I found the motion to be quite puzzling. The Conservatives cannot seem to decide what point they are making—whether the issue at hand is getting good care to people who need it, or not spending public money on public services. I believe that the system should be about getting good care to people who need it.
“Postcode lottery” is a favourite term of the Conservatives, but today they are criticising the Scottish Government for taking forward proposals to create a national care service—an idea that is overwhelmingly backed by the public and would standardise care across the country—and are instead suggesting that we implement what is, essentially, a formal postcode lottery.
I am a Highlands and Islands MSP and I hate centralisation, but this is not centralisation. We can have national standards without centralising. From everything that I have heard so far about the proposals and the overall intention of this ambitious public sector overhaul, I am not worried that it is a power grab. The proposals are about combining national standards with local expertise to get rid of a postcode lottery.
As the bill takes shape, colleagues can count on me spending the rest of the process making sure that Highlands and Islands voices are heard and that their local expertise and local good practice—where it exists, and it does exist—are taken forward.
I have already heard extremely helpful, constructive and thoughtful input to the proposals from people with lived experience of caring or of receiving care. This is a huge opportunity, and it would be a real shame to chuck it out instead of putting in the work. As a Conservative colleague asked only minutes ago, why throw the baby out with the bath water?
Besides the fact that it is ridiculous to say that because the care sector is in crisis it is the wrong time to fix it, I find the brass neck of the Tories in talking about the care crisis at all astounding, because nothing has harmed care services recruitment more than Brexit, which their party forced on this country. Despite the best efforts of the Scottish Government, we are haemorrhaging EU nationals who worked, or would have worked, in those roles.
I mentioned earlier the fact that the Conservatives voted against the creation of the national health service—our NHS—22 times. I would have hoped that by now, in 2022, we would have got to the point at which we do not need a war to get folk behind us in looking after our citizens.
Out of interest, I looked up Hansard for the debate on the 1942 Beveridge report—which was not the first attempt at creating a national health service but was the beginning of the successful one—because I suspected, correctly, that there might be some similarities between that debate and today’s debate.
On 16 February 1943, Sir William Davison, a Conservative MP, questioned the cost of delivering that massive overhaul of social security, and asked:
“What about the millions of money for those who are not in want?”
Arthur Greenwood, of Labour, responded:
“They ought to thank God that they are in those happy circumstances”.
Scottish Unionist Charles MacAndrew also worried about the cost, and told the House:
“It does not satisfy me to be told that we cannot afford to be without it”—[Official Report, House of Commons, 16 February 1943; Vol 386, c 1620, 1646.]
However, I think that all of us here today agree that NHS Scotland is vital—that it is a core institution and that it is worth spending massive amounts of money on for the sake of saving and improving lives—and that we also agree that we cannot afford to be without it.
I encourage members to think about the following question when they speak. In 80 years, what will folk who are living in a country with a national care service think when they dig up some members’ comments in the Official Report, and will they be on the right side of history, this time?