Primary 6 and 7 in receipt of the Scottish Child Payment just exacerbates that stigma.”

Do you agree with that? Do you agree that it sounds like the children’s commissioner does not support the regulations?

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

It is not my job, as cabinet secretary, to comment on the views of the children’s commissioner. The committee will hear from her shortly. However, the Parliament voted for a budget that commits the Government to expanding free school meals to those in receipt of the Scottish child payment. You and your party voted against the budget, but the SSI—

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

You and your party voted against a motion—

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

Sorry, Mr Ross, but you completed your question and now you are talking across me.

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Cabinet secretary, that is because you are repeating a point that you have already—

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

You are repeating a point that you have already made.

Do you respect the will of Parliament, on 10 September last year, to provide universal free school meals? Regardless of what was in the budget earlier this year, there was a vote in the Parliament to provide universal free school meals, and the regulations will allow you not to implement that, despite all the concerns from political parties and, as I have just articulated, the children’s commissioner.

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

I do not agree with that assertion. Targeting the expansion of free school meals at those receiving the Scottish child payment was agreed to in advance of the next stage of the universal roll-out. Therefore, the SSI does not preclude the Government from meeting its ultimate aspiration, which is to deliver universality. If anything, it compels the Government to deliver on—

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

If it compels you, when will you deliver it?

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

You just said that the regulations compel you to deliver universal free school meals, so when will you deliver that? I am just using your words. That has now convinced me, so well done. If the regulations compel you to deliver universal free school meals, as you said, when will you do that?

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

The budget, as negotiated, commits the Government to the delivery of free school meals for primary 6 and 7 children in receipt of the Scottish child payment. It also commits us to further work on the test of change projects for secondary 1 to 3 pupils. You and your party voted against the budget. Today’s regulations will allow us to deliver on the budget that was passed by the Parliament. You are suggesting that the Government is not listening to the will of Parliament, but I am advancing the will of Parliament in that regard.

However, I accept the point about universal free school meals. The financial challenge that the Government faces is well known to the committee. I have talked about the budget gap in relation to the £256 million of investment that is required for universality. That budget line has not been updated for two years, so I am unable to give you a firm date today regarding universality, but I will continue to work across the chamber on the delivery of universality, because it is so important.

We talk about child poverty and about some of the impacts that have been borne by children in our schools. I hope that Mr Ross will also reflect on the impact that austerity has had on our children and their educational attainment in recent years. Some of the impacts on the Scottish Government’s budget have been caused by decisions that have been made by Governments elsewhere, including those made by his party.

I do not think that there is disagreement today—

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

There is big disagreement, cabinet secretary. I have let you make your points, but there is big disagreement.

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

You have repeatedly interrupted me, convener.

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

I did not interrupt you there. You got—

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

—to make all the points that you wanted to make.

Can you not just tell us when you will deliver universal free school meals? If you are saying that the regulations will take you forward towards that aim, tell us when that will happen.

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

Convener, as I have set out, the modelling that the Government last undertook on that is two years old—

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

That is on the Government. You could have done that in the past couple of years, could you not?

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

Convener, are you going to allow me to answer your question?

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Yes. Could you have done new modelling in the past couple of years on the cost of the universal provision of free school meals?

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

The modelling that I have is two years old and puts the estimated cost at £256 million. I am more than happy to engage with political parties on how we deliver universality, but members well know, as we have discussed and debated at length, that that will not be during this session of Parliament because of the costs associated with the roll-out. However, the Government has taken the decision to work on a cross-party basis on the deliverability of the roll-out for children in receipt of the Scottish child payment. Today’s SSI will allow us to move forward at pace on that and will allow more families to obtain access to free school meals provision, which I think is a good thing for families and children in Scotland.

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

You have said that the Government has not looked at that figure for two years, so it is two years out of date. Are you saying, while pretending that you respect the will of Parliament, that, after the vote on 10 September last year, when your Government was defeated and the Parliament agreed to introduce universal free school meals, you did no work at all on how much that would cost?

