Parliament Workbench
Data: Motions & questions to 19 Nov 2026 · Votes to 12 Nov 2026

Motion For Debate · S6M-06523 · Session 6

National Care Service Viability

Carried Lodged by Craig Hoy Con Lodged 31 Oct 2022 Debate 2 Nov 2022 3 supporters

The motion

That the Parliament notes the significant cross-party and cross-sectoral concern about the monumental risks involved in the creation of a National Care Service; warns that the financial memorandum to the Bill estimates that the creation of the service could cost up to £1.3 billion over five years and questions the accuracy of the Scottish Government’s estimates currently before the Parliament; raises concern about the rationale for creating a National Care Service through major structural reform at a time when social care is in crisis; acknowledges the considerable concerns from local government, trades unions and other industry stakeholders about the potential negative impacts of centralisation; believes that better value for money and better patient care will be achieved by directing investment into frontline provision and staffing rather than reorganisation, and calls for the creation of a Local Care Service focussed on better local delivery, underpinned by a local care guarantee.

What MSPs voted on: the motion as amended

The Conservatives’ motion was rewritten by an SNP amendment (S6M-06523.3) before this vote. A vote ‘for’ was a vote for the SNP’s wording.

That the Parliament
146 words removed by S6M-06523.3notes the significant cross-party and cross-sectoral concern about the monumental risks involved in the creation of a National Care Service; warns that the financial memorandum to the Bill estimates that the creation of the service could cost up to £1.3 billion over five years and questions the accuracy of the Scottish Government’s estimates currently before the Parliament; raises concern about the rationale for creating a National Care Service through major structural reform at a time when social care is in crisis; acknowledges the considerable concerns from local government, trades unions and other industry stakeholders about the potential negative impacts of centralisation; believes that better value for money and better patient care will be achieved by directing investment into frontline provision and staffing rather than reorganisation, and calls for the creation of a Local Care Service focussed on better local delivery, underpinned by a local care guarantee.
S6M-06523.3 SNP that the experience of the COVID-19 pandemic highlights the imperative for the National Care Service (NCS) to end the postcode lottery in the provision of adult social care; believes that there must be a rights-based, user-led approach to social care with consistent and fair access to high-quality care and support; further believes that the NCS should embed ethical commissioning that promotes fair work and climate change ambitions; recognises that the key consideration is how improvements are made for people who rely on the services of the NCS; welcomes that the NCS will be shaped by co-design and that services will be delivered locally; supports the creation, in line with the recommendation of the Independent Review of Adult Social Care, of a system of national collective bargaining on pay, terms and conditions within the social care sector and for workforce representatives, such as trade unions, to be involved in the governance of the service, including through full membership of Local Care Boards; notes that, in establishing the NCS, including any transfer of financial resources from local authorities to reformed integration boards, the Scottish Government should take into consideration the impact on local authorities’ ability to resource and deliver other services; understands that the UK Government’s mismanagement of the economy has heaped more pressure on care providers who were already adversely affected by the consequences of Brexit, and recognises the importance of local authorities, health boards, and the Scottish Government working constructively together to deliver improvements to social care in the interim, while mitigating the impact of the UK Government’s actions.

Final wording as read into the Official Report at Decision Time. The marked changes are worked out by this site from the amendment texts and match that wording.

Amendments

  1. S6M-06523.3 SNP Kevin Stewart Agreed vote, 62–49
  2. S6M-06523.1 Liberal Democrat Alex Cole-Hamilton Not put to a vote (worked out by this site: never called at Decision Time: not selected or not moved)
  3. S6M-06523.2 Labour Jackie Baillie Fell (worked out by this site: the Presiding Officer announced it would fall if another amendment was agreed, and that one was)

Signatures by party

3 MSPs besides the lodger · 0 from other parties
Con 3

Party on the day each MSP signed. Signing a motion is voluntary and not whipped. Who signs whose motions

Vote

1 division
  1. 2 Nov 2022
    National Care Service Viability
    S6M-06523as amended by SNP
    Carried
    61 for, 50 against

Amendments

3
  1. No recorded vote
  2. No recorded vote
  3. Carried
    62 for, 49 against

Supporters

3 MSPs

Con 3

Show all 3 supporters by party

Con 3

Party shown is each supporter’s party when the motion was published.

In the Official Report

5 contributions mention S6M-06523
  1. 2 Nov 2022
    National Care Service
    Liam McArthur LD Meeting of the Parliament

    The next item of business is a debate on motion S6M-06523, in the name of Craig Hoy, on national care service viability. I ask members who wish to participate to press their request-to-speak buttons now or as soon as possible. I encourage …

  2. 2 Nov 2022
    National Care Service
    Paul O'Kane Lab Meeting of the Parliament

    I am running short of time, as I am into my final minute. I am sure that the minister will be able to raise his point in his concluding remarks. The Scottish Government needs to go back to the beginning of this process to substantively and…

  3. 2 Nov 2022
    Decision Time
    Annabelle Ewing SNP Meeting of the Parliament

    There are seven questions to be put as a result of today’s business. I remind members that, if the amendment in the name of Kevin Stewart is agreed to, the amendment in the name of Jackie Baillie will fall by way of pre-emption. The first …

  4. 2 Nov 2022
    Decision Time
    Annabelle Ewing SNP Meeting of the Parliament

    The next question is, that motion S6M-06523, in the name of Craig Hoy, on national care service viability, as amended, be agreed to. Are we agreed? Members: No.

  5. 2 Nov 2022
    Decision Time
    Annabelle Ewing SNP Meeting of the Parliament

    The result of the division on motion S6M-06523, in the name of Craig Hoy, on national care service viability, as amended, is: For 61, Against 50, Abstentions 0. Motion, as amended, agreed to, That the Parliament notes that the experience o…