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

Of course we constantly consider those costs. Following that debate, I engaged directly with the Scottish Futures Trust, particularly on the figure of £256 million that was put to us by the trust and was independently analysed.

Mr Ross’s colleague Liam Kerr, who was the education spokesperson at the time, put forward—he might have included it in your party’s motion—a different figure, which we differed on because, as I understand it, it did not include capital costs. I am in constant contact with the SFT about driving down those costs, and I am more than happy to consider other suggestions. Mr Kerr came forward with a suggestion, although I do not think that it was borne out by the facts, because the Government, with its expansive provision and the funding associated with that, has had to spend millions of pounds of capital on building kitchens, which has increased costs, but those costs were not accounted for in the Conservatives’ figure.

Let us go back to the budget negotiations. If the provision of universal free school meals is such a pressing issue for Mr Ross and his party, why was it not part of their budget negotiations?

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

It is very easy—

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Sorry, cabinet secretary, but it is very easy to answer that.

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

Convener, you have spoken over me today at length—

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

You have asked me a question—

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

—but you are not allowing me to answer the questions that you have put to me.

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

You have just put a question to me and I am happy to answer it. There is no need—

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

I will sit very quietly and allow you to interrupt and interject consistently. It is not particularly pleasant, but I will allow you to continue, Mr Ross.

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

That is very magnanimous of you—thank you, cabinet secretary.

You asked why the issue was not included in our budget negotiations. That was potentially because the Parliament had already agreed—the will of Parliament was clear on 10 September 2024, when your Government was defeated.

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

The Parliament also backed a budget to deliver on provision of the Scottish child payment, and that is what I am here to do today. You cannot pick and choose. We remain committed to the roll-out of universal free school meals.

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

It sounds as though you are picking and choosing. You have given a number of different timeframes. Can you clarify whether it has been two years since you have looked at the figures, which is why you cannot give us more accurate information, or whether you got figures just before or just after the debate on 10 September last year? You have given two answers on that.

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

The analysis that the SFT provided was from 18 months ago, and I have met the SFT and engaged further with it since that time. I am not aware that the SFT has given us a further update, because we will not be able to deliver universality during this session of Parliament. However, through the budget negotiations, we have been able to identify the additional funding required to deliver for P6 and P7 pupils receiving the SCP and to deliver on the asks by other parties regarding the roll-out of free school meals for S1 to S3 pupils. That is really important.

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

When your Government was defeated on 10 September, you did not go away and ask for updated figures.

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Are the figures that you are using from two years ago or from September last year? That is all that I am trying to get from you.

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

The £256 million figure was presented to us by the SFT 18 months ago.

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

What did you get in September last year, when you asked?

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Can you not tell us, cabinet secretary?

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

We engaged with the SFT directly on those points and asked it to consider the figure again. My expectation, given my engagement with the SFT last year, is that, if anything, the figure will have increased from £256 million because of inflationary pressures. That was the discussion that I had with the SFT at that time.

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Do you have a more recent figure than the one from two years ago?

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

The SFT has not carried out further modelling work on that, because it will not be possible to deliver universal free school meals during this parliamentary session.

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Even though the Parliament agreed to that last year.

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

The Parliament agreed to that, but it also agreed to the budget. Universal free school meals will not be deliverable by the end of this parliamentary session, Mr Ross. I think that you know that.

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

We do not know, because you do not have up-to-date costs.

Pam Duncan-Glancy Lab Glasgow
link

Good morning, cabinet secretary and officials. Thank you for joining us.

There is no doubt that people watching today will be disappointed that, although the Government came into office in 2021 having promised in its manifesto to provide free school meals for children in primaries 1 to 7, the committee is being asked to accept the fact that the Government has failed to meet that commitment and to accept, instead, a second-best option. Does the cabinet secretary agree?

Pam Duncan-Glancy Lab Glasgow
link

Does the cabinet secretary think that free school meals for children in primaries 1 to 7 will be delivered in this parliamentary session?

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

It is my expectation that, through work with local authorities, that will be delivered during this parliamentary session. That is my expectation and my understanding.

Based on my discussions with officials, we expect the vast majority of those projects to be delivered by the end of this calendar year. Some of them are more complex because—I was trying to make this point to Mr Ross—they require more extensive building works than others do. In the budget last year, we made provision for capital spending; this year, we have made provision available for resource spending. The funding has been made available. We have also provided the regulatory updates, which is what today’s SSI is about, and we are enabling local authorities to get on and deliver on the Parliament’s expectations, particularly in relation to the budget agreement.

Pam Duncan-Glancy Lab Glasgow
link

But not on universal free school meals for children in primaries 1 to 7.

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

The budget agreement does not provide for that.

Pam Duncan-Glancy Lab Glasgow
link

Does the cabinet secretary think that the budget agreement will provide for, at some point in this parliamentary session, the delivery of free school meals for children in primaries 1 to 7?

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

No, because that is not the budget requirement. The budget will deliver the roll-out for P6 and P7 pupils who receive the SCP and the test of change project for pupils in S1 to S3.

Pam Duncan-Glancy Lab Glasgow
link

The Government will not deliver free school meals to all pupils in primaries 1 to 7 in this parliamentary session.

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

That was confirmed in the parliamentary chamber many months ago.

Pam Duncan-Glancy Lab Glasgow
link

That is the case despite manifesto commitments, expectations and the parliamentary vote.

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

The budget that the Parliament voted for commits us to the roll-out for primary 6 and 7 pupils who receive the Scottish child payment and for those in S1 to S3 through the test of change programme. It does not commit to universality. Ms Duncan-Glancy knows that, because we have discussed it at length in the chamber.

Pam Duncan-Glancy Lab Glasgow
link

I accept that, but, with respect, cabinet secretary, it was the Government that proposed that budget.

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

Yes, it tends to be the Government that proposes the budget.

Pam Duncan-Glancy Lab Glasgow
link

That budget did not propose funding to do what the Government said that it would do.

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

The budget proposes funding for roll-out that is targeted at those receiving the Scottish child payment. That was also in the programme for government last September. The Government has been pretty clear about its commitment, and the issue has been discussed at length in the chamber.

Pam Duncan-Glancy Lab Glasgow
link

Why has the Government decided not to continue with its original aim of providing free school meals for all children in primaries 1 to 7?

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

Again, I have discussed that at length in the chamber. It is unaffordable. In relation to the budget gap, the Scottish Futures Trust last assessed the figure 18 months ago. The figure was assessed internally by the SFT, and we have pushed the SFT further in relation to that figure. Such provision is unaffordable in the remainder of this parliamentary session.

Pam Duncan-Glancy Lab Glasgow
link

Does the cabinet secretary accept that the United Kingdom budget provided the largest budget settlement for the Scottish Government since devolution? People watching will be wondering: if not now, in these circumstances, when?

10:00

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

If the budget settlement from the UK Government was so generous, I am at a bit of a loss to understand why Ms Duncan-Glancy and her party abstained on the Scottish budget, which commits the Scottish Government—as does the SSI—to moving forward and doing more. I gave the example of the City of Edinburgh Council. In that local authority area alone, we expect thousands of families to benefit from the SSI. The instrument commits the Government to moving on the budget that was negotiated with and voted for by the Parliament—in other words, it commits us to progress.

I could sit back and allow local authorities to use the data-sharing measures that they currently use, but we know that those do not capture most families who receive the Scottish child payment. The SSI will ensure that local authorities have the data that they need to deliver on the funding that we have provided through the budget in relation to the Scottish child payment.

I agree with Ms Duncan-Glancy’s overall point about universality. She well knows the inflationary pressures that the Government was forced to contend with in 2021, which have made everything much more expensive. Building kitchens, for example, is now much more expensive than it was three years ago. There have been other costs that we have had to meet, not least in relation to pay deals, which has affected the budget that I have had to manage and what we have been able to pay for.

From a personal perspective as cabinet secretary, I deeply regret the fact that we have not been able to deliver universality. It remains an aspiration and a commitment of the Government. I am pleased that we are making progress in relation to the roll-out of the Scottish child payment. The SSI is the next step in our commitment to universal roll-out, and the Government stands by that.

Pam Duncan-Glancy Lab Glasgow
link

Thank you for those responses. I have probably exhausted that line of questioning, so I will move on to data sharing.

The cabinet secretary will be aware that, in some situations, including in the pilot in the north-east on widening access to universities, data sharing has been an issue. Some witnesses have said in evidence to the committee that the pilot would not be scalable because of some of the data-sharing concerns. Does the cabinet secretary think that a unique learner number could be part of the solution to that?

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

It could, but there are differences when it comes to some of the widening access work that Mr Dey gave evidence on recently. I see the SSI as being part of the solution in the longer term for the exact same reason, because it will allow for a national approach to data sharing, which we do not currently have. In this instance, it will help local authorities to identify those who are in receipt of the Scottish child payment—I acknowledge that Mr Dey was giving evidence in relation to free school meals. More broadly, the instrument gives us an opportunity to learn how we might be able to better provide for data sharing between national Government, via—in this case—the auspices of Social Security Scotland, and local authorities.

I know that there have been significant challenges with the north-east pilot, which Mr Dey has written to the committee about, but I am keen that the approach that we are using in relation to the Scottish child payment, which compels the Government and local authorities to act, is one that we might be able to learn from in relation to widening access and to use in that space in the future.

Pam Duncan-Glancy Lab Glasgow
link

A number of health organisations have recognised that a national approach could be useful. I do not disagree with what the cabinet secretary has said, but it could be quite cumbersome to have agreements in every case, which is why the idea of a unique learner number has been suggested. Is the Government exploring that?

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

We are considering such options. Ms Duncan-Glancy is absolutely correct to say that, if we have 32 different councils doing 32 different things, the process will take a lot longer. The SSI will allow our councils to move at pace.

Deliverability is key. It is our expectation that the measure will be delivered. I have spoken about the funding that has been made available in last year’s budget and this year’s budget, but the SSI enables the data to be shared and allows councils to get on with it. If we allowed local authorities to do their own thing, it would be much more challenging for them to obtain that data and to work with families. As I understand it, Social Security Scotland will provide the information directly to education authorities as soon as the SSI comes into force on 19 May. That will allow them to move at pace and to contact the families in question directly.

I think that there is learning that could be taken from what we are doing here, and I accept the point about a unique learner number.

Pam Duncan-Glancy Lab Glasgow
link

We received a letter from the Information Commissioner’s Office, which said:

“The committee should note that we have not, to date, had any discussions with the Scottish Government, local authorities or institutions on how data can be shared fairly and proportionately to support widening access to university ... Nor have we had any engagement with the Scottish Government on the Data Protection considerations associated with establishing an identifier like the ULN.”

I was surprised to read that, given the undertakings that we have had about the Government’s willingness to consider a unique learner number. Will you now engage with an open mind with a view to progressing that?

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

The committee will be well aware that the Information Commissioner takes a keen interest in all these data sharing issues, and for good reason. His office has raised no concerns with us about the SSI—I want to be very clear on that point. However, there are things that we can learn from the SSI that can be taken to a widening access space in relation to the points that Pam Duncan-Glancy raises. I would want to talk to the Information Commissioner’s office directly about how we might be able to use the SSI in a widening access context, because, thus far, the approaches have been quite different. I do not want to conflate the approach that has been taken in that regard. However, I will take away the point that Ms Duncan-Glancy has raised, because it is an important one.

Pam Duncan-Glancy Lab Glasgow
link

The minister and others gave the impression that the unique learner number is something that the Government has explored but, for various reasons, could not take forward. However, given that the Government has not had those conversations, it appears strange that it has already come to such a conclusion.

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

I do not want to speak on behalf of Mr Dey. I reassure Ms Duncan-Glancy that I will take that point away from today’s evidence session and seek to engage directly with the Information Commissioner, particularly on this SSI and how it might be used as a learning point for us in relation to widening access.

As the member knows well, there have been real challenges in that regard. Mr Dey and I met Universities Scotland—I think at the start of this year—to talk about some of those challenges, because we want to have better data sharing. The Information Commissioner’s office has a direct role when there are challenges, and we need to be assured of all that we are doing. That assurance has been given in relation to this SSI. It may be that there is an opportunity to dovetail the approach that we have taken with this SSI in relation to Social Security Scotland and a national approach to widening access. I would be keen to pursue that with his office.

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

On that point, do you understand, that there will be some frustration today that the proposal has not been pursued? The unique learner number is not a new thing; it is something that the commissioner for fair access has referred to in the past. I do not know whether Mr Dey would accept this comment, but there was disappointment when he was at the committee that he was not able to tell us whether the unique learner number would need legislation, what it would cost or details about some of those data-sharing issues.

Several weeks have now passed and you have only today given a commitment to speak to the Information Commissioner. Many people will have hoped that the Government would have done that before now. If this is something that you are treating seriously, why have you not done that?

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

It would be remiss of me to speak on behalf of Mr Dey. The approach that has been used in relation to widening access has been quite different to the one that we have undertaken with the Scottish child payment more broadly. However, I take the point that the convener has made. As I mentioned, we discussed the issue with Universities Scotland very recently. The approach in this SSI has been in the making with Social Security Scotland for many months, if not longer. It has taken longer than it should have taken to get the data share with Social Security Scotland. We want to learn from that experience and see whether the proposal is possible.

I have not been presented with advice on this, so I do not want to speak out of turn. However, I want to discuss with officials whether we could lift the approach that has been used in relation to the SCP and apply it to widening access. As I said, thus far, I have not had advice on that. There is a slight difference with the unique learning number that you spoke about. I see that Ms Meikle is nodding—she may want to come in on that point.

Laura Meikle Scottish Government
link

I understand that Social Security Scotland is currently considering whether the approach could have wider applicability. It would be for Social Security Scotland to provide an update on that, if that would be helpful.

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

We will ask Social Security Scotland to provide a written update to the committee. We want more young people to have access to university and higher education, but we also want them to have access to free school meals, which is the purpose of the SSI that is before us today. We will take that point away and provide the committee with a further update on the points that Ms Duncan-Glancy has raised, which are very fair.

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

I am just trying to understand this. Clearly, you and your officials thought that we need to get agreement and have conversations with the ICO on the proposal. The minister accepted that. The unique learner number has been discussed for years and has been recommended by the commissioner for fair access and others. Given those points, why have officials not said to Mr Dey or others in Government, “We are having a discussion with the ICO on this SSI; we also need to have a discussion if we are going to make progress with the unique learner number”? Has no one raised that with you or the minister?

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

I have not been given advice on that issue. This SSI relates to the Scottish child payment. However, I take your point, convener. The point that Ms Duncan-Glancy raises about engagement with the Information Commissioner’s Office is a fair one. As I understand it, higher education officials regularly engage with the office—I see officials nodding. I want to take this away to be absolutely assured of that point with them.

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

On 28 March, the Information Commissioner’s Office wrote to the committee, and I will quote from its letter:

“The committee should note that we have not, to date, had any discussions with the Scottish Government, local authorities or institutions on how data can be shared fairly and proportionately to support widening access to university or any engagement on the North East Scotland pilot. Nor have we had any engagement with the Scottish Government on the Data Protection considerations associated with establishing an identifier like the ULN.”

That is very clear to us.

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

Part of the challenge here is that the north-east pilot is a locally owned project, which is why the data sharing at local level, as I understand it—having discussed it with Universities Scotland—is being carried out between Aberdeen City Council, Aberdeenshire Council and Robert Gordon University. They are all currently finalising data-sharing arrangements. I would expect that, through the finalisation of those data-sharing arrangements, there will be engagement with the Information Commissioner and his office.

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

But the minister was specifically asked about rolling that out. It would not just be between local areas; it would involve making that a national issue, in the same way that the unique learner number would be nationwide.

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

The north-east project is a pilot and, as I understand it, the view was that a pilot would be undertaken in one part of the country and learning would be taken from that. In order for us to go to the Information Commissioner’s Office and take that learning, we first need to have a pilot to evaluate.

That data sharing is due to take place in the spring, and evaluation of that work is planned for later this year. At that point, I would fully expect engagement with the Information Commissioner’s Office to be undertaken to ensure a robust approach to national roll-out. Further, if there is applicable learning from this SSI, across the board, we can use that at a national level.

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

But that would not be the case with the unique learner number.

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Because there is not a pilot for that.

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

The pilot that has been identified in the north-east does not use that approach, but—

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

So, the unique learner number is something that has just been—are you shaking your head?

Nico McKenzie-Juetten Scottish Government
link

Sorry?

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Are you shaking your head?

Nico McKenzie-Juetten Scottish Government
link

I don’t think so—no.

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

You were shaking your head and I thought you wanted to come in, but you do not want to come in.

Nico McKenzie-Juetten Scottish Government
link

Apologies—no, I do not.

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

So, cabinet secretary, the unique learner number is not subject to a pilot.

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

As I understand it, no. However, we will learn from the pilot, so I am not discounting it. A pilot is something that we have to learn from at national level. In rolling it out with the individual local authorities that I named and with Robert Gordon University, we will seek to learn from the process, and we will engage the Information Commissioner’s Office on the best way to do that at national level. That does not preclude your suggestions in relation to the unique learner number, which I know has been discussed at length at the committee previously.

Pam Duncan-Glancy Lab Glasgow
link

The issue is not so much about the pilot and its scalability at this point, as the pilot is still on-going. The point is that, during the process, organisations said that one of the issues that would always make the work difficult to do, even if the pilot was found to be good and useful, was that there is not an ease of data sharing.

We are trying to get a commitment from the cabinet secretary. We have previously been under the impression that the Government was considering the idea of a unique learner number. That was for a number of reasons, not least in the light of the Hayward review and in relation to the issue that we are discussing today. That is why I have raised the matter today, when we are talking about data sharing.

To be really clear, can the cabinet secretary confirm that the Government will now engage the Information Commissioner in considering whether a unique learner number would potentially be something that it could bring in, for data sharing and for other purposes?

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

There has been continuous engagement with the Information Commissioner’s Office in relation to data sharing across the board. The point that I was trying to make is that we have a local pilot happening in the north-east. On the chronology of what needs to happen next—this has been going on for some time now—the data-sharing arrangement is currently being finalised. The data sharing is due to take place in the spring, and the evaluation work is planned for later this year, at which point I would expect engagement to be undertaken with local partners and the Information Commissioner’s Office.

From that pilot we will learn how best to approach a national roll-out. Of course we will have to engage with the Information Commissioner’s Office on that, and on the learning from the pilot, but the pilot and the data-sharing arrangement have not yet been completed. The chronology of that is important in relation to the engagement with the Information Commissioner’s Office, the learning from the pilot and how we can upscale it and potentially roll it out at national level.

10:15

Pam Duncan-Glancy Lab Glasgow
link

Sorry, but I am finding this a little bit frustrating. I am not talking about any action that the Government takes on this being contingent on the learning from the pilot. In the discussion that the committee had, it was put to us that the ULN could be one solution not only in relation to the pilot in the north-east but in other areas, including in relation to what Hayward suggested in the review.

The minister said, “We have looked at it, but we cannot do it, but we are not sure why we cannot do it”—I have to say that he was not all that clear—but now, the Information Commissioner’s Office has said that the Government has not discussed the matter with it. I am trying to get some recognition of that and to give the Government an opportunity to say that it will now consider the suggestion, given that there was some acceptance from the minister that it might be useful. In fact, the Minister for Children, Young People and The Promise also said that.

This is an opportunity for the Government to say that it will look at the matter and will engage with the Information Commissioner’s Office, regardless of what happens with the pilot. The pilot could be helpful in that regard, but pursuing the ULN issue is not necessarily contingent on the pilot.

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

I do not think that we are at odds here, Ms Duncan-Glancy. We agree that we want to engage with the Information Commissioner’s Office on all this in relation to data sharing, and we have done that extensively in relation to the SSI that I am here to discuss.

In relation to the Aberdeen widening access pilot, we must also be mindful that, although the Government has a role in relation to the budget and our commitment to delivery of the SCP, we are talking about Aberdeen City Council, Aberdeenshire Council, Robert Gordon University and the University of Aberdeen. The universities are autonomous and independent of Government, and our councils have the statutory responsibility for the delivery of education. What we are able to do in relation to the widening access pilot might not look exactly the same as what we have done to apply the SSI to the SCP roll-out. However, in all of those projects, we must engage with the Information Commissioner’s Office.

In today’s session, Ms Duncan-Glancy has heard my willingness to pursue the matter further with the Information Commissioner’s Office. I also hear the convener’s point on that. My view is that we should take learning from the SSI to allow us to move at pace in relation to data sharing. The widening access pilot has had challenges regarding the timescales that are associated with it, which we accept; however, the SSI that we are discussing today commits the Government to move at pace and it will mean that local authorities will have that data in their hands by 19 May, when the SSI comes into effect, and they will be able to share that data with families accordingly.

If any information or learning can be taken from the approach that I am talking about today and applied to the widening access pilot or the broader national approach, I would be keen to do that, with the Information Commissioner’s Office.

Miles Briggs Con Lothian
link

Good morning. I want to clarify some points in your statement and in what you have said this morning. First, am I correct in saying that the figures that were presented to Parliament around extending free school meals are two years out of date?

Miles Briggs Con Lothian
link

Is it right that the figures that were presented to Parliament in the budget were inflation proofed in order to deliver on the commitments that they support? I think that the Liberal Democrats and the Greens supported that.

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

The budget commits us to the roll-out of free school meals to children in primary 6 and 7 who are in receipt of the Scottish child payment, and to children in S1 to S3 who are in receipt of the Scottish child payment in the eight test of change local authorities that I referred to earlier.

Miles Briggs Con Lothian
link

Can you tell the committee which local authorities those will be?

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

I cannot. I wrote to all local authorities two weeks ago. I have yet to be provided with advice from Ms Meikle; we discussed that earlier. I expect to receive that advice in the coming days. I would be happy to share the advice with the committee when I have it, but it has not yet been presented to me.

Miles Briggs Con Lothian
link

That would be very helpful.

On the issue of children missing out, how many should be receiving free school meals under the Government’s manifesto commitment but will not be by the end of this parliamentary session?

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

Do you mean in relation to children who are in receipt of the Scottish child payment or universally?

Laura Meikle Scottish Government
link

The estimated number of children and young people who would benefit from universal free school meals is about 90,000, and the estimated number of children who will benefit as a result of this piece of work is 25,000. That is in addition to the children and young people who are eligible through the criteria in the Education (Scotland) Act 1980.

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

The 25,000 are the extra children whom we anticipate will be captured by the SSI. There are thousands of families who are currently missing out on free school meals for their children, which is not good.

We want all families who should be in receipt of free school meals to have that for their child or young person. The SSI will mean that the data sharing is much better and more granular at a local level, and it will allow local authorities to move at pace in implementing the extra funding that we have provided them with to deliver on that commitment.

Miles Briggs Con Lothian
link

The issue is not new—it has been raised with the Cabinet Secretary for Social Justice, and other committees have raised it, too. The Government has been very slow to make progress on the issue. Am I right in saying that there are 90,000 children who are entitled to free school meals, but there are 25,000 young people who are not receiving free school meals who should be, or is that the number of children who will receive free school meals?

Laura Meikle Scottish Government
link

Twenty-five thousand extra children and young people will receive free school meals as a result of the SSI, which will take provision to around 84 per cent of all children and young people in primary schools. That would leave around 90,000 children and young people who would have benefited from universal free school meals.

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Sorry. I thought that it would leave 65,000 children, but the 25,000—

Laura Meikle Scottish Government
link

I had not deducted the 25,000 from the 90,000.

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

So, there are still 90,000 children across Scotland who will not get free school meals because the Government has not—

Laura Meikle Scottish Government
link

No. I am sorry—it is 65,000.

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

It is 65,000—okay.

Laura Meikle Scottish Government
link

It is 65,000. I did not do the maths.

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

At the moment, the total is 90,000. If the SSI is agreed to, we will decrease the 90,000 by 25,000 to 65,000.

Laura Meikle Scottish Government
link

Yes. My apologies.

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

I just wanted to check. I am getting nods of agreement—that is good.

Finally, cabinet secretary, I read you a number of quotes from the children’s commissioner, and you said that you would not put words in her mouth. I will read one of those quotes again and invite you to respond:

“One of the greatest barriers to the take up of school meals are feelings of shame and stigma, and only providing meals to P6-P7 in receipt of the Scottish Child Payment just exacerbates that stigma.”

Do you accept that the SSI that you are asking us to approve will, according to the children’s commissioner, exacerbate the shame and stigma for young people who take up free school meals?

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

You and I are probably of similar ages. Certainly, when we were at school, those who were in receipt of free school meals were provided with a certain colour of ticket for the dinner queue, which created stigma. My understanding is that that approach is not used in our schools any more, which has really helped to take away some of the stigma.

I accept the children’s commissioner’s point and think that it is valid. There are many different ways in which schools deal with reducing stigma, such as their work on the cost of the school day, which we have been able to fund through the pupil equity fund. Schools are adept at managing when children and their families are in need.

Would I like us to get to universality? Yes, and that remains the Government’s firm focus. There is no provision in the budget for us to do that, because of the associated costs that we have spoken about, such as inflationary pressure and things being much more expensive. The Government has also had to meet the cost of pay deals. Although we agree with those pay deals, that has ultimately made our original commitment on free school meals unaffordable.

However, the SSI will allow us to make firm progress, and it will expand the number of families who can receive free school meals. I think that that will be a good thing for the children of Scotland.

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

I was in receipt of free school meals for a period when my father lost his job, so I totally understand what you have said. However, I specifically asked you whether you agreed with the children’s commissioner’s view that the SSI that you have lodged will exacerbate stigma, because it will result in free school meals being provided only to primary 6 and primary 7 children who are in receipt of the Scottish child payment. Do you agree with that view?

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

Under the nutritional regulations, local authorities are legally required not to create stigma for young people in their schools. That is really important. Nico McKenzie-Juetten can keep me right on that.

Nico McKenzie-Juetten Scottish Government
link

Section 53B of the Education (Scotland) Act 1980 provides for the protection of the identity of pupils who receive free school lunches. That is existing law, which would kick in here, too. Reasonable steps must be taken by education authorities to ensure that the identity of those who are receiving free school meals is not revealed, other than to people who need to know in order to provide meals to them.

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

I am going to try again, cabinet secretary. For the third time, do you agree with the children’s commissioner that your SSI will, by providing free school meals only to primary 6 and primary 7 students who are in receipt of the Scottish child payment, exacerbate stigma?

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

You have just heard from Nico that there is a legal requirement for local authorities not to stigmatise children. In my experience, I do not see evidence of that happening in our schools. I trust Scotland’s teachers, who are trained caring professionals, not to stigmatise the young people who are in their care. That is not how members of the teaching profession and those who work in our schools work with our children and young people. When families are in need, they work with them every day. We need to be very careful about suggesting otherwise.

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

So, you disagree with the children’s commissioner on that point. We will hear from her next, and I would like to put the point to her.

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

I have set out the SSI; we are dancing on the head of a pin.

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report

No recorded division on this motion that day: decisions taken without a vote are not in the divisions feed.

  1. 09:30 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 1
  2. 09:30 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 279
  3. 10:45 Children and Young People’s Commissioner Scotland Evidence session · 189

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